<h4>Op Sindoor planner tied to choosing terror targets in Pakistan: Who is Ram Temple CEO Jeetendra Mishra?</h4><h4>Jeetendra Mishra
Latest News

Op Sindoor planner tied to choosing terror targets in Pakistan: Who is Ram Temple CEO Jeetendra Mishra?Jeetendra Mishra accompanied Prime Minister Narendra Modi to the Adampur air base in Punjab after Operation Sindoor. Updated on: Sep 3, 2026, 08:00:02 IST By Rahul Singh

<h4>Banks’ 'Certificate of Deposits' rates dip as FCNR flows hit $127 billion</h4><h4>The RBI’s scheme for attracting foreign currency
Latest News

Banks’ 'Certificate of Deposits' rates dip as FCNR flows hit $127 billionThe RBI’s scheme for attracting foreign currency deposits from NRIs has boosted banking-system liquidity, reducing banks’ need to raise funds through CD's. Updated on: Sep 3, 2026

<h4>IAF veteran, Delhi businessman, lawyer, RSS worker: Meet Ram Temple Trust’s new faces</h4><h4>Jeetendra Mishra
Latest News

IAF veteran, Delhi businessman, lawyer, RSS worker: Meet Ram Temple Trust’s new facesJeetendra Mishra, the Ram Temple trust’s first CEO, is an IAF veteran. He was also among the senior planners of Operation Sindoor. Updated on: Sep 3, 2026, 07:42:26 IST By Pawan Dixit | Edited by Priyanshu

Controversy is swirling around Rachel Cusk's new novel and its movie-star protagonist named
Life Style

Controversy is swirling around Rachel Cusk's new novel and its movie-star protagonist named "M". Why the fuss – and could the character be based on Natalie Portman? From Truman Capote mining the secrets of his high society friends for his writing to The Devil Wears Prada's Miranda Priestly

<h4>India retains status as fastest-growing large economy with latest GDP growth of 7.8%: Kwatra</h4><h4>India retains status as
Latest News

India retains status as fastest-growing large economy with latest GDP growth of 7.8%: KwatraIndia retains status as fastest-growing large economy with latest GDP growth of 7.8%: Kwatra Published on: Sep 3, 2026, 07:22:47 IST PTI Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link New York, India's 7

<h4>Did Travis Kelce’s ex Kayla Nicole really ‘expose’ him? Viral cheating and $5M claims debunked</h4><h4>The viral Kayla Nicole and
Latest News

Did Travis Kelce’s ex Kayla Nicole really ‘expose’ him? Viral cheating and $5M claims debunkedThe viral Kayla Nicole and Travis Kelce claims raise questions about cheating, $5 million, and what Nicole actually said. Published on: Sep 3, 2026

<b>For almost two decades, Lady Victoria Beckham has been trying to prove that she is more than simply Posh Spice. Now, her fashion and beauty business
Life Style

For almost two decades, Lady Victoria Beckham has been trying to prove that she is more than simply Posh Spice. Now, her fashion and beauty business has reached a milestone many doubted it would achieve: profitability. Victoria Beckham Holdings announced an operating profit of £7

Spotify will not ban AI-generated music but will focus on preventing impersonation. The company introduced AI Credits for artists to disclose AI usage in songs
Technology

Spotify will not ban AI-generated music but will focus on preventing impersonation. The company introduced AI Credits for artists to disclose AI usage in songs. New AI Persona badges will identify profiles that appear to be AI-generated. This approach aims to inform listeners and protect genuine

Collegium recommendation review will open ‘pandora’s box’

Posted By: Tarun Kumar Posted On: Jun 23, 2026Share Article
Collegium recommendation review will open ‘pandora’s box’
The Supreme Court of India. (File)

Collegium recommendation review will open ‘pandora’s box’: SC

Collegium recommendation review will open ‘pandora’s box’: SC

The Supreme Court denied a judge's petition for reconsideration of his elevation, citing concerns it could set a troubling precedent.

Published on: Jun 23, 2026 6:50 AM IST By Abraham Thomas, New Delhi Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link The Supreme Court on Monday refused to entertain a petition filed by a Himachal Pradesh family court judge seeking reconsideration of his elevation by the high court collegium observing that doing so will open a Pandora’s Box. The Supreme Court of India. (File) Allowing the officer to withdraw and pursue his remedies before the HImachal Pradesh high court, a bench of justices BV Nagarathna and Joymalya Bagchi said, “Once collegium recommendation is made and there are discussions on it, how can we interfere on the judicial side? This will open a Pandora’s Box.” The judge, Arvind Malhotra, agreed to withdraw his plea to avail the remedy of approaching the high court. Senior advocate Balbir Singh appearing for him submitted that the high court collegium on September 23, 2025 recommended three names of judicial officers junior to him. Malhotra feared that the choice may have been influenced by an allegation against him that he claims has no grounds. According to Singh, on September 17, Malhotra received a notice from Registrar (Vigilance) of the HP high court to which he responded on September 25. According to him, since the HC collegium had already made its recommendation by then, there was no opportunity for Malhotra’s response being considered. The petition in the apex court came after the Supreme Court collegium, on June 2, endorsed the high court collegium’s recommendations jeopardising Malhotra’s case for elevation despite being senior. The bench said: “Merely because you are in seniority does not make you entitled for elevation. The high court collegium even interacted with you and called for certain documents. There is secrecy attached to the collegium proceedings. Now the Supreme Court collegium recommendation is a supervening circumstance. What you may now be required to challenge is the Supreme Court collegium and not the high court collegium’s recommendation.” Singh pointed out that this is not the first time he has approached the top court seeking denial of consideration for elevation. In September 2024, the top court passed an order on a petition filed by him and another officer Chirag Bhanu Singh requesting thehigh court to reconsider their names. Incidentally, Chirag Bhanu Singh figures in the list of three judicial officers recommended by SC Collegium on June 2. The court said, “You need to have some patience in these matters. Your candidature has not been rejected. We cannot be functioning like RTI asking the high court collegium to disclose to you the contents pertaining to your consideration.” The bench found that no cause of action arises as of now. “At best, we are left to guess what was there before the high court collegium when they had an interaction with you and that they may have deferred consideration. The Supreme Court collegium, being a more wiser body, is privy to all the material and has decided what is decided by the high court collegium to be just and fair. If the SC collegium had not taken a call, we may still have a window open.” Singh urged the court to issue a direction to the high court to reconsider his case as it did in 2024. He pointed out that even the ground for the vigilance notice does not survive as the basis of the allegation was closed by the full bench of the high court in his favour. The court demurred. “Can a direction be made to the high court collegium or the Supreme Court collegium on your guessing? We do not want to open a Pandora’s Box here on the proceedings conducted in the collegium. Ultimately there may be nothing against you. You may only be imagining things. We are not privy to anything,” said the bench, allowing the officer’s plea to be withdrawn. Singh told the court that Malhotra may either approach the administrative side (of the high court) to know the fate of his response on the Registrar (Vigilance) notice. Himachal Pradesh Supreme Court Check India news real-time updates, latest news on Hindustan Times and more across India. Home/India News/Collegium Recommendation Review Will Open ‘pandora’s Box’: SC See Less

The Supreme Court on Monday refused to entertain a petition filed by a Himachal Pradesh family court judge seeking reconsideration of his elevation by the high court collegium observing that doing so will open a Pandora’s Box.

Allowing the officer to withdraw and pursue his remedies before the HImachal Pradesh high court, a bench of justices BV Nagarathna and Joymalya Bagchi said, “Once collegium recommendation is made and there are discussions on it, how can we interfere on the judicial side? This will open a Pandora’s Box.”

The judge, Arvind Malhotra, agreed to withdraw his plea to avail the remedy of approaching the high court. Senior advocate Balbir Singh appearing for him submitted that the high court collegium on September 23, 2025 recommended three names of judicial officers junior to him. Malhotra feared that the choice may have been influenced by an allegation against him that he claims has no grounds.

According to Singh, on September 17, Malhotra received a notice from Registrar (Vigilance) of the HP high court to which he responded on September 25. According to him, since the HC collegium had already made its recommendation by then, there was no opportunity for Malhotra’s response being considered.

The petition in the apex court came after the Supreme Court collegium, on June 2, endorsed the high court collegium’s recommendations jeopardising Malhotra’s case for elevation despite being senior.

The bench said: “Merely because you are in seniority does not make you entitled for elevation. The high court collegium even interacted with you and called for certain documents. There is secrecy attached to the collegium proceedings. Now the Supreme Court collegium recommendation is a supervening circumstance. What you may now be required to challenge is the Supreme Court collegium and not the high court collegium’s recommendation.”

Singh pointed out that this is not the first time he has approached the top court seeking denial of consideration for elevation. In September 2024, the top court passed an order on a petition filed by him and another officer Chirag Bhanu Singh requesting thehigh court to reconsider their names. Incidentally, Chirag Bhanu Singh figures in the list of three judicial officers recommended by SC Collegium on June 2.

The court said, “You need to have some patience in these matters. Your candidature has not been rejected. We cannot be functioning like RTI asking the high court collegium to disclose to you the contents pertaining to your consideration.”

The bench found that no cause of action arises as of now. “At best, we are left to guess what was there before the high court collegium when they had an interaction with you and that they may have deferred consideration. The Supreme Court collegium, being a more wiser body, is privy to all the material and has decided what is decided by the high court collegium to be just and fair. If the SC collegium had not taken a call, we may still have a window open.”

Singh urged the court to issue a direction to the high court to reconsider his case as it did in 2024. He pointed out that even the ground for the vigilance notice does not survive as the basis of the allegation was closed by the full bench of the high court in his favour.

The court demurred.

“Can a direction be made to the high court collegium or the Supreme Court collegium on your guessing? We do not want to open a Pandora’s Box here on the proceedings conducted in the collegium. Ultimately there may be nothing against you. You may only be imagining things. We are not privy to anything,” said the bench, allowing the officer’s plea to be withdrawn. Singh told the court that Malhotra may either approach the administrative side (of the high court) to know the fate of his response on the Registrar (Vigilance) notice.

Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


<h4>Shriya Pilgaonkar says Guilty Minds Season 2 cancellation ‘broke my heart’: ‘Rare to get a part like that’ |
Entertainment
Shriya Pilgaonkar says Guilty Minds Season 2 cancellation ‘broke my heart’

Shriya Pilgaonkar says Guilty Minds Season 2 cancellation ‘broke my heart’: ‘Rare to get a part like that’ | InterviewDuring the promotions of Haiwaan, the actor told Hindustan Times that the show remains closest to her heart even if season 2 was not comissioned by Prime Video

14 hours ago

Himachal Pradesh Assembly passed a bill amending the state university recruitment system. The government aims for transparent and merit-based appointments in
Politics
Himachal Assembly passes university amendment Bill amid protests over recruitment powers

Himachal Pradesh Assembly passed a bill amending the state university recruitment system. The government aims for transparent and merit-based appointments in universities. Opposition legislators and university teachers protested the proposed changes to recruitment powers

14 hours ago

Sanjeev Sanyal, a member of the Prime Minister’s Economic Advisory Council, in an interview to India Today on Tuesday defended the Union government’s
Business
PM’s economic adviser denies allegations of Centre manipulating GDP data

Sanjeev Sanyal, a member of the Prime Minister’s Economic Advisory Council, in an interview to India Today on Tuesday defended the Union government’s change in the methodology for calculating the gross domestic product amid Opposition’s allegations of data manipulation.Sanjeev Sanyal

14 hours ago

Donald Trump's portrait has made its way on to a US coin - the first time a living president has appeared on American currency in a century
Business
Trump $1 coin makes him first living president on US currency in a century

Donald Trump's portrait has made its way on to a US coin - the first time a living president has appeared on American currency in a century. The US Mint launched the commemorative $1 coin with a portrait of Trump alongside the words "In God we trust", to celebrate America's 250th anniversary

14 hours ago

<h4>Uber layoffs: CEO Dara Khosrowshahi to cut 10% of staff to simplify business. Read full memo</h4><h4>Uber is cutting 10% of its global
Latest News
CEO Dara Khosrowshahi to cut 10% of staff

Uber layoffs: CEO Dara Khosrowshahi to cut 10% of staff to simplify business. Read full memoUber is cutting 10% of its global workforce to flatten organisational layers, CEO Dara Khosrowshahi said in a memo. Updated on: Sep 3, 2026, 07:08:17 IST By Trisha Sengupta Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy

14 hours ago

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.<h4>Google Pixel 10a covers: 4 official
Technology
Google Pixel 10a covers

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Google Pixel 10a covers: 4 official options on Flipkart if you want style and protectionJust bought the Google Pixel 10a? These four official Google cases on Flipkart offer different

14 hours ago

A little bit of hunger is good for you,
Life Style
In the studio with Kasabian

A little bit of hunger is good for you," says Serge Pizzorno. "Keeps you going. The Kasabian frontman is describing a typical day in his home recording studio. Snacks and phones are banned, but he might screen a film in the background (typically something by David Lynch) while he tinkers with his

1 days ago

<h4>Three killed in separate wall collapse incidents in Odisha amid heavy rainfall</h4><h4>Odisha recorded 1,154
Latest News
Three killed in separate wall collapse incidents in Odisha amid heavy rainfall

Three killed in separate wall collapse incidents in Odisha amid heavy rainfallOdisha recorded 1,154.3 mm of rainfall between June 1 and August 31 against its normal seasonal rainfall of 1,150.2 mm Updated on: Sep 2, 2026, 07:49:44 IST By Debabrata Mohanty Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link

1 days ago

If you’re depositing your PF with a company, this is important. This is big news for the millions of members of the Employees’ Provident Fund Organization
Latest News
EPFO 3.0 big update

If you’re depositing your PF with a company, this is important. This is big news for the millions of members of the Employees’ Provident Fund Organization (EPFO). The central government is making major changes to the EPFO’s digital system, and under EPFO 3.0

1 days ago

Commercial LPG Cylinder Price Hike September 1: The revised prices, effective from September 1, and are expected to raise the operating costs for businesses
Latest News
LPG Rates From Sept 1

Commercial LPG Cylinder Price Hike September 1: The revised prices, effective from September 1, and are expected to raise the operating costs for businesses such as hotels, restaurants and cloud kitchens that rely on LPG for their day-to-day activities

1 days ago

<h4>GoPro sold for $285 million: Starman Optical to take 90% stake in camera maker</h4><h4>GoPro is being bought by Starman Optical for $285
Business
GoPro sold for $285 million

GoPro sold for $285 million: Starman Optical to take 90% stake in camera makerGoPro is being bought by Starman Optical for $285 million as the action-camera maker faces debt, rising memory chip prices and tough Chinese competition. Updated on: Sep 1, 2026

1 days ago

Vaishnavi Patil, 26, was supposed to share the stage with Rahul Gandhi at a Congress party event for women in Pune last month. She could not address the crowd
Politics
Will Rahul Gandhi’s ‘smash the patriarchy’ call attract young

Vaishnavi Patil, 26, was supposed to share the stage with Rahul Gandhi at a Congress party event for women in Pune last month. She could not address the crowd because of time constraints but was far from disappointed. “This was the first event where a political party head was talking about

1 days ago

<h4>3-day national youth athletics meet kicks off at Guru Nanak Stadium in Ludhiana</h4><h4>Being held from September 1 to 3 under the aegis
Latest News
3-day national youth athletics meet kicks off at Guru Nanak Stadium in Ludhiana

3-day national youth athletics meet kicks off at Guru Nanak Stadium in LudhianaBeing held from September 1 to 3 under the aegis of the Athletics Federation of India (AFI) and organised by the Punjab Athletics Association, the opening day witnessed competition for national honours across various

1 days ago

Aug 31 (Reuters) - Anthropic said on Monday it resumed external cybersecurity testing of AI models after deploying new safeguards
Technology
Anthropic resumes external cyber tests after Claude AI hacks

Aug 31 (Reuters) - Anthropic said on Monday it resumed external cybersecurity testing of AI models after deploying new safeguards, following incidents last month in which Claude models accessed the internet and hacked into other systems during security evaluations

1 days ago

<h4>ICTS 2026: Centre says Delhi set to get comprehensive road-grid plan within 3-4 months</h4><h4>The Capital is set to get a comprehensive
Latest News
Centre says Delhi set to get comprehensive road-grid plan within 3-4 months

ICTS 2026: Centre says Delhi set to get comprehensive road-grid plan within 3-4 monthsThe Capital is set to get a comprehensive road-grid plan within months as the Centre moves to implement the city’s new master plan, a senior Union housing and urban affairs ministry official said on Tuesday

1 days ago

<h4>The John Ternus era: How Apple is redefining design beyond the Jony Ive years</h4><h4>John Ternus has evolved the approach from the Jony
Business
The John Ternus era

The John Ternus era: How Apple is redefining design beyond the Jony Ive yearsJohn Ternus has evolved the approach from the Jony Ive era on three key characteristics. Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 21:11:24 IST By Vishal Mathur Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Before John Ternus

1 days ago

<h4>Fact check: Is Dollywood closing permanently after a fire? Could Disney buy the park for $200 billion?</h4><h4>Rumors that Dollywood
Latest News
Is Dollywood closing permanently amid fire

Fact check: Is Dollywood closing permanently after a fire? Could Disney buy the park for $200 billion?Rumors that Dollywood burned down and is permanently closing are false. The park remains open. While, Disney takeover claims are also untrue. Published on: Sep 2, 2026

1 days ago

HONG KONG, Sept 2 (Reuters) - While Nvidia is synonymous with the AI boom, a lesser-known group of power and cooling equipment suppliers is cashing in on a
Technology
Analysis-Not just Nvidia

HONG KONG, Sept 2 (Reuters) - While Nvidia is synonymous with the AI boom, a lesser-known group of power and cooling equipment suppliers is cashing in on a global data centre construction spree as developers race to avoid infrastructure bottlenecks

1 days ago

September has begun, bringing a fresh set of money-related changes and important financial dates for taxpayers, investors and households
Latest News
September 2026 money changes

September has begun, bringing a fresh set of money-related changes and important financial dates for taxpayers, investors and households. While the August 31 deadlines for certain ITR filers and LPG e-KYC have now passed, September has several dates to watch

1 days ago

As India moves from AI experimentation to real-world application, the ET AI Awards 2027 recognise organisations, teams and leaders driving AI innovation
Technology
ET AI Awards 2027

As India moves from AI experimentation to real-world application, the ET AI Awards 2027 recognise organisations, teams and leaders driving AI innovation, business transformation and measurable impact. Across AI startups, SMEs and enterprises, the awards spotlight excellence in AI products

1 days ago

From September 1, international passengers departing from India will no longer be required to get their boarding passes stamped at immigration counters
Latest News
September 1 new rules

From September 1, international passengers departing from India will no longer be required to get their boarding passes stamped at immigration counters. The Bureau of Immigration has introduced the change to simplify the departure process and make immigration clearance faster and more convenient

1 days ago

<h4>Erin Piacenti’s killer posted about ‘stabbing others for no reason’ months before attack</h4><h4>Months before killing Bank of
Latest News
Erin Piacenti’s killer posted about ‘stabbing others’ months before attack

Erin Piacenti’s killer posted about ‘stabbing others for no reason’ months before attackMonths before killing Bank of America VP Erin Piacenti, Pamela Cisneros shared a series of posts where she rambled about religion, the meaning of life and more Updated on: Sep 2, 2026

1 days ago

<b>Premier League clubs have broken their all-time summer transfer record after spending reached £3.46bn.</b> English top flight clubs had already
Sports
Premier League breaks transfer record for second straight summer

Premier League clubs have broken their all-time summer transfer record after spending reached £3.46bn. English top flight clubs had already pushed well beyond the £3bn barrier when Iliman Ndiaye's move from Everton to Manchester City on deadline day for an initial £60m took the amount spent past

1 days ago

Ariana Grande made an emotional exit on Tuesday night, as she wrapped up her Eternal Sunshine tour, and prepared to step back from public life
Life Style
Ariana Grande completes tour and steps back from public life

Ariana Grande made an emotional exit on Tuesday night, as she wrapped up her Eternal Sunshine tour, and prepared to step back from public life. The singer was occasionally close to tears - most notably during One Last Time, the song that took on extra meaning as an anthem for survivors of the 2017

1 days ago

About a century ago, long before environmental degradation became the crisis of our times, Nobel Laureate Rabindranath Tagore had sounded early warning bells
World
Mankind destroyed whatever was gifted as life

About a century ago, long before environmental degradation became the crisis of our times, Nobel Laureate Rabindranath Tagore had sounded early warning bells about the destruction of forests. Though Tagore was born in the city of Kolkata, he had a deep and abiding contact with nature from childhood

1 days ago

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.<h4>The joy of drawing anywhere starts
Technology
When inspiration strikes

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.The joy of drawing anywhere starts with the right tablet, and these six options make a strong case for leaving the deskLarge canvases

1 days ago

<h4>Cops quiz witnesses to form ‘watertight’ case over Greater Noida-Delhi bus gangrape</h4><h4>A police officer associated with the
Latest News
Police prepare to form ‘watertight’ case over Greater Noida-Delhi bus gangrape

Cops quiz witnesses to form ‘watertight’ case over Greater Noida-Delhi bus gangrapeA police officer associated with the probe said that they have written to the Forensic Science Laboratory to expedite the report. Updated on: Sep 2, 2026, 07:21:59 IST By Hemani Bhandari Prefer HTon Google Share

1 days ago