New Red Bull CEO and team principal Laurent Mekies was left juggling optimism and damage control after rookie Isack Hadjar crashed the RB22 late on day two of pre-season running at the Circuit de Catalunya. The crash came at the final corner
A former singer for Spandau Ballet has been found guilty of rape and attempted rape. Ross Davidson, who used Ross Wild as his stage name, was known for singing with the 80s band Spandau Ballet in 2018 as well as starring in the Queen-themed West End musical We Will Rock You
SEATTLE (AP) — As Seattle Mariners chairman John Stanton spoke fondly of Rick Rizzs on Wednesday morning, the longtime play-by-play broadcaster pulled a box of tissues close and looked around the team's interview room in anticipation of the inevitable
In modern times, the world's most powerful and influential states have also had the largest economies. When the United States overtook Britain in the early 20th century, it was only a question of time before it assumed international political leadership too. Indeed
The aircraft encountered extremely dense fog in Pune district and the Baramati region, which caused it to lose its course NCP chief and Maharashtra Deputy Chief Minister Ajit Pawar was killed in an aircraft crash near Baramati, with preliminary inputs pointing to poor weather conditions as a key
Why experts say AI tool to detect Bangladeshis will be open to misuse
In 1997, Babar Ali Mandal migrated from Nadia district in West Bengal to Mumbai in search of work.
In the three decades since, he has made Mumbai his home. He runs a small workshop to make footwear in Govandi, a slum cluster located in the east of the Maharashtra capital.
In his free time, he often scrolls through social media sites.
What he sees is distressing. “A lot of people from my state are being targeted for speaking Bengali,” he said. The fear of being labelled Bangladeshi has intensified in the last one year, he added.
As Scroll has reported, the police in several states ruled by the Bharatiya Janata Party, including Maharashtra, have over the last year accused Indian citizens of being Bangladeshis and thrown them across the border, without giving them time or opportunity to prove their citizenship – in violation of the Centre's own rules.
Maharashtra Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis has gone a step further. Last week, at a media event, Fadnavis said that the state government is building an artificial intelligence tool to help it detect Bangladeshi immigrants.
According to a report in Hindustan Times, which cited officials aware of the project, the language-based verification AI tool “will analyse speech patterns, tone and linguistic usage to help identify suspected illegal Bangladeshi nationals and Rohingyas in the state”.
It is being developed by the state information technology department in collaboration with IIT Bombay. However, Maharashtra IT minister Ashish Shelar told Scroll that the project is being handled by the chief minister's office and he did not have the “finer details” about it.
The IIT Bombay spokesperson refused to answer Scroll's queries about the tool, as did IT secretary Virendra Singh.
But experts warn that the idea of a language-based AI tool to help detect a person's nationality is inherently flawed and may lead to more harassment of working-class Bengali-speaking migrants in Maharashtra.
To start with, experts questioned the existence of two distinct forms of Bengali or Bangla – one spoken in India and the other in Bangladesh, given the history of Partition and the creation of Bangladesh in 1971.
Gorky Chakraborty, faculty at the Institute of Development Studies in Kolkata, pointed out that both events led to millions crossing over into India.
“Millions who migrated from that part of Bangladesh to this part of India still have the same dialect and diction,” Gorky said. “The social continuum has not been ruptured by political borders.”
Others pointed out that Bengali has a wide variety of dialects and accents.
Arijit Mukherjee, an artificial intelligence expert and principal scientist at a multinational research organisation, pointed out that while the Bengali language has “regional variations”, they are too broad for a technological tool to distinguish.
“There are no unique markers to distinguish the language spoken in India from the one spoken in Bangladesh,” Mukherjee said.
He added: “In order to make such a determination, the tool has to be fed a huge volume of data. It will need thousands of audio clips from each region to be able to give credible results.”
The IIT-Bombay team has so far not disclosed what data they are using to train the AI model.
Adil Hossain, assistant professor at Azim Premji University, said it is impossible to use technology to detect the nationality of people who belong to the same geography. “Be it a Hindu or a Muslim, people will have the same dialect on both sides of the border,” he said.
Hossain, a political anthropologist, was referring to the nine districts of West Bengal that share a border with Bangladesh – North 24 Parganas, Murshidabad, Cooch Behar, Malda and Nadia, among them. For example, a person from Nadia will have the same manner of speaking as someone from Chuadanga district in Bangladesh, which is across the border from Nadia. “The accent and dialect comes from geography not religion,” Hossain noted.
This phenomenon is not limited to Bengal. The large Bengali-speaking population in Assam's Barak Valley and other states in the North East speak Sylheti, a dialect spoken in Bangladesh's Sylhet district, Chakraborty pointed out.
Perhaps aware of the challenges, Fadnavis has said that the AI tool being designed by IIT has so far reached 60% accuracy. It will take another six months to be rolled out.
Mukherjee, the scientist, contested the perception that AI is “unerring” and that its decisions are beyond question. “The government is using that belief about AI to push its narrative,” he said. “But this seems like a politically motivated agenda and a case of AI being used for political gains.”
This, he said, is what digital experts have been warning against – the unethical use of AI to discriminate against marginalised people.
As Bengali is spoken in a large region spanning West Bengal and states in the North East such as Meghalaya, Tripura and Assam, a language-based AI tool could become a “tool to terrorise people” from these regions, Mukherjee said.
Chakraborty, too, said he worried that the tool would be disproportionately biased against Bengali Muslims and Bangla-speaking migrant workers. “A labourer who migrates from [Assam or Bengal] will speak in a certain dialect,” he said. “He may not know the local languages in Maharashtra. The chances of harassment are high, because it gets difficult for them to prove their identity.”
Mandal is fearful of exactly this. “My village is 50 km from the Bangladesh border. Our way of speaking Bengali is similar to those across the border,” he said. “We have already seen so many cases of wrongful deportation of Bengalis.”
Last June, four men from West Bengal, living in Mira Bhayander, were picked up by the Maharashtra police and pushed into Bangladesh on suspicion of being illegal immigrants. They were were brought back later.
Mandal added: “It could be me one day.”
Source: Scroll
Related Posts: Australian Open triggers maximum heat warning with 45C forecast Aryna Sabalenka dominates Iva Jovic to reach Australian Open final four Extreme heat eases at Australian Open as Musetti plots ‘revenge’ on Djokovic Elina Svitolina stuns Coco Gauff at Australian Open EU to show Google how to open up to rival AI services Jannik Sinner Reacts To Novak Djokovic Moving Into Australian Open Quarters Without Playing EU deal to open $750 billion electronics market for Indian manufacturers Elena Rybakina storms into Australian Open semi-finals Novak Djokovic Marches On At Australian Open As Injured Lorenzo Musetti Pulls Out When is Australian Open 2026 Final
Dulquer Salmaan's Aakasamlo Oka Tara teases a heartwarming, feel-good story with Shruti Haasan in a powerful mentor role, set for a multi-lingual Summer 2026 release. Dulquer Salmaan's upcoming Telugu film Aakasamlo Oka Tara has quietly built anticipation ever since the teaser hinted at a
Just now
Assam CM Himanta Biswa Sarma has directed BJP workers to file bulk Form-7 objections against 'Miyas' during the electoral roll revision, citing suspected Bangladeshi infiltrators. This move follows Congress's allegations of unsubstantiated Form-7 submissions and calls for electoral officer
Just now
Congresswoman Ilhan Omar is sprayed with a foul-smelling liquid during a town hall, highlighting heightened tensions in Minnesota during aggressive federal immigration actions. Washington: Minnesota Congresswoman Ilhan Omar was sprayed with a foul-smelling liquid during a town hall she was hosting
Just now
Veteran rocker Neil Young is giving the people of Greenland free access to his entire music catalogue. The musician announced the offer on his blog on Tuesday, saying it is intended to provide comfort amid tensions affecting the Danish territory
Just now
In a quiet corner of Udaipur, far from red carpets and premieres, an old photograph is now doing the rounds online. The reason is quite surprising. A local tailor claims that Oscar-winning actor Judi Dench once walked into his home to get a jacket stitched
Just now
The Election Commission of India has appointed West Bengal's state home secretary and commissioner of police-Howrah as central observers. They will attend a briefing in New Delhi on February 5 and 6. Officers absent from this meeting face disciplinary action. Meanwhile
Just now
The report noted that the overall influence of the Union Budget has narrowed over the years due to several extra-budgetary measures taken by the government. As a result, equity markets are likely to look for targeted and selective steps that can boost growth in specific sectors and help improve
Just now
Federal troops sent to six US cities by the Trump administration have cost taxpayers nearly $500 million. Continued deployment could surpass $1 billion. Senator Jeff Merkley highlighted the significant expenditure. The White House claims these efforts have reduced crime
Just now
Serious allegations of sexual exploitation have levelled against Jana Sena Party MLA and government whip Arava Sridhar, setting off a major political controversy in Andhra Pradesh. The controversy began on Tuesday when a woman posted a video on social media
Just now
(Bloomberg) -- Google is launching an artificial intelligence assistant on its Chrome browser that can open websites and click around on a user's behalf. The feature, called auto browse, will allow users to ask an assistant powered by Gemini to complete tasks such as shopping for them without
Just now
Before flying on the Baramati-bound plane, Captain Shambhavi Pathak texted her grandmother: “Hi, good morning, Dadda". Her grandmother, Meera Pathak, replied softly, “Good morning, Chini". Little did she know that this subtle exchange would soon turn into a memory she would hold on to
Just now
DeepSeek's AI models rival US offerings with less computing power Letter says Nvidia provided technical assistance to DeepSeek, boosting training efficiency US concerns over Nvidia chips aiding China's military despite restrictions U.S. chipmaker Nvidia helped China's DeepSeek hone artificial
Just now
The tragic death of Maharashtra Deputy Chief Minister Ajit Pawar in a plane crash near Baramati on Wednesday has sent shockwaves through the state's political landscape. As the leader of the Nationalist Congress Party (NCP) faction that broke away from his uncle Sharad Pawar in 2023
Just now
Novak Djokovic moves closer to a record Australian Open title. He advanced after Lorenzo Musetti retired injured while leading. Iga Swiatek's Grand Slam bid ended with a loss to Elena Rybakina. Jessica Pegula also reached the semi-finals. Djokovic expressed sympathy for Musetti's unfortunate
Just now
Firsts are not easy to come by for Jose Mourinho at this stage of his long, often highly dramatic, career. But on Wednesday night in Lisbon, Anatoly Trubin provided such a moment. Simply beating 15-time European champions Real Madrid was not going to be enough for Benfica
Just now
Glenn Phillips smashed his 100th T20 International six for New Zealand, becoming only the third player from the country to achieve this impressive milestone. This feat occurred during the fourth T20I against India in Visakhapatnam, where he contributed 24 runs off just 16 deliveries
Just now
Meta boss Mark Zuckerberg plans to ramp up spending on artificial intelligence (AI) projects this year, even as other executives warn of a potential bubble in the industry. During a call with financial analysts on Wednesday to discuss the Facebook-owner's 2025 financial results
Just now
In 1997, Babar Ali Mandal migrated from Nadia district in West Bengal to Mumbai in search of work. In the three decades since, he has made Mumbai his home. He runs a small workshop to make footwear in Govandi, a slum cluster located in the east of the Maharashtra capital.In 1997
Just now
The toll in the fire at two warehouses in Kolkata on Monday increased to 19, ETV Bharat quoted the police as saying on Wednesday. The warehouses, one operated by quick-service restaurant chain Wow! Momo and the other by a decorator, are located in East Kolkata's Anandapur area
Just now
Opposition leaders opted for a "dignified and brief" protest during the President's address instead of a boycott, fearing political repercussions. They registered their dissent when the President mentioned the new VB-G RAM G Act, which replaced MGNREGA, avoiding disruption of proceedings
Just now
Lobsang Tsering, my octogenarian fellow villager, was a voracious reader and traditional knowledge keeper. Before he died in 2024, he made it his mission to give me a clear sense of the social, political and economic histories of our village – the site of my fieldwork for my PhD thesis on
Just now
National Corn Chip Day, celebrated annually on January 29, is a reminder that some of the most loved comfort foods come from the simplest ingredients. Made from corn and endlessly versatile, corn chips have evolved far beyond their humble origins to become the foundation of one of the world's most
Just now
The NBA trade deadline may feel oddly calm so far this season. Why? Because the Giannis Antetokounmpo conversation has officially entered dangerous territory. According to ESPN's Shams Charania, the Milwaukee Bucks are more open than ever to listening to trade offers for their two-time MVP ahead of
Just now
China is sending a team to Australia to help in the search for a man who allegedly doused a baby with boiling coffee in 2024. The nine-month old was attacked while his family were at a park in Brisbane's southern suburbs, suffering serious burns to his face and limbs
Just now
The Premier League is flexing its muscles in Europe as five English teams finished in the top eight of the Champions League to reach the knockouts. That could become six in the last 16 if Newcastle win their two-legged play-off after they finished 12th in the league phase following a 1-1 draw at
Just now
Delhi Traffic Restrictions: The Delhi Police has issued a traffic advisory ahead of the full dress rehearsal for the Beating Retreat ceremony. Vijay Chowk and the nearby areas will remain completely closed between 4 and 6 pm on Wednesday.Delhi Traffic Restrictions: The Delhi Police has issued a
Just now
The investment required for upcoming PSPs is estimated at around Rs 5.8 lakh crore, calculated at an average cost of Rs 6 crore per MW, CEA said in a report outlining the roadmap for PSPs till 2035-36 on Wednesday. Our BureauNew Delhi: India's total installed capacity of pumped storage projects
Just now
