Traffic chaos during the BJP’s demonstration over the women’s reservation bill in Mumbai's Worli area prompted an irate woman to confront Maharashtra Minister Girish Mahajan, blaming him for the snarls. The incident occurred on Tuesday (April 21
Outgoing Apple, Inc. CEO Tim Cook oversaw a period where the company sank far deeper roots in the Indian market than had been done in the decades prior. Most notably, he presided over the firm’s supply chain expansion, during which it set up iPhone assembly operations in Tamil Nadu and Karnataka
West Bengal polls: Polling for the 2026 West Bengal Legislative Assembly elections will be held in two phases on April 23 and 29, with counting of votes on May 4. West Medinipur: Union Home Minister on Tuesday launched a sharp attack on West Bengal Chief Minister
The Jharkhand Academic Council (JAC) is likely to announce the results for the Class 10 (Matric) and Class 12 (Intermediate) board examinations for the 2025–2026 academic session. According to board officials and reports, the JAC Board has completed the process of preparing the Jharkhand 10th
The Supreme Court on Tuesday issued notice on a public interest litigation challenging the validity of the 2008 National Investigation Agency Act, Live Law reported. The Act set up the National Investigation Agency in 2008 and contains a list of scheduled offences that it has the power to
Why India’s trading communities face resentment
In August, protests in Telangana accusing Marwari traders of “taking over local markets” tapped into an old unease. India's trading communities, the Marwaris, Gujaratis, Parsis and others, have long been symbols of enterprise and economic influence. But across regions, mercantile success has often been shadowed by suspicion and, at times, hostility.
In a 2023 research project I co-authored on ventures founded by members of trading castes, we observed that entrepreneurial success was often accompanied by suspicion and vilification – as if success itself invited suspicion. Although our study did not measure hostility directly, the broader literature we reviewed offered some clues about where this sentiment was coming from.
Trading communities often rely on dense internal networks for capital, apprenticeship, and market information, which outsiders may interpret as exclusionary. When such groups cluster in specific sectors and expand rapidly, local competitors can perceive this as disproportionate economic sway, fuelling narratives of encroachment or dominance.
Like in Telangana, similar incidents of resentment have surfaced in Karnataka and Odisha. For instance, in 2019 in Bengaluru, pro-Kannada groups publicly threatened the Marwari community over language and cultural issues, framing them as outsiders in the city's landscape. These regions host trading groups such as the Shettys in Karnataka, Klings in Odisha and Komatis in Telangana.
Still, the Marwaris, originally from Rajasthan, have repeatedly borne the brunt of resentment. By contrast, in West Bengal, such flare-ups have been far less common since Marwaris have had a long and well-established presence there.
Resentment towards trading communities is rarely driven by economics alone. It emerges from a mix of caste identities, migration histories and tightly-knit business networks that can appear closed to outsiders. When these factors combine with limited social interaction, even routine commercial competition can harden into mistrust. Building broader networks of trust is essential to prevent stereotypes from hardening into hostility.
Historically, trading communities, particularly the Marwaris, were central to India's economic development. In the pre-Independence era, these communities were not only traders but also moneylenders and local bankers, directly fueling commerce. Their use of hundis, the precursors to bills of exchange, enabled the transfer of funds without physical cash. Their readiness to migrate, aided by the expansion of railways under the British, helped them build networks far beyond their native regions.
After Independence, these communities have continued to shape India's business landscape. Major Indian conglomerates such as the Tata Group, the Aditya Birla Group, the Goenkas, Godrej Enterprises, the Mahindra Group and the Ambani and Adani Groups trace their origins to trading community backgrounds.
Studies suggest that trading community members account for nearly 45% of directors on listed company boards and were involved in half of all new ventures launched between 1991 and 2014, with Marwaris, bania and Jain communities from Gujarat, and Parsis playing an especially prominent role.
Caste, too, plays a part in how trading communities are seen, though its impact differs across regions. Many trading groups themselves are organised along caste lines, with tightly-knit internal networks that historically helped build trust, capital, and mobility in unfamiliar markets. But these same networks can also translate into concentrated economic power in particular sectors which local groups may interpret as caste-linked dominance.
In Telangana, for instance, local caste-based trader groups and Dalit organisations viewed migrant Marwaris as outsiders in an already competitive marketplace. In such situations, caste identity can amplify economic rivalry and heighten the sense of being socially separate, allowing grievances to surface more quickly.
This perception of distance is often reinforced by economic prominence. Local competitors may view the dominance of trading groups as suffocating, while their cultural insularity reinforces perceptions of separateness. Merchant communities often sustain insular social practices: shared meals, community-exclusive religious schools to supplement modern education with religious instruction, strict rules of marriage, and early immersion in family businesses. These traditions preserve culture and commercial acumen, as well as caste boundaries, but limit interaction outside the community.
Such insularity can deepen divides. Parallel schooling narrows social exposure, while early immersion in commerce discourages entry into broader professional networks. What ensures continuity within the community can, unintentionally, restrict bridges to the broader society. Sameness strengthens trust within groups, but it can also build walls. As management thinker Erin Meyer notes in the Harvard Business Review, when people don't understand each other's unspoken codes and habits, mistrust creeps in easily.
India's own history shows that when groups do not interact regularly, whether across religions, caste or regions, small gaps in understanding can turn into deep divides. Political scientist Ashutosh Varshney observed this in his study of Indian cities: places with dense everyday economic and social interactions between communities tended to remain more stable. Varshney's study dates back almost three decades and focused on Hindu-Muslim relations, but the underlying idea holds.
In many recent flashpoints, including Telangana, resentment has arisen not across religions but local caste groups and merchant communities. Here too, the absence of shared spaces, social overlap, and routine interaction can allow economic competition to turn into suspicion.
How, then, can resentment toward trading communities be addressed?
Reframing is one strategy, where what was once stigmatised became normalised. But reframing requires effort on both sides. A starting point is to ask whether the presence of trading communities is an asset.
For locals, caricatures of “profiteers” obscure the fact that trading groups anchor entire value chains sustained by non-trading participants. For merchants, the task is to engage more deliberately with the wider community through visible civic participation and greater openness in everyday social interactions, so that economic ties are accompanied by social ones.
West Bengal offers an instructive example. Stereotypes persist but the state has not witnessed the anti-Marwari agitations seen elsewhere. Kolkata's Marwaris invested early in social capital, supporting the nationalist movement, advancing women's education and funding hospitals, schools and charitable trusts. Philanthropy also secured legitimacy. The civic contributions of the Marwari traders earned recognition and embedded them in Bengal's social fabric.
Trading communities are complex actors in India's economic and social story. Recognising that complexity is the first step toward avoiding cycles of resentment.
Trading communities must proactively build bridges with the broader population where they are recent arrivals. Local societies, in turn, must resist easy scapegoating and value the contribution these groups make. Only by cultivating broader networks of trust can stereotypes be prevented from hardening into hostility.
Abu Rehan Abbasi is an assistant professor at IIM Kashipur. Views expressed are personal.
Source: Scroll
Related Posts: Dutch bride surprises Marwari groom with Rajasthani dance Aquarius Weekly Horoscope (18th August – 24th August) Aquarius Weekly Horoscope (25th August – 31st August) Pisces Weekly Horoscope (25th August – 31st August) Pisces Weekly Horoscope (18th August – 24th August) India traders brace for volatility as US-Iran ceasefire talks loom NSE cautions traders Worry eats into traders as ‘Bikaneri bhujia’ takes a hit amid US-Iran war Oil prices rise as traders eye fragile US-Iran ceasefire Special registration drive for Shram Yogi Maandhan and NPS Traders schemes from January 15
Woman gives 5 reasons she’ll never return to a corporate job even with 2x salaryA Dubai-based woman has explained why she will never return to a corporate job, even if her pay were to be doubled. Updated on: Apr 22, 2026 11:45 AM IST By Sanya Jain Share via Copy link A Dubai-based woman has
1 days ago
Rajasthan Royals wicket-keeper Dhruv Jurel, who effected a stunning stumping of Kolkata Knight Riders batter Cameron Green in the IPL on Sunday (April 19, 2026), said he was grateful to be working with the legendary Sri Lankan gloveman Kumar Sangakkara.Rajasthan Royals wicket-keeper Dhruv Jurel
1 days ago
The Congress said that Opposition leader Rahul Gandhi’s visit to West Bengal on Thursday to campaign for the Assembly elections had to be cancelled after the administration allegedly denied permission, The Telegraph reported. Gandhi was to address a rally in Kolkata and another in Serampore
1 days ago
Shah Rukh Khan stayed calm amid fan frenzy during visit to Ajmer dargah, reveals bodyguardBodyguard Yusuf Ibrahim revealed that he had accompanied Shah Rukh Khan to the Ajmer dargah on a Friday, but the visit quickly turned chaotic. Apr 22, 2026
1 days ago
Karnataka recently rolled out a draft policy to alter the taxation structure on liquor sold in the state. The policy proposed taxing liquor based on the actual volume of alcohol present in it — or the Alcohol-in-Beverage taxation system, a popular practice in western countries
1 days ago
Inherited peripheral neuropathies (IPN) are cruel genetic diseases that affect around 1 in 2,500 individuals. A person affected by IPN develops high foot arches, curled toes, thin calves, and walks awkwardly or trips. Their fingers may become clawed and, because they lose sensation
1 days ago
Kedarnath Dham portals open today, CM Dhami offers prayersChar Dham Yatra began on April 19, with the opening of the portals of Gangotri and Yamunotri shrines in Uttarakhand on the occasion of Akshaya Tritiya Published on: Apr 22, 2026 1:33 PM IST By HT Correspondent
1 days ago
No, ICSE Class 10 Result 2026 will not be declared today, April 22, despite the false claim floating on social media platforms. The Council for the Indian School Certificate Examinations (CISCE) told Times of India (TOI) dismissed the rumour and said that the board has not made any announcement
1 days ago
Kevin Warsh has clashed with Democratic senators during a fiery confirmation hearing to decide whether he should be installed as Federal Reserve chairman. From suggestions that he would be President Donald Trump's "sock puppet" to questions over his links to paedophile financier Jeffrey Epstein
1 days ago
Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Panasonic ACs are trending this summer! Grab top deals with up to 30% discountPanasonic ACs are becoming a top choice this summer. Check out the latest deals, key features
1 days ago
A Mumbai woman has gone viral after angrily confronting Maharashtra minister Girish Mahajan over a massive traffic jam allegedly caused by a political rally in Worli, with many on social media calling her the voice of ordinary commuters. The clip, shared by X user Prashant Dhumal
1 days ago
IIT Kharagpur professor invites students to his birthday party, internet enviousAn IIT Kharagpur student left the internet surprised—and a little envious—after sharing a video of a professor’s birthday celebration with his class. Updated on: Apr 22
1 days ago
The Iran war has caused a significant drop in global oil demand, with consumption plummeting due to supply disruptions and record-high fuel prices. While this short-term destruction accelerates the shift to EVs and biofuels, the conflict's longer-term impact may paradoxically boost oil demand
1 days ago
Global oil prices edged lower in Asia on Wednesday after US President Donald Trump said he would extend a ceasefire with Iran until peace talks between the two countries have progressed. He added that the US will continue to blockade Iran's ports until Tehran presents a "unified proposal"
1 days ago
Abhishek Sharma smashed an explosive century on Tuesday. He scored an unbeaten 135 runs from 68 balls. This helped Sunrisers Hyderabad defeat Delhi Capitals by 47 runs in the Indian Premier League. Sharma's performance was the fifth-highest individual score in the tournament's history
1 days ago
One year after the terror attack in Pahalgam on 22 April 2025, which claimed 26 lives in a targeted assault on civilians, the meadows of Kashmir seem to have begun their slow healing with a return to tourism. Yet for the families left behind, time has not healed in the way society often expects
1 days ago
At least 13 people have been killed in an explosion at a firecracker factory in India's southern state of Kerala, officials say. The incident took place in Thrissur, where around 40 people were believed to be assembling firecrackers in a cluster of sheds for an upcoming festival
1 days ago
Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Stay safe and protected this summer with these SPF-infused skin and hair productsKeep your skin and hair protected with these SPF-infused products. Published on: Apr 22
1 days ago
David Wilcock death rumors: Rep. Anna Paulina Luna sounds the alarm about dead, missing US scientists, ‘Something is up’Rep. Anna Paulina Luna has sounded the alarm about an increasing number of missing and dead scientists amid rumors that David Wilcock has died by suicide. Updated on: Apr 22
1 days ago
The protests by workers across Indian cities through early April are an urgent signal that survival is impossible on wages that hover around the bare legal minimum. Domestic, gig and delivery workers to industrial labourers in the Delhi-National Capital Region protested demanding an increase in
1 days ago
Walk into most classrooms today, and you will find students who can define empathy, write about conflict, and explain decision-making. But ask them to navigate a difficult conversation, respond to peer pressure, or articulate what they feel; the confidence disappears
1 days ago
V. Muthuraja returns to contest Pudukkottai seat for DMK in 2026 Tamil Nadu electionsV. Muthuraja, a key DMK politician from Tamil Nadu, won the Pudukkottai seat in 2021 with 85,802 votes, aims to defend his position in the 2026 elections. Published on: Apr 22
1 days ago
Learn how to search your name in the voter list 2026, verify details in the electoral roll, and download your Voter ID card online via NVSP and ECI portals. Step-by-step guide with direct links and troubleshooting tips. With Assembly elections in Tamil Nadu and West Bengal approaching
1 days ago
Nineteen hundred exhibitors from Italy and around the world. 700 designers, all under the age of 35. Over 169,000 sq.m. of exhibition. The numbers give a sense of the scale of this year’s Salone del Mobile.Milano, the landmark European furniture and interiors design trade fair that attracts a
1 days ago
Taiwan President Lai Ching-te has cancelled a presidential trip to the southern African nation of Eswatini, accusing Beijing of putting pressure on other countries to bar his aircraft from flying over their territories. Seychelles, Mauritius and Madagascar revoked Lai's overflight permits after
1 days ago
International benchmark Brent crude futures traded at $99.29 per barrel, up 0.82 per cent, while US West Texas Intermediate (WTI) rose 1.15 per cent to $90.71. Mumbai: Global crude oil prices edged higher to nearly $100 a barrel on Wednesday as traders and investors analysed the outlook for US-Iran
1 days ago
Diet Coke has become an unexpected casualty of supply chain disruptions linked to the ongoing tensions involving Iran, with several Indian cities witnessing stock-outs of the popular sugar-free beverage due to a severe shortage of aluminium cans. The crunch has also affected other canned drinks
1 days ago
