Tim Cook wrote a winning recipe for AppleWill it work for his successor? Published on: Apr 26, 2026 3:43 PM IST The Economist Share via Copy link SOMETIMES A COMPANY encapsulates its times. Ford and its Model T captured the go-getting mood of the Roaring Twenties
Dressed in a black tuxedo just hours after he was at the centre of yet another major security incident, US President Donald Trump told reporters: "I can't imagine that there's any profession that is more dangerous." While a small army of Secret Service agents make the president arguably the world's
There’s a flavour movement quietly brewing in Indian kitchens and it isn’t smoky or spicy, but umami. Once considered a foreign concept, Indian chefs are now tapping into the country’s own rich legacy of umami-forward ingredients and techniques to reimagine comfort food for a cleaner, deeper
Violence erupted in West Bengal's Howrah and Haroa districts before the second phase of polling. Clashes between Trinamool Congress and BJP supporters occurred in Howrah. In Haroa, a police sub-inspector was injured during a confrontation between Trinamool Congress and Indian Secular Front
Mann Ki Baat: PM Modi praises Great Indian Bustard conservationPopulation of Great Indian Bustard has declined to fewer than 200 individuals, with the majority found in Rajasthan Published on: Apr 26, 2026 5:31 PM IST By Vijay Mathrani, Barmer/Jaisalmer Share via Copy link Prime Minister Narendra
Who really needs college education? A hard look beyond the Silicon Valley narrative
Who really needs college education? A hard look beyond the Silicon Valley narrative Premium
A few weeks ago, an Indian tech founder remarked that many bright American students now skip college altogether, urging Indian parents to rethink their assumptions about higher education. The comment echoed long-standing Silicon Valley views. U.S. based AI company Palantir, co-founded by Peter Thiel, has been running a “Meritocracy Fellowship” programme from 2023 giving students a chance to directly start working rather than joining college. Peter Thiel also funds students who drop out to start companies through a separate “Thiel Fellowship” since 2011. Elon Musk repeats, often and confidently, that “you don't need college to learn anything important.”
These ideas travel fast. They resonate with young people already questioning the value of degrees and with parents anxious about rising costs and uncertain job markets. But what is often missed is that these statements come from a context very different from ours. The American education system, its K–12 preparedness, financial-aid structures, and recognition of non-traditional credentials bear little resemblance to those of India.
In India, the question “Who needs university education?” does not lend itself to a single answer. It has two answers that sit almost in tension with each other. One with a question mark, and one with an exclamation point.
Not everyone. And certainly not everyone at eighteen.
For lakhs of young Indians, going to college is almost an automatic next step. They complete school and, without pause or reflection, enter a degree programme. Families offer little counsel beyond “get a degree and life will improve.” The assumption is that any degree is better than no degree.
But the reality is more complicated. The steady stream of graduates, and even postgraduates, applying for clerical government jobs reflects a startling mismatch between what universities are meant to do and what they actually deliver. In too many institutions, students spend three or four years without acquiring either employable skills or the intellectual confidence that higher education should cultivate.
Many are simply not ready for university at eighteen—academically, emotionally, experientially or practically. They would gain far more by first building discipline and clarity through a vocational course, an apprenticeship, a job, or even a year spent engaging with the world. Because public higher education is often free or subsidised, young people enter college “because there is nothing better to do,” and the result is frustration.
This is where the Silicon Valley narrative sounds tempting. Skip college, learn online and just hustle your way forward. But that story works only in an ecosystem where students have strong school preparation, access to mentors, career counselling, early exposure to problem-solving, and a labour market willing to recognise unconventional pathways. That is not the reality for most Indian students.
For them, the right question is not “Do we need university education?” but “Are we ready for university education now?”
More people than ever, but only if universities remain true places of learning.
For a large segment of young Indians, university is not only relevant but essential. And not as a virtual video playlist, but as a physical space where intellectual, emotional, and social transformation takes place.
The years between eighteen and twenty-two are truly transformative. Identities shift. Curiosity deepens. Friendships and networks form beyond the family. A campus is where young people learn to think independently, communicate clearly, listen deeply, disagree without hostility, collaborate on messy problems, meet deadlines, balance competing commitments, and handle failure, all in the company of peers and mentors. These are not skills transmitted through online modules. They are lived, observed, and absorbed.
Space matters too. Human beings think with their bodies as much as with their minds. We take walks when we want clarity; we don't sit inside a cupboard. The corridors of a university, its libraries, studios, labs, and informal corners expand thought. They create encounters. They shape imagination. Online learning can deliver information and some skills but does not necessarily cultivate judgment.
As families become more inward-looking and screens occupy every shared space, the university remains one of the few places where genuine human interaction still occurs. Ironically, as technology advances, the need for physical universities may grow stronger.
However, the universities of tomorrow will not be the same as of today. Those universities that reinvent themselves, adapt rapidly and stay nimble will be in high demand. The university clientele is also going to change rapidly.
India aims to raise its Gross Enrolment Ratio in higher education to 50%. This expansion is necessary, but unless accompanied by real improvements in quality, it risks producing more degrees but not more learning.
Two truths must be acknowledged.
First, all students are not ready for university at eighteen. We need gap-year pathways, stronger counselling in schools, bridging curricula, and opportunities to enter or return to university later at any age.
Second, the quality of institutions must improve substantially. Too many universities today carry the label without the substance. They neither challenge students nor prepare them for life and work. Expansion without quality will only deepen the mismatch.
Online degrees and education is an option but with definite limitations of informing without really educating.
The belief that all formal education must end by twenty-two is outdated. Universities must evolve into places where people come at different stages, at eighteen, twenty-five, forty, or even sixty, whenever they are ready to learn something new. The goal should be an 18-to-80 university, not an 18-to-22 one.
So, who needs university education? Some young people, not yet. And many others, absolutely yes. India's task is to build a system that recognises both truths: one that gives time and alternativeWho Really Needs University Education in India? A Hard Look Beyond the Silicon Valley Narratives to those who need to grow first, and strengthens universities for those ready to learn deeply.
Our aim must be not more institutions, but better ones. Not more degrees, but more learning. And above all, universities that help young people grow into thoughtful, capable, confident, and compassionate adults.
(Prof. Rudra Pratap is Founding, Vice-Chancellor, Plaksha University)
Published - January 23, 2026 04:46 pm IST
Source: TheHindu
Related Posts: Hasan Piker ripped for saying he doesn't have ‘any patriotism’ for America Indian banks far more mature than a decade ago Indian student who went missing six days ago in United States found dead Indian scientists spot Milky Way-like galaxy from 12 billion years ago How Bright Lights Of Diwali Hide A Dark Trade Truth Between India And China Fort Kochi’s viral Christmas tree shines bright with more than 100 AYG success presents a bright picture for women’s boxing in India Bright, peppy sneakers for women to instantly upgrade their mood and outfit Srinagar’s Ghanta Ghar Celebrations Ignite Hope For Bright Future Trump's bright anti-China idea begins to dim
The sacred fast of Mohini Ekadashi will be observed on Monday, April 27, 2026, by devotees of Lord Vishnu across India. This auspicious Ekadashi is believed to cleanse sins and grant spiritual upliftment, with devotees also seeking blessings from Goddess Lakshmi
1 days ago
The Mexican government says two US agents who died last weekend in a car crash had not been authorised to operate in the country. The officials, who reportedly worked for the CIA, had taken part in a raid on suspected drug labs in the northern state of Chihuahua before their vehicle skidded off a
1 days ago
Perhaps clay hasn’t been kind to him this time. But Carlos Alcaraz is already looking ahead. In a significant blow to the clay-court season, the World No. 2 has officially withdrawn from the French Open due to a wrist injury sustained during the opening round of the Barcelona Open
1 days ago
![Chennai (Tamil Nadu) [India], April 26 (ANI): Captain Ruturaj Gaikwad played a lone hand with a resilient unbeaten 74 as Chennai Super Kings (CSK) managed to](http://newsorbit360.com/files/news/en/imgs/gaikwads-gritty-74-leads-csk-to-158-vs-gt-after-rabadas-3-fer.webp?height=520)
Chennai (Tamil Nadu) [India], April 26 (ANI): Captain Ruturaj Gaikwad played a lone hand with a resilient unbeaten 74 as Chennai Super Kings (CSK) managed to post a competitive 158/7 against Gujarat Titans (GT) at Chepauk in their Indian Premier League (IPL) 2026 match on Sunday
1 days ago
Sri Lanka is seeking investors for Mattala Rajapaksa International Airport. The airport has been a financial drain since opening in 2013. A previous lease agreement with an Indo-Russian venture did not materialize. The government highlights the airport's potential for tourism and strategic
1 days ago
From screen time to sleep: 6 everyday habits that may be fuelling your stressStress doesn’t develop all of a sudden. Certain daily habits can quietly accelerate it without you even realising. Here are the habits to watch out for. Published on: Apr 26
1 days ago
On an August day in 2013, WhatsApp, the messaging app now owned by Meta, made an announcement. With relatively little fanfare, they revealed the voice note, the messaging feature that lets you send a clip of your own voice to friends and family
1 days ago
Senior AAP leader Sanjay Singh refutes reports of Punjab MLAs being in touch with Raghav Chadha. He labels these claims as misinformation spread by the BJP. Protests are ongoing in Punjab against Chadha and other Rajya Sabha MPs who joined the BJP
1 days ago
An Indian government notification on April 17 tapped ethanol to make Sustainable Aviation Fuel (SAF). Aviation has been hard to decarbonise because aircraft can’t use batteries or hydrogen at commercial scale yet, leaving SAF to be the primary way to comply with international emissions frameworks
1 days ago
Did you know soluble fibre intake can help with irritable bowel syndrome? Maryland doctor explainsAdding more soluble fibre to the daily diet can help manage IBS symptoms better. Dr Kunal Sood explains how. Published on: Apr 26, 2026 5:43 PM IST By Debapriya Bhattacharya Share via Copy link
1 days ago
I am an educator committed to nurturing critical thinking among learners and strengthening social cohesion in our diverse nation. The Hindu Education Plus / education / school / teaching and learning / teachers / language / English / Hindi / university / universities and colleges / careers /
1 days ago
Dhanush recalls being mocked for his physique, says Polladhavan turned things around: ‘I got claps for my body’Dhanush showed off his six-pack abs during a pivotal scene in Polladhavan. The film was released in 2007. Apr 26, 2026, 17:33:02 IST By Santanu Das Share via Copy link Dhanush is
1 days ago
NTA to issue NEET UG 2026 admit cards today. Step-by-step guide to check websiteNEET UG Admit Card 2026: Candidates are required to carry a valid original ID proof, since entry will not be allowed without an ID proof. Updated on: Apr 26, 2026 1:21 PM IST By HT News Desk Share via Copy link The
1 days ago
Double Dhamaal: From Toxic to Ramayana, upcoming Indian films starring actors in two rolesThese upcoming films promise double the fun with! Published on: Apr 26, 2026 5:31 PM IST By Mahima Pandey Share via Copy link Double roles and dual roles are a popular and much-loved trope in Indian cinema
1 days ago
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Sunday (April 26, 2026), expressed relief over the safety of U.S. President Donald Trump and First Lady Melania Trump. U.S. Secret Service agents bundled the U.S. President from the stage as shots rang out Saturday (April 25, 2026) evening at a media gala
1 days ago
Signal, an end-to-end encrypted messaging app long considered one of the most secure in the world, has recently faced attacks from hackers accused of links to Russia.Top German officials on Saturday blamed Moscow-backed groups for phishing attacks targeting senior politicians on the messaging app
1 days ago
In a major setback for Indian solar photovoltaic manufacturers, the US has announced to impose a 123 per cent anti-dumping duty on solar imports, which will badly hurt their businesses. Following the investigation, the US Department of Commerce (DoC) has concluded that solar cells imported from
1 days ago
How to think about foreign policy in the new geoeconomic eraMiddle powers need to tread skilfully around the biggest blocs, writes Yvette Cooper Published on: Apr 26, 2026 3:46 PM IST The Economist Share via Copy link WITH EVERY day of disruption in the Strait of Hormuz, the economic damage mounts
1 days ago
Chennai, Apr 26 (PTI) Scoreboard of IPL match between Chennai Super Kings and Gujarat Titans here on Sunday. Chennai Super Kings: Sanju Samson c Buttler b Rabada 11 Ruturaj Gaikwad not out 74 Urvil Patel c Holder b Rabada 4 Sarfaraz Khan c Buttler b Mohammed Siraj 0 Dewald Brevis c Shubman Gill b
1 days ago
PM Modi in Mann Ki Baat said that ongoing Census exercise is not just a government task but a responsibility of all citizens and participation of everyone is vital. PM Modi’s Mann Ki Baat: Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Sunday highlighted India’s growing achievements across sectors ranging
1 days ago
Police in Kolkata found approximately 100 crude bombs at a residence in Bhangar. The house belonged to an individual reportedly affiliated with the TMC. This discovery occurred just days before the second phase of the West Bengal assembly elections
1 days ago
Pakistan Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif spoke with Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian and discussed the evolving regional situation. During the telephonic conversation on Saturday (April 25, 2026) evening, which coincided with Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi's visit to Islamabad
1 days ago
The man arrested after shots were fired inside the hotel where the White House Correspondents' Dinner was being held on Saturday night has been named to the BBC's US news partner CBS by law enforcement sources as Cole Tomas Allen. The 31-year-old suspect is from Torrance in the Los Angeles region
1 days ago
Can Raghav Chadha, others lose RS seats over BJP merger? AAP seeks their removal amid legal complexitiesSeven AAP Rajya Sabha MPs exited the party on Friday and merged with the BJP, citing the 2/3rds exception to the Anti-Defection Law. Updated on: Apr 26
1 days ago
People in the UK could face higher energy, food, and flight ticket prices for at least eight months after the end of the US-Israel war with Iran, a senior minister has said. Darren Jones, Chief Secretary to the Prime Minister, told the BBC the government was "looking at all of those things" as it
1 days ago
Srinagar Khel Sankalp document outlines national vision to strengthen sports cultureSrinagar Khel Sankalp document outlines national vision to strengthen sports culture Updated on: Apr 26, 2026 4:38 PM IST PTI Share via Copy link Srinagar, Sports Minister Mansukh Mandaviya on Sunday released
1 days ago
Dhoni isn’t part of the Chennai unit for the game against GT, amid reports that he does not want to meddle with the team composition that seems to be working. Chennai Super Kings take on Gujarat Titans at the MA Chidambaram Stadium in Chennai on Sunday in a blockbuster encounter between the sides
1 days ago
![New Delhi [India], April 26 (ANI): Team India’s head coach, Gautam Gambhir, on Sunday, shared adorable fam-jam pictures. As his daughter Anaiza turned nine](http://newsorbit360.com/files/news/en/imgs/gautam-gambhir-s-daughter-anaiza-turns-9.webp?width=120&height=70)
