A chance to set a precedent: Mercedes Kilmer on father Val Kilmer’s AI-powered final roleA chance to set a precedent: Mercedes Kilmer on father Val Kilmer’s AI-powered final role Apr 30, 2026, 14:19:13 IST PTI Share via Copy link Los Angeles
There was "no meaningful shift" away from big tech platforms like TikTok and Instagram in the immediate wake of Australia's world-leading teen social media ban, government documents obtained by AFP show.Australia in December banned under 16s from a raft of popular social media platforms
Do the 2026 exit polls signal a comeback for the Congress, or do they underline its shrinking footprint? Projections across key states point to a familiar, uneven story—pockets of resilience in the South, particularly Kerala, but continued struggles in high-stakes battlegrounds like Assam and
The Bombay High Court on Wednesday granted bail to Sharad Kalaskar, one of the convicts in the murder of anti-superstition activist Narendra Dabholkar, Live Law reported. A bench of Justices Ajay Gadkari and Ranjitsinha Bhonsale also expressed doubts about Kalaskar being identified as the assailant
Yami Gautam says Dhurandhar's success tells ‘it was always about scripts’; reveals Aditya Dhar is ‘unaffected’ by itYami Gautam emphasised that Dhurandhar's success reflected a shift towards quality storytelling, while she and Aditya remain humble and grateful. Apr 30, 2026
Why historical literacy matters today
Why historical literacy matters today Premium
Recently, during an engaging discussion with an educator about the ‘Vande Mataram’ controversy, I asked if students today possessed historical literacy. She responded in the negative.
Studying history is different from developing historical literacy. The former focuses merely on acquiring knowledge about past events, whereas the latter equips students with the ability to evaluate sources critically, situate events within their proper context, recognise bias, and draw meaningful connections between the past and the present, ensuring that they are better prepared to participate responsibly and thoughtfully in civic life.
Ever since celebrations for the 150th anniversary of ‘Vande Mataram’ began in November 2025, the song has become the subject of widespread debate across India. Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath’s announcement that all educational institutions in the state should sing the song, along with the recent directive from the Union Home Ministry mandating the playing of the full six-stanza version at government functions, has further intensified the discussion about the government’s motive.
In this context, it is important to examine the reasons for these directives, the historical context in which the song was written, its role during the freedom struggle, the controversy around certain stanzas, and its contemporary relevance. According to Adityanath, making the national song compulsory in schools and colleges is to “instil a sense of reverence and pride towards the nation” and strengthen India’s unity.
Opponents, however, contend that compelling non-Hindus to sing the song — particularly stanzas three to six that portray the motherland as a Hindu goddess — violates their religious freedom. Critics also refer to the 1986 Supreme Court judgment in Emmanuel vs. State of Kerala, which upheld the fundamental rights of three students who were expelled for refusing to sing the national anthem, ruling that standing silently and respectfully constitutes sufficient expression of respect. The verdict further affirmed that forcing citizens to sing violates freedom of conscience under Article 25, and freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a), as no legal provision mandates singing.
Meanwhile, several historians and educators, though not opposed to the first two stanzas, view the mandatory inclusion of all six as an attempt to make people believe that the full song was accepted by all freedom fighters. They note that only the first two stanzas were adopted by the Constituent Assembly and argue that enforcing the complete version reflects an effort to advance a Hindutva-oriented perspective.
A similar debate arose when the hymn ‘Abide with Me’ was removed from Republic Day celebrations in 2022. Although the government described the move as part of a process to “decolonise India”, critics viewed it as sidelining a song associated with Mahatma Gandhi and reshaping historical memory.
These controversies highlight a broader concern: patriotism cannot be instilled through coercion, but flourishes through the lived practice of equality, fraternity, and liberty. Making the singing of ‘Vande Mataram’ mandatory is unlikely to cultivate authentic pride and may heighten religious tensions. True education fosters tolerance and peaceful coexistence, upholding the Constitution’s guarantee of religious freedom and avoiding the privileging of any single faith.
The deliberate manipulation of historical narratives is a powerful form of indoctrination that seeks to control the present by reshaping the past. When history is distorted or selectively presented, it profoundly influences how individuals understand their society. In this way, control over the past becomes a means of shaping public consciousness in the present.
In response to this danger, students must be encouraged to question the narratives placed before them. Rather than accepting accounts at face value, they should learn to examine evidence carefully, challenge manufactured or selective versions of events, and critically assess the perspectives that shape historical interpretation. Without these skills, they risk becoming passive recipients of narrow or biased viewpoints that restrict their understanding of the world. This is where historical literacy becomes essential.
At a time when divisive “us versus them” narratives are constructed along ideological lines, and history is frequently reinterpreted to advance particular agendas, the need for historical literacy is urgent. It is the moral and social responsibility of educators to ensure that students are aware of the rights guaranteed to them by the Constitution. Through this commitment, we help nurture informed citizens capable of applying critical thinking to the complex issues that shape their lives and their society.
Those who have developed historical literacy understand well the meaning behind George Orwell’s statement: “Who controls the past controls the future; who controls the present controls the past.” However, whether our education system can help students develop this essential skill remains a crucial question.
The writer is an ELT resource person and education columnist. Email rayanal@yahoo.co.uk
Published - February 22, 2026 12:00 pm IST
universities and colleges / higher education / careers / university / students / The Hindu Education Plus
Source: TheHindu
Related Posts: Sahir Doshi on being a “hip-hop wildlife educator” TikTok Says It’s Engaging With Indonesia After License Suspended India engaging global partners more intensively Looking forward to engaging constructively’ with India Bengaluru Hosts Engaging EBC Networking Event with Global Participation Beer giant Asahi not engaging with hackers after cyberattack FIR filed against journalist Abhisar Sharma for accusing Assam CM of engaging in communal politics Lok Sabha to hold special discussion on the impact of Astronaut Shukla’s space mission Opposition MPs walk out of Rajya Sabha demanding discussion on SIR
In a time when wellness and mindful eating are reshaping everyday kitchens, the focus is shifting from restrictive diets to nourishing, balanced meals that support long-term health. Today’s approach to food is less about cutting out ingredients and more about choosing what truly fuels the body
1 days ago
US-Iran War: Russian President Vladimir Putin held a telephonic conversation with US President Donald Trump and warned of “inevitable and extremely damaging consequences" if the United States and Israel resume military action against Iran, the Kremlin said after the call
1 days ago
Priyanka Chopra has opened up about the many phases in her career, starting from being a pageant winner to becoming a global star who has conquered both Bollywood and Hollywood. Priyanka made her debut in 2002 in Thamizhan. In 2003, she was seen in both The Hero: Love Story of a Spy and Andaaz
1 days ago
Cristiano Ronaldo moved a step closer to the elusive 1000-goal milestone after scoring in Al-Nassr’s 2-0 win over Al-Ahli SFC on Wednesday. The goal took his official tally for club and country to 971, underlining his remarkable longevity. Kingsley Coman added the second to seal a result that
1 days ago
The Council for the Indian School Certificate Examinations (CISCE) has announced the results of the Class 10 (ICSE) and Class 12 (ISC) board examinations on Thursday (April 30, 2026) at 11 a.m., officials said. Parents and students can access the official CISCE websites for downloading the
1 days ago
What is ‘Operation Child Protector VIII’? All about US sting that led to arrest of ‘for-hire Santa Claus’ & 18 othersAs many as 19 people have been arrested during an undercover operation – ‘Operation Child Protector VIII’ – that focused on child predators. Published on: Apr 30
1 days ago
One of Malayalam cinema’s most anticipated releases, Patriot, is gearing up for a grand theatrical release on May 1. Directed by Mahesh Narayanan, the spy action thriller has already generated significant buzz, largely due to its star-studded cast and gripping premise
1 days ago
Strong demand for in China has nearly doubled prices for 's B300 servers to about 7 million yuan ($1 million) each, industry sources said, as a crackdown on chip smuggling dries up black-market supply.Prices of Nvidia's most advanced and powerful server
1 days ago
At Jus Drums, there is a variety of percussion to choose from at their 24th annual summer camp; the drums, konakkol or the art of vocal percussion which has its origins in South India, cajón which is a box-shaped instrument from Peru played by slapping its hide, and the djembe
1 days ago
Nepal Airlines on Thursday (April 30, 2026) apologised for what it described as cartographic inaccuracies in the wake of a furore showing Jammu and Kashmir as part of Pakistan in a “network map”. The airlines had deleted the social media post on Wednesday (April 29) following the backlash
1 days ago
Was Nancy Guthrie crime scene ‘staged’ to mislead authorities? Experts's chilling theory, ‘Killed somewhere else…’A renowned forensic psychologist has suggested that the physical evidence left at Nancy Guthrie’s home may have been “staged.” Updated on: Apr 30
1 days ago
Skeptical Democrats confronted Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth on Wednesday (April 29, 2026) for the first time since the Trump administration went to war with Iran, touching off tense exchanges over a costly conflict with unclear objectives that has been waged without congressional approval
1 days ago
Anti-stigma campaign, digital tool help mitigate mental health problems in slums: StudyAnti-stigma campaign, digital tool help mitigate mental health problems in slums: Study Published on: Apr 30, 2026 2:38 PM IST PTI Share via Copy link New Delhi
1 days ago
U.S. President Donald Trump warned Tehran on Wednesday (April 29, 2026) that it should "get smart soon" and capitulate to Washington's demands for tight controls on its nuclear programme, as a U.S. naval blockade turned the screws on Iran's economy
1 days ago
Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Power cuts this summer are unavoidable: These 10 inverter and battery combos keep you preparedPower cuts during summer can disrupt daily life
1 days ago
Supreme Court reserves order on Cong leader Pawan Khera’s anticipatory bail pleaSenior advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi, who appeared for Congress leader Pawan Khera, argued that the case did not justify arrest Published on: Apr 30, 2026 2:42 PM IST By Ayesha Arvind Share via Copy link The Assam
1 days ago
Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) appointed Care Ratings Ltd. to function as the Past Risk and Return Verification Agency (PaRRVA), according to a circular released 29, April 2026. The agency will vet Investment advisors and research analysts for their past performance and risk
1 days ago
China will ban the sale of drones in Beijing and require permits to fly them under new rules that take effect on Friday. Drones and key components will be prohibited from being sold, rented or brought into the Chinese capital. Drone owners will also be required to register their devices with the
1 days ago
‘He didn’t stop because he accepted my ride’: Bengaluru woman gives T-shirt to drenched auto driver, internet movedA Bengaluru woman shared how she helped a drenched auto driver during rain, winning hearts online. Published on: Apr 30, 2026 2:07 PM IST By Mahipal Singh Chouhan Share via Copy
1 days ago
India’s agricultural transformation has long been driven by technological shifts—from the Green Revolution’s high-yielding varieties to the widespread use of synthetic fertilisers. Today, nano urea is being positioned as the next leap: a precision input that promises higher efficiency
1 days ago
Exit polls are revealing potential political shifts across India. In West Bengal, the Trinamool Congress faces its toughest challenge yet from the BJP. Assam shows continued BJP dominance. Tamil Nadu sees a complex scenario with the DMK alliance ahead but Vijay's new party disrupting the scene
1 days ago
Kara Twitter review: Best Dhanush film ‘in recent years’ floors viewers, internet hails Vignesh Raja's gripping thrillerKara Twitter review: Dhanush plays a small-time thief who specialises in robbing the rich in this crime thriller directed by Vignesh Raja. Apr 30, 2026
1 days ago
The IPL 2026 season isn’t just heating up on the pitch; it’s practically boiling over on social media. A new video released by the Rajasthan Royals (RR) has fans convinced that the franchise just took a massive, “pink-tinted" swipe at RCB icon Virat Kohli
1 days ago
‘Ghost’ claim leads Guj officials to skeletal remains in 30-yr-old caseThe remains are suspected to belong to Farzana alias Shabnam, a Mumbai resident who had come to Ahmedabad to meet her partner, Shamshuddin over three decades ago Published on: Apr 30
1 days ago
Former FBI Director James Comey surrendered to authorities to face charges alleging that an image he briefly shared on social media posed a threat to the life of US President Donald Trump. The case stems from a 2025 Instagram post shared by Comey
1 days ago
Can autism or ADHD be diagnosed in adulthood? Psychologist shares what they look like in adultsExpert debunks common myths and discloses how ADHD and autism can be masked for years, well into adulthood. Published on: Apr 30, 2026 2:40 PM IST By Adrija Dey Share via Copy link Austism is usually
1 days ago
Hyundai has taken its compact SUV and added a sporty twist with the Venue N Line N10 DCT Dual Tone, priced at Rs 15,66,000 (ex-showroom). This is the top model in the Venue N Line range and is aimed at buyers who want a small SUV that is not just practical, but also fun to drive
1 days ago
