In an unprecedented twist, soccer enthusiasts in India and China are bracing for a World Cup viewing crisis. Negotiations for broadcast rights in India remain unresolved, while China is yet to clarify its stance. With the tournament's kickoff just around the corner
From Mumbai’s ambitious, sound-inspired Pan-Asian sanctuaries to the secret speakeasies of New Delhi and the artisanal pizza workshops of Bengaluru, here are the essential coordinates for your May social calendar. Specialty Restaurants Limited brings its progressive Pan-Asian vision to Bandra
Filing your income-tax returns (ITR) have become more accessible over the past few years with the full process available online via the Income-Tax (I-T) website. However, there are a lot of things that can be confusing for first-time taxpayers
Puducherry Chief Minister N Rangasamy on Monday won the Assembly election from the Thattanchavady constituency, defeating E Vinayagam of the Neyam Makkal Kazhagam. Rangasamy, the chief of the All India NR Congress, garnered 10,024 votes. He defeated Vinayagam by 4,441 votes
Seven killed in four road accidents in JharkhandSeven killed in four road accidents in Jharkhand Published on: May 04, 2026 5:17 PM IST PTI Share via Copy link Ranchi, Seven people, including three minors, were killed in four road accidents in Jharkhand over the past 24 hours, police said on Monday
New Delhi, Imposing fixed timelines on governors and the president to act on bills passed by a state Assembly would amount to one organ of the government assuming powers not vested in it by the Constitution and lead to a "constitutional disorder", the Centre has told the Supreme Court.
New Delhi, Imposing fixed timelines on governors and the president to act on bills passed by a state Assembly would amount to one organ of the government assuming powers not vested in it by the Constitution and lead to a "constitutional disorder", the Centre has told the Supreme Court.
The Centre has said this in the written submissions filed in the Presidential Reference raising constitutional issues on whether timelines could be imposed for dealing with bills passed by a state Assembly.
"The alleged failure, inaction or error of one organ does not and cannot authorise another organ to assume powers that the Constitution has not vested in it. If any organ is permitted to arrogate to itself the functions of another on a plea of public interest or institutional dissatisfaction or even on the justification derived from the Constitution ideals, the consequence would be a constitutional disorder not envisaged by its framers," it has said.
The note filed by Solicitor General Tushar Mehta has argued that the apex court imposing fixed timelines would dissolve the delicate equilibrium that the Constitution has established and negate the rule of law.
"The perceived lapses, if any, are to be addressed through constitutionally-sanctioned mechanisms, such as electoral accountability, legislative oversight, executive responsibility, reference procedures or consultative process amongst democratic organs etc. Thus, Article 142 does not empower the court to create a concept of 'deemed assent', turning the constitutional and legislative process on its head," the note says.
The positions of the governor and president are "politically plenary" and represent "high ideals of democratic governance". Any perceived lapses, the note says, must be addressed through political and constitutional mechanisms, and not necessarily through "judicial" interventions.
The perceived issues, if any, deserve political answers and not necessarily judicial, Mehta has submitted.
Challenging the decision of the apex court, Mehta has contended that Articles 200 and 201, which deal with the governors' and president's alternatives after receiving a state bill, deliberately contain no timelines.
"When the Constitution seeks to impose time limits for taking certain decisions, it specifically mentions such time limits. Where it has consciously kept the exercise of powers flexible, it does not impose any fixed time limit. To judicially read in such a limitation would be to amend the Constitution," Mehta has said.
Despite the proliferation of checks and balances, there are certain zones that remain exclusive to either of the three organs of the State and cannot be trenched upon by the others, the note says, adding that the high plenary positions of governors and the president fall within that zone.
"The gubernatorial assent is a high prerogative, plenary, non-justiciable power which is sui generis in nature. Although the power of assent is exercised by the person at the apex of the Executive, however, the assent itself is legislative in nature.
"This blended and unique nature of assent clothes it with a constitutional character, whereby no judicially-manageable standards exist. Thus, despite the expanding contours of judicial review, there are some zones like assent that remain non-justiciable. The classical notion of judicial review cannot be lifted and applied to assent as the factors at play during the grant or withholding of an assent have no legal or constitutional parallel. The unique duality of assent, thus, deserves a uniquely-calibrated judicial approach," the note says.
The top court has fixed a time schedule for hearing the Presidential Reference and proposed to start the hearing from August 19.
A five-judge bench headed by Chief Justice of India B R Gavai has asked the Centre and states to file their written submissions.
Asking the parties to strictly adhere to the timeline, the bench, also comprising Justices Surya Kant, Vikram Nath, P S Narasimha and A S Chandurkar, has said it will first hear the preliminary objections filed by states like Kerala and Tamil Nadu, questioning the maintainability of the Presidential Reference, for an hour on August 19.
The court has said the Centre and the states supporting the Presidential Reference will be heard on August 19, 20, 21 and 26, while those opposing it will be heard on August 28 and September 2, 3 and 9.
In May, President Droupadi Murmu exercised powers under Article 143 to know from the top court whether timelines could be imposed by judicial orders for the exercise of discretion by the president while dealing with bills passed by state assemblies.
The president's decision came in light of an April 8 verdict of the apex court that was delivered in a matter over the powers of the governor in dealing with bills that were questioned by the Tamil Nadu government.
The verdict, for the first time, prescribed that the president should decide on the bills reserved for her consideration by the governor within three months from the date on which such a reference is received.
In a five-page reference, Murmu posed 14 questions to the Supreme Court and sought to know its opinion on the powers of the governor and president under Articles 200 and 201 in dealing with bills passed by the state legislature.
The verdict had set a timeline for all governors to act on the bills passed by the state assemblies and ruled that the governors do not possess any discretion in the exercise of functions under Article 200 in respect to any bill presented to them and must mandatorily abide by the advice tendered by the council of ministers.
It had said state governments can directly approach the Supreme Court if the president withholds assent on a bill sent by a governor for consideration.
This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.
Source: HindustanTimes
Related Posts: SC Says Courts Cannot Fix Timelines For President Or Governors On Bill Assent SC reserves verdict on presidential reference over timelines for governors No timelines for governors Former South Korean President Yoon receives life sentence for imposing martial law Tamil Nadu, West Bengal get new governors ahead of polls PM Modi Accuses Congress Govt In Himachal Of Imposing New Cement Tax Despite Lower GST Rates SC verdict may embolden governors to stall decisions in opposition-ruled states Eyes on Governors’ Republic Day speech in three southern states SC asks if it can remain idle when governors fail in their duty
What a day and what a pattern for Italy’s brightest sporting stars. Jannik Sinner and Kimi Antonelli both claimed massive wins yesterday in their respective sports, continuing one of the most bizarre and brilliant coincidences in modern sport. Let’s break it down
1 days ago
Gold prices decline as US Hormuz plan, Iran peace talks elevate hopesThe Iran-US war has kept energy prices elevated, dimming hopes for interest-rate cuts by central banks, a negative for non-yielding bullion. Published on: May 04, 2026 4:03 PM IST Bloomberg Share via Copy link Gold fell
1 days ago
IndiGo's Head of Global Sales Vinay Malhotra on Monday (May 4, 2026) resigned to pursue opportunities outside the airline. Mr. Malhotra will step down from his position and be relieved of his duties effective at the close of business hours on July 3, IndiGo said in a regulatory filing
1 days ago
New Mexico State prosecutors are seeking fundamental changes to Meta's social media apps and algorithms to safeguard children in the second phase of a landmark trial on allegations that platforms such as Instagram have created a public safety hazard
1 days ago
Yamaha has revised the colour palette of the R25 in Malaysia with two options – Icon Blue and Mint Green. Here’s all you need to know about the new colours, and other specifications of the new R25. Yamaha has launched the 2026 YZF-R25 in Malaysia with new colour options – Icon Blue and Mint
1 days ago
Union Minister Giriraj Singh announces plan to transform Mizoram into hub of Muga silk productionUnion Minister Giriraj Singh announces plan to transform Mizoram into hub of Muga silk production Published on: May 04, 2026 5:10 PM IST PTI Share via Copy link Aizawl
1 days ago
In a moment that feels bigger than sport, North Korea’s Naegohyang Women’s FC will travel south to face Suwon FC Women on May 20, marking the first visit by North Korean athletes to South Korea in eight years. The semi-final of the AFC Women’s Champions League will take place at the Suwon
1 days ago
The 51-year-old leader of Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam made a significant impact in his maiden electoral debut and proved that the electoral battle was a straight contest between the TVK and DMK. Chennai: Actor-politician Vijay's electoral debut, as his appearance in his films, was packed with suspense
1 days ago
The Prime Ministers of Japan and Australia agreed to deepen cooperation in a wide range of areas, including energy security, defence and critical minerals, as the Iran war threatens global supply chains. Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi met her Australian counterpart Anthony Albanese at
1 days ago
Assam Election Results: The BJP is poised to win the Assam Assembly elections, bucking anti-incumbency trends seen elsewhere. Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma's campaign, focused on infrastructure, welfare, and protecting indigenous identity, appears to have resonated strongly with voters
1 days ago
Ranchi, May 4 (PTI) Seven people, including three minors, were killed in four road accidents in Jharkhand over the past 24 hours, police said on Monday. In Giridih district, on Monday, two persons, including an 8-year-old minor girl, were killed, and around 14 to 15 others suffered injuries
1 days ago
A Gurgaon-based professional’s candid post about struggling to make ends meet in Gurgaon on an annual salary of Rs 11 lakh has struck a chord online, triggering a broader discussion on compensation, taxes, and work-life balance. Shared on the r/IndianWorkplace subreddit
1 days ago
The counting of votes in the bye-elections to seven Assembly seats in five states was underway on Monday. In Maharashtra, Deputy Chief Minister and Nationalist Congress Party chief Sunetra Pawar was ahead by 1,50,342 votes against New Rashtriya Samaj Party RY Ghutukade in the Baramati Assembly seat
1 days ago
Reliance Jio has reshaped its prepaid plans for feature phone users and the Mukesh Ambani-owned company has introduced a new category called ‘4G Feature Phone Plans’, replacing older offerings and streamlining its lineup. If you’ve been using a JioPhone or any 4G keypad device
1 days ago
BenQ 27-inch 500Hz gaming monitor launched in India: Price, features and moreBenQ EX271QZ gaming monitor has launched in India, bringing a 27-inch QHD display with 500Hz refresh rate for gamers seeking faster performance and visuals. Published on: May 04
1 days ago
State-owned Central Bank of India does not expect any significant impact from the Reserve Bank of India’s expected credit loss (ECL) framework, managing director and CEO Kalyan Kumar said, citing adequate provisioning buffers. Under the ECL framework
1 days ago
A significant initiative has been undertaken to make learning easier and simpler for students in the 11th and 12th grades. The National Council of Educational Research and Training (NCERT) has launched free online courses aimed at providing quality education to students through digital mediums
1 days ago
An Indian-origin software engineer at Microsoft has gone viral after opening up about her years-long struggle with repeated visa rejections, detailing how persistence and an unexpected route eventually helped her secure permanent residency in the United States
1 days ago
Who is Anu Sharma? Internet curious about Indian techie who left Google to join PalantirAnu Sharma responded to the online buzz with an Instagram post. Published on: May 04, 2026 3:44 PM IST By Trisha Sengupta Share via Copy link In the middle of the 2026 Assembly Elections counting frenzy
1 days ago
At the age of 32, Rhea was busy building her career when she felt something unusual during a routine self-check. The days that followed moved quickly: doctor visits, tests, and then a diagnosis she never expected to hear at her age, breast cancer. Suddenly
1 days ago
Counting of votes for the five state elections is underway, with trends indicating a stronger-than-expected showing for the Bharatiya Janata Party. The party is currently leading in West Bengal, Assam and Puducherry, ahead of rivals including Mamata Banerjee’s Trinamool Congress and the Indian
1 days ago
Elon Musk contacted OpenAI President Greg Brockman to gauge interest in a settlement two days before their high-stakes trial got underway in Oakland federal court, according to a new court filing. Assembly Elections 2026 When Brockman suggested both sides drop their claims
1 days ago
Low risk to public, no travel restrictions needed: WHO on hantavirus outbreak on Atlantic cruise vesselThree people have succumbed to the hantavirus outbreak on an Atlantic Ocean cruise ship. Updated on: May 04, 2026 5:22 PM IST Edited by Sana Fazili Share via Copy link An outbreak of Hantavirus
1 days ago
DRDO Internship 2026 program launched with ₹30,000 stipend, engineering students can apply at drdo.gov.inDRDO has launched internship program for engineering students. Interns will get stipend of ₹30000 per month. Published on: May 04, 2026 4:43 PM IST By HT Education Desk | Edited by Papri
1 days ago
The Pentagon said Friday (May 1, 2025) that it has reached deals with seven tech companies to use their artificial intelligence in its classified computer networks, allowing the military to tap into AI-powered capabilities to help it fight wars. Google, Microsoft, Amazon Web Services, Nvidia
1 days ago
Dairy and healthy snacks brand Epigamia has appointed as its new chief executive officer. Assembly Elections 2026 The leadership change comes , founder of Epigamia’s parent company, . He passed away at the age of 42 on December 21, 2024, following a cardiac arrest
1 days ago
Assam Congress chief Gaurav Gogoi loses high profile Jorhat seat in 2026 Assam polls. BJP candidate Hitendra Nath Goswami wins by 23182 votes. Assam Congress chief Gaurav Gogoi has lost the high-profile Jorhat Assembly seat, marking a major setback for the party in the 2026 Assam elections
1 days ago
