<h4 class=
Entertainment

Riteish Deshmukh on his relationship with paparazzi: I have never refused a pap pic till date because…Actor Riteish Deshmukh shares insights on his relationship with paparazzi, highlighting the effort they put into their work. Published on: May 09

<h4 class=
Sports

WFI issues show-cause notice to Vinesh Phogat, accuses her of multiple breaches; grappler barred from competingWFI declares Vinesh Phogat ineligible to compete till June 26. A show-cause notice has also been issued. Updated on: May 09, 2026 2:38 PM IST By Vishesh Roy Share via Copy link The

The image of a doctor has traditionally been a professional grounded in anatomy, pharmacology, pathology, and clinical skill. For decades
Education

The image of a doctor has traditionally been a professional grounded in anatomy, pharmacology, pathology, and clinical skill. For decades, this depth of knowledge has defined medical excellence. But healthcare in the 21st century is no longer a closed clinical ecosystem; it is shaped by artificial

Flood hazard assessments for Uttarakhand have routinely underestimated the danger to its towns and villages because they have leaned on long-term average
Science

Flood hazard assessments for Uttarakhand have routinely underestimated the danger to its towns and villages because they have leaned on long-term average rainfall figures rather than the extreme downpours that actually trigger disasters, according to a study in Current Science

Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing () and Corp., on Friday, announced plans to establish a joint venture in Kumamoto, Japan, to develop and produce
Technology

Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing () and Corp., on Friday, announced plans to establish a joint venture in Kumamoto, Japan, to develop and produce next-generation image sensors.According to a report by Focus Taiwan, the two companies signed a non-binding memorandum of understanding (MOU) to

Bharatiya Janata Party leader Suvendu Adhikari on Saturday took oath as the chief minister of West Bengal. He became the first BJP leader to hold the post
Politics

Bharatiya Janata Party leader Suvendu Adhikari on Saturday took oath as the chief minister of West Bengal. He became the first BJP leader to hold the post. Adhikari was sworn-in five days after the BJP defeated the Trinamool Congress in the Assembly elections

Delivering for your nation at a World Cup brings heightened pressure, and doing so at a home tournament takes the expectation up to a whole new level
Sports

Delivering for your nation at a World Cup brings heightened pressure, and doing so at a home tournament takes the expectation up to a whole new level. Red Roses prop Maud Muir did just that last September, winning a home Rugby World Cup with England in front of a record women's rugby crowd of 81

The Enforcement Directorate on Saturday conducted searches at five locations in Delhi, Gurugram and Chandigarh linked to Punjab Cabinet minister Sanjeev Arora
World

The Enforcement Directorate on Saturday conducted searches at five locations in Delhi, Gurugram and Chandigarh linked to Punjab Cabinet minister Sanjeev Arora and his company on suspicion of alleged money laundering, The Hindu reported. The searches were conducted at the office premises of Hampton

SC asks if it can remain idle when governors fail in their duty, reserves verdict on presidential reference

Posted By: Jogendra Kumar Posted On: Sep 11, 2025Share Article
The Supreme Court, acting as the Constitution's custodian, questioned its inaction if a Governor fails in their duties, while reserving judgment on presidential reference regarding bill assent. A Constitution bench, led by CJI Gavai, heard arguments on whether courts can set timelines for Governors and the President to approve bills.

The Supreme Court, acting as the Constitution's custodian, questioned its inaction if a Governor fails in their duties, while reserving judgment on presidential reference regarding bill assent. A Constitution bench, led by CJI Gavai, heard arguments on whether courts can set timelines for Governors and the President to approve bills.

Calling itself the "custodian of the Constitution", the Supreme Court on Thursday asked if it could "sit idle" if a constitutional functionary like Governor failed to discharge duties as it reserved the verdict on the presidential reference on grant of assent to bills.

In the marathon hearings spanning 10 days, a Constitution bench of headed by Chief Justice B R Gavai heard legal luminaries including Attorney General R Venkataramani, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta and senior advocates Kapil Sibal, Abhishek Singhvi, Gopal Subramanium, Arvind Datar and others on the presidential reference which centered around Article 200 and 201 and the key issue whether constitutional court can impose timelines for governors and President to assent to bills.

On the last day, the bench, also comprising Justices Surya Kant, Vikram Nath, P S Narasimha and A S Chandurkar, interjected Mehta when he referred to the separation of powers as one of the basic structures of the Constitution and said the court should not fix timelines and interfere with the discretionary powers of governors.

"Whosoever high one may be, as a custodian of the Constitution (refers to SC)... I have publicly said that I am a firm believer in the doctrine of separation of powers and though judicial activism has to be there, there should not be judicial terrorism or adventurism. But at the same time, if one wing of democracy fails to discharge its duty, is the custodian of the Constitution powerless and would sit idle?" the CJI asked.

Mehta said, "Not only the court, the executive is also a custodian of the fundamental rights of citizens...Legislature is also custodian, all three organs."

The law officer went on, "But, issuing mandamus (a writ asking a person to perform a public duty) to governors with regard to the legislatively discretionary functions of a coordinate constitutional functionary would violate the theory of separation of powers and this separation of power is a part of basic structure."

Mehta said while governors couldn't sit perpetually over a bill, it didn't mean they lacked discretionary powers under Article 200 and timelines could be fixed for granting assent as a "straitjacket formula".

He went on to outline governors' discretionary powers even in the case of promulgation of ordinance by the state government.

Assailing the submissions of opposition-ruled states which stressed Governor ought to act on the aid and advice of the council of ministers only, Mehta asked, "Suppose a state legislature passes a bill declaring it will no longer be a part of the Union of India, the Governor has no choice but to withhold assent."

He underscored the constitutional discretion to governors and President in certain contexts, though he said their actions were ordinarily guided by ministerial aid and advice.

Article 200, he said, provides Governor four options on bills and contains implied discretion, particularly in situations where a bill undermines constitutional values or carries national implications.

The law officer said the term "as soon as possible" used in Article 200 cannot mean indefinitely.

He reiterated 90 per cent of the bills passed by state assemblies since 1970 have received gubernatorial assent within a month whereas assents were withheld by governors only in 20 instances of the total 17,150 bills.

Addressing the absence of express timelines in the constitutional text, Mehta said it reflected "cautious choice of words" rather than vacuum.

"This system has functioned in harmony for decades. Only recently, with the NCT Delhi episode, has litigation on this issue proliferated," he added.

He said there was no vacuum in the constitutional scheme where the court should step in and fix timelines for governors.

The court would likely opine on the 14 questions referred to by President Droupadi Murmu, including whether constitutional authorities could indefinitely withhold assent to bills and if courts could impose mandatory time frames.

The issues essentially relate to Article 200 which governs powers of Governor regarding bills passed by the state legislature, allowing them to either assent to the bill, withhold assent, return the bill for reconsideration or reserve the bill for the consideration of the President.

Add as a Reliable and Trusted News Source Add Now! In May, President Murmu exercised powers under Article 143(1) to know from the top court whether judicial orders could impose timelines for the exercise of discretion by the President while dealing with bills passed by state assemblies.


Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


<h4 class=
Latest News
IIT Kharagpur students make mango pickle using storm-fallen raw mangoes

IIT Kharagpur students make mango pickle using storm-fallen raw mangoes, internet says ‘sarv gun sampann’An IIT Kharagpur student showed how fallen raw mangoes were turned into pickle inside a hostel. Published on: May 09, 2026 4:19 PM IST By Mahipal Singh Chouhan Share via Copy link A student

1 days ago

A now-viral post on Reddit has triggered a debate on why more men seemingly want marriage and children, while more women are increasingly choosing to remain
Latest News
Men Want Kids And Women Do Not

A now-viral post on Reddit has triggered a debate on why more men seemingly want marriage and children, while more women are increasingly choosing to remain childfree. The post, originally shared on the Reddit community r/childfree, quickly spread across social media platforms and drew thousands of

1 days ago

<b>University of Surrey GREAT Scholarships India</b> Offered by the University of Surrey, the U.K., in partnership with the British Council under
Education
May 9, 2026

University of Surrey GREAT Scholarships India Offered by the University of Surrey, the U.K., in partnership with the British Council under the GREAT Britain Campaign. Eligibility: Indian citizens with a valid passport who have an unconditional offer to pursue a full-time postgraduate course from

1 days ago

<h4 class=
World
Who is Suzy Lamb

Who is Suzy Lamb? Joni Lamb's daughter-in-law opens up about anger, loss after her death: 'I really hate...'Joni Lamb's passing brings attention to her family, particularly son Jonathan and wife Suzy, who have a complex relationship with Daystar TV. Updated on: May 09

1 days ago

The sky’s blue is due to Rayleigh scattering — when molecules in the air scatter light of shorter wavelength (bluer) much more efficiently than that of
Science
On hotter days

The sky’s blue is due to Rayleigh scattering — when molecules in the air scatter light of shorter wavelength (bluer) much more efficiently than that of longer ones. On hotter days, however, there can be other things in the air and which can affect how light is scattered

1 days ago

A cyber attack hit several universities and schools in the US, Canada and Australia, causing chaos, confusion and major disruptions amid the high stakes
Business
International cyber attack disrupts swathe of universities and schools

A cyber attack hit several universities and schools in the US, Canada and Australia, causing chaos, confusion and major disruptions amid the high stakes end-of-year season. The hacking group ShinyHunters claimed responsibility for the attack

1 days ago

Senior Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader Nisith Pramanik on Saturday took oath as a cabinet minister in the new West Bengal government to be helmed by chief
Politics
Who Is Cooch Behar Strongman Nisith Pramanik

Senior Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) leader Nisith Pramanik on Saturday took oath as a cabinet minister in the new West Bengal government to be helmed by chief minister Suvendu Adhikari, days after the saffron party stormed to power in the state. Pramanik

1 days ago

Hantavirus infections have come under renewed global scrutiny following a recent outbreak aboard the Dutch-flagged cruise ship MV Hondius
Life Style
What Is The Treatment Of Hantavirus

Hantavirus infections have come under renewed global scrutiny following a recent outbreak aboard the Dutch-flagged cruise ship MV Hondius, which was travelling across the southern Atlantic with multiple port stops. As of Friday, Health authorities have reported confirmed and suspected cases among

1 days ago

Vladimir Putin has used his annual Victory Day speech in Moscow's Red Square to justify his war in Ukraine and denounce Nato. Speaking in front of hundreds of
Latest News
Putin denounces Nato at scaled back Victory Day parade

Vladimir Putin has used his annual Victory Day speech in Moscow's Red Square to justify his war in Ukraine and denounce Nato. Speaking in front of hundreds of military personnel and flanked by a few world leaders, the Russian president said he was fighting a "just" war and called Ukraine an

1 days ago

The U.S. announced Project Freedom on May 4 to end the Iranian blockade of the Strait of Hormuz. It was suspended the next day even as merchant ships and U.S
World
Why U.S. Project Freedom couldn’t secure free navigation in Strait of Hormuz

The U.S. announced Project Freedom on May 4 to end the Iranian blockade of the Strait of Hormuz. It was suspended the next day even as merchant ships and U.S. Navy craft came under attack. Though U.S. President Donald Trump cited progress in negotiations with Iran as the reason for calling off the

1 days ago

The United States said on Friday (May 9, 2026) it was organising an evacuation flight for Americans on a hantavirus-struck cruise ship that has sailed to the
World
U.S. plans evacuation flight for Americans on hantavirus ship

The United States said on Friday (May 9, 2026) it was organising an evacuation flight for Americans on a hantavirus-struck cruise ship that has sailed to the Canary Islands, which are part of Spain. “The Department of State is arranging a repatriation flight to support the safe return of American

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Business
Samsung launches fifth edition of Solve for Tomorrow

Samsung launches fifth edition of Solve for Tomorrow, raises winning grants to ₹2 croreLaunching Solve for Tomorrow 2026, Samsung increases grants to ₹2 crore for youth innovation in tech solutions. Updated on: May 09, 2026 12:59 PM IST By Aditi Anand Share via Copy link Samsung has launched

1 days ago

Indian Grandmaster Abhijeet Gupta has approached the Sports Ministry seeking intervention over alleged non-payment of prize money from the organisers of the
Sports
India Grandmaster Approaches Sports Ministry

Indian Grandmaster Abhijeet Gupta has approached the Sports Ministry seeking intervention over alleged non-payment of prize money from the organisers of the Odisha Open 2026. Gupta says he was assured the winnings would be released within a month of his victory in January this year

1 days ago

Indian cricketers Yashasvi Jaiswal and Shafali Verma have received notices from the National Anti-Doping Agency. This follows their failure to be available for
Sports
Indian cricketers Yashasvi Jaiswal

Indian cricketers Yashasvi Jaiswal and Shafali Verma have received notices from the National Anti-Doping Agency. This follows their failure to be available for scheduled dope tests last year. Both players are part of NADA's Registered Testing Pool

1 days ago

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.<h4 class=
Life Style
These stunning kurta pant sets are now up to 80% off

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.These stunning kurta pant sets are now up to 80% off: Picksfrom top brands for womenAmazon Great Summer Sale 2026 brings up to 80% off on stylish kurta pant sets

1 days ago

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.<h4 class=
Technology
Running out of space

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Still using a single-door fridge? These side-by-side refrigerators may fix summer storage problemsRunning out of fridge space this summer? These side-by-side refrigerators offer

1 days ago

Thalapathy Vijay’s bodyguard, Aroon Suresh, recently took to the stories section of his Instagram handle and penned down a positive cryptic note
Entertainment
Vijay's Bodyguard Pens Cryptic Note Ahead Of TVK Chief's Oath Taking

Thalapathy Vijay’s bodyguard, Aroon Suresh, recently took to the stories section of his Instagram handle and penned down a positive cryptic note. Though Suresh did not mention TVK Chief’s name, he shared a message that read, “Beautiful outcomes come after hard battles

1 days ago

<h4 class=
World
US flight hits pedestrian on runway

Frontier Airlines flight hits pedestrian on runway, leads to engine fire: What we knowThe Frontier Airlines flight, an Airbus A321, was carrying 224 passengers and seven crew members at the time of the incident. Updated on: May 09, 2026 4:59 PM IST Written by Majid Alam Share via Copy link A flight

1 days ago

For the longest time, global gourmet culture carried a certain predictability. Luxury was associated with imported cheeses, European techniques
Life Style
Desi Was Always Gourmet

For the longest time, global gourmet culture carried a certain predictability. Luxury was associated with imported cheeses, European techniques, exotic berries flown across continents, and ingredients that sounded sophisticated simply because they were foreign. Meanwhile, some of the most layered

1 days ago

National Commission for Women Chairperson Vijaya Rahatkar on Friday said that the panel will recommend to the Union government a complete ban on parole for
World
Women’s commission to seek ban on parole for those convicted of rape

National Commission for Women Chairperson Vijaya Rahatkar on Friday said that the panel will recommend to the Union government a complete ban on parole for those convicted in cases of rape, aggravated sexual assault and other serious offences against women and children, PTI reported

1 days ago

Newly sworn-in West Bengal Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari held a crucial meeting with top officials. He reviewed the state's law and order situation
Politics
Suvendu Adhikari reviews law and order

Newly sworn-in West Bengal Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari held a crucial meeting with top officials. He reviewed the state's law and order situation. Discussions also covered the smooth continuation of schemes from the previous government. Progress on Writers' Buildings renovation was also a key

1 days ago

After almost eight months away from competition, Neeraj Chopra is finally inching closer to a return — but not before completely rebuilding his body first
Sports
When Will Neeraj Chopra Return To Action

After almost eight months away from competition, Neeraj Chopra is finally inching closer to a return — but not before completely rebuilding his body first. The 28-year-old from Panipat hasn’t competed since finishing eighth at the 2025 World Athletics Championships in Tokyo last September

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
NPF farmers' wing to undertake statewide inquiry tour across Nagaland

NPF farmers' wing to undertake statewide inquiry tour across NagalandNPF farmers' wing to undertake statewide inquiry tour across Nagaland Published on: May 09, 2026 5:30 PM IST PTI Share via Copy link Kohima, The ruling Naga People's Front's farmers' wing on Saturday announced a statewide tour to

1 days ago

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.<h4 class=
Technology
Need a fitness smartwatch without overspending

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Need a fitness smartwatch without overspending? Best picks under ₹5000 you should considerFrom AMOLED displays to Bluetooth calling and fitness tracking, these smartwatches under ₹5

1 days ago

A now-viral post alleging misconduct by an Uber parcel delivery driver has sparked outrage online, with several users raising concerns about the safety and
Latest News
Uber Parcel Driver Allegedly Marks Delivery As Failed

A now-viral post alleging misconduct by an Uber parcel delivery driver has sparked outrage online, with several users raising concerns about the safety and reliability of app-based parcel services in India. The post shared on X by user Yusuf DFI claimed that one of his staff members had booked an

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Indian man in Singapore warns of ‘comfort trap’ after 7 years abroad

Indian man in Singapore warns of ‘comfort trap’ after 7 years abroad: ‘Don’t let your lifestyle become your cage’An Indian man in Singapore said expats stayed longer abroad after getting addicted to comfort and efficiency. Published on: May 09

1 days ago

Have you ever noticed how sometimes a simple look or a shared smile with your partner can make you feel instantly closer? It’s easy to think that intimacy is
Life Style
Everyday Habits That Can Help Strengthen Your Relationship And Intimacy

Have you ever noticed how sometimes a simple look or a shared smile with your partner can make you feel instantly closer? It’s easy to think that intimacy is all about what happens in the moment, but in reality, it’s often shaped by the small, everyday choices we make. The way we move, eat

1 days ago


Sing Up