Tensions between Iran and the United States have taken a lighter turn online, with both sides using humour and memes to make their point. One such post has now caught people’s attention for the way it mocks a major political claim. The post takes aim at US President Donald Trump
Agriculture has long been one of the strongest foundations of economic and social progress. It supports food security, generates livelihoods, supplies raw materials to industries, and sustains rural economies. Even today, for millions of families
43-year-old laid off from Amazon shares how he got a new job in 90 daysA man's post about landing a job after getting laid off from Amazon has resonated with many. Published on: Apr 28, 2026 11:05 AM IST By Trisha Sengupta Share via Copy link A 43-year-old professional has gone viral after
Farhan Akhtar breaks silence on Don 3 row after Ranveer Singh’s exit: ‘Nothing can be taken for granted’Farhan Akhtar recently opened up about the Don 3 fallout with Ranveer Singh, recalling the pleasant experiences he has had while making films in his career. Apr 28, 2026
OpenAI has fallen short of its goals for new users and revenue in recent months, sparking concern among some company leaders over whether it can support its extensive data-center spending, the reported on Monday, citing people familiar with the matter
Rimjhim Sinha has been an activist since 2016, first as a student at Kolkata’s Presidency University and then as part of the vibrant women’s movement in the city. But, by her own estimate, her activism never reached more than “100 or 150 people”
A first information report has been registered against 13 persons, including students from Delhi University’s Hansraj College, for alleged violence and misconduct during an annual festival earlier this month, The Indian Express reported on Tuesday
The second phase of elections for 142 Assembly seats in West Bengal on April 29 will decide the electoral fate of more than half a dozen Ministers of West Bengal government along with Chief Minister and party chairperson Mamata Banerjee. While the Trinamool Congress chairperson is locked in a
Why are Meta and WhatsApp facing a judicial ultimatum in India?
Why are Meta and WhatsApp facing a judicial ultimatum in India? Premium
For years, Meta, the parent company of WhatsApp, has treated user data as the “exhaust” of its messaging engine—a valuable byproduct to be harvested and refined for its advertising machine. But on February 3, 2026, India's Supreme Court suggested a different metaphor: theft.
In a hearing that could redefine the economics of the internet in the world's most populous digital market, a three-judge Bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant signaled that “consent” in the age of monopolies may be little more than a legal fiction. The court's observations go beyond simple privacy; they strike at the heart of Meta's business model, questioning whether a platform's market dominance renders the “choice” to share data essentially coercive.
The friction began in 2021, when WhatsApp issued a “take-it-or-leave-it” update to its privacy policy. The update allowed for increased data sharing between the messaging app and its parent, Meta. While WhatsApp insisted that end-to-end encryption kept messages private, the Competition Commission of India (CCI) saw the move as an abuse of dominance. It argued that for the average Indian user, “leaving” WhatsApp is not a viable option as it is the country's digital town square. The CCI slapped Meta with a ₹213.14 crore ($25m) penalty—a sum that is pocket change for a trillion-dollar company, but a significant regulatory shot across the bow.
Meta then appealed the decision in the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), which last year delivered a nuanced, if controversial, verdict. The NCLAT upheld the CCI's finding that Meta had abused its market position. However, it significantly “softened” the regulatory blow.
While it retained the financial penalty, the NCLAT set aside a crucial CCI directive that would have barred Meta from sharing user data with its other entities for advertising purposes for a period of five years.
The NCLAT's rationale was rooted in a traditional interpretation of corporate integration. It appeared to argue that while the method of obtaining consent was coercive, the act of sharing data across a parent and subsidiary was a standard business practice in the digital age.
The tribunal likely feared that a total five-year moratorium on data-sharing was a disproportionate “structural remedy” that could break the technical synergy of Meta's platforms. Furthermore, with the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act of 2023 then looming on the horizon, the NCLAT seemed content to let privacy-specific legislation handle the nuances of data flows, rather than a competition regulator using the blunt instrument of an antitrust ban.
Unhappy with the penalty and NCLAT's verdict, Meta, eventually reached the Supreme Court. However, the apex court seemed in no mood for compromise. Chief Justice Kant's retort to Meta's lawyers—that opting out of WhatsApp in India is akin to “opting out of the country”—captures the “network effect” trap that competition regulators globally are struggling to dismantle.
Yet, the most provocative argument came from Justice Joymalya Bagchi, who shifted the debate from privacy to “value.” India's Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act of 2023 focuses primarily on the sanctity of personal information. But Justice Bagchi noted a vacuum in the law regarding the “rent-sharing” of data. If Meta uses a rural Indian's behavioural trends to sell targeted ads, who owns the profit derived from that data?
This “data-as-property” logic aligns India more closely with the European Union's Digital Services Act than with the more laissez-faire approach of the United States. By impleading the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY), the court forced the government to consider whether privacy is enough, or if the economic “value” of a citizen's digital footprint requires a new form of sovereign protection.
The Solicitor General's remark—that users are “not only consumers, but also products”—reflects a growing fatigue with the “free” internet model. When a user discusses medicine with a doctor and receives a pharmaceutical ad minutes later, the court views this not as a feat of engineering, but as an intrusion.
Meta's defense remains rooted in the “cleverly-crafted” language of terms and conditions. But the Chief Justice's “simple query” regarding whether a domestic helper could navigate such a policy serves as a reminder that in a country with varying levels of digital literacy, transparency is not the same as understanding.
The court has now issued an ultimatum: Meta must provide an undertaking to stop sharing personal data, or face the dismissal of its case and “very strict conditions.” As the case heads toward interim directions on February 9, the message is clear. In the eyes of the Indian judiciary, a billion “silent consumers” are no longer willing to be the raw material for Meta's bottom line. The era of “decent theft” may be coming to a close.
Published - February 04, 2026 08:16 am IST
technology (general) / The Hindu Explains
Source: TheHindu
Related Posts: WhatsApp tells Supreme Court it does not share data with Meta Facebook's parent company just decided humans are too expensive Nexperia's Chinese parent says company's Dutch unit seeking to permanently strip its control User's consent mandatory for WhatsApp for collection of advertising & non-advertising data Discord user data leaked after breach at customer service partner TikTok US venture to collect precise user location data Mixpanel data breach exposes OpenAI API user names This Company Beats TCS To Become Third Largest Company In India Kashmiris being treated as suspects after Delhi blast Iga Swiatek thinks Tennis players are treated like zoo animals
Union Minister on Tuesday arrived in to participate in the foundation stone laying ceremony of the AI Data Centre at Tarluvada in Anandapuram mandal.Minister and other Telugu Desam Party public representatives welcomed Union Minister Ashwini Vaishnaw at Visakhapatnam Airport
9 hours ago
As many as 20 crore Indians could face life-threatening heat conditions, warns a report from the Harvard University’s Salata Institute. New Delhi: India’s rising heat is no longer only a seasonal discomfort. A new study warns that it is becoming a major challenge for jobs
9 hours ago
‘Return of pirates’: Tehran slams US' seizure of vessels carrying Iranian oil in Indian OceanIran has reportedly extended an offer proposing easing its grip on the Strait of Hormuz if the US ends its blockade on the key trade waterway. Published on: Apr 28
9 hours ago
The man who authorities say tried to storm the White House Correspondents' Association dinner with guns and knives was on Monday (April 27, 2026) charged with the attempted assassination of President Donald Trump. He appeared in court to face charges in a chaotic encounter that resulted in shots
9 hours ago
Manabadi AP SSC 10th Results 2026 Date Time Live: The Board of Secondary Education, Andhra Pradesh (BSEAP) is likely to release the AP SSC Results 2026 shortly. As per media reports, the results are expected to be announced in the final week of April. In the previous year
9 hours ago
Gold rate today: After delivering strong returns over the past two years, gold may be entering a more uncertain phase, prompting ASK Private Wealth to dial down its bullish stance. ASK Private Wealth CIO Somnath Mukherjee has shifted his tactical view on gold from “overweight” to “neutral”
9 hours ago
Winning the elusive Golden Ticket hidden in a Wonka Bar is every chocolate aficionado’s dream. The iconic, fictional pass created by Roald Dahl in his book Charlie and the Chocolate Factory gave five children the opportunity to tour one of the world’s biggest candy-making factories
9 hours ago
The BJP has launched an aggressive and multi-pronged campaign for the 2026 West Bengal Assembly elections, combining large welfare promises, a strong law-and-order agenda, development pledges, and cultural identity politics to challenge the ruling TMC. Unveiling its “Sankalp Patra
9 hours ago
For many in the ballroom at the White House Correspondents' Association dinner on Saturday night, the scene was painfully familiar. Shots fired, confusion and panic, and a sense that the normal order of things had been violently interrupted. Erika Kirk, whose husband
9 hours ago
After keeping a relatively quiet public profile in recent days, Deepika Padukone stepped out in Mumbai on Tuesday, drawing attention for more than one reason. The actor was spotted at the airport alongside husband Ranveer Singh, marking her first appearance since the couple shared news of their
9 hours ago
Mukesh Chhabra slams troll culture, reacts to ‘too much’ negativity around Ramayana, Dhurandhar: 'I feel bad and scared'Casting director Mukesh Chhabra praised for his work on Dhurandhar and Ramayana discusses the negativity surrounding both films. Apr 28, 2026
9 hours ago
China has blocked Meta’s acquisition of AI startup Manus, the top economic planning body said Monday, after a regulatory review that reportedly also saw Beijing restrict two co-founders from leaving the country. Facebook owner Meta had agreed to acquire Manus
9 hours ago
“Still or sparkling?" For the longest, even the most discerning diners didn’t really know the difference. I actually believed sparkling water meant soda. To feel fancy, you order the latter and the waiter brings a glass that hits the back of your throat with a punchy, aggressive fizz
9 hours ago
As app-based domestic services expand and discussions around wages in the informal sector grow louder, the sharp divide between traditional domestic workers and those employed through online platforms is becoming increasingly visible. For many women working in neighbourhood homes
9 hours ago
Executions rose sharply in North Korea during the Covid-19 pandemic, according to a Seoul-based NGO. From January 2020 to the end of 2024, at least 153 people were executed or sentenced to death - a sharp increase from 44 people in the five years before the pandemic
9 hours ago
It was close — really close — but Cooper Flagg had the edge where it counted. The Dallas Mavericks forward is now the 2025/26 NBA Rookie of the Year, narrowly beating former Duke teammate Kon Knueppel of the Charlotte Hornets. The 2025-26 @Kia NBA Rookie of the Year is… Cooper Flagg! pic
9 hours ago
Vedanta Demerger: Mining major Vedanta is set to undergo its much-anticipated demerger, under which four of the Anil Agarwal-led group’s businesses will operate as separate listed entities. The company has fixed May 1 as the record date to determine shareholder eligibility
9 hours ago
Ranveer Singh and Farhan Akhtar have been hitting headlines following a controversy that erupted after the Dhurandhar star walked away from Farhan’s upcoming film ‘Don 3’. Amid this, Farhan has finally reacted to it, and revealed what he learned from the setback. In a recent interview
9 hours ago
Anxiety around fuel prices, including LPG, has been high since the West Asia conflict has continued to disrupt the energy markets. While both domestic and commercial LPG cylinders have witnessed at least one hike each since March, media reports are suggesting a fresh revision in LPG prices from May
9 hours ago
CBSE Class 12th Result 2026 Release Date, Time Live Updates: The Central Board of Secondary Education is expected to declare the CBSE Class 12 results 2026 soon. Considering the rapid announcement of the Class 10 results this year and the use of the on-screen marking system
9 hours ago
Motorola Edge 70 Pro is a practical and polished pitch for phones under ₹40,000This clearly isn’t an annual spec-sheet exercise, as Motorola has gotten the fundamentals thoughtfully right Published on: Apr 28, 2026 10:35 AM IST By Vishal Mathur Share via Copy link It goes without saying that
9 hours ago
From early morning jogs in parks to all-day wear in offices and cafés, athleisure in form of stretch leggings, moisture-wicking T-shirts and stain-resistant jackets is no longer limited to the gym. But a recent report by The Washington Post has drawn attention to the presence of PFAS
9 hours ago
West Bengal votes today in the final phase of assembly elections. The outcome will decide if the TMC keeps its southern dominance or the BJP secures a path to the state secretariat. This phase focuses on Kolkata, Howrah, and surrounding districts, crucial for both parties
9 hours ago
Aamir Khan, R Madhavan, Sharman Joshi, and Kareena Kapoor Khan’s 3 Idiots, released in 2009, remains one of the most loved and impactful films to date. Directed by Rajkumar Hirani, the coming-of-age drama struck a chord with audiences across generations for its refreshing take on the education
9 hours ago
Neurologist shares dos and don’ts after waking to optimise health, mood, energy: First 60 mins sets the tone for the dayHow we start our morning influences the rest of the day. Dr Kumar lists waking up habits to inculcate and avoid to improve our health and mood every day. Updated on: Apr 28
9 hours ago
‘Shashi Tharoor accepted that Congress was anti-women’: Kiren Rijiju reveals post-Parliament session conversationKiren Rijiju's remarks come days after Shashi Tharoor shared a picture, clarifying how he pointed out to the minister that no one can call him “mahila virodhi”
9 hours ago
The Indian Railway Catering and Tourism Corporation (IRCTC) proudly announces the launch of an extraordinary international rail-cum-road journey — the “Bharat-Bhutan Mystic Mountain Tour” aboard the state-of-the-art Bharat Gaurav Deluxe AC Tourist Train
9 hours ago
