The ET GenAI Hackathon 2026 has announced the results of its Idea Submission phase, with the shortlist finalised after evaluating entries from more than 54,000 builders across India. Shortlisted teams now advance to the Prototype Development Phase
The fast-expanding war between the United States, Israel, and Iran has captured global attention largely because it is disrupting oil and gas supplies from the Persian Gulf. Yet another resource is now emerging as far more critical to the survival of the region’s societies. Water
Indian technology stocks have seen an unprecedented rout over the past few weeks over fears of artificial intelligence upending the traditional outsourcing model that powers the country's $300bn (£223bn) back-office industry. The sell-off - part of a global correction in traditional software and
The ruling Bharatiya Janata Party-led National Democratic Alliance (NDA) on Monday managed an easy victory in the biennial polls to five Rajya Sabha seats in Bihar, with its candidates including Chief Minister Nitish Kumar and BJP national president Nitin Nabin
Star Brazilian forward Neymar didn’t receive a call-up to the national team squad for the upcoming friendlies against France and Croatia, although striker Endrick found a spot. With this snub, Neymar’s hopes of playing at the upcoming FIFA World Cup have received a massive blow
Why historical literacy matters today
Why historical literacy matters today Premium
Recently, during an engaging discussion with an educator about the ‘Vande Mataram’ controversy, I asked if students today possessed historical literacy. She responded in the negative.
Studying history is different from developing historical literacy. The former focuses merely on acquiring knowledge about past events, whereas the latter equips students with the ability to evaluate sources critically, situate events within their proper context, recognise bias, and draw meaningful connections between the past and the present, ensuring that they are better prepared to participate responsibly and thoughtfully in civic life.
Ever since celebrations for the 150th anniversary of ‘Vande Mataram’ began in November 2025, the song has become the subject of widespread debate across India. Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath’s announcement that all educational institutions in the state should sing the song, along with the recent directive from the Union Home Ministry mandating the playing of the full six-stanza version at government functions, has further intensified the discussion about the government’s motive.
In this context, it is important to examine the reasons for these directives, the historical context in which the song was written, its role during the freedom struggle, the controversy around certain stanzas, and its contemporary relevance. According to Adityanath, making the national song compulsory in schools and colleges is to “instil a sense of reverence and pride towards the nation” and strengthen India’s unity.
Opponents, however, contend that compelling non-Hindus to sing the song — particularly stanzas three to six that portray the motherland as a Hindu goddess — violates their religious freedom. Critics also refer to the 1986 Supreme Court judgment in Emmanuel vs. State of Kerala, which upheld the fundamental rights of three students who were expelled for refusing to sing the national anthem, ruling that standing silently and respectfully constitutes sufficient expression of respect. The verdict further affirmed that forcing citizens to sing violates freedom of conscience under Article 25, and freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a), as no legal provision mandates singing.
Meanwhile, several historians and educators, though not opposed to the first two stanzas, view the mandatory inclusion of all six as an attempt to make people believe that the full song was accepted by all freedom fighters. They note that only the first two stanzas were adopted by the Constituent Assembly and argue that enforcing the complete version reflects an effort to advance a Hindutva-oriented perspective.
A similar debate arose when the hymn ‘Abide with Me’ was removed from Republic Day celebrations in 2022. Although the government described the move as part of a process to “decolonise India”, critics viewed it as sidelining a song associated with Mahatma Gandhi and reshaping historical memory.
These controversies highlight a broader concern: patriotism cannot be instilled through coercion, but flourishes through the lived practice of equality, fraternity, and liberty. Making the singing of ‘Vande Mataram’ mandatory is unlikely to cultivate authentic pride and may heighten religious tensions. True education fosters tolerance and peaceful coexistence, upholding the Constitution’s guarantee of religious freedom and avoiding the privileging of any single faith.
The deliberate manipulation of historical narratives is a powerful form of indoctrination that seeks to control the present by reshaping the past. When history is distorted or selectively presented, it profoundly influences how individuals understand their society. In this way, control over the past becomes a means of shaping public consciousness in the present.
In response to this danger, students must be encouraged to question the narratives placed before them. Rather than accepting accounts at face value, they should learn to examine evidence carefully, challenge manufactured or selective versions of events, and critically assess the perspectives that shape historical interpretation. Without these skills, they risk becoming passive recipients of narrow or biased viewpoints that restrict their understanding of the world. This is where historical literacy becomes essential.
At a time when divisive “us versus them” narratives are constructed along ideological lines, and history is frequently reinterpreted to advance particular agendas, the need for historical literacy is urgent. It is the moral and social responsibility of educators to ensure that students are aware of the rights guaranteed to them by the Constitution. Through this commitment, we help nurture informed citizens capable of applying critical thinking to the complex issues that shape their lives and their society.
Those who have developed historical literacy understand well the meaning behind George Orwell’s statement: “Who controls the past controls the future; who controls the present controls the past.” However, whether our education system can help students develop this essential skill remains a crucial question.
The writer is an ELT resource person and education columnist. Email rayanal@yahoo.co.uk
Published - February 22, 2026 12:00 pm IST
universities and colleges / higher education / careers / university / students / The Hindu Education Plus
Source: TheHindu
Related Posts: Volkswagen Tayron R-Line India launch today – here are the features Gold Rate Today (February 20 Don't Need Historical S**t Gold Rate Today (February 19 PM Modi to address AI Summit today Silver prices bleed today (Feb 18) Gold Rate Today (February 18 US flies nuclear reactor – why this technology matters for India CBSE Board Exams 2026 Begin Today For Classes 10 & 12 Nissan Gravite MPV launching today – here is what to expect
Former India captain Sunil Gavaskar has said Sunrisers Leeds' signing of Pakistan spinner Abrar Ahmed "indirectly contributes to the deaths of Indian soldiers and civilians". Gavaskar's comments are the most high-profile criticism of Sunrisers' deal for Abrar at last week's Hundred auction
5 hours ago
The US artificial intelligence (AI) firm Anthropic is looking to hire a chemical weapons and high-yield explosives expert to try to prevent "catastrophic misuse" of its software. In other words, it fears that its AI tools might tell someone how to make chemical or radioactive weapons
5 hours ago
If one wants to explore the many debates and controversies surrounding the Congress and its role in shaping India’s political trajectory, there may soon be a new address in the capital to turn to. At 3, Safdarjung Lane, the official residence of Nishikant Dubey — the Bharatiya Janata Party MP
5 hours ago
Chelsea have been handed a Premier League record fine of £10.75m and a suspended transfer ban. It was a result of the club making secret payments to unregistered agents and third-parties over transfers between 2011 and 2018. But it could have been a lot worse
5 hours ago
Kerala Congress (M), BDJS announce names of 12 candidates eachKerala Congress (M) and BDJS announced candidates for the upcoming assembly polls, including KC(M) chairman Jose K Mani from Pala and 12 others from BDJS. Published on: Mar 17, 2026 7:36 AM IST By Vishnu Varma
5 hours ago
Iran’s National Security Chief Ali Larijani on Monday penned a note to Muslim countries, questioning their lack of support for Tehran as the US-Israeli war is now entering its third week with no clear end in sight, disrupting global energy supplies and raising fears of a spike in global inflation
5 hours ago
Nagaon MP Pradyut Bordoloi expressed strong displeasure over Dr. Asif Nazar being considered for the Lahorighat Assembly ticket, citing Nazar's alleged association with an individual charged in an attack on Bordoloi. Bordoloi wrote to AICC General Secretary Jitendra Singh
5 hours ago
A sessions court in Gujarat’s Gir Somnath district on Monday convicted five persons and acquitted 35 others in connection with a 2016 case in which seven Dalits were assaulted in the town of Una, The Indian Express reported. Additional Sessions Judge Jignesh Pandya of the court in Veraval
5 hours ago
It's Hollywood's biggest night. The 98th Academy Awards featured emotional speeches, comical relief and a bevy of backstage fun. But it was perhaps a night to forget for Timothée Chalamet. As well as losing out to Michael B Jordan for best actor and One Battle After Another for best picture
5 hours ago
US President Donald Trump on Monday said more than 30 mine laying ships of Iran have been destroyed which has affected Tehran’s capacity to threaten commercial shipping in the Strait of Hormuz. “We are hammering their capacity to threaten commercial shipping in the Strait of Hormuz with more
5 hours ago
Love Horoscope Today for March 17, 2026: A spontaneous moment could lead to a meaningful connectionLove Horoscope Today, March 17, 2026: Find daily astrological predictions for all sun signs. Published on: Mar 17, 2026 7:28 AM IST By Neeraj Dhankher Share via Copy link Aries: Mars is pushing you to
5 hours ago
Dubai arrests Iranian drone strike survivors after they sent explosion photos to loved ones3 foreigner nationals who survived drone strike in Dubai have been arrested after sending photos of the explosions to family members. Updated on: Mar 16
5 hours ago
‘Firms need to move to adaptive, energy-efficient AI models’Sarah Hooker is convinced that the future lies in AI systems that use less computing power, cost less to run and can adapt to the needs of users. Published on: Mar 17, 2026 6:58 AM IST By Shweta Taneja Share via Copy link In the last
5 hours ago
Baghdad witnessed a significant drone and rocket attack on the U.S. embassy early Tuesday. This incident marks the most intense assault since the commencement of the U.S.-Israel war with Iran. Iraqi security forces have heightened their presence across the capital. The Green Zone
5 hours ago
Russell Wilson trade update: Chiefs hand a shock to Giants QB with Justin Fields move Published on: Mar 17, 2026 5:03 AM IST By Khushi Arora Share via Copy link New York Giants quarterback Russell Wilson (3) waves to fans after the game against the Dallas Cowboys (IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect)
5 hours ago
![London [UK], March 17 (ANI): The Premier League has completed a disciplinary process with Chelsea FC in respect of historical breaches relating to Financial](http://newsorbit360.com/files/news/en/imgs/chelsea-fined-and-faces-supended-transfer-ban-by-premier-league.webp?height=520)
London [UK], March 17 (ANI): The Premier League has completed a disciplinary process with Chelsea FC in respect of historical breaches relating to Financial Reporting and Third Party Investment.In 2022, Chelsea FC’s current owners voluntarily reported to the League that they had evidence of
5 hours ago
A Bengaluru-based cafe has drawn attention on social media after adding a 5 per cent “Gas Crisis Charge" to a customer’s lemonade order, sparking debate on social media platform X. The unusual fee, applied on a bill for two mint lemonades, has left many users amused and some questioning its
5 hours ago
Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Still using an older laptop? These Intel 13th Gen laptops show what modern performance feels likeIntel 13th Gen laptops bring improved performance
5 hours ago
US President Donald Trump said on Monday that he is planning to delay a high stakes visit to China later in March by about a month because of the Iran war. "We've requested that we delay it a month or so," he told reporters at the White House
5 hours ago
LDF ally ISJD, UDF ally RSP name candidates for four seats eachThe ISJD and RSP announced their candidates for Kerala Assembly polls, with ISJD's K Krishnankutty retiring from politics and RSP seeking assembly representation. Published on: Mar 17, 2026 7:30 AM IST By Vishnu Varma
5 hours ago
Horoscope Today, March 17, 2026: Operational strategies at work need refinementHoroscope Today: Read the astrological predictions for each zodiac sign based on an expert's guidance on March 17, 2026. Published on: Mar 17, 2026 7:19 AM IST By Dr Prem Kumar Sharma
5 hours ago
The report from Elara Capital said retail gasoline and diesel prices “could be fully protected through excise cuts until roughly $110/bbl, beyond which price hikes on diesel and gasoline would become inevitable”. Also Read :Fino Payments Bank Shares Fall To 52-Week Low Amid Probe Reports;
5 hours ago
Punjab Assembly session: House passes motion against LoP Bajwa over ‘band player’ remarkThe Punjab assembly condemned opposition leader Partap Singh Bajwa for alleged derogatory remarks about a minister, leading to chaos and a walkout by Congress. Published on: Mar 17
5 hours ago
More than a thousand citizens in Ladakh's Leh and Kargil regions rallied on Monday, echoing calls for statehood and adherence to the Sixth Schedule. Leaders from the Apex Body Leh alongside the Kargil Democratic Alliance expressed their discontent regarding the central government's stance
5 hours ago
Menstrual pain is often dismissed as an inevitable part of being a woman. But when cramps become debilitating, interfere with daily life or are accompanied by chronic pelvic discomfort, they may signal something more serious. One such condition is endometriosis – a long-term disorder affecting
5 hours ago
Khushbu Sundar comes out in support of Trisha amid her viral pics with Vijay: ‘She is one of the most dignified women’Khushbu Sundar has addressed the online chatter surrounding the public appearance of Vijay and Trisha Krishnan, after the divorce petition filed by Sangeeta. Mar 17, 2026
5 hours ago
Rex Culpepper's fiancee pays sweet tribute after tragic bike accident death: ‘I don’t regret' Published on: Mar 17, 2026 4:55 AM IST By Yash Nitish Bajaj Share via Copy link Former Syracuse quarterback Rex Culpepper died after an accident on Saturday (Instagram/Rex Culpepper) Rex Culpepper
5 hours ago
