A 6.5 per cent expansion is still faster than most large economies manage. But the direction matters as much as the figure — and the direction has shifted
Business

A 6.5 per cent expansion is still faster than most large economies manage. But the direction matters as much as the figure — and the direction has shifted, driven almost entirely by forces outside India's control. New Delhi: India's economic momentum is running into a wall it did not build

Assam Dispur Election 2026: Pradyut Bordoloi is a seasoned politician as he has represented Assam’s Nagaon parliamentary constituency twice as a Congress MP
World

Assam Dispur Election 2026: Pradyut Bordoloi is a seasoned politician as he has represented Assam’s Nagaon parliamentary constituency twice as a Congress MP and four times as an MLA from the Margherita assembly seat. Assam Election 2026: When former Congress leader Pradyut Bordoloi

Prime Minister Narendra Modi is scheduled to unveil infrastructure, industrial, and cultural projects spanning several districts during his visit to Gujarat on
Politics

Prime Minister Narendra Modi is scheduled to unveil infrastructure, industrial, and cultural projects spanning several districts during his visit to Gujarat on Tuesday (March 31, 2026) The visit will begin in Koba village of Gandhinagar district, where the Mr

As the government signals that one of India’s longest-running internal conflicts may finally be nearing its end, the conversation around Naxalism is once
Latest News

As the government signals that one of India’s longest-running internal conflicts may finally be nearing its end, the conversation around Naxalism is once again in focus. Beyond politics and policy, the subject has also found space in cinema, though only occasionally

<h4 class=
Technology

6 straightforward prompts to try on Google Ask Maps to improve your search resultsGoogle claims that this new feature, powered by Gemini, “is fundamentally changing what a map can do.” Updated on: Mar 31, 2026 11:24 AM IST By Trisha Sengupta Share via Copy link Google has officially launched

<strong>Assembly elections 2026 live updates:</strong> After the Election Commission of India announced the schedule for the 2026 Assembly
World

Assembly elections 2026 live updates: After the Election Commission of India announced the schedule for the 2026 Assembly elections, political activity has intensified across Assam, West Bengal, Kerala, Tamil Nadu, and Puducherry. Assembly elections 2026 live updates: After the Election Commission

Mahavir Jayanti celebrates the birth of Lord Mahavir and reminds us to follow the path of non-violence, truth, and compassion in our lives
Life Style

Mahavir Jayanti celebrates the birth of Lord Mahavir and reminds us to follow the path of non-violence, truth, and compassion in our lives. Mahavir Jayanti is one of the most sacred festivals in Jainism, celebrating the birth of Lord Mahavir, the 24th Tirthankara

U.S. President Donald Trump has told his aides that he's willing to end the military operation against Iran even if the Strait of Hormuz remains largely closed
World

U.S. President Donald Trump has told his aides that he's willing to end the military operation against Iran even if the Strait of Hormuz remains largely closed, leaving the campaign to reopen it for a later date, the Wall Street Journal reported, citing administration officials.U.S

Where the Manchester derby was won and lost - tactical analysis

Posted By: Aditya Gogoi Posted On: Sep 15, 2025Share Article
It was a Manchester derby to forget for Ruben Amorim's Manchester United, with defeat at the Etihad meaning the Portuguese's Premier League record now reads eight wins from 31 matches.</b> But was Sunday's 3-0 loss a case of a faulty philosophy, individual mistakes, or an impressive performance from Manchester City?

It was a Manchester derby to forget for Ruben Amorim's Manchester United, with defeat at the Etihad meaning the Portuguese's Premier League record now reads eight wins from 31 matches.

But was Sunday's 3-0 loss a case of a faulty philosophy, individual mistakes, or an impressive performance from Manchester City?

Here we analyse the game, focusing on both teams' tactics.

City focused much of their play down the left-hand side in the first half.

Blues boss Pep Guardiola aimed to exploit weaknesses in United's defensive approach, with an eye on their back five, two central midfielders and the aggressive manner in which the wider centre-backs are asked to step out to press.

The hosts' left-back - Nico O'Reilly - took a wider position on the touchline, aiming to draw United right wing-back Noussair Mazraoui towards him.

Jeremy Doku - City's left winger - would ordinarily have been marked by Mazraoui, but as O'Reilly took the wide position, Doku was more central.

That gave Mazraoui the difficult task of knowing who to pick up. His decision was to ignore Doku and instead defend the wide spaces - stepping up to press O'Reilly when the ball went to him.

Doku's inside position ensured City had an overload around United's midfield.

Rodri, Phil Foden (who had dropped deeper), Doku (who had moved inside) and Tijjani Reijnders formed a box around United's midfield duo.

It was the same tactic Fulham used against United earlier this season, when Alex Iwobi vacated his left-wing position to create an overload in midfield.

With Doku infield, it was Leny Yoro - United's right centre-back - who was tasked with pushing up aggressively on him.

That is a difficult ask for a natural central defender, especially with Doku dropping as deep as his own half, and it was made more difficult as Foden also occupied those areas.

Yoro's front-footed defending made the midfield battle a four against three - rather than four against two - at times, but he would often retreat when City's players moved deeper as he did not want to end up too far from his backline.

By not committing entirely to backing up the press in a man-to-man fashion, United's press was disjointed - meaning City had a free man somewhere.

United captain Bruno Fernandes touched on this after the match, admitting his team needed to be "more brave with full pressure" to prevent the opening goal.

"City take that risk against us - we need to do the same," he said.

"I was trying to press Rodri because the aim of the midfielders was for one to jump on Rodri, with one of the defenders on Foden.

In the first moment, I can cover both but Leny comes up so I go more on Rodri. And Leny was going backwards because of a miscommunication and we end up giving too much space on the pitch.

A team-wide man-to-man press would ensure easy passing options aren't available for the opposition.

As Fernandes mentions, it was the job of one of the defenders - namely Yoro - to jump on Foden. But the clever positioning of O'Reilly and movement of Doku meant he was left in two minds.

Foden was able to receive the ball under no pressure and carry it up the pitch - a situation that was replicated later in the game.

City's use of pinning was particularly impressive.

Pinning is the act of positioning a player in a certain area with the result an opponent also has to stay there.

If a winger stands on the touchline next to the opposition full-back, for example, the defender is unlikely to leave that area as the attacker would be free. The winger has, therefore, 'pinned' the full-back.

City used pinning throughout Sunday's game to make United's aggressive defending tactics weaker, and to open up space for their attackers.

We've already spoken about how O'Reilly pinned Mazraoui to the touchline, leaving Doku free to move inside without being followed.

On the other flank, we saw clever movement from Reijnders on to Luke Shaw that prevented him from leaving the back five. As a result, Doku's unorthodox positioning - having vacated his flank - allowed him to pick up the ball unopposed.

Amorim asks his wide centre-backs to step out and apply pressure to the extra opposition player if United are outnumbered in midfield, but with Shaw stuck with Reijnders, City had Doku free.

Given time, Doku was able to turn and drive with the ball and provided the assist for the first goal.

For City's first goal, Fernandes and Manuel Ugarte were back in defensive positions, but the hosts were able to pick up the loose ball in the penalty area uncontested.

Late runs into the box had already resulted in goals against United this season, with Fulham's Emile Smith Rowe scoring in that manner last month. For both that goal and Foden's on Sunday, Fernandes failed to track the midfield run.

Fernandes plays in midfield for Amorim for his engine, industry, direct passing and ability to switch play. As a naturally attacking midfielder, his relative strengths don't include defensive awareness and tracking late runs.

Should he do better here? Probably. But it raises a bigger question as to whether United have platformed their individuals according to their strengths, while minimising their weaknesses.

Comparatively, Guardiola's use of Foden - as somebody who is capable of well-timed runs into the box - behind Erling Haaland was an intelligent choice that paid off.

After the match, much of the debate was focused on whether United's struggles are down to personnel or the system.

Better personnel always improves performance but United's struggles this season have also been down to their structure and the roles players have been asked to perform.

With better individuals, perhaps United's wide centre-backs would press man to man high up the pitch. But regardless of who plays, opponents would still be able to create midfield overloads by using the same rotations with which City and Fulham have found success.

If teams are finding specific ways to unpick a system, a manager failing to nullify that will concern fans.

Amorim, however, appears to be doubling down on his system.

Speaking after Sunday's game, he said: "When I want to change my philosophy, I will change. If not, you have to change the man."

But United's squad will not change before the January transfer window, so nullifying the above issues may need an adaptation to the system or players' roles.

Not for the first time, Guardiola showed on Sunday he has a willingness to adapt his system to maximise his players' strengths and minimise their weaknesses.

His use of new goalkeeper Gianluigi Donnarumma appeared to indicate they may adopt a more direct approach when building from the back.

That is perhaps something most may not associate with a Guardiola side but shows a manager can keep their broad philosophy while adapting a system to suit their players.

Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


Pakistan's role as intermediary in this conflict took many by surprise. The head of its armed forces, Field Marshall Asim Munir, is in US President Donald
World
How Pakistan won over Trump to become an unlikely mediator in the Iran war

Pakistan's role as intermediary in this conflict took many by surprise. The head of its armed forces, Field Marshall Asim Munir, is in US President Donald Trump's favour. The US leader frequently refers to him as his "favourite" Field Marshall and has previously spoken about how Munir knows Iran

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Entertainment
Hrithik Roshan's son Hridaan heads to California to study filmmaking at USC

Hrithik Roshan's son Hridaan Roshan to follow in dad's footsteps? 17-year-old heads to US to study filmmakingHrithik Roshan's younger son, Hridaan, has enrolled at the prestigious University of Southern California to study filmmaking. Mar 31, 2026

3 hours ago

Indian GM R Praggnanandhaa continued his steady start at the FIDE Candidates Tournament, playing out a composed draw with China’s Wei Yi in Round 2 to remain
Sports
FIDE Candidates 2026

Indian GM R Praggnanandhaa continued his steady start at the FIDE Candidates Tournament, playing out a composed draw with China’s Wei Yi in Round 2 to remain in joint lead with 1.5 points on Monday. Coming off an impressive opening-round win over Anish Giri

3 hours ago

<strong>Tamil Nadu Assembly Elections 2026: </strong>The battle lines are drawn and Tamil Nadu is ready for a high-stakes assembly election on
Politics
Tamil Nadu Election

Tamil Nadu Assembly Elections 2026: The battle lines are drawn and Tamil Nadu is ready for a high-stakes assembly election on April 23, which will move away from a traditionally bipolar to a three-cornered contest this time. Tamil Nadu’s 56.7 million-strong electorate is set to decide the future

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Stampede reported at Sheetla Temple in Bihar's Nalanda

Stampede reported at Sheetla Temple in Bihar's Nalanda; casualties fearedStampede reported at Sheetla Temple in Bihar's Nalanda; casualties feared Updated on: Mar 31, 2026 11:24 AM IST By HT News Desk Share via Copy link A stampede reportedly broke out at the Sheetla Temple in Nalanda, Bihar

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Am I being exploited

'Am I being exploited?': First-time employee questions 13-hour shift, just 2 leaves a monthA Reddit user claims their new job requires employees to inform management if they travel outside Kochi during their weekends. Updated on: Mar 31, 2026 11:21 AM IST By Trisha Sengupta Share via Copy link A

3 hours ago

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.<h4 class=
Technology
Mini home theatre under ₹20

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Mini home theatre under ₹20,000: Stream, play and watch on a bigger displayPlanning a home theatre on a budget? These mini projectors under Rs. 20,000 bring large screen viewing

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
KitKat theft sparks witty brand reactions on X

Meme of the day: KitKat theft becomes a marketing moment as brands flood X with witty reactionsBrands reacted with humour after a massive KitKat theft in Europe. Published on: Mar 31, 2026 11:11 AM IST By Mahipal Singh Chouhan Share via Copy link A massive shipment of KitKat chocolate bars has been

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Education
Karnataka 1st PUC Result 2026 declared at result

Karnataka 1st PUC Result 2026 declared at result.proed.in, direct link to check here Updated on: Mar 31, 2026 9:33 AM IST By HT Education Desk | Edited by Papri Chanda Prefer HTon Google Quick Read Share via Copy link The Karnataka School Examination and Assessment Board has declared the Karnataka

3 hours ago

Assam elections: Prime Minister Narendra Modi highlighted Assam's transformation from instability to peace and progress under the BJP government
Politics
Assam moved from violence to progress

Assam elections: Prime Minister Narendra Modi highlighted Assam's transformation from instability to peace and progress under the BJP government. He credited peace agreements for lasting stability, especially in Bodoland. Modi urged party workers to focus on booth-level engagement, voter education

3 hours ago

JSW Sports, the distinguished sports arm of Indian conglomerate JSW Group, has confirmed the signing of Niki Prasad, captain of India's ICC Women's U19 T20
Sports
JSW Sports signs U19 Women's T20 WC winning skipper Niki Prasad

JSW Sports, the distinguished sports arm of Indian conglomerate JSW Group, has confirmed the signing of Niki Prasad, captain of India's ICC Women's U19 T20 World Cup 2025 winning team. At just 20 years of age, Niki has already demonstrated exceptional leadership and consistency

3 hours ago

The United States is weighing military options to target Iran’s Kharg Island, a critical oil export hub, as tensions escalate in the Gulf
World
Seizing Kharg Island

The United States is weighing military options to target Iran’s Kharg Island, a critical oil export hub, as tensions escalate in the Gulf. Experts say while capturing the island may be feasible, sustaining control could prove far more challenging amid Iran’s military reach

3 hours ago

Korean Air says it is moving into emergency management mode to buffer the impact of surging jet fuel costs as the global economy is rocked by the ongoing
Business
Korean Air takes emergency action as fuel prices soar

Korean Air says it is moving into emergency management mode to buffer the impact of surging jet fuel costs as the global economy is rocked by the ongoing US-Israel war with Iran. A spokesperson for the national flag carrier said on Tuesday that it will implement "internal cost-reduction measures"

3 hours ago

Sanand (Gujarat) [India], March 31 (ANI): The Khele Sanand Season 3 came to a rousing end on March 30 as the Andej boys' team and the DG School girls' team
Latest News
Khele Sanand Season 3 comes to a rousing end with Andej

Sanand (Gujarat) [India], March 31 (ANI): The Khele Sanand Season 3 came to a rousing end on March 30 as the Andej boys' team and the DG School girls' team were crowned as U-14 Kabaddi champions. Taking on teams from Shela and Zamp in their respective finals

3 hours ago

Iran’s ability to continue fighting depends heavily on how long its missile and drone arsenal can sustain operations. According to Reuters
World
How Long Can Iran Fight

Iran’s ability to continue fighting depends heavily on how long its missile and drone arsenal can sustain operations. According to Reuters, US intelligence assesses that only about one-third of Iran’s missile stockpile has been definitively destroyed

3 hours ago

Star Portuguese footballer Bernardo Silva is set to leave Manchester City as his contract is nearing its end. The Portuguese star has offers from across the
Sports
Bernardo Silva All Set To Leave Manchester City As Contract Nears End

Star Portuguese footballer Bernardo Silva is set to leave Manchester City as his contract is nearing its end. The Portuguese star has offers from across the globe, but his preferred destination is clear: Barcelona. As per A Bola, Silva, who joined City in 2017

3 hours ago

CSK’s aggressive approach fails vs RR. Gaikwad and Hussey react after crushing IPL 2026 defeat. The Chennai Super Kings are already showing signs of trouble
Sports
Blame game in Chennai Super Kings

CSK’s aggressive approach fails vs RR. Gaikwad and Hussey react after crushing IPL 2026 defeat. The Chennai Super Kings are already showing signs of trouble after they lost to the Rajasthan Royals by 8 wickets. Captain Ruturaj Gaikwad and batting coach Mike Hussey have ideas about what went wrong

3 hours ago

India is rapidly witnessing an expansion of public policy education that teaches students such subjects as data analysis, impact assessment and policy
World
Many takers for public policy studies

India is rapidly witnessing an expansion of public policy education that teaches students such subjects as data analysis, impact assessment and policy implementation. The number of policy schools has risen from around 10 in 2016 to over 130 in 2024

3 hours ago

Amid the resounding success of “Dhurandhar
Entertainment
Amid Dhurandhar 2 Craze

Amid the resounding success of “Dhurandhar", author Harinder Sikka has expressed regret over the cinematic adaptation of his 2008 espionage novel Calling Sehmat, which inspired the 2018 film “Raazi" starring Alia Bhatt and directed by Meghna Gulzar. Sikka took to X

3 hours ago

The report from Deloitte India’s said the muted rise was due to subdued equity‑market performance, which reduced the value of stock‑linked compensation
Business
Indian CEOs’ median pay rises 5% to Rs 10

The report from Deloitte India’s said the muted rise was due to subdued equity‑market performance, which reduced the value of stock‑linked compensation — a significant component of executive pay. New Delhi: Median compensation for professional chief executives in India rose 5 per cent

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Sports
Who is Jaden Ivey's wife Caitlyn Newton

Who is Jaden Ivey's wife Caitlyn Newton? All about their family and children Published on: Mar 31, 2026 8:27 AM IST By Shirin Gupta Share via Copy link Ivey's remarks about NBA Pride events spark controversy, influencing interest in his family and relationship with wife, Caitlyn Newton

3 hours ago

Iranian Parliament Speaker Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf warned of a strong response to perceived enemy aggression amid US military build-ups in West Asia
World
Iranian Parliament Speaker warns enemy's threats

Iranian Parliament Speaker Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf warned of a strong response to perceived enemy aggression amid US military build-ups in West Asia. He accused adversaries of psychological operations and stated Iran would defend its rights, making the enemy regret their actions

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Life Style
Fitness trainer shares exact blueprint to lose 2kg in April without visiting gym

Fitness trainer shares exact blueprint to lose 2kg in April without visiting the gym: Lists home exercises with dumbbellIt is possible to stay on the fitness journey by consistently working out at home when going to the gym is not feasible, shares Divy Chheda. Updated on: Mar 31

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
BJP manifesto promises investment

Assam assembly polls: BJP manifesto promises ₹5 lakh crore investment, protection of indigenous peopleBJP's 'Sankalp Patra' comprises 31 promises, including the recovery of encroached land from Bangladeshi Miyas, bringing UCC, and ensuring development. Published on: Mar 31

3 hours ago

<strong>Quote of the day:</strong> Mahavir’s teaching reminds us to treat all beings with the same care and empathy we feel for ourselves
Life Style
Quote of the day by Bhagwan Mahavir

Quote of the day: Mahavir’s teaching reminds us to treat all beings with the same care and empathy we feel for ourselves, fostering compassion, equality, and inner harmony. Quote of the day: Mahavira (also known as Vardhamana) was the 24th and last Tirthankara of Jainism, born in 599 BCE in Bihar

3 hours ago

MELBOURNE, Australia (AP) — Australia’s online safety watchdog said Tuesday it was considering court against Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat
Latest News
Meta, Snapchat, TikTok and YouTube arent fully complying with child account ban, Australia says

MELBOURNE, Australia (AP) — Australia’s online safety watchdog said Tuesday it was considering court against Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat, TikTok and YouTube alleging they are not doing enough to keep Australian children younger than 16 off their platforms.MELBOURNE

3 hours ago

Nitesh Tiwari’s Ramayana, starring Ranbir Kapoor and Sai Pallavi in the lead roles, has had the audience waiting for the teaser for quite some time now
Entertainment
Ranbir Kapoor’s Ramayana Teaser Gets CBFC Clearance Ahead Of April 2 Release

Nitesh Tiwari’s Ramayana, starring Ranbir Kapoor and Sai Pallavi in the lead roles, has had the audience waiting for the teaser for quite some time now. With the makers locking April 2 as the release date of the film’s teaser, the audience can’t wait any longer

3 hours ago


Sing Up