Himanta Biswa Sarma will be sworn in as Assam Chief Minister for a second consecutive term on Tuesday. Governor Lakshman Prasad Acharya will administer the oath at 11:40 am. Prime Minister Narendra Modi and other dignitaries are expected to attend
The Delhi High Court has ordered to restore the YouTube channel 4PM News, which had been blocked in March following directions from the Centre under the Information Technology Rules. The court also directed that 26 allegedly “objectionable” videos remain blocked
British Prime Minister Keir Starmer has been told by Interior Minister Shabana Mahmood and other senior cabinet Ministers to consider setting out a timeline for his departure, TheTimes newspaper reported on Monday (May 11, 2026). The Times reported that Ms
Indian equity benchmarks opened sharply lower on Tuesday, weighed down by heavy selling in IT and banking stocks. The BSE Sensex plunged over 680 points in early trade to 75,335, while the NSE Nifty50 slipped nearly 184 points to trade around 23,632
Malaysian PM Anwar Ibrahim congratulates ‘friend’ Vijay on becoming Tamil Nadu CMCongratulating his “friend” on the electoral victory, Malasian PM Ibrahim referred to Vijay’s political slogan, “Oru Viral Puratchi”. Published on: May 12, 2026 10:48 AM IST PTI | By Aditi Anand Share via
Why welfare isn't winning elections in India like it used to
India's welfare politics is not collapsing - but its electoral magic may be fading.
Over the past decade, cash transfers, subsidised services and women-focused schemes have become the default grammar of state politics in India, with welfare increasingly used to soften the effects of a growth model that has struggled to generate enough jobs.
Across party lines, governments now promise a familiar basket of benefits: pensions, direct cash transfers, scholarships, free or subsidised electricity, cheap foodgrain, self-help group support for women and allowances for unemployed youth.
What began as a competitive advantage for a few regional parties has hardened into a bipartisan consensus: from the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam (DMK) in Tamil Nadu to the Trinamool Congress (TMC) in West Bengal and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in Assam, parties now compete less over whether to offer welfare than over how much.
But recent state elections suggest that extensive welfare delivery alone is no longer enough to secure incumbency.
The DMK - long seen as the architect of India's most durable welfare-transfer model - has lost power in Tamil Nadu. Mamata Banerjee's TMC was swept out of office in West Bengal after three terms despite women-centric welfare schemes that had once been central to its electoral dominance. The Congress-led United Democratic Front has returned in Kerala despite the Left Democratic Front government's expansive welfare record. All the three chief ministers who lost were known as welfarist leaders.
"We should resist the easy binary: welfare won or welfare failed," says political scientist Bhanu Joshi.
Welfare is already the floor of Indian politics. What decides elections now is what parties build above it. Voters understood that long ago. Analysts are still arguing about the floor while the contest has moved to the ceiling.
That, Joshi argues, is why welfare can no longer be viewed in isolation from the broader political coalitions parties assemble around it.
In West Bengal, he says, the TMC's old "electoral equilibrium of welfare delivery, women voters, Muslim consolidation and enough Hindu support" may have fractured, contributing to its loss to the BJP.
In neighbouring Assam, meanwhile, the BJP's rise rests "not only on religious rhetoric but also on welfare schemes, women's self-help groups, roads, state institutions and Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma's image of administrative efficiency", Joshi says.
Women have become central to this expanding welfare architecture - seen both as more reliable managers of household spending and as an increasingly decisive voting bloc whose turnout now often exceeds that of men.
To be sure, the political and fiscal stakes are enormous: India's state governments now run more than 2,000 cash transfer programmes.
According to the latest Ministry of Finance Economic Survey, states are expected to spend roughly $18bn (£13.2bn) on unconditional cash transfers alone in 2025-26, much of it targeted at women.
In just three years, the number of states operating such schemes has increased more than fivefold, including many already running revenue deficits, the survey says.
In some states, the transfers account for as much as half the monthly consumption expenditure of poorer rural households. For female casual labourers and self-employed women, they form a substantial share of income.
Yet the survey reads less like a celebration than a warning.
India's states, it argues, are increasingly borrowing to fund recurring welfare payouts while squeezing spending on roads, schools, health systems and job creation.
With salaries, pensions, subsidies and interest payments already consuming more than 60% of state revenues, every additional rupee spent on cash transfers risks crowding out capital investment - the kind economists associate with longer-term growth and employment.
That trade-off is beginning to shape the political debate too.
Election after election, we've seen that welfare alone is not enough to win," says Louise Tillin, a professor of politics at King's College London. "It may help at the margins, but it is rarely the decisive factor.
One reason, Tillin says, is the rise of "competitive welfarism": almost every major party now offers some version of cash transfers, subsidies or free services, often trying to outbid rivals during campaigns.
That makes it harder for voters to distinguish between parties on welfare," she says, "and harder for parties not to have a welfare offer at all.
In a forthcoming paper using government survey data, Tillin found that even many welfare beneficiaries preferred higher public spending on infrastructure over expanded welfare - especially those who voted for the BJP-led government.
The research points to a growing gap between the political imagination of welfare and the way many recipients themselves understand it.
Voters may value welfare - but increasingly ask what comes after it: jobs, wages, mobility, aspiration.
"People do not aspire to be beneficiaries," says Tillin.
The shift has also reshaped the political language of welfare itself.
"Much of welfare delivery in India remains top-down and paternalistic - the political leader dispenses benefits and claims credit for them. It becomes a politics of gifts rather than rights," says Tillin.
Yamini Aiyar, a senior visiting fellow at Brown University, calls this "techno-patrimonialism" to describe how governments use "cash-transfer technology to recast welfare as a personal gift from political leaders".
Many appear to want something more enduring: jobs, mobility and economic self-worth.
That shift is also reflected in emerging research on how beneficiaries - especially women - view welfare.
"The media produced a narrative of cash transfers leading to electoral success. Political scientists who study elections don't really see a causal link," says Prabha Kotiswaran, a professor of law and social justice at King's College London.
Kotiswaran has researched women beneficiaries across several Indian states. In one project, she and fellow researchers interviewed women a year after cash-transfer schemes were introduced in Assam, West Bengal, Tamil Nadu and Karnataka - states where major parties had increasingly converged around unconditional transfers.
"The majority of the women in all these states said they did not vote for the party in power due to the cash transfers," she says.
Her fieldwork points to something more politically sophisticated than the transactional model often assumed by strategists. Many women, she says, viewed welfare not as a gift exchanged for votes but as partial compensation for state failure.
Some questioned how governments could sustain payouts indefinitely. Others argued that lowering prices or creating jobs mattered more than direct transfers.
"Women were far more worried about various other things, primarily the cost of living, decent work in rural areas for themselves and their educated children, and state specific issues like debt and alcoholism in Tamil Nadu," says Kotiswaran.
Welfare still matters politically, not least because women have become central to India's electoral landscape.
What was once an outlier idea - direct cash transfers to women - has, since 2021, become a near-universal campaign promise across parties.
"I think it is a positive development from a feminist perspective and needs to form the basis for a new generation of rights on the right to care," says Kotiswaran.
But as welfare becomes common across parties, it may no longer be enough on its own to secure voter loyalty.
"A party might get punished for withdrawing welfare. But whether it is getting rewarded (for offering it) is the real question," says Tillin.
Source: BBC
Related Posts: India’s Aadhaar-Linked Payments Cut Welfare Leakage By 12 India Seeks To Unite BRICS Potential To Promote Global Welfare Assam guv urges Sainik Welfare Board to reach out to ex-servicemen As Ladki Bahin squeezes Maharashtra welfare schemes IAMAI urges Karnataka to defer gig worker welfare fee on ecomm firms till specifics are defined WCD ministry holds workshop to identify reforms in social welfare Claude AI to Prioritize Its Own "Welfare" by Breaking Off Abusive Chats Kerala BJP pitches welfare push and big-ticket infrastructure in 2026 poll manifesto Government suspends fortified rice rollout in welfare schemes citing shelf-life concerns TMC To Release Film ‘Lokkhi Elo Ghore’ To Highlight Mamata’s Welfare Schemes Ahead Of Bengal Polls
A Filipino senator who oversaw former president Rodrigo Duterte's deadly war on drugs has taken refuge inside the country's Senate, hours before the International Criminal Court unsealed a warrant for his arrest. Ronald Dela Rosa was pictured fleeing into the Senate on Monday as officers chased
1 minutes ago
Internet fixes White House’s ‘treatment’ list for ‘Trump Derangement Syndrome’The term “Trump Derangement Syndrome” has been used by Donald Trump and his administration on several occasions. Published on: May 12, 2026 10:17 AM IST By Trisha Sengupta Share via Copy link Donald Trump
1 minutes ago
Actor-director Anshuman Jha’s upcoming film Lakadbaggha 2: The Monkey Business is set for an exclusive market screening at the Marché du Film at the Cannes Film Festival ahead of its official world premiere later this year. The film is backed by German production company Webfilmland Productions
1 minutes ago
Indian rupee hits record low 95.50 against US dollar as crude prices rise and dollar strengthens amid Iran-US war fears, after Trump calls ceasefire with Iran on life support Indian rupee’s downward trajectory continued on Tuesday, around the concerns of elevated global crude oil prices and the
1 minutes ago
Career Horoscope Today for May 12, 2026: A draining work cycle may eventually be coming to a close todayCareer Horoscope Today, May 12, 2026: Get career astrological predictions to help you prosper at your workplace. Published on: May 12, 2026 8:30 AM IST By Kishori Sud Share via Copy link Aries
1 minutes ago
Prolonged closure of the Strait of Hormuz has pushed Brent crude price forecasts up to USD 90‑95 per barrel from USD 82‑87 previously and is expected to keep crude oil prices elevated for longer, the report from Crisil Ratings said. New Delhi: India’s gross domestic product (GDP) is expected
1 minutes ago
A Noida-based pizza shop owner landed in police custody after a shocking CCTV clip allegedly showed him spitting on pizza dough while preparing food orders. The accused, identified as Mujammil, operates a food outlet named Pizza Hunt in Chaura village of Sector-22
1 minutes ago
is expected by analysts to report another robust on Wednesday as the technology investor benefits from its growing bet, though concerns are increasing over the debt it is taking on to fund it.While SoftBank's "all-in" bet on OpenAI has proven lucrative so far - the ChatGPT-creator's valuation has
1 minutes ago
The Enforcement Directorate (ED) on Monday alleged that Punjab minister and Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) leader Sanjeev Arora played a central role in the operations of a company accused of carrying out fake exports and laundering funds. CNN-News18 accessed key details from the investigation into the
1 minutes ago
AIADMK splitting? Anti-EPS faction backs Vijay, flexes MLA 'majority'The AIADMK rebel faction also claimed that majority party MLAs back them, not EPS, and that their only alliance was with TVK. Updated on: May 12, 2026 10:30 AM IST By HT News Desk Share via Copy link The spectacular political rise
1 minutes ago
An AIADMK faction has declared support for the TVK government led by Chief Minister C Joseph Vijay. Senior MLAs S P Velumani and C Ve Shanmugam will submit a letter to CM Vijay. They stated their opposition to party general secretary Edappadi K Palaniswami's alleged desire to form a government with
1 minutes ago
India's welfare politics is not collapsing - but its electoral magic may be fading. Over the past decade, cash transfers, subsidised services and women-focused schemes have become the default grammar of state politics in India, with welfare increasingly used to soften the effects of a growth model
1 minutes ago
A deadly hantavirus outbreak linked to the cruise ship MV Hondius has spread across multiple countries, leaving at least three people dead and several others infected as health authorities race to trace passengers repatriated across Europe and the United States
1 minutes ago
OpenAI said on Monday it is setting up a new company with more than $4 billion in initial investment to help organisations build and deploy artificial intelligence systems, and will acquire an AI consulting firm, Tomoro, to quickly scale up the unit
1 minutes ago
Mumbai woman declares Bengaluru’s food superior, calls for iconic eateries 'Nagarjuna and Meghana' to open in MumbaiA debate erupted after Reha Adani praised Bengaluru's food scene, stating it surpasses Mumbai's – some foodies defended Mumbai, others echoed Reha's sentiments
1 minutes ago
Eighteen Americans evacuated from a cruise ship after possible exposure to hantavirus are being closely monitored by health officials, as authorities say the risk to the public remains "very, very low". Officials say one passenger aboard the Dutch vessel MV Hondius has tested positive for the Andes
1 minutes ago
Gold was little changed following a modest two-day gain, as investors assessed the deadlock in the Middle East conflict, and swings in Asian stock markets ahead of a key US inflation report. Bullion for immediate delivery traded near $4,726 an ounce, paring earlier gains
1 minutes ago
Sensex, Nifty open in the red again as worries over US-Iran war fallout continueThe BSE Sensex opened at 75,573.63, down 441.65 points or 0.58% over persistent worries over the economic impact of elevated oil prices. Updated on: May 12, 2026 9:45 AM IST By HT News Desk Share via Copy link Indian
1 minutes ago
Recently, on 30 April, the Council for the Indian School Certificate Examinations (CISCE) announced the results of the Class 10 (ICSE) and Class 12 (ISC) board examinations, with both recording pass percentages above 99 per cent. Around 2.5 lakh students appeared for the ICSE examination
1 minutes ago
Gold Monetization Scheme: Gold is not merely for adornment and investment; it can also serve as a source of regular income for you. Let us tell you all about Gold Monetization. Gold Monetization Scheme: For Indians, gold is not limited merely to being an item of adornment; it is also a significant
1 minutes ago
Over the past year, has gone from an artificial intelligence afterthought to the one firm in the market with dominant positions in nearly every aspect of the technology. Now it’s on the brink of overtaking AI chip giant Corp. as the largest company in the world
1 minutes ago
Actress Amrita Puri, known popularly for starring in ‘Aisha’, has weighed in on the ongoing debate around working hours in the Hindi film industry, linking it to the wider discussion sparked by Deepika Padukone’s reported demand for an 8-hour work shift
1 minutes ago
Anjali Sivaraman to play Amrita Sher-Gil in Mira Nair's 'Amri'; Priyanka, Jaideep also featureAnjali Sivaraman to play Amrita Sher-Gil in Mira Nair's 'Amri'; Priyanka, Jaideep also feature May 12, 2026, 10:56:13 IST PTI Share via Copy link New Delhi
1 minutes ago
Following allegations that the question paper for the NEET-UG 2026 entrance examination held on May 3 was leaked, the National Testing Agency (NTA), which conducted the test, said it was aware of reports regarding the action initiated by the Rajasthan Special Operations Group (SOG) in connection
1 minutes ago
Asia's first defences against energy shocks from the Iran war are running short and a more consequential second wave of impacts is beginning to hit. Also Read: Updates on Iran-Israel war When the war started, governments scrambled to adapt to the closure of the Strait of Hormuz
1 minutes ago
If you are looking to install a new broadband connection at home, you should know which broadband provider offers the best benefits at the lowest price. If you are planning to get an Airtel broadband connection for your home, you’ll be pleased to know that the company offers an affordable plan
1 minutes ago
Step inside Gaurav Gera’s simple Mumbai bachelor pad that impressed Farah Khan with its ‘beautiful sunlight and views’Farah Khan stepped inside Gaurav Gera’s cosy Mumbai bachelor pad in her latest YouTube video, offering a glimpse of its minimal and peaceful interiors. Published on: May 12
1 minutes ago
