When AI meets classical music, the guru–shishya parampara holds steady

When AI meets classical music, the guru–shishya parampara holds steady Premium

In an AI-driven world, the emergence of Robotic Gurus imparting music education may no longer be science fiction. However, music teachers and scholars beg to differ. They say in music education the Guru-Shishya Parampara, the ancient Indian tradition, will prevail in an AI-driven world, not necessarily in an antagonistic mode, but in a complementary way, leveraging its ability to systematise teachings and archival functions to preserve knowledge for posterity.

Rajshri Ramakrishna, Associate Professor and Head, Department of Indian Music at the University of Madras, believes Guru–Śhiṣhya Parampara is not merely a method of instruction; it is a value system that nurtures discipline, humility, and deep immersion in the art. “While modern classrooms and technology have transformed the way we teach, the essence of this tradition — personalised guidance, close observation, and learning through immersion remains indispensable,” she said.

“In today's world, I believe the parampara must adapt without losing its spirit. Structured curricula, academic rigour, and technology can certainly support learning, but the refinement of voice, the nuances of gamaka, and the aesthetic depth of manodharma still require the insight and lived experience of a Guru. True musical growth happens only when both approaches complement each other,” she said.

On tech gadgets possibly impacting the sounds of traditional musical instruments, Prof. Rajshri is clear while technology can assist, it cannot replace traditional instruments. “The timbral richness, microtonal sensitivity, and intuition-based accompaniment offered by live instrumentalists, be it the sitar, tabla, vina, mridangam, or violin, cannot be replicated fully by electronic devices. Gadgets may provide convenience in certain contexts, such as practice sessions, rehearsals, or academic demonstrations. But in a concert, music breathes only through human artistry,” she averred.

In her view, AI will become a supportive tool rather than a substitute for the Guru. It can assist in areas like notation, pitch and tala analysis, personalised practice feedback, archival research, and global accessibility to musical resources. Students may benefit from AI-driven apps that help refine shruti alignment or tala precision. However, the emotional depth, aesthetic judgement, and subtlety required to understand rāga and manodharma cannot be learnt from algorithms.

Hindustani classical vocalist Bharat Balvalli is on the same page. “For me, the Guru–Shishya Parampara is not just an old system of teaching; it is the living heartbeat of our music. I have learnt for 15 years under my revered Guru, Pt. Yashwantbuva Joshi. In that long tapasya of taleem, I realised that a Guru does not only correct your sur and laya – he chisels your consciousness,” he said.

“Today we have universities, online classes, apps, short-term courses and instant certificates. They have their place: they spread awareness, create structure, and help a large number of students touch the fringes of classical music. But the core transmission of rāga, shruti, bhaav and adhyatma still happens in a very old-fashioned way – one heart learning from another heart,” he said.

“In Guru–Shishya Parampara, the Guru does not teach only music; he teaches how to live as a musician. You watch how he reacts to praise, how he faces failure, how he protects the purity of a raga in front of commercial pressure. This silent education is what shapes an artist's character,” he added.

Noted singer and music composer Shankar Mahadevan is equally an acolyte of the master-disciple bonding. “It is love and respect and the equation that goes between a Guru and Shishya. So this Parampara has existed and will always exist because without that, you can't teach or learn music,” he maintained.

“Guru and Shishya are like father and son. It's a deep relationship that AI can not destroy. I am running an academy very successful in 94 countries, and some teachers love their students.”

On the fate of traditional Gharanas, he said every Gharana system has positive points and styles and approaches which every student must learn, but evolve their own style. “So I don't believe in the Gharana system alone,” he said.

On a scenario of AI-powered robotic Gurus, he said it was possible, as it's definitely a matter of seeking information and data. So, based on data AI guru will start teaching, but where will the love, emotion and respect come, which happens when you are learning in an institution from a Guru.

Balvalli says, “So, should Guru–Shishya Parampara apply to today's modern teaching of music? My answer is an emphatic yes. It should not stand outside modern systems as a museum piece; it should sit at their very centre as the spiritual core.”

Somewhat reinforcing Mahadevan's views, Balvali said, “Today, a student can sit in New York and learn from a Guru in Mumbai on video call. Every lesson can be recorded, every Taan slowed down, every Shruti measured on an App. AI can generate accompaniment, design Riyāz routines, even suggest where the Sur went slightly off.”

But technology also brings new challenges. The speed and convenience of AI can create an illusion of depth: a student feels “I know this raga” because an app shows 100% accuracy, while the inner bhaav is still shallow.

The personal bond between Guru and Shishya is not created only by “teaching time”; it is woven from the silences in between. Online classes can support Parampara, widen its reach, and keep learning continuous even in a crisis. But can they substitute the living, breathing, karmic bond of Guru–Shishya, which is the real vehicle of Vidya?” he wondered.

On the surface, the idea of AI-powered robotic Gurus is no longer pure science fiction. Today, AI can already listen to your singing, analyse pitch and rhythm, show intonation errors in real time, suggest tailored Riyaz routines, and store thousands of bandishes with perfect recall.

An AI can map what you sang; a Guru intuits what you are ready for. Such a robot can become a finely polished mirror; it cannot become the sacred flame from which the shishya lights his inner Naad,” he said.

Balvalli says, “Modern methods can organise information and reach; only Parampara can transmit Anubhava and Anugraha. Technology may amplify the sound; Guru–Shishya Parampara alone has the power to awaken the Naad within and turn learning into Upasana. So I feel Guru-Shishya Parampara should be the centre, and all modern methods should revolve around it like satellites to emphasise the real virtues of the Bharatiya Knowledge System, he opined.

(Sign up for THEdge, The Hindu's weekly education newsletter.)

Published - December 04, 2025 04:17 pm IST

music / Artificial Intelligence / teaching and learning

Source: The Hindu
Related Posts: Google DeepMind Will Open a Robotic AI Lab in the UK to Discover New Materials American man shocked after trying robotic legs in China Inside South India’s Only Dual-Certified GI Surgery Hub with Robotic Indian-Origin Surgeon Carries Out UK's First Long-Distance Robotic Surgery From 2 Why UGC’s NEP-driven higher education reforms are faltering on campus Why AI-Driven Security Must Become India’s Core Digital Infrastructure NBDSA orders Times Now Navbharat to take down ‘agenda-driven’ report on Assamese singer’s arrest Intruders will be driven out from Kedarnath to Kanyakumari Why India’s renewed engagement with China must be driven by caution IATA warns tariff-driven supplier price hikes could worsen aircraft delays for airlines