U.S. President Donald Trump said on Saturday (May 23, 2026) a deal with Iran had been “largely negotiated,” with the proposal including opening the crucial Strait of Hormuz, though the agreement was “subject to finalisation.” “An Agreement has been largely negotiated
A person who approached a White House security checkpoint and began firing at officers has died, according to federal officials. The U.S. Secret Service said in a statement late on Saturday (May 23, 2026) that, according to a preliminary investigation
After spending 35 years at , consumer chief marketing officer is preparing to leave the company following the end of its next fiscal year, according to an internal memo as reported by Business Insider.Mehdi told employees he would remain at Microsoft until June 2027 to support the company
Pakistani woman says corporate culture makes employees feel guilty for taking leave: ‘Rest needs justification’A Pakistani woman said corporate jobs made employees feel guilty for taking paid leaves they were allowed to use. Published on: May 24
This crunchy veggie rice paper pancake is the perfect quick-fix snack for sudden hunger cravings at home: Full recipeFrom crispy edges to flavour-packed bites, try this veggie rice paper pancake recipe for an ultimate comfort snack for lazy evenings. Updated on: May 24
Amazon techie earning ₹11 lakh/month has 1 house in US, 4 properties in India, Range Rover — but no emergency fundAn Amazon employee earning close to $300,000 feels financially insecure despite significant savings and investments. Published on: May 24
Rare lung transplant at Apollo saves a life; spotlight on India's organ donor shortageRare lung transplant at Apollo saves a life; spotlight on India's organ donor shortage Published on: May 24, 2026 10:33 AM IST PTI Share via Copy link New Delhi, A year ago, every breath felt borrowed
Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.These countertop organisers, crockery pick and jars can give your kitchen a Pinteresty spin by keeping the clutter awayTurn your kitchen into a photo-ready space with stylish organisers
What Jammu University gets wrong about removing ‘Muslim’ thinkers from the syllabus
The recommendation by a committee at Jammu University on March 22 to purge material about Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Syed Ahmed Khan and Muhammad Iqbal from the MA Political Science syllabus is a distressing signal about the state of higher education in India.
The decision has been framed as a response to public sentiment, but it is a fundamental misunderstanding of the purpose of a university. Aristotle once said that it is the mark of an educated mind to be able to entertain a thought without accepting it.
By removing apparently “controversial” figures, the university is telling its postgraduate students, who are ostensibly being trained for high-level analysis, that they are not intellectually mature enough to study the architects of the subcontinent’s history without being “corrupted” by them.
The primary casualty of this erasure is critical thinking. Studying the Two-Nation Theory advanced by Iqbal and Jinnah, alongside Khan’s concepts of Muslim distinctiveness, is essential to understanding the evolution of Muslim political dynamics in South Asia. Not reading the primary proponents of those ideas is akin to studying the French Revolution without mentioning the Jacobins or the Cold War without reading Karl Marx.
When a curriculum is sanitised to include only thinkers deemed “acceptable”, it ceases to be a tool of education and becomes an exercise in indoctrination. If students are not exposed to conflicting, uncomfortable, and even antagonistic ideas, the classroom transforms into a sterile echo chamber.
Understanding Jinnah or Iqbal is a prerequisite for understanding the modern Indian state, its borders and its constitutional journey. To ignore them is to leave a vacuum in a student’s historical consciousness – a vacuum that will inevitably be filled by polemics rather than scholarship.
The controversy often stems from a reductionist view of these figures as mere villains of Partition. However, scholarship suggests a far more nuanced and often contradictory reality. In her seminal work, Secular and Nationalist Jinnah, Ajeet Javed meticulously documents the secular aspects of Jinnah’s early politics.
Before Jinnah’s communal pivot, he was hailed as an “ambassador of Hindu-Muslim unity”, a legal thinker who staunchly opposed the mixing of religion with mass politics. Students deserve to analyse this metamorphosis – not to praise the man, but to understand the political failures and the hardening of identities in the 1930s and ’40s that led to such a shift.
Similarly, Rajmohan Gandhi in Understanding the Muslim Mind provides a balanced lens on Sir Syed Ahmed Khan and Muhammad Iqbal. Gandhi illustrates that Khan’s primary impetus was the modernisation of the Muslim community through Western education and scientific temper.
The career of Iqbal, the “poet-philosopher”, is equally layered. While he is celebrated in Pakistan, his earlier poems, such as Tarana-e-Hindi, remain foundational to the Indian soul.
To truly understand the “adventure of ideas” that defines the subcontinent, one must look at the syncretism that often defined these thinkers. Iqbal was a philosopher rooted in India.
In his famous poem Ram, featured in his book Bang-e-Dara, Iqbal elevates Ram to a position of supreme spiritual leadership, famously referring to him as Imam-e-Hind – the Spiritual Leader of India.
For Iqbal, Ram represented the pinnacle of ethical conduct. In removing Iqbal, the university removes the record of this syncretic heritage. Without exposure to such verses, students are left with a one-dimensional caricature, losing the chance to ask the vital historical question: How did a poet who praised Ram as the soul of India eventually come to envision a separate state? Engaging with this transition is the very “dissection” Aristotle spoke of.
Rafiq Zakaria, in Iqbal: The Poet and the Politician, notes that Iqbal’s transition from a poet of universalism to a proponent of a separate Muslim identity was a complex reaction to the socio-political anxieties of the 1930s. If a master’s student of political science is denied the opportunity to grapple with these contradictions, they are being denied the tools to understand the roots of South Asian political thought.
The removal of Syed Ahmed Khan ignores one of the most significant intellectual reforms in South Asian history. Long before he was a political figure, Khan was a champion of rationalism and a pioneer of scientific temperament. His approach to the Quran was radical for its time. He famously argued that the word of god (scripture) cannot contradict the work of god (nature). He insisted that if a traditional religious interpretation contradicted the proven laws of science, the interpretation must be re-evaluated. This “naturalist” (nechari) approach sought to bridge the gap between faith and the burgeoning scientific age.
For Khan, any religious belief that shackled the human mind or prevented the adoption of modern scientific education was a misinterpretation of the faith. In his Tafsir-ul-Quran, Commentary on the Quran, he challenged traditional dogmas. He was sceptical of supernatural phenomena that violated the laws of physics. He often interpreted Quranic accounts of miracles – such as the splitting of the sea or the nature of angels and jinns – as metaphors or psychological states, rather than literal, physical disruptions of the natural order.
He argued that many legal injunctions in the Quran were specific to the socio-historical context of seventh-century Arabia and were not intended to be immutable laws for all eternity. This distinction between the essential faith and accidental social laws was a landmark in modern Islamic reform.
This heterodoxy was the driving force behind the Aligarh Movement. When Khan founded Aligarh Muslim University in 1875, he wanted to create a “learned mind” that could, as Aristotle suggested, entertain modern, Western scientific thought without losing its cultural identity.
By removing Khan from the political science syllabus, the Jammu University is erasing the history of indigenous secularism and rationalist reform. Without understanding Khan’s appeal to reason, students lose the context of the internal debates that shaped the modern South Asian identity. To study the “Muslim mind” without its most prominent rationalist is to study a caricature. By erasing Khan’s philosophy, the university succumbs to demands of the modern-day echo chamber while denying students the tools to navigate the complexities of the past.
The head of the Political Science Department at Jammu University, Baljit Singh Mann, correctly argued that the inclusion of these thinkers is consistent with the norms and curricula of the University Grants Commission, followed by premier universities nationwide.
Universities must be spaces where diverse viewpoints are presented for critical evaluation instead of being sidelined fearing controversy.
Shielding students from the “unpleasant” parts of history, produces graduates who are ill-equipped to defend the democratic and secular values of India against uninformed critique.
Faisal CK is Deputy Law Secretary to the Government of Kerala. Views are personal.
Source: Scroll
Related Posts: U.S. cuts broad recommendation for four childhood vaccines including flu Punjab University Or ‘Thar University’ NCERT reconstitutes textbook committee after Supreme Court rap BJP leaders arrive in Delhi ahead of core committee meet on Bihar polls Committee formed to probe suicide of medical student Tejasvi Surya appointed Chairman of Select Committee on Jan Vishwas Bill Rahul Gandhi arrives in Patna to attend Congress Working Committee meeting UGC Forms Committee To Investigate Student's Death At Dharamshala College Raghav Chadha appointed chairman of Rajya Sabha Committee on Petitions DGCA Forms Committee To Review
Indian athletics witnessed a historic evening in Ranchi as Tejaswin Shankar became the first Indian ever to breach the 8000-point barrier in decathlon at the Federation Cup on Saturday. The 27-year-old produced a sensational all-round performance to finish with 8057 points
7 hours ago
The Centre released draft rules for the Viksit Bharat – Guarantee for Rozgar and Ajeevika Mission (Gramin) Act, 2025 for public consultation. The rules focus on governance, grievance redressal, and transitioning from MGNREGA to the new rural employment scheme
7 hours ago
The National Threat Analytics Unit of the Indian Cybercrime Coordination Centre (I4C) has warned of a sophisticated phishing campaign impersonating Apple tech support to target whose devices have been lost or stolen, officials said on Saturday.The I4C, which functions under the Union Home Ministry
7 hours ago
Sachin Tendulkar praised his son Arjun's IPL debut for Lucknow Super Giants. Arjun Tendulkar showed patience and skill in his first match. He bowled well and took a wicket. Sachin Tendulkar expressed pride in his son's performance and attitude
7 hours ago
White House shooting suspect claimed to be ‘real’ Osama bin Laden, threatened Trump online: ReportOsama bin Laden was the founder and leader of the terror group Al-Qaeda, which was reportedly responsible the 9/11 attacks. Updated on: May 24, 2026 11:02 AM IST By Anita Goswami Share via Copy
7 hours ago
May 24, Birthday Horoscope: Here's what the tarot cards have in store for youIf your birthday falls on May 24, here’s what your year ahead looks like, as per Tarot. Published on: May 24, 2026 11:00 AM IST By Kishori Sud Share via Copy link If you were born on May 24
7 hours ago
George Russell may have delivered the perfect answer to mounting pressure at Mercedes. After a fiery sprint race clash with championship-leading teammate Kimi Antonelli earlier on Saturday, the Briton bounced back in style to grab pole position for Sunday’s Canadian Grand Prix — edging the
7 hours ago
BJP candidate Debangshu Panda is leading significantly in the Falta assembly constituency repoll. After five rounds of counting, Panda has secured a lead of over 14,000 votes against his CPI(M) rival. The repoll followed allegations of EVM tampering and irregularities during the initial polling
7 hours ago
The suspect in a shooting near the White House was killed in an exchange of fire with Secret Service agents on Saturday evening, officials have confirmed. BBC's US media partner CBS has named the suspect as Nasire Best, a 21-year-old man who was known to the Secret Service and had a documented
7 hours ago
CPI(M) MP raises concerns over CBSE's digital evaluation, seeks interventionCPI(M) MP raises concerns over CBSE's digital evaluation, seeks intervention Published on: May 23, 2026 5:22 PM IST PTI Share via Copy link New Delhi, The Rajya Sabha leader of the CPI, John Brittas
7 hours ago
Imagine enjoying a decadent, fudge‑like treat that also supports your hormones, libido, and menstrual rhythm, all while being packed with collagen, magnesium, adaptogens, and lignan‑rich omega‑3s. These Seed Cycling Hormone Bliss Balls are designed around the simple yet powerful practice of
7 hours ago
Weekly Love Horoscope for May 24-30, 2026: The stars brings positive energies for these zodiac signsWeekly Love Horoscope for May 24-30, 2026: This week asks for patience, trust, and emotional resilience. Published on: May 24, 2026 7:30 AM IST By Kishori Sud Share via Copy link Aries Love feels
10 hours ago
Perhaps the fullest realisation of what Mohamed Salah has achieved at Liverpool will only come with time. But as he prepares to say his goodbyes on Sunday, there is plenty to appreciate and admire in the here and now. There are the standards Salah helped to set that emanated through the club in his
10 hours ago
From a darkly comic tale of revenge to a beautiful contemplation on friendship, here are the year's most acclaimed works of fiction so far. "Daring, deranged, cleverly written," is how Vogue describes the buzzy debut by Caro Claire Burke. In this satirical thriller
10 hours ago
Jaipur real estate: Ashiana Housing has launched the first phase of its 10.35-acre residential project ‘Ashiana Oma’ in Ajmer Road at Mansarovar Extension Ashiana Housing will invest nearly ₹560 crore to develop a residential project in Jaipur
10 hours ago
Overnight fires in Delhi: Shops, homes gutted in four blazesA fire department officer was injured after the tin shed of one of the shops he was standing on during the firefighting operation collapsed. Updated on: May 24, 2026 7:37 AM IST By Karn Pratap Singh Share via Copy link Four separate fire
10 hours ago
As per the government, the new rules enable families living in Delhi to submit applications if their annual household income is within the newly prescribed limit. New Delhi: The Delhi government has reopened the process of issuing fresh ration cards under changed eligibility criteria after a gap of
10 hours ago
The reported disruption of AI-animated film Critterz after OpenAI allegedly shut down Sora has sparked a larger conversation around one major issue in tech and entertainment: what happens when creators build entire projects on platforms they do not control?The reported disruption of AI-animated
10 hours ago
Ex-Meta employee says non-Chinese workers were targeted for layoffsA laid-off Meta engineer has alleged that he was routinely excluded and ostracised by his Chinese colleagues at the company. Updated on: May 24, 2026 7:01 AM IST By Sanya Jain Share via Copy link A laid-off Meta engineer has alleged
10 hours ago
Mackenzie Shirilla wanted Kim Kardashian's help; here's why it's not happeningMackenzie Shirilla sought Kim Kardashian's legal support following the release of The Crash documentary, but Kardashian reportedly has no plans to get involved. May 24, 2026
10 hours ago
The first scientific survey of fishing cats (Prionailurus viverrinus) in Kaziranga National Park and Tiger Reserve has recorded 57 individuals, confirming that the species is widely distributed and actively reproducing across the reserve’s floodplains
10 hours ago
X warns founder against reuploading White House shooting video: 'Revenue reduced by 90%'Nikita Bier of X warned a user against reuploading the White House shooting video, asking him to ‘Quote’ or ‘Video Reshare’ instead. Updated on: May 24, 2026 6:14 AM IST By Sanya Jain Share via Copy link
10 hours ago
Sonam Wangchuk says Article 371 talks for Ladakh still ‘work in progress’; backs Cockroach Janta PartySonam Wangchuk hoped constitutional safeguards will be granted to Ladakh after recent talks between Ladakh groups and the Centre. Updated on: May 24
10 hours ago
Talking about international partnerships, PM Modi said India’s growing ties with global companies and countries would create new opportunities for young people. Prime Minister Narendra Modi distributed more than 51,000 appointment letters to newly recruited candidates during the 19th Rozgar Mela
10 hours ago
The Archaeological Survey of India’s circular in December on tourist guides at Red Fort has opened a larger debate: who gets to interpret the past? The circular states that only guides licensed by the Ministry of Tourism and endorsed by the Archaeological Survey of India may offer services inside
10 hours ago
Dipika Kakar’s father-in-law in ICU after suffering stroke, Shoaib Ibrahim seeks prayers: ‘24 hrs are crucial’Shoaib Ibrahim took to Instagram to inform fans that his father has been hospitalised once again after suffering another stroke. May 24, 2026
10 hours ago
Oleksandr Usyk struck lucky to retain his world heavyweight titles in Egypt with a highly controversial 11th-round stoppage win against boxing novice Rico Verhoeven. Verhoeven, in just his second professional boxing fight, was the clear aggressor for long spells
10 hours ago
