A viral video of a Chinese youth mocking burqa-clad women in Islamabad's F-10 Markaz has triggered a national debate on cultural respect and legal accountability. A video clip of a Chinese national making derogatory remarks and harassing burqa-clad women in the F-10 Markaz area of Islamabad has
Black garlic neither has the same features as its white variant nor the same intended health benefits. Rather than the familiar ivory-hued clove used to enhance the taste and aroma of Indian dishes, black garlic is dark and comes with a subtle and balsamic sweetness. Unlike regular garlic
Gold and silver have seen a rollercoaster end to a year in which their prices are on track to record their biggest annual gains since 1979. The price of gold soared by more than 60% this year to hit a record high of more than $4,549 (£3
Mumbai: Unlike the first phase of local body elections that largely saw a straight contest between the ruling Mahayuti alliance and the opposition Maharashtra Vikas Aghadi (MVA), the municipal corporation polls in major cities across Maharashtra have thrown up a different picture
Bihar Public Service Commission, on Monday, said that the written examination for the post of Assistant Education Development Officer (AEDO), scheduled to be held from 10-16 January next year, has been postponed. Why the AEDO written exam is postponed?Bihar Public Service Commission
Why restitution is a better word than repatriation for the return of looted artifacts
Museums and universities around the world hold vast collections of cultural artefacts, artworks, objectified belongings and even ancestral remains. Many were not freely given but taken during colonial times, through force, manipulation, theft or violence. For decades, they have sat in storerooms and display cases, classified into categories like anthropology, natural history or ethnology, separated from the people and communities to whom they once belonged.
In recent years, there has been growing recognition that these collections carry painful legacies.
Calls for their return have become part of a global conversation about decolonisation, justice and healing. In 2018 French president Emmanuel Macron produced a report which called for a new ethics of humanity, setting off a new willingness to return African artworks and material culture. But African calls for restitution were made at least five decades earlier following former president of the Democratic Republic of the Congo Mobutu Sese Seko's address to the UN.
In all these engagements, two words are often used: repatriation and restitution.
At first glance they may seem to mean the same thing, and both involve the return of something. But as South African scholars, working in the fields of history, museum studies and human biology, we argue that the difference between these terms is not just semantic. The choice of word reflects deeper politics of justice, recognition and repair.
In our recent article we explained how we see this difference, and why the work of restitution restores people's power over their future, and gives them a sense of agency. We argue that, for its part, repatriation has come to represent something less concerned with community restoration and has more to do with an administrative and logistical exercise.
We argue that, unlike repatriation, restitution speaks directly to justice.
The word repatriation comes from the Latin patria, meaning “fatherland”. Traditionally, it refers to the return of a person or their remains to their country of origin. Governments often use this term for the logistical and legal transfer of people, artworks, or ancestral remains across national borders.
In countries that were settled by colonisers, like the US, Canada, Australia and New Zealand, repatriation has become the dominant language. This is partly due to specific laws and frameworks. In the US, for example, the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act requires museums to return human remains and cultural items to Indigenous communities in a proactive manner.
In New Zealand, the national museum Te Papa plays a central role in repatriating Māori and Moriori ancestral remains from overseas institutions before returning them to local communities. In Australia, the choice of repatriation by activists, communities and scholars also sought strategically to draw a connection with the return of the remains of fallen soldiers.
In these contexts, repatriation is often framed as a process of giving back. States or museums take the lead, and communities receive.
Some Indigenous scholars and activists have challenged this framing, pointing out its patriarchal and statist overtones. They have introduced the concept of “rematriation”, signalling a return to “Mother Earth” rooted in Indigenous feminist perspectives, spirituality and community balance.
In South Africa, too, the term repatriation has been used, especially when the state arranged for the return of remains from abroad, as in the case of the return of Sarah Baartman from France.
Baartman was a 19th century Khoe (Indigenous South African) woman put on display in freak shows in Europe. Her body was later dissected by scientists within the realm of racial science and made to enter the systems of collecting and exhibition at the Musée de l'Homme in Paris. After being turned into an international symbol of the oppression of black women, Baartman also became a focus of claims for return made by Khoe and other activists and social movements in South Africa.
Repatriation has also been used for the return of the remains of ex-combatants and other patriots.
But unease began to grow. Was this language adequate for the deep work of justice and healing that communities were calling for? Or was it more concerned with national prestige than with community restoration?
Restitution is about returning something to its rightful owner, not simply as a transfer of property, but as an act of recognition, repair and healing.
Restitution is not just an event, like handing over an artefact in a ceremony. It is a process, time-consuming, emotional, and often painful. It involves research into how items were acquired, conversations with descendant communities, and decisions about how to care for or honour what has been returned. It recognises that the belongings taken were not just curiosities or objects, but were tied to community, and to language, ceremony and identity.
In many cases, ancestral remains were classified and objectified as human remains and specimens, stripping them of their humanity. Restitution, by contrast, restores them as ancestors with dignity and agency.
Our research uses the phrase “restitutionary work” to describe the labour involved. This work goes far beyond diplomacy, logistics and transport. It includes:
For example, South Africa's land restitution programme has shown that restitution is not simply about restoring what once was. It is about creating conditions for justice today and possibilities for tomorrow.
Similarly, cultural restitution is less about putting things “back where they came from” and more about empowering communities to reconnect with their heritage in ways that matter today.
The distinction between repatriation and restitution is not academic nitpicking. Words shape power. If return is framed as repatriation, the emphasis is often on the giver, the returner, in the form of the state or museum, granting something back. If it is framed as restitution, the emphasis shifts to the claimant, to the community asserting rights and demanding justice.
Restitution is not about recovering a lost past. That past cannot be restored exactly as it was. Instead, it is about creating new futures built on justice, dignity and respect. For communities around the world still living with the legacies of colonial dispossession, that distinction matters deeply.
Victoria Gibbon is Professor in Biological Anthropology, Division of Clinical Anatomy and Biological Anthropology, University of Cape Town.
Ciraj Rassoo is Senior Professor of History, University of the Western Cape.
This article was first published on The Conversation.
Source: Scroll
Related Posts: Virat Kohli Marks Domestic Return With Magnificent Hundred In Vijay Hazare Tarique Rahman To Return To B Rafael Nadal Opens Door To Davis Cup Return Balance Your Meals And Lifestyle To Manage Your Weight Better I wanted better sound for my New Year party Tarique Rahman enrolls for Bangladesh’s voter list following return Request Sonia Gandhi to return Nehru's letters to Prime Ministers' Museum Fred Warner drops major hint about postseason return Will Virat Kohli return to VHT 2025-26 again for Delhi before IND vs NZ ODIs No. 3 Georgia is eager to make better Sugar Bowl memories while No. 6 Ole Miss eyes payback
It had seemed like Arsenal were starting to wobble. After starting December with defeat by Aston Villa, they were far from convincing as they beat Wolves, Everton and Brighton by narrow margins. But the Gunners ground out vital results and they answered any lingering doubts over their title
Just now
The UAE rejected Saudi claims over Yemen, denied involvement in tensions or arms supply, reaffirmed support for Saudi security, called for restraint, coordination, and de-escalation to preserve regional stability. The United Arab Emirates expressed concern regarding the statement issued by the
Just now
Global trade is slowly shifting from dollar dominance. Using local currencies is no longer an economic choice, it is becoming a strategic tool. Local Currency Trade: For decades, the global economy revolved around the US dollar, but the dynamics are now changing. Rising geopolitical tensions
Just now
Pisces experiences a deeply emotional yet disciplined love year in 2026. Saturn remains in your first house, making you more serious and introspective in relationships. This placement can delay emotional expression but strengthens long-term commitment
Just now
British boxing star Anthony Joshua was injured in a fatal highway crash in Nigeria, just ten days after defeating Jake Paul in a Netflix bout. The former heavyweight champion, who has a significant fan base and a decorated career including an Olympic gold medal
Just now
Director Sriram Raghavan is taking on the war epic genre for the first time with his upcoming film, Ikkis. Over the years, the filmmaker has established a reputation for telling stories in thrillers and dark spy films. In a day and age when that has become the norm with films like Dhurandhar
Just now
Aries: Emotionally, today might feel an intense need for security. Take the time to bond with those who respect your space and who do not rush your feelings. Sometimes, silence is even more powerful than the spoken word. If you are in a relationship
Just now
Bollywood icon Rekha once again reminded the fashion world why she remains unmatched in elegance. Celebrating Christmas in a striking Manish Malhotra ensemble, the 71-year-old actress effortlessly blended festive glamour with her signature old-world charmBollywood icon Rekha once again reminded the
Just now
The process of conducting a special intensive revision of the voter rolls in Uttar Pradesh has been extended again, the state chief electoral officer said on Tuesday. The draft voter list will now be published on January 6, while the final list will be published on March 6
Just now
A street confrontation in Maharashtra has drawn attention after visuals showed a delivery agent being assaulted following a minor road incident. The episode reportedly occurred in Nagpur and was captured on camera by bystanders. The footage shows the delivery worker being attacked by occupants of a
Just now
Not every powerful scene comes easily, even when it ends up leaving a deep mark on audiences. One of the most unsettling moments in Dhurandhar — involving Ranveer Singh's character Hamza — almost didn't happen at all. Actor Naseem, who played Lulli in the film
Just now
I spent the early years of my career at a university campus working as a student counsellor. Those years gave me a chance to experience belonging and warmth, and develop my skills of active listening sprinkled with capacity and opportunities for fun. The campus offered me the gift of community
Just now
Even some of those who supported the rate cut acknowledged "the decision was finely balanced or that they could have supported keeping the target range unchanged," given the different risks facing the U.S. economy, according to the minutes released on Tuesday
Just now
The wife of an Indian man who died after waiting for nearly eight hours to see a doctor at a Canadian hospital has demanded justice. On December 22, Prashant Sreekumar reached Grey Nuns Hospital in Edmonton complaining of severe chest pain and loss of vision in one eye
Just now
Television superstar Hina Khan has stated what intimacy means to her and has expressed her immense love and gratitude for her husband, Rocky Jaiswal, who never fails to make her feel special, even after 13 years of togetherness. The couple, who are on a vacation to the Maldives
Just now
It was late May and I was in Darjeeling district of West Bengal interviewing tea estate managers and workers about the struggles their world famous industry was facing due to climate change and competition. On my first day there I had joined protesting activists and workers at Longview tea estate
Just now
East Bengal FC's Fazila Ikwaput and Soumya Guguloth both scored hat-tricks as the footballing powerhouse beat Sesa Football Academy 9-0, bagging their largest-ever victory in the Indian Women's League on Tuesday. Fazila (9′, 22′, 25′, 72′) scored four goals, Soumya (6′
Just now
At a time when fraud attacks on the Indian financial services ecosystem is going up, banks are pushing the adoption of video KYC instead of electronic KYC as a way to open digital accounts, according to people in the know. The central bank allows lenders to open digital savings accounts with just a
Just now
As the New Year rolled in, I felt like refreshing my setup, not just for better sound, but for something that actually looked fun and modern on my desk. Plain headphones did the job, but they never quite matched the energy of late-night gaming sessions, movie breaks, or music breaks
Just now
New Year celebrations often mean full homes, shared meals, and a kitchen that never seems to rest. In such moments, dishwashers play a quiet yet important role. After hosting friends or family, the focus should remain on conversations and memories, not piles of dirty utensils
Just now
Dense to very dense fog is set to persist across large parts of north and east India over the next several days, accompanied by cold wave and cold day conditions in multiple regions, the India Meteorological Department (IMD) announced. In its latest weather bulletin
Just now
The Special Court for People's Representatives in Bengaluru on Tuesday granted conditional bail to Congress MLA from Challakere constituency KC Veerendra, also known as Pappi, four months after his arrest by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) in a money laundering case linked to online betting
Just now
India's Gen Z, numbering 380 million, is a powerful force driving change. This generation is impacting innovation, politics, and spending habits. Their direct and influenced spending is set to grow significantly. Gen Z's evolving preferences for celebrations, online expression
Just now
Caballero defends Maresca after Palmer substitution sparks jeers Chelsea assistant coach Willy Caballero defended Enzo Maresca's decision to replace Cole Palmer after the controversial substitution sparked jeered from angry fans during the 2-2 draw against Bournemouth on Tuesday
Just now
Khaleda Zia, Bangladesh's first woman prime minister, died after a prolonged illness, said her Bangladesh Nationalist Party. She was 80. She had been suffering from advanced cirrhosis of the liver, arthritis, diabetes, chest and heart problems.Khaleda Zia, Bangladesh's first woman prime minister
Just now
A dynamic new “consumer class” emerging from Africa is attracting international attention. With the prospect of rising incomes and a young population, international consulting firms see the continent as the next frontier for consumer goods
Just now
Eventful as it was, 2025 was also a year of profound loss, with several celebrated personalities who contributed greatly in the fields of art and politics bidding the world a goodbye. From advertising legend Piyush Pandey to 'He-man' Dharmendra, India lost some great gems in 2025.Eventful as it was
Just now
