‘Loot lo, loot lo,’ a man yells while recording scenes after a truck toppled in Andhra Pradesh’s Nellore. His video is now going viral
Latest News

‘Loot lo, loot lo,’ a man yells while recording scenes after a truck toppled in Andhra Pradesh’s Nellore. His video is now going viral, sparking discussions online over ‘insensitivity’. But what exactly happened? The truck was loaded with bottles of cold drinks (primarily bottles of Thums

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.<h4 class=
Technology

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Big price drop on 4K smart TVs: Up to 60% off on Samsung, Sony, LG and moreSmart TVs on Amazon are seeing noticeable price drops, making it easier to upgrade to sharper visuals

<h4 class=
Latest News

NRI installs Statue of Liberty replica atop Jalandhar home after 26 years in New YorkAn NRI installed a Statue of Liberty replica on his Jalandhar home, drawing visitors and going viral online. Published on: Mar 22, 2026 7:39 AM IST By Mahipal Singh Chouhan Share via Copy link A unique

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on Saturday described Prime Minister Narendra Modi as the “biggest infiltrator” and reiterated her criticism of
Politics

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on Saturday described Prime Minister Narendra Modi as the “biggest infiltrator” and reiterated her criticism of the Bharatiya Janata Party-led Union government in connection with the special intensive revision of voter rolls, PTI reported

<h4 class=
Sports

Meet Team USA's ‘giantkillers’ who handed Tom Brady, Joe Burrow brutal losses in Fanatics Flag Football Published on: Mar 22, 2026 4:11 AM IST By Yash Nitish Bajaj Share via Copy link U.S. National Flag team's Isaiah Calhoun reacts after scoring a touchdown against the Wildcats FFC (AP) Key

A crumbling system is depriving India's young offenders of a 'second chance'

Posted By: Anita Mamgai Posted On: Jan 14, 2026Share Article
A crumbling system is depriving India's young offenders of a 'second chance'

A crumbling system is depriving India's young offenders of a 'second chance'

Pooja* was 16 years old when she was accused of murdering her mother.

The teenager, who lived with her alcoholic stepfather in a poor neighbourhood in the northern Indian state of Uttar Pradesh, was arrested in 2018 and sent to jail.

Her lawyer told the police that Pooja was a minor. According to Indian law, she should have been produced before a Juvenile Justice Board (JJB) - a three-member bench that deals with matters concerning children in conflict with the law - within 24 hours of her arrest. But this was not done, Yamina Rizvi, a lawyer who took over Pooja's case in 2024, told the BBC.

JJBs, which comprise of a principal magistrate and two social workers, decide if a child aged 16-18 should be tried as an adult in case of heinous crimes - a provision introduced in India's Juvenile Justice law after the 2012 Delhi gang rape case.

But instead of appearing before a JJB, Pooja was lodged in a prison for six years while her case was heard in an adult court.

"JJBs are also required to make regular visits to prisons to check if minors have been lodged there. But not a single check was conducted while Pooja was in prison," Rizvi alleges.

In 2024, Pooja's case was finally transferred to a JJB, which found that she was indeed a minor at the time of the alleged crime. She was released on time served as the maximum sentence for a juvenile is three years and Pooja had already spent six years in prison.

"Pooja is one of thousands of children who have been let down by the juvenile justice system," Rizvi says.

It has been nearly four decades since India passed its first comprehensive legislation to deal with children in conflict with the law - the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act. It has been amended several times since then to strengthen its provisions.

The law aims to protect children and create opportunities for reform so that they can reintegrate into society and live meaningful lives.

But experts who work with children say that there is a long way to go before the system can properly implement the ideals the law preaches.

The strength of India's juvenile justice system depends heavily on the health of its JJBs - quasi-judicial panels tasked with ensuring that a child's rights are protected even as they face the legal consequences of their actions.

JJBs, established in 2000, don't function in isolation but are the fulcrum of a network comprising child-friendly services including sensitised police units, legal aid services and rehabilitation centres.

But research shows that all is not well with these pivotal panels. For one, getting information about them is difficult as there is no single government portal that tracks and publicly shares data related to them.

Data shared in November by the India Justice Report (IJR) - a report created by civil society organisations to track the effectiveness of India's justice system - shows that as of 2023, more than half the cases before 362 JJBs were pending hearing. The report doesn't cover all of India's JJBs as it is based on answers from states that responded to a set of questions sent by IJR through the Right to Information Act.

According to the report, India's 745 districts have 707 JJBs.

The report also found that one in four JJBs lacked a full bench, even though the law mandates that every district should have at least one fully-staffed JJB.

Maja Daruwala, editor at IJR, says that the dearth of accurate data indicates poor oversight and creates a lack of accountability, which in turn seriously impacts the quality of care and rehabilitation opportunities juveniles receive.

Fr Antony Sebastian, founder of Echo, an NGO working for the welfare of juveniles, says that in the absence of JJBs, children lose not just the protection guaranteed to them by law, but also the chance to reform.

"These children largely come from poor backgrounds and dysfunctional families, and they grow up witnessing violence and scarcity. When the police beat them and dump them in jails, they're revictimised all over again," says Fr Sebastian, a former principal magistrate on two separate JJBs in Bengaluru city.

For minors not sent to jail, there isn't much scope for reformation in child care institutions (facilities that house children in conflict with the law), says Deeksha Gujral, programme director at iProbono, which offers legal aid to vulnerable people.

JJBs can send children accused of crimes to observation homes, while those found to have committed an offence are placed in special homes. A separate facility, called a 'place of safety', houses children aged 16-18 years who are accused or found guilty of committing heinous offences.

JJBs are mandated to inspect these facilities every month to ensure they meet the standards prescribed by law. However, many children's rights advocates say that regular checks seldom happen and even if they do, they're conducted in a superficial manner.

Gujral, who has visited several observation and special homes in the course of her work, says that many of them are overcrowded, and lack counsellors or meaningful recreational, educational and vocational facilities. Additionally, while there are separate facilities for boys and girls, the mandated age-based segregation within these facilities is not always adhered to.

"All the children do is eat, sleep and watch TV. In places like Delhi, where there already exists a strong gang and drug culture, these power dynamics are replicated within the residential facilities. Younger, less-experienced children look to older boys with connections to gangs outside the facility for protection," Gujral says, adding that incidents of violence and sexual abuse are also not uncommon.

The BBC has sent a list of questions to the federal ministry of women and child development, which oversees the juvenile justice system, but has not received a response.

Rizvi says that authorities in many facilities are also jaded.

"They believe that these children are beyond help, and nothing they do will change them," she says, adding that she has seen this belief in many lawyers who represent children too.

Fr Sebastian says that apathy takes root when there's a lack of understanding about the child's reality and the spirit of the law.

He says that Echo, which runs a special home, has seen success stories where children found guilty of serious offences like murder and rape have been able to turn around their lives.

He attributes this to the focus Echo places on running vocational training programmes like dairy and poultry farming, and hotel management, as well as offering regular counselling sessions.

Darshan* was brought to Echo after he was found guilty of murdering his friend during a fight about a cricket match. Before that, he lived on the streets.

"Counselling sessions at Echo helped Darshan confront what he had done, but also examine why he had done it," Fr Sebastian says.

He was then enrolled in a behaviour modification programme while he completed his education through distance learning. Later, he trained in hotel management and is working with a well-known hotel.

Every child deserves a second chance," Fr Sebastian says. "As a society, we owe them at least that much.

*Names have been changed as Indian law prohibits the disclosure of a juvenile offender's identity.

Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


The US has lifted sanctions on some Iranian oil, as it scrambles to contain the impact of its war in Iran on energy markets. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent
Business
US lifts sanctions on some Iranian oil as energy prices soar

The US has lifted sanctions on some Iranian oil, as it scrambles to contain the impact of its war in Iran on energy markets. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent announced the issuing of a narrowly tailored, short-term authorisation permitting the sale of Iranian oil currently stranded at sea

6 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Delhi engulfed in ‘not very common’ fog in March

Delhi engulfed in ‘not very common’ dense fog in March; records lowest temperature since February 26Experts attributed the occurrence of fog to a combination of recent rain, high moisture content in the atmosphere and relatively calm winds overnight. Updated on: Mar 22

6 hours ago

Bournemouth held Manchester United to a 2-2 draw at the Vitality Stadium on Saturday in their Premier League clash. Bruno Fernandes strike and an own goal
Sports
Isn't VAR For Clearing Things Up And

Bournemouth held Manchester United to a 2-2 draw at the Vitality Stadium on Saturday in their Premier League clash. Bruno Fernandes strike and an own goal accounted for United’s tally, while Ryan Christie and Junior Kroupi found the net for the Cherries in a match that also saw Harry Maguire sent

6 hours ago

Chandrasekhar, who is fighting against CPI(M) leader and state Education Minister V Sivankutty, and K S Sabarinadhan from the Congress in the April 9 polls
Politics
BJP state chief Rajeev Chandrasekhar declares assets of over Rs 93 crore

Chandrasekhar, who is fighting against CPI(M) leader and state Education Minister V Sivankutty, and K S Sabarinadhan from the Congress in the April 9 polls, submitted his nomination papers before the returning officer during the day, accompanied by Rajasthan CM Bhajanlal Sharma.Chandrasekhar

6 hours ago

In 2018, a young tigress stopped appearing on camera traps in Bandhavgarh Tiger Reserve in Madhya Pradesh. There was no official report of conflict as well as
World
Wildlife corridors between Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh help increase tiger population

In 2018, a young tigress stopped appearing on camera traps in Bandhavgarh Tiger Reserve in Madhya Pradesh. There was no official report of conflict as well as no records of carcass recovery or poaching incidents. This indicated that she had not died within the reserve.In 2018

6 hours ago

The Union government on Saturday allowed an additional 20% allocation of commercial liquefied petroleum gas to states and Union Territories
World
Centre hikes commercial LPG allocation to 50%

The Union government on Saturday allowed an additional 20% allocation of commercial liquefied petroleum gas to states and Union Territories, taking the overall allocation to 50%. Of the total amount, an allocation of 10% will be given on the condition that states undertake measures to ease the

6 hours ago

<h4 class=
Business
DICGC risk-based premium

DICGC risk-based premium: How much will banks pay for deposit insurance?RBP framework provides a bank with a discount of up to 33.33% on the deposit insurance premium based on its rating category and an up to 25% vintage incentive. Updated on: Mar 22

6 hours ago

Maharashtra politics heats up after a state women's commission chief resigns due to her association with a spiritual leader accused of rape
Politics
UBT Sena targets Eknath Shinde after Rupali Chakankar resigns over Ashok Kharat row

Maharashtra politics heats up after a state women's commission chief resigns due to her association with a spiritual leader accused of rape. The Uddhav Balasaheb Thackeray Sena now targets Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde. Leaders demand action against political followers of such spiritual

6 hours ago

TikTok star Taylor Frankie Paul sat uneasily in her chair during a live interview on ABC's Good Morning America this week, caught between trying to promote her
Life Style
The Bachelorette's messy break-up with its unlikely star Taylor Frankie Paul

TikTok star Taylor Frankie Paul sat uneasily in her chair during a live interview on ABC's Good Morning America this week, caught between trying to promote her turn in the network's new series of The Bachelorette and addressing fresh domestic violence allegations lodged against her by her

6 hours ago

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee assured the minority community of her support during her Eid-ul-Fitr address, criticizing the BJP's alleged deletion
Politics
Mamata Banerjee’s Eid speech targets BJP

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee assured the minority community of her support during her Eid-ul-Fitr address, criticizing the BJP's alleged deletion of minority names from electoral rolls. She vowed to challenge these actions in the Supreme Court

6 hours ago

In the age of convenience, using frozen, deep-fried or processed meats that are brimming with preservatives is the norm. It makes life easier on days when work
Life Style
Eating Ultra-Processed Foods Raises Risk Of Stroke by 67%

In the age of convenience, using frozen, deep-fried or processed meats that are brimming with preservatives is the norm. It makes life easier on days when work and life collide. However, a new study has found that eating too much ultra-processed food may significantly increase the risk of serious

6 hours ago

<h4 class=
Entertainment
Mohit Suri on eight-hour shift debate

Mohit Suri on eight-hour shift in film industry debate: ‘Emraan Hashmi shot 24 hours with me’Director Mohit Suri feels improved working hours shouldn’t be reserved only for actors, but must also consider the well-being of the entire crew. Mar 22, 2026

6 hours ago

Cuba’s national power grid suffered a nationwide collapse on Saturday, plunging the island into darkness for the second time in a week as the communist
Latest News
Cuba Announces Second Nationwide Power Blackout In A Week

Cuba’s national power grid suffered a nationwide collapse on Saturday, plunging the island into darkness for the second time in a week as the communist government struggles to maintain electricity supplies for its 10 million residents amid a U.S.-imposed oil blockade and ageing infrastructure

6 hours ago

The National Farmers' Union has warned that food prices in the UK are likely to go up as a result of the conflict in the Middle East
Business
Food prices likely to rise due to Iran war

The National Farmers' Union has warned that food prices in the UK are likely to go up as a result of the conflict in the Middle East. NFU President Tom Bradshaw told the BBC that the price of cucumbers and tomatoes could rise over the next six weeks

6 hours ago

Global intelligence agencies, including the CIA and Mossad, were closely watching during Nowruz on Friday to see whether Iran’s new Supreme Leader
World
Mojtaba Khamenei Breaks Nowruz Tradition With No Public Address

Global intelligence agencies, including the CIA and Mossad, were closely watching during Nowruz on Friday to see whether Iran’s new Supreme Leader, Mojtaba Khamenei, would uphold his father’s tradition of a New Year’s address. However, the holiday went by without Mojtaba’s address

6 hours ago

Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) on Saturday claimed it had struck an Israeli F-16 fighter jet over central Iran, even as Israel announced
World
IRGC Claims Strike On Israeli F-16 Over Iran As IDF Says It Hit Missile Facilities

Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) on Saturday claimed it had struck an Israeli F-16 fighter jet over central Iran, even as Israel announced fresh overnight strikes on ballistic missile production facilities in Tehran. In a statement carried by Sepah News

6 hours ago

These have been directed by PNGRB to shorten the timeline between the submission of applications and the commencement of gas supply to consumer households and
Business
City gas firms advised to prioritise PNG connections for commercial entities

These have been directed by PNGRB to shorten the timeline between the submission of applications and the commencement of gas supply to consumer households and pursue mass awareness initiatives. Also Read :India set to become rich by 2047? How growth

6 hours ago

The combined wealth of Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma and his wife Riniki Bhuyan Sarma has increased to Rs 35.16 crore in 2026 from 17
Politics
Wealth of Himanta Sarma

The combined wealth of Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma and his wife Riniki Bhuyan Sarma has increased to Rs 35.16 crore in 2026 from 17.27 crore in 2021, showed the affidavit filed by the Bharatiya Janata Party leader on Friday. Himanta Biswa Sarma had filed the affidavit along with his

6 hours ago

When </b>Liverpool</b> came to </b>Brighton</b> last May, the away end was in party mode at the full-time whistle despite the defeat as
Sports
If Liverpool play like that at PSG it could be 10

When Liverpool came to Brighton last May, the away end was in party mode at the full-time whistle despite the defeat as they sang and celebrated with inflatables and balloons. By then, Arne Slot's side had won the Premier League title and a trip to the south coast was another excuse to enjoy

6 hours ago

The National Highways Authority of India will use advanced AI dashcams on 40,000 km of highways. This initiative aims to improve road maintenance and safety
World
NHAI turns on AI dashcams for smarter highway monitoring

The National Highways Authority of India will use advanced AI dashcams on 40,000 km of highways. This initiative aims to improve road maintenance and safety through data-driven operations. High-resolution imagery will help identify over 30 types of defects

6 hours ago

For most office workers in India, the concept of working out like Bollywood’s “New Age Action Hero
Life Style
Too Busy To Work Out

For most office workers in India, the concept of working out like Bollywood’s “New Age Action Hero" Vidyut Jammwal, who is known for his incredible Kalaripayattu-powered feats, seems absurdly unattainable. The actor is believed to exercise for up to nine hours every day

6 hours ago

In the high-stakes arena of the 2026 Assam assembly elections, observers say Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma has deployed a political strategy that is as
Politics
The Great Assam Migration

In the high-stakes arena of the 2026 Assam assembly elections, observers say Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma has deployed a political strategy that is as audacious as it is effective: dismantling the Congress party by absorbing its most influential DNA. On March 19

6 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Indian man escorted off flight after demanding seat change from US-based techie

Indian man escorted off flight after demanding seat change from US-based techieA United States-based software developer has sparked a discussion on in-flight etiquette after refusing to switch seats with an Indian man on a plane Published on: Mar 22

6 hours ago

India faces an LPG crisis as the US-Israeli war on Iran disrupts shipments through the Strait of Hormuz, which supplies 85-90% of the country’s imports
Latest News
Rajasthan Man’s ‘Vishwaguru Chulha’ Can Cook For 25 People in 30 Minutes

India faces an LPG crisis as the US-Israeli war on Iran disrupts shipments through the Strait of Hormuz, which supplies 85-90% of the country’s imports. Tanker delays and safety concerns have caused cylinder shortages, rising prices, and rationing, hitting households and eateries hard

6 hours ago

<h4 class=
Business
Comprehensive financial planning

Comprehensive financial planning: Reflect on FY25 and plan for FY26 and beyondThe annual review of the financial year. Updated on: Mar 22, 2026 4:10 AM IST By Gopal Gidwani Share via Copy link The financial year-end is a good time to reflect on what worked well this year and what did not go as

6 hours ago

With the inauguration of the Noida International Airport in Jewar drawing closer, a key concern for travellers across Delhi-NCR is accessibility
Auto
Which Airport Will Actually Save You Time

With the inauguration of the Noida International Airport in Jewar drawing closer, a key concern for travellers across Delhi-NCR is accessibility. While the airport promises to ease pressure on Delhi’s existing aviation infrastructure, its location in western Uttar Pradesh means commute time will

6 hours ago

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.<h4 class=
Technology
7 Running watches that actually help you run better in 2026

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.7 Running watches that actually help you run better in 2026Running watches have changed how people track every mile. Here are seven options that stand out when it comes to performance

6 hours ago


Sing Up