At least four people were killed and dozens injured when two trains collided outside the Indonesian capital Jakarta on Monday. State media report that a stationary commuter train was hit from behind by a long-distance commuter train arriving on the same track
Colour is at the heart of Kashmir’s textile traditions, especially for the world renowned Pashmina shawls and Kashmir silks. Yet producing these rich hues often comes with an environmental cost to ecosystems. Studies show that many textile industries use synthetic dyes during dyeing and printing
Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.What makes side-by-side door refrigerators a popular choice in Indian homes? (2026)These refrigerators come with energy efficient inverter compressors and are ideal for families of five
Mumbai man sets road on fire to record birthday reel, gets arrested as video goes viralThe man was booked for pouring inflammable liquid on the road and setting it on fire. Published on: Apr 28, 2026 6:09 AM IST By Trisha Sengupta Share via Copy link A 33-year-old Mumbai car dealer was arrested by
Starting a business is a dream for many young people today. More individuals are now choosing entrepreneurship over traditional jobs, hoping to build financial independence and long-term success. However, lack of funds often becomes the biggest hurdle
Love Horoscope Today for April 28, 2026: Your love life may take an unexpected turnLove Horoscope Today: Find daily astrological predictions for all sun signs. Updated on: Apr 28, 2026 7:41 AM IST By Kishori Sud Share via Copy link Aries Horoscope Today Love Energy: Attraction and confidence Love
India on Monday named Bharatiya Janata Party leader and former Union minister Dinesh Trivedi as its next high commissioner to Bangladesh. The appointment is a rare instance of a non-Indian Foreign Service officer being named to the role and comes as New Delhi seeks to reset ties with Dhaka
RRB NTPC UG Exam City Slip 2026 released, download link hereRRB NTPC UG Exam City Slip 2026 has been released. The direct link to download the city intimation slip is given here. Updated on: Apr 28, 2026 7:44 AM IST By HT Education Desk | Edited by Papri Chanda Share via Copy link The Railway
Building on a tax gamble that did not pay off
Building on a tax gamble that did not pay off Premium
One interesting thing about the Budget is that people usually do not do a reality check vis-a-vis the previous Budget because the current one takes centre stage. Since Budget 2026-27 is quite run of the mill, it will not be out of place to start with the last Budget.
If there is one thing you would recall about Budget 2025-26, it was the big-ticket announcement of an unprecedented tax cut for the “middle class”. The government assumed that despite the tax cut, income tax revenues would go up because of higher compliance and rise in middle-class incomes. But did that happen?
As we had argued last year in these columns, the tax gamble may not pay off and it has not. Income tax revenues have fallen woefully short of the estimated 14.38 lakh crore. In the Revised Estimate (RE), the collection is 13.12 lakh crore, so a shortfall of 1.26 lakh crore. Add to that a similar shortfall of 1.31 lakh crore in GST collections. But for a marginally better than expected performance from corporate tax, union and excise duties, the shortfall in the overall gross tax revenue would have been much higher than 1.92 lakh crore (tax part of the chart).
To be sure, this shortfall in itself could be dismissed as a mistake in expectations. But when expenditures are linked to tax collections (which they strictly are under the rules of fiscal deficit targets), the matter is far more serious. When spending is directly tied to revenue collections, a shortfall of this magnitude inevitably results in sharp expenditure cuts. Not surprisingly, there has almost been an across-the-board cut in expenditure (expenditure part of the chart). Even the much-touted capital expenditure (capex) saw a cut, as did agriculture, education, health, rural as well as urban development. A mistake in the government's expectations cost the poor their income, their employment, their education and, their health.
Budget 2026-27 needs to evaluated in light of this. This is going to be an uncertain year, both politically and economically. India is precariously placed between a current account surplus with the U.S. but a deficit with China. If its exports gets affected as a result of President Donald Trump's tariff war, without its imports countering the fall, the external situation for India may actually worsen. The Economic Survey at least acknowledged this possibility, although with a low probability of 10%. In a fundamentally uncertain world that we currently find ourselves in, you don't want to take refuge in probability theory.
The Budget seems to have taken this probability a little too literally. It has been planned as if we are still in 2025 and such a worsening of the external sector may not happen. If the external demand actually worsens, it is important for the government to focus on domestic demand as well, at least as plan B. A run-of-the-mill Budget like this one would have been fine in normal times but not this year. The focus remains on fiscal prudence, capex, supply-side measures for employment, and credit guarantees to MSMEs, much like the previous Budget or the ones before. Despite the same macroeconomic approach in earlier Budgets, employment numbers, particularly among the youth, have not been encouraging at all. Corporate investment has not been either. Should not the government have gone back to the drawing board if their existing strategies were not working? And yet what we got is more of the same. This lack of imagination comes from a blinkered vision of how the economy works. Supply-side measures work only when complemented with demand, not on their own.
Let us again take the case of public capex as a demand measure. All capex are not the same. Capex in agriculture or health or education is not the same as capex in highways. The first creates jobs along with boosting demand. Now in a world where you don't pit one capex against the other, this would not have been an issue. But if capex in infrastructure comes at the cost of capex in the form of development expenditures, and that too in an economy where gainful employment is limited, there is a serious problem. We keep boasting about our demographic dividend, which is going to peak in 2030, but we have lost most of it already with a high unemployment rate among the youth. For women, particularly in the urban areas, it is even worse.
What could the Budget have done instead? First, it should have kept its hawkish fiscal stance in abeyance, especially for an uncertain year such as this. It should have prioritised employment intensive development expenditure, and welfare expenditure, which also have a multi-round demand generating capacity. And second, this was perhaps the year to take the pollution bull by the horn. People were on the streets of Delhi demanding action. For the first time, it became a political issue. We needed a war on pollution but it does not even find a mention, let alone allocation. It is an opportunity lost.
Rohit Azad teaches Economics at JNU; Indranil Chowdhury teaches Economics at PGDAV College, Delhi University
Published - February 02, 2026 12:48 am IST
Union Budget
Source: TheHindu
Related Posts: Most flowers usually pick one father and stick with him The World Cup draw is usually a spectacle I find it very interesting when you open your soul and say what you’re thinking 5 interesting things about Giants You might lose your LPG connection — Unless you do this one thing within 3 months Tinder is now making new users in India do this one thing before they can match Pink Drinking Water Is A Thing And It Is Available In India Katy Perry, Justin Trudeau's cosy winter vacay photo album is all things LOVE LeBron James Reveals The ONLY Thing He’s Not Excited About In His NBA Comeback Most beautiful thing
Pakistani attacks on the east Afghan province of Kunar have killed at least seven people and injured 75, among whom are students and a professor at Kunar University, multiple sources have told the BBC. According to the Taliban government, 30 of the injured are university students
3 hours ago
Apple’s foldable iPhone leak hints at ultra-thin, passport-shaped design, debut likely in SeptemberNew reports suggest Apple’s first foldable iPhone may arrive soon, featuring a thinner design, larger display, and a key role in its next leadership era. Updated on: Apr 27
3 hours ago
Union Home Minister Amit Shah on Monday said that the Central Armed Police Forces would remain deployed in West Bengal for at least 60 days after the Assembly elections and told voters not to be concerned about “Didi’s goons”. Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee is popularly known as “Didi”
3 hours ago
The International Monetary Fund’s April 2026 World Economic Outlook arrives with an unusually candid subtitle – Global Economy in the Shadow of War – in the same month that NATO has locked in its most ambitious military spending target in history
3 hours ago
In Purba Bardhaman, potato farmers face price caps, weak markets and migration woes. As elections near, discontent simmers, but TMC still appears deeply rooted across the region. The rest of the country may be all agog about voting in West Bengal tomorrow
3 hours ago
Bayern Munich must find a way to stop Paris Saint-Germain winger Khvicha Kvaratskhelia. He has scored eight goals in the Champions League. His performances have drawn comparisons to football legends. Kvaratskhelia's ability to cut inside and shoot is a key threat
3 hours ago
SSB may increase quota for ex-Agniveers from 10% to 50%, exempt testsThe SSB proposal mirrors similar draft rules prepared by the Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) Published on: Apr 28, 2026 7:35 AM IST By Prawesh Lama, NEW DELHI Share via Copy link The Sashastra Seema Bal (SSB) has proposed
3 hours ago
Priya Banerjee says Bollywood has lost its way, slams its lack of originality: ‘Same rom-coms, ladki ladka bike pe hain’In an interview with Hindustan Times, Priya Banerjee talked about Bollywood's lack of original ideas and revealed she doesn't like watching Hindi films. Apr 28, 2026
3 hours ago
In mid-2025, frustration boiled over for Cedrik Sixtus. Finding his Spotify playlists increasingly sprinkled with tracks he suspected were AI generated, the Leipzig-based software developer built a tool to automatically label and block them from his listening.In mid-2025
3 hours ago
India’s new trade deal with New Zealand may just be bigger than any other free trade agreement, for it signals where New Delhi wants to go next. With $20 billion in investments and duty-free access for all Indian exports from Day 1, the India-NZ FTA opens up meaningful opportunities
3 hours ago
Describing the agreement a “big win,” New Zealand’s Prime Minister Christopher Luxon said it would help expand exports across key sectors. India and New Zealand will sign a bilateral Free Trade Agreement (FTA) on Monday, which was finalised by PM Narendra Modi and New Zealand’s PM
3 hours ago
Anthony Joshua has signed a deal to fight fellow former world heavyweight champion Tyson Fury, Eddie Hearn has announced. Joshua, who has not fought since he was a passenger in a fatal car crash in December, will first have a comeback fight against Kristian Prenga in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
3 hours ago
PM Narendra Modi expresses confidence of BJP forming govt in Bengal, vows to return for oath ceremony, while Mamata Banerjee holds roadshows as high-voltage campaigning ends. Kolkata: In his last campaign rally in the industrial belt of Barrackpore's Jagatdal
3 hours ago
Now, India pushes diesel, LPG blending plansTechnical teams at BIS, India’s standards-setting body, are working through consultations with stakeholders before finalisation Updated on: Apr 28, 2026 7:07 AM IST By Zia Haq, NEW DELHI Share via Copy link The government is taking decisive steps
3 hours ago
Taiwan's defense ministry reported spotting two Chinese warships, a destroyer and a frigate, operating southwest of the Penghu islands. Taiwan's naval and air forces were dispatched to closely monitor the Chinese vessels. This incident occurs amidst China's regular military activities around the
3 hours ago
‘I rejected IIM Bangalore’: Techie shares reason behind ‘controversial’ decisionA video of a techie’s confession on rejecting IIM Bangalore and continuing his job instead has prompted varied reactions. Published on: Apr 28, 2026 6:53 AM IST By Trisha Sengupta Share via Copy link A digital
3 hours ago
Haryana: Congress boycotts special session, Saini dubs it ‘anti-women’ mindsetThe day-long special session, hurriedly convened a month after the budget session’s conclusion, was triggered by the Union government’s setbacks in the Lower House on April 17
3 hours ago
While Anthropic has continued to warn about the impacts of AI on the job market, the company is itself looking to hire for a new role and is offering $400,000 in salary to find the right candidate. The new role is based out of San Francisco or New York, with a salary range of $320,000 to $400,000
3 hours ago
Sugar-free products with sugar. ‘Real’ juices with artificial ingredients. Misleading food ads are fuelling a public health crisis in India. Help Scroll expose the systemic failure. Support our investigation.Sugar-free products with sugar. ‘Real’ juices with artificial ingredients
3 hours ago
Cooper Flagg vs Kon Knueppel stats: How Flagg beat his former Duke teammate for Rookie of the YearCooper Flagg won the NBA Rookie of the Year award, narrowly defeating teammate Kon Knueppel by 26 points. Published on: Apr 28, 2026 7:04 AM IST By Shirin Gupta Share via Copy link Duke freshmen Cooper
3 hours ago
Adani Airport Holdings Limited and MakeMyTrip have launched an online duty-free pre-booking service for international travellers, allowing passengers to browse and reserve products before arriving at the airport. The service enables travellers to pre-book duty-free items across more than 10
3 hours ago
"One more year, one more year Casemiro," bellowed the Stretford End as the Brazilian midfielder made his way down the tunnel to the Manchester United dressing room. The 34-year-old had just completed the full 90 minutes in a 2-1 win over Brentford that highlighted everything that makes him such an
3 hours ago
European flight prices are falling as airlines try to overcome customer "hesitancy" over the economic hit from the US-Israel war with Iran, Wizz Air's chief executive has said. József Váradi said European airlines can make price cuts in the "short term" because they have bought fuel at a price
3 hours ago
A 21-year-old man is going on trial in Austria charged with planning and preparing a terrorist attack on a Taylor Swift concert in Vienna in August 2024. The Austrian man, named only as Beran A., has been charged with terrorism and other offences and is appearing in court in Wiener Neustadt
3 hours ago
The Jammu and Kashmir High Court on Monday quashed the preventive detention of Aam Aadmi Party MLA Mehraj Malik under the Public Safety Act, setting aside the order issued by the Doda district administration in September. Malik, who represents the Doda constituency and heads the party’s Jammu and
3 hours ago
Mortars and missiles from Pakistan struck a university and homes in Afghanistan's Kunar Province, killing seven and wounding 85. Pakistan denied targeting the university, calling the accusation a "blatant lie." This incident marks the first major attack since Chinese-mediated peace talks aimed at
3 hours ago
Deepika Padukone makes first appearance after announcing second pregnancy; Ranveer Singh seen in protective modeDeepika Padukone and Ranveer Singh kept the airport outing lowkey and didn’t pose for the photographers stationed outside the airport in Mumbai. Apr 28, 2026
3 hours ago
