Kiara Advani’s bodyguard recalls scary incident after a fan tried to hug her during pregnancy: ‘Sidharth was afraid’Kiara Advani’s bodyguard recalled a scary incident during her pregnancy when a fan tried to hug her, leading to a tense situation. Apr 25, 2026
BJP National President Nitin Nabin met and welcomed the Rajya Sabha MPs Raghav Chadha, Sandeep Pathak, and Ashok Mittal at the BJP Headquarters in Delhi after they joined the Bhartiya Janata Party. New Delhi: BJP National President Nitin Nabin met and welcomed the Rajya Sabha MPs Raghav Chadha
Indian Railways: Indian Railways periodically formulates rules to ensure the convenience of its passengers. For those traveling by train with young children, the rules regarding fares and seat bookings are determined based on the child’s age
Residents of Punjab are urged to stay calm as a high-risk civil defence mock drill is scheduled for April 24, from 8:00 PM to 8:15 PM. Chandigarh: Residents across Punjab are advised to remain calm as the state government prepares to conduct a high-risk civil defence mock drill tonight, April 24
RBI cancels Paytm Payments Bank licenceBacked by One97 Communications, Paytm Payments Bank secured a limited banking licence in August 2015 to take small deposits but not give out loans. Updated on: Apr 24, 2026 7:47 PM IST By HT Business Desk Share via Copy link The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has
Sheltering stray dogs is impractical when evidence shows India’s animal birth control rules work
The suggestion in court hearings and in recent media coverage that community dogs are a menace has come as a surprise to many of us working in international dog welfare and public health.
After years of measurable public-health progress, human-canine interactions in India appear to be as compassionate and tolerant as they have ever been.
Yet India is now being told it has a growing “dog problem”
This is not to suggest that there are no challenges – until there are zero human rabies deaths, no one can claim the job is done. But the tone of the debate does not reflect the data nor reality.
Rabies deaths and dog bites in India have declined substantially over the past two decades. A study published in The Lancet: Infectious Diseases in 2025 found that rabies deaths had fallen to around 5,700 per year in 2022 and 2023 as compared to 20,000 deaths per year reported in 2003.
The same study reported a dog bite incidence of 5.6 per 1,000 persons in 2022 and 2023, which is approximately three times lower than the incidence of 15.6 per 1,000 persons reported in 2003 using the same community survey methodology.
The Lancet study also called for accelerated action in India to reach the goal of eliminating rabies infections by 2030. The infection is caused by the rabies virus and transmitted through bites from infected dogs.
There are two key factors to consider.
First, there has been an apparent retreat from implementing the Indian government's Animal Birth Control Rules – capturing community dogs, sterilising and vaccinating them and then returning them to their habitats.
Second, there is a growing – misplaced – conviction that creating shelters for dogs on a large scale is a viable alternative to animal birth control measures.
The work of our organisation Humane World for Animals India in cities such as Vadodara, Dehradun and Lucknow over the past nine years has shown that sterilising 80% of the local stray dog populations led to a noticeable reduction in complaints about dog bites and aggression on helplines.
Similarly, Abodh Aras of the Mumbai-based The Welfare of Stray Dogs wrote in Scroll in August that consistent sterilisation has led to a stable and decreasing population of non-rabid street dogs in the city.
There is certainly a larger conversation to be had about the risks and fears arising from dog bites on passersby but abandoning the proven method of animal birth control in favour of sheltering is impractical and unsustainable.
I empathise with citizens demanding greater action. Nobody wants to fear being bitten by community dogs or rabies, to watch public money being wasted or see animals suffer. But sheltering is being presented as a false solution.
Shelters are governed by a harsh arithmetic of “input” and “output”. Intake into shelters does not stop when animals are rounded up for the first time. Dog populations rebound rapidly through breeding, immigration and abandonment: remove some dogs from the street and others soon take their place, overwhelming shelters quickly.
It also explains why culling is endless and ineffective, and demonstrates how animal birth control measures disrupt this cycle of continual replacement through sterilisation and return to prevent rebound.
The United States offers a sobering lesson in shelter economics. It spends over $3 billion a year on more than 4,000 shelters, serving around six million animals each year. Despite the dedicated efforts of staff and volunteers, over 600,000 dogs and cats are killed annually to make space for more animals relinquished by owners or offloaded by authorities who have removed them from the streets.
Britain is no better. The country has a history of the mass killing of stray dogs, like in the mid-18th century in London. This legacy lingers on in some Commonwealth countries where culling laws persist.
In India, too, the mass killing of stray dogs was regarded as the only viable solution until the introduction of animal birth control rules in 2001. These rules aimed to reduce population size by limiting birth rather than increasing death and followed the epidemiological principle of herd immunity, using the vaccination of dogs as the most effective weapon against rabies virus.
The Animal Birth Control Rules, 2023, strengthen the existing framework while also addressing concerns raised by the Supreme Court.
India's animal birth control measures have inspired similar animal-welfare movements worldwide.
South Asian countries like Thailand, Sri Lanka, Nepal and Bangladesh follow animal birth control measures, like in India. Bhutan has gone further, with royal leadership and an army of youth workers taking the lead, by claiming to have sterilised and vaccinated 100% of the country's community dog population.
Bhutan had previously tried to shelter stray dogs, which proved expensive and cost the lives of the animals. Culling dogs sporadically also clashed with the country's cultural emphasis on non-violence. The country turned to animal birth control, implementing it nationwide with success.
Where animal birth control is implemented professionally and at sufficient scale, it works.
In India, the challenge lies not in the method but in its inconsistent execution. In some Indian cities, animal birth control is applied reactively, in response to isolated complaints, or ignores entire neighbourhoods.
Other Indian cities have shown that animal birth control measures can reduce dog populations, dog bites and human rabies deaths when implemented comprehensively.
Like in Jaipur, where the efforts of an organisation called Help in Suffering have halved the community dog population since 1996, establishing herd immunity and significantly reducing rabies. A 2013 study found that in Jaipur, dog bites had also declined by more than half over the previous decade, not only because of lower dog numbers but because sterilisation reduces aggressive behaviour.
Seasonal bite analysis showed that many incidents were associated with mothers defending puppies from perceived threats and that widespread sterilisation sharply reduced these situations.
Evidence, ethics, economics
Putting away all stray dogs in shelters ignores the scale, cost and consequences of such an exercise. In the US, the minimum cost of sheltering and adopting a dog starts at around $380, or Rs 34,000, and it rises steeply with length of stay, behavioural and medical needs.
In contrast, most Indian municipalities spend less than Rs 2,000 per dog to sterilise, vaccinate and return a community dog, like in Lucknow, where the municipal corporation got 11,527 dogs sterilised and vaccinated between January-October 2025, paying about Rs 1,250 per dog.
Attempting to shelter India's vast population of community dogs living in public institutions such as schools, hospitals, and temples, is logistically and financially unfeasible, and risks leading to immense animal suffering.
India stands at a point where evidence, ethics and economics converge. The animal birth control framework, imperfectly implemented in some places yet undeniably successful where taken seriously, offers a proven, culturally-aligned public health intervention.
Sheltering is an illusory alternative: financially prohibitive, operationally unmanageable at scale, and unavoidably cruel.
The path forward is not to abandon animal birth control but to professionalise it by ensuring consistent city-wide coverage, sufficient intensity, rigorous monitoring and accountability from municipal authorities.
With political will and proper execution, India can strengthen and surpass the successes already achieved in India and abroad, protecting both people and animals, while staying true to the compassionate principles that inspired animal birth control measures in the first place.
Elly Hiby is the director of the International Companion Animal Management Coalition. Views expressed here are her own and do not necessarily reflect those of ICAM.
Source: Scroll
Related Posts: Smriti Mandhana's Suggestion Leads To Stadium Honors For Mithali Raj US Media Outlets Criticise Pentagon's New Restrictions On Media Coverage Trump says his negative media coverage is Trump says his negative media coverage is Recent Media Reports Are Premature FM Nirmala Sitharaman bats for wider NPS coverage Tamil Nadu Nears 100 Per Cent Coverage As SIR Form Deadline Ends Today Australian Open 2026 Coverage In India AP reporters go behind the story in discussing coverage of the Sean SIR document verification hearings spark anxiety among Matuas in Bengal
At least 23 ordinances—including key measures on human rights, judicial oversight, anti-corruption, and policing—have been repealed or allowed to lapse after failing to secure parliamentary approval within the constitutional timeframe. New Delhi: In a significant development
2 hours ago
Aquarius Horoscope Today for April 25, 2026: Today's cosmic shifts bring positive outcomes in your personal lifeAquarius Horoscope Today: If savings, investments, or trading are involved, avoid making major moves while unsettled. Published on: Apr 25
2 hours ago
The eldest son of the late Hollywood director Rob Reiner has told how his world "collapsed" after his parents were stabbed to death, and his own brother was charged with their murders. Jake Reiner, 34, wrote in a blog post that "nothing compares to losing both of them at the same time and
2 hours ago
Multilevel facility: ‘Poor infra, fire safety’, MC lists Sector-17 parking overhaulPointing to broken pathways, doors, window panes and rolling shutters, he directed officials to get them repaired without delay Published on: Apr 25, 2026 7:54 AM IST By HT Correspondent
2 hours ago
IPL 2026 DC vs PBKS Delhi police has issued traffic advisory for tomorrow. Check list of roads to avoid, diversion points, stadium entry gate numbers and free parking details. The Delhi Traffic Police has released a traffic advisory in view of the Day-Night IPL match scheduled for tomorrow
2 hours ago
Seven Aam Aadmi Party Rajya Sabha MPs have resigned from the party. Raghav Chadha and others stated the party has strayed from its founding principles. Delhi Chief Minister Rekha Gupta described the resignations as a blow to Arvind Kejriwal's leadership
2 hours ago
Iran is preparing an offer to meet United States demands. Peace talks are anticipated to restart in Pakistan soon. United States envoys will travel to Islamabad for discussions with an Iranian delegation. President Trump stated the U.S. military will maintain a blockade against Iran's ports until
2 hours ago
Reliance Q4 results 2026: Mukesh Ambani-led oil-to-telecom conglomerate Reliance Industries Ltd (RIL) declared its Q4 results 2026 on Friday evening. When the Reliance Q4 results 2026 were declared, the Indian stock market was closed, but the London Stock Exchange was open
2 hours ago
Ahaan Panday reveals what he learnt from superstar ‘uncle’ Shah Rukh Khan; talks about why there's ‘no one like him’Ahaan Panday, who grew up with Shah Rukh Khan's son Aryan Khan, talked about the superstar in a recent interview and said this. Apr 25, 2026
2 hours ago
Kohli led the 206-run chase with a commanding 81 off 44 balls, sharing a decisive stand with local favourite Devdutt Padikkal at the batting-friendly M. Chinnaswamy Stadium, sealing the win in 18.5 overs. Put in to bat, Gujarat opener Sudharsan dominated the Bengaluru attack from the outset
2 hours ago
Patrick Mahomes gives thumbs up as Chiefs draft LSU star Mansoor Delane at No. 6Patrick Mahomes expressed excitement over the Chiefs selecting LSU cornerback Mansoor Delane with the No. 6 pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. Updated on: Apr 25, 2026 7:42 AM IST Edited by HT Global Sports Desk Share via Copy
2 hours ago
LONDON (AP) — Running past Buckingham Palace during training, Tilly Dowler is closing in on a goal she once thought out of reach. Dowler, who has Stargardt disease and says she has about 10% useful vision, only began running last year, starting with a couch to 5K program before building up to
2 hours ago
European Trade Commissioner Maros Sefcovic discussed U.S. sanctions relief on Russian oil with U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent. Sefcovic understood the relief was temporary, addressing difficulties faced by lower-income nations due to Strait of Hormuz closures
2 hours ago
Brain teaser: Can this tricky puzzle really predict your thoughts? Internet says yesA brain teaser stunned internet users as many got the same answer after following simple maths steps. Published on: Apr 24, 2026 9:59 PM IST By Mahipal Singh Chouhan Share via Copy link Brain teasers have long
2 hours ago
The Gauhati High Court on Friday rejected Congress leader Pawan Khera’s plea for anticipatory bail. In a setback for Pawan Khera, the Gauhati High Court on Friday rejected the Congress leader’s plea for anticipatory bail in the case recently registered against him by the Crime Branch of Assam
2 hours ago
A Delhi court on Friday dismissed an interim bail petition of jailed Lok Sabha MP Abdul Rashid Sheikh to meet his father, who is critically ill, PTI reported. Sheikh, who is popularly known as Engineer Rashid, has been in jail since August 2019 in connection with a terror-funding case filed by the
2 hours ago
Ahead of the India Africa Forum Summit, officials urged deeper engagement with African financial institutions and enhanced insurance for projects. India's commitment to Africa's development is evident in its expanding diplomatic presence and significant overseas development assistance
2 hours ago
Union Home Minister Amit Shah declared that the BJP will prevent the construction of a "Babri Masjid" in West Bengal as long as a single party worker remains alive. He accused Mamata Banerjee of permitting a mosque modeled on the Babri Masjid in Murshidabad
2 hours ago
China’s DeepSeek Launches Long-Awaited AI ModelChina’s DeepSeek launched preview versions of its long-awaited V4 model, breaking months of silence from one of the country’s most closely watched AI labs. Published on: Apr 24, 2026 6:59 PM IST WSJ Share via Copy link China’s DeepSeek launched
2 hours ago
The Union government on Friday said that of the 26 Indians whose families had moved the Supreme Court seeking their safe return from Russia, 10 have died while fighting the war in Ukraine, reported Live Law. Most of them had joined the Russian military voluntarily, the Centre claimed
2 hours ago
Iran’s military might was never going to be a match for the US and Israel. So instead it turned to the highly effective weapon it has at its disposal – geography. Blocking off the Strait of Hormuz has shaken the global economy. It has doubled the price of a barrel of crude oil
2 hours ago
The seven-times Grand Slam champion picked up the injury in the first round of the Barcelona Open earlier this month before withdrawing from the tournament. Scans showed the issue was more serious than initially thought, after which the 22-year-old also withdrew from the Madrid Open
2 hours ago
High court orders rape accused to pay Rs75,000 monthly to victim, child in KarnatakaThe court directed the accused to either pay the amount himself if he had the means to do so, or, get his parents to pay the amount. Updated on: Apr 25, 2026 7:34 AM IST By Ayesha Arvind Share via Copy link The
2 hours ago
India to host a three-day Heads of Mission meet on West Asia tensions, Strait of Hormuz crisis, US-Iran standoff and possible non-career envoy appointments. The impact of the ongoing tensions in West Asia on regional economies, diplomacy, and shifting geopolitical alignments will dominate
2 hours ago
India Palm Oil Crisis: Indonesia, the world’s largest palm oil producer, will now use it to make diesel instead of exporting it. India imports 90% of its palm oil, which is used in everything from soap and biscuits to chips and shampoo. Palm Oil crisis: The Iran war could lead to another major
2 hours ago
Stop switching apps: You can now recharge your Jio or Airtel plan while chatting on WhatsAppBut there's a catch. This feature is being rolled out for prepaid users only. Updated on: Apr 24, 2026 4:55 PM IST Share via Copy link Recharging your mobile numbers is about to get a whole lot easier in
2 hours ago
“Go Beyond Classrooms,” says Gurugram’s Advit Agarwal after scoring 99.8% in CBSE 10th exam - check study tipsAdvit Agarwal of Gurugram shares his study tips, preparation strategy and message to juniors for scoring highest marks. Published on: Apr 24
2 hours ago
