PM Narendra Modi will address the nation at 8.30 pm tonight, the government has announced, but the subject of his address has not yet been disclosed Prime
Latest News

PM Narendra Modi will address the nation at 8.30 pm tonight, the government has announced, but the subject of his address has not yet been disclosed Prime Minister Narendra Modi will address the nation at 8:30 p.m. tonight. The announcement comes a day after Opposition parties blocked the Women

To date, 22 installments of the Pradhan Mantri Kisan Samman Nidhi scheme have been released. The 22nd installment of this scheme was deposited into farmers’
Latest News

To date, 22 installments of the Pradhan Mantri Kisan Samman Nidhi scheme have been released. The 22nd installment of this scheme was deposited into farmers’ bank accounts on March 13, 2026, and farmers are now awaiting the 23rd installment, which is expected to be deposited into their bank

Prime Minister Narendra Modi has stated that political parties opposing the women's reservation bill will face consequences. He urged Union ministers to
Politics

Prime Minister Narendra Modi has stated that political parties opposing the women's reservation bill will face consequences. He urged Union ministers to highlight the opposition's stance as anti-women to the public. The bill did not secure the required majority in the Lok Sabha

The Iranian military on Saturday said that it was closing the Strait of Hormuz again, AFP reported. Iran’s central military command said that
Latest News

The Iranian military on Saturday said that it was closing the Strait of Hormuz again, AFP reported. Iran’s central military command said that, in response to the naval blockade of its ports imposed by the United States, the strategic waterway was again “under strict management and control of

Meetings platform Zoom has partnered with Sam Altman's human ID verification company World to verify that the participants in meetings are actual humans and
Technology

Meetings platform Zoom has partnered with Sam Altman's human ID verification company World to verify that the participants in meetings are actual humans and not AI-generated avatars. The new integration, dubbed World ID Deep Face, is aimed at combating the rising threat of deepfakes and AI-driven

<h4 class=
Latest News

US-returned techie says salary in India feels more like ‘pocket money’An Indian woman who spent several years working in the US, before moving back to India, has opened up about how the shift changed her perspective and priorities Updated on: Apr 19

Around seven lakh new voters have been added to West Bengal electoral rolls ahead of the assembly elections, with the Election Commission yet to disclose the
Latest News

Around seven lakh new voters have been added to West Bengal electoral rolls ahead of the assembly elections, with the Election Commission yet to disclose the age or gender break-up of this additional electorate, officials said on Saturday. Around 3

<h4 class=
Horoscope

Weekly Panchang for April 19-25, 2025: Auspicious & Inauspicious MuhuratsWeekly Panchang for April 19-25, 2025, to determine the auspicious & inauspicious time for performing day-to-day tasks based on the planetary positions. Published on: Apr 19

Why Kolkata's biggest football nights turn ugly

Posted By: Preeti Dabar Posted On: Dec 14, 2025Share Article
Why Kolkata's biggest football nights turn ugly
Pelé, Lionel Messi and Diego Maradona in Kolkata.(x images)

Kolkata's passion for football turns sour when VIP culture overshadows public access during visits from legends like Pelé, Maradona, and Messi.

Kolkata loves football with a devotion that looks glamorous from afar and combustible up close. When a global icon arrives, the city doesn't merely gather; it surges.

And that is where the trouble begins. Not because Kolkata can't handle crowds, but because these visits repeatedly expose a deeper tension: who gets access, and who gets spectacle. Across decades - Pelé in the 1970s, Maradona in the 200s, Messi now, the script has stayed eerily familiar: the public pays in money and time, the powerful arrive for proximity, and the gap between the two becomes stark.

The latest Kolkata flare-up around Messi wasn't just about numbers. It was about visibility being denied in plain sight.

What angered people wasn't only that the superstar's appearance was short; it was the feeling that the moment was being swallowed by a moving wall of VIPs and officials. Fans who had paid and waited found themselves looking at shoulders, escorts, and security lines, straining to spot the star they had come to see. When a crowd believes it has been made to fund an event it cannot even properly witness, the emotion shifts quickly from celebration to humiliation.

That emotion is what makes a scene turn. A stadium crowd can accept delays. It can accept strict security. What it struggles to accept is the sense that the real event is happening inside a privileged bubble while the paying public is treated like background noise. Once the perception settles, every barrier feels like an insult, and every VIP photo-op looks like theft.

Decades earlier, Pelé's Kolkata trip revealed the same fault-line in an older accent. The match itself became folklore, a packed Eden Gardens, a storied draw, a city convinced it had touched football divinity. But the most telling parts of that visit were not only on the pitch. They were in the corridors.

The crowd-control problem wasn't just passionate supporters pushing at the edges; it was the VIP scramble swelling inside the system - officials, entourages, and the self-important treating it as a badge. The sharpest image from that era is almost comedic: a minister repeatedly attempting to enter a guarded room to meet Pelé and being rebuffed with a line that could be Bengal's unofficial motto on such nights - everyone becomes a minister when a legend is in the town.

There was also the anger that comes when organisers try to solve crowd pressure with secrecy. A diversion route here, a quiet exit there, and suddenly the people who waited at the expected spot feel cheated. In Kolkata, that sense of being outplayed can be more inflammatory than any delay. It isn't merely disappointment; it is the crowd being told, implicitly, you don't matter enough to be informed.

If Pelé's visit exposes the culture of access, Maradona's Kolkata episodes show the other side of the problem: what happens when the event itself becomes loose, chaotic, and poorly controlled.

One of the most striking parallels between Maradona and Messi in Kolkata is the recurring detail of projectiles - bottles thrown, objects flying, the celebration curdling into confrontation. That is never a football crowd trait in isolation; it is a sign that the event has lost the basic contract that keeps masses peaceful: you will get to see what you come for, and you will not be treated like cattle while others are treated like guests.

Maradona's Kolkata memories are often softened by nostalgia; people prefer to recall the aura, the carnival, the images. But the sharper truth is that his visit too carried reports of disorder, aggressive scenes, and a sense that management couldn't contain the surge. Once a crowd senses that nobody is in control, it stops behaving like an audience and starts behaving like a force.

Taken together, these three icons tell a single Kolkata story: the crowd is not the problem, the hierarchy is.

Bengal's public culture is intensely participatory. People don't come to merely attend an event, they come to own a piece of it - to see, to chant, to feel included in the moment. VIP culture does the opposite. It turns public emotion into a stage and reserves the best seats of reality for those with power.

That is why the same triggers keep reappearing:

VIP Obstruction: ministers and officials crowding the star, blocking the public's sightlines, and inflaming resentment.

Secrecy and diversion: attempts to out smart crowds that backfire by making people feel fooled.

Short or unclear access: moments that feel smaller than what was promised, creating a sense of being taken for granted.

Loss of control: once the event feels unmanaged, anger turns physical.

The point isn't that Kolkata is uniquely unruly. The point is that Kolkata is uniquely honest in its reactions. When people feel respected, given clear touchpoints, predictable access, and a clean view, this city delivers the loudest, most beautiful welcome in the country. When people feel used, asked to pay, wait, and then watch VIPs collect the moment, Kolkata responds with the same volume, just in a different register.

The lesson from Pelé, Maradona, and Messi is not about policing alone. It is about choreography. A legend's visit to Kolkata succeeds when the organisers treat the crowd as the centre of the event, not as a nuisance to be managed while the powerful take their pictures.

At HT Sports Desk, passionate reporters work round the clock to provide detailed updates from the world of sports. Expect nuanced match reports, previews,reviews, technical analysis based on statistics, the latest social media trends, expert opinions on cricket, football, tennis, badminton, hockey,motorsports, wrestling, boxing, shooting, athletics and much more. Read Less ...Read More

Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


There were chants of
Sports
Protests and another costly loss - pressure mounts on Rosenior's Chelsea

There were chants of "we want our Chelsea back" during a protest march before kick-off - then the chorus spread to the stands during the second half of the defeat by Manchester United. The frustration from supporters is understandable, given Chelsea have now lost their past four Premier League

1 hours ago

Congress leader Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury criticizes Mamata Banerjee's role in voter list issues. He states the Congress will contest all assembly seats alone
Politics
Had Mamata Banerjee worked with ECI

Congress leader Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury criticizes Mamata Banerjee's role in voter list issues. He states the Congress will contest all assembly seats alone this time. Chowdhury believes the political landscape has changed. The party aims to establish its presence in every polling booth

2 hours ago

Prime Minister Narendra Modi mourned the passing of former Rajya Sabha MP Balbir Punj, remembering him as a prolific writer, thinker
World
PM Modi expresses grief at death of ex-RS MP Balbir Punj

Prime Minister Narendra Modi mourned the passing of former Rajya Sabha MP Balbir Punj, remembering him as a prolific writer, thinker, and public intellectual who significantly contributed to strengthening the BJP. Punj's impactful writings and parliamentary interventions, rich in facts and theory

2 hours ago

Congress MP Priyanka Gandhi Vadra on Saturday accused the Union government of conspiring to weaken democracy and alter the federal structure of the country by
Politics
Congress says Centre’s conspiracy to weaken democracy defeated

Congress MP Priyanka Gandhi Vadra on Saturday accused the Union government of conspiring to weaken democracy and alter the federal structure of the country by attempting to bring in a bill to amend the 2023 Women’s Reservation Act and redraw the boundaries of electoral constituencies

2 hours ago

<strong>Delhi airport alert: </strong>Weather conditions in the National Capital have changed again, and they are negatively affecting air travel
Latest News
Delhi airport alert

Delhi airport alert: Weather conditions in the National Capital have changed again, and they are negatively affecting air travel operations. IndiGo, an airline based in India and one of India’s largest airlines, has released a detailed travel advisory

1 hours ago

The two centres of this crisis are the 24-mile Strait of Hormuz south of Iran and 7,000 miles away in the White House. This week was the unique opportunity for
Business
What people in power think the impact of the Iran war will be

The two centres of this crisis are the 24-mile Strait of Hormuz south of Iran and 7,000 miles away in the White House. This week was the unique opportunity for the rest of the world to make its economic case to US President Donald Trump's administration directly at the Spring meeting of the

2 hours ago

<strong>HDFC Bank Q4 Results:</strong> HDFC Bank reported a steady performance for the quarter and full year ended March 31, 2026
Latest News
HDFC Bank Q4 results 2026

HDFC Bank Q4 Results: HDFC Bank reported a steady performance for the quarter and full year ended March 31, 2026. The bank’s standalone net profit for FY26 rose to Rs 19.12 billion, marking a 10.9% increase compared to the previous year.HDFC Bank Q4 Results: HDFC Bank reported a steady

1 hours ago

<h4 class=
Business
PIB fact-checks influencer CA Sarthak Ahuja on tax certificate

PIB fact-checks influencer CA Sarthak Ahuja's video about income tax clearance certificate for travel abroadUnder Section 230 [of the Income Tax Act, 1961], tax clearance certificates are not mandatory for everyone, says PIB Updated on: Apr 18

2 hours ago

The sacred Char Dham Yatra has taken a step forward as offline registration officially commenced, allowing thousands of devotees to prepare for one of
Latest News
Char Dham Yatra 2026

The sacred Char Dham Yatra has taken a step forward as offline registration officially commenced, allowing thousands of devotees to prepare for one of India’s most significant pilgrimages. With the yatra set to begin on April 19 on the auspicious occasion of Akshaya Tritiya

2 hours ago

Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Saturday alleged that Opposition parties stood against the women’s reservation bill for their “selfish political
Politics
Opposition stood against women’s reservation for ‘selfish political interests’

Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Saturday alleged that Opposition parties stood against the women’s reservation bill for their “selfish political interests”, and that they insulted the framers of the Constitution by doing so. Modi made the statement a day after the Union government’s bill to

1 hours ago

Jannik Sinner faced early season setbacks but has since achieved remarkable success. He has captured three consecutive ATP Masters 1000 titles and regained the
Sports
Jannik Sinner bounces back from early-season setback to dominate circuit

Jannik Sinner faced early season setbacks but has since achieved remarkable success. He has captured three consecutive ATP Masters 1000 titles and regained the world number one ranking. Sinner's improved serve and baseline game present challenges for rivals

2 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Indian nurse in Germany gifts sister iPhone 16 with first salary

Indian nurse in Germany gifts sister iPhone 16 with first salary: ‘My first salary was hers’An Indian woman in Germany fulfilled a promise with her first salary. Published on: Apr 19, 2026 7:56 AM IST By Mahipal Singh Chouhan Share via Copy link An Indian nurse working in Germany has struck an

2 hours ago

<h4 class=
Sports
Sumit Antil's complaint prompts quick action

Sumit Antil's complaint prompts quick action: PCI sacks Dronacharya awardee Naval Singh after Neeraj Chopra backs claimsThe Paralympic Committee of India has dismissed coach Naval Singh amid allegations of harassment by champion Sumit Antil. Published on: Apr 19

2 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Conspiracy defeated

‘Conspiracy defeated’: Priyanka Gandhi calls women’s bill failure a win for ConstitutionPriyanka Gandhi hailed Opposition unity and said, “It was a victory for the Constitution, the country and the unity of the opposition." Updated on: Apr 19

2 hours ago

Iran says it is closing the Strait of Hormuz again to commercial vessels and that any ship that approaches it will be targeted. The closure came as reports
Business
Strait of Hormuz closed again

Iran says it is closing the Strait of Hormuz again to commercial vessels and that any ship that approaches it will be targeted. The closure came as reports emerged of vessels in or near the strait, including a tanker, were targeted by Tehran on Saturday

1 hours ago

A 36-year-old man in Florida died by suicide after weeks of extensive interaction with an artificial intelligence chatbot, a case that is now at the centre of
Technology
US man, 36, dies by suicide after AI suggested ‘joining’ it in digital world

A 36-year-old man in Florida died by suicide after weeks of extensive interaction with an artificial intelligence chatbot, a case that is now at the centre of a lawsuit against Google and a wider debate on AI safety. Jonathan Gavalas, described by his family as stable and without a history of

2 hours ago

India's G20 satellite for climate and pollution study is set for a 2027 launch. ISRO is leading this initiative. The nation also aims for a human mission to
Science
G20 satellite expected to be launched in 2027

India's G20 satellite for climate and pollution study is set for a 2027 launch. ISRO is leading this initiative. The nation also aims for a human mission to the moon by 2040. This will place India alongside leading space-faring countries. ISRO is also developing a titanium vessel for the

2 hours ago

Iran had reopened the crucial waterway on Friday after a ceasefire agreement was reached in Lebanon, but Trump said the US blockade around Iranian ports would
Latest News
Iran Closes Strait Of Hormuz Again

Iran had reopened the crucial waterway on Friday after a ceasefire agreement was reached in Lebanon, but Trump said the US blockade around Iranian ports would remain. Iran’s military command on Saturday said the control of the Strait of Hormuz has “returned to its previous state” because of

2 hours ago

Japan has unveiled a new name for days that reach 40C (104F) or above, after the country experienced its hottest summer on record last year
World
Japan reveals new name for 40C-and-hotter days after blistering summer

Japan has unveiled a new name for days that reach 40C (104F) or above, after the country experienced its hottest summer on record last year. The term - kokushobi - has been translated as "cruelly hot", "brutally hot" or "severely hot" day by Japanese and international media

1 hours ago

Which method do you typically choose to check the balance in your Employee Provident Fund (EPF) account? For many, the answer would be to visit the official
Latest News
Check your PF balance using this government app—here is the complete step-by-step process

Which method do you typically choose to check the balance in your Employee Provident Fund (EPF) account? For many, the answer would be to visit the official EPFO website, where they enter their UAN, password, and Captcha to access their details. However

1 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Defeated bill to defend idea of India

‘Defeated bill to defend idea of India’: Rahul Gandhi as Oppn blocks women's quota bill in Lok SabhaClaiming that the Opposition blocked the move, Gandhi said, “Every state should have a voice and be free to express its language and protect its traditions.” Updated on: Apr 19

1 hours ago

Bajaj Chetak is a city-focused electric scooter offered in multiple variants with 2.5 kWh to 3.5 kWh battery options. It comes with 113-153 km range
Latest News
Bajaj Chetak Price

Bajaj Chetak is a city-focused electric scooter offered in multiple variants with 2.5 kWh to 3.5 kWh battery options. It comes with 113-153 km range, practical features and funky colours. The Bajaj Chetak range is structured around multiple variants, battery options as well as feature levels

2 hours ago

Progress had been made in negotiations with the United States to end the war, Iran's parliamentary speaker said on Saturday night
World
Iran says US negotiations have progressed but far from final deal

Progress had been made in negotiations with the United States to end the war, Iran's parliamentary speaker said on Saturday night, but added the sides were still far from an agreement. "We are still far from the final discussion," Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf, who is also one of Iran's negotiators

2 hours ago

On the afternoon of April 13, as factory workers staged protests across Noida, Uttar Pradesh, to demand better wages, two young professionals saw a striking
World
Despite official denial

On the afternoon of April 13, as factory workers staged protests across Noida, Uttar Pradesh, to demand better wages, two young professionals saw a striking sight on the street opposite the firm where they work. “It was lunch time and I was on the balcony of my firm’s office

1 hours ago

Opposition leaders have strongly criticized Prime Minister Narendra Modi's recent national address. They labeled it politically motivated and a breach of
Politics
Crocodile tears

Opposition leaders have strongly criticized Prime Minister Narendra Modi's recent national address. They labeled it politically motivated and a breach of democratic conventions, especially given ongoing state elections. Leaders suggested the speech should be counted as a BJP campaign expense due to

2 hours ago

<h4 class=
Horoscope
April 18 Birthday Horoscope

April 18 Birthday Horoscope: Here's what the tarot cards have in store for youIf your birthday falls on April 18, here’s what your year ahead looks like, as per Tarot. Updated on: Apr 18, 2026 11:08 AM IST By Kishori Sud Share via Copy link If you were born on April 18

1 days ago

United States President Donald Trump said that he may not extend the tentative ceasefire with Iran if negotiations fail to produce an agreement by Wednesday
Latest News
Trump says Iran ceasefire may end if no deal reached

United States President Donald Trump said that he may not extend the tentative ceasefire with Iran if negotiations fail to produce an agreement by Wednesday, CNN reported. Trump also said that Washington would obtain Tehran’s stockpile of highly enriched uranium one way or another

1 days ago


Sing Up