Vishal Jethwa expressed a mix of heartbreak and immense pride following the announcement, that India's official entry, Homebound, failed to secure a final
Life Style

Vishal Jethwa expressed a mix of heartbreak and immense pride following the announcement, that India's official entry, Homebound, failed to secure a final nomination for the 98th Academy Awards. Mumbai: Actor Vishal Jethwa has expressed his disappointment after his movie Homebound failed to make it

The State Health Society, Bihar (SHSB) has released the Bihar ANM (Auxiliary Nurse Midwives) Result 2026. The results are available in PDF format on the SHSB's
Education

The State Health Society, Bihar (SHSB) has released the Bihar ANM (Auxiliary Nurse Midwives) Result 2026. The results are available in PDF format on the SHSB's official website, shs.bihar.gov.in. The PDF contains the roll numbers of those shortlisted for the next stage.The State Health Society

Suspended Trinamool MLA Humayun Kabir has extended an olive branch to the BJP, contingent on securing the chief ministerial position
Politics

Suspended Trinamool MLA Humayun Kabir has extended an olive branch to the BJP, contingent on securing the chief ministerial position. He has also opened dialogues with Congress, CPI-M, and ISF, advocating for a coalition of opposition parties. Trinamool leaders have swiftly condemned Kabir's move

Raipur (Chattisgarh) [India], January 24 (ANI): All-rounder Shivam Dube has hailed Ishan Kishan and captain Suryakumar Yadav's partnership
Sports

Raipur (Chattisgarh) [India], January 24 (ANI): All-rounder Shivam Dube has hailed Ishan Kishan and captain Suryakumar Yadav's partnership, which helped Team India chase down a massive 209-run target in just 15.2 overs against New Zealand in the second T20I on Wednesday.Raipur (Chattisgarh) [India]

Do Deewane Seher Mein is a modern romantic drama starring Siddhant Chaturvedi (as Shashank) and Mrunal Thakur (as Roshni/Rohini). New Delhi: Siddhant
Entertainment

Do Deewane Seher Mein is a modern romantic drama starring Siddhant Chaturvedi (as Shashank) and Mrunal Thakur (as Roshni/Rohini). New Delhi: Siddhant Chaturvedi has shared some truly adorable behind-the-scenes pictures from the song Aasma from his upcoming film Do Deewane Seher Mein

UK’s new immigration policy makes English a test of belonging

Posted By: Vanshika Pathak Posted On: Jan 24, 2026Share Article
UK’s new immigration policy makes English a test of belonging
A counter demonstration against an anti-immigration protest called by far-right activists, outside the Asylum Welcome immigration support service offices in

What happens when learning English stops being a bridge into society and starts to feel like a test of belonging you can fail?

That is the question raised by the the UK government's proposed new immigration policy, which would raise English-language requirements for most visa routes, with the aim of improving integration and workforce readiness.

This represents an increase in emphasis on language proficiency. Applicants would have to demonstrate higher proficiency in speaking, reading, writing and listening. There would be stricter testing standards and fewer exemptions, aligning immigration with strong communication skills for employment and community participation.

Ministers say the proposed policies will promote “integration” and “opportunity”. But it risks doing the opposite, by turning English for speakers of other languages (Esol) into a tool of surveillance rather than inclusion.

We are part of the Coalition for Language Education, a network of academics, teachers and organisations. The group argues that the proposed policy treats the ability to speak English less as a means of empowerment and more as a mechanism of immigration control.

By tying long-term residence and citizenship to staged progress in learning English, the policy reframes language not as a shared public good, but as a condition of acceptance. In effect, English becomes a kind of border.

Language shapes how we live together. It's how people build relationships, find work, take part in communities and participate in democracy. But it can also be used to divide and exclude.

For non-native speakers, learning English has long been about helping people navigate everyday life, express themselves and feel at home. The government's proposals, however, position English proficiency as a test of belonging – something to be proved, measured and monitored.

Under the plan, migrants seeking settlement or citizenship would be required to show staged progress in English, moving from basic to upper-intermediate levels over a ten-year period. Language attainment would be linked to a points-based system that also tracks employment and civic participation.

Language acquisition, however, is not linear. Progress is shaped by trauma, health, caring responsibilities, work patterns and previous education. For refugees and others who have experienced displacement or interrupted schooling, the expectation of steady, testable improvement can be unrealistic and punitive.

Reducing these complex learning journeys to tick-box benchmarks turns learning English into a compliance exercise. Linguistic ability becomes confused with effort, morality and even loyalty. Passing tests is seen as proof of trying hard, so failure implies laziness. Fluency becomes linked to being a “good” or “deserving” migrant. High proficiency signals commitment to national identity, while lower ability is framed as resistance.

This is not just a UK issue either. Around the world, language education has increasingly been tied to immigration control. What is new with this proposal is how openly English is framed as something to be audited.

In the UK, attendance, test results and progression targets risk becoming data points used to monitor behaviour, rather than tools to support learning. Teachers are pushed to prioritise performance indicators over dialogue, confidence-building and community connection.

When language becomes a tool of control, it reshapes citizenship itself, testing people against a narrow linguistic ideal and eroding democratic values. Equality, fairness, inclusion and participation erode when language becomes a gatekeeping tool. Narrow linguistic standards exclude diverse speakers, denying equal access to citizenship and civic rights.

Beyond its ideology, the proposed policy also fails on practical grounds. Esol provision across the UK is already underfunded and uneven. Community and voluntary providers, who support many of the most marginalised learners, are expected to deliver high-stakes outcomes with limited resources.

But there are no commitments to teacher training, pay, or access for women, refugees, or rural learners. There is little recognition of the barriers many learners face, including trauma, caring responsibilities or lack of access to childcare and transport. Nor is there any serious engagement with trauma-informed or learner-centred teaching approaches. Instead, the policy doubles down on a technocratic model that values what can be measured over what actually matters in the classroom.

Language should help people connect, not police their right to stay. Integration cannot be engineered through fear of failure or threat of exclusion. It grows when education is welcoming, well resourced and rooted in respect.

Linguistic diversity is not a problem to be solved. It is a public resource that enriches communities and strengthens democracy. Teaching English works best when it builds on what learners already know, rather than treating their languages as obstacles to overcome.

Instead of tethering language learning to immigration enforcement, the government should invest in trauma-informed, learner-centred provision that meets learners' needs. Assessment, too, needs rethinking. It should prioritise real-world communication and participation, not abstract benchmarks that silence voices.

Most importantly, integration must be understood as a two-way process. Host communities have as much to learn as newcomers.

If the government believes in empowerment, then education should amplify voices, not diminish them. Language policy should open doors, not lock them.

By replacing the language of rights and participation – teaching English not just for jobs, but to empower migrants to understand, claim and exercise their rights and engage in civic life – with conditional belonging, the proposed policy risks reinforcing inequality rather than reducing it. Presenting linguistic mastery as proof of national worth corrodes the democratic values language education should uphold.

Language should unite, not divide. When the English language is turned into an instrument of control, the very medium through which democracy operates is weakened. The task ahead is not to “restore control” over language, but to restore trust – in learners, in teachers and in the power of linguistic diversity to bring people together.

Declan Flanagan is Lecturer in Applied Languages and Intercultural Studies, Dublin City University.

Mike Chick is Professor of ESOL, University of South Wales.

This article was first published on The Conversation.

Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


US President Donald Trump has sharply criticised Canada over its reported opposition to his proposed “Golden Dome
Latest News
China Will Eat Them Up

US President Donald Trump has sharply criticised Canada over its reported opposition to his proposed “Golden Dome" missile defence system in Greenland, accusing Ottawa of undermining its own security while deepening ties with China. In a post on Truth Social

Just now

Religious scriptures across faiths have long offered descriptions of heaven and the path to reach it after death. Now, a former Harvard physics professor has
World
This Scientist Says He Knows Where Heaven Is And How Far It Is From Earth

Religious scriptures across faiths have long offered descriptions of heaven and the path to reach it after death. Now, a former Harvard physics professor has reignited debate by claiming that science may have identified where heaven is located. Dr Michael Guillen

Just now

Congress leaders Mallikarjun Kharge and Rahul Gandhi met senior Kerala Congress leaders in New Delhi to discuss election preparations
Politics
Shashi Tharoor's absence at Delhi Congress' Kerala meeting triggers 'Kochi Chill' buzz

Congress leaders Mallikarjun Kharge and Rahul Gandhi met senior Kerala Congress leaders in New Delhi to discuss election preparations, but the absence of Congress Working Committee member Shashi Tharoor drew attention. The absence came days after Rahul Gandhi did not mention Tharoor during a party

Just now

Pakistani police on Friday arrested prominent human rights lawyer Imaan Zainab Mazari-Hazir and her husband, lawyer Hadi Ali Chattha
World
Fascism At Its Peak

Pakistani police on Friday arrested prominent human rights lawyer Imaan Zainab Mazari-Hazir and her husband, lawyer Hadi Ali Chattha, as they were heading to a court in Islamabad. The couple was on their way to appear before the Additional District and Sessions Court in a case linked to

Just now

Congress Leader Rahul Gandhi stoked a major controversy on Friday by repeating US President Donald Trump's ‘dead economy' jibe for India
Politics
Problem Is With Beta

Congress Leader Rahul Gandhi stoked a major controversy on Friday by repeating US President Donald Trump's ‘dead economy' jibe for India, saying the Centre must wake up to save the country's textile industry from the 50% tariffs imposed on Indian goods over Russian oil purchases

Just now

Polycystic Ovary Syndrome (PCOS) is often discussed as a condition affecting adult women, yet its roots frequently begin much earlier. For many teenage girls
Life Style
Why PCOS In Teens Goes Undiagnosed And How Early Action Can Help

Polycystic Ovary Syndrome (PCOS) is often discussed as a condition affecting adult women, yet its roots frequently begin much earlier. For many teenage girls, the first signs appear during adolescence – quietly, gradually, and often masked by normal pubertal changes

Just now

premium device that will be looking to appeal to buyers with its design and overall features. The company has upgraded its camera system for this new model
Technology
Motorola Signature With Triple 50MP Cameras And 165Hz Display Launched

premium device that will be looking to appeal to buyers with its design and overall features. The company has upgraded its camera system for this new model which had made its global debut at the CES 2026 in Las Vegas just a few weeks back. And unlike what people in other regions will be paying for

Just now

PM Narendra Modi arrived in Kerala to inaugurate development projects, flag off Amrit Bharat Express trains, and address a BJP-NDA public meeting in
Latest News
PM Modi To Launch Multiple Projects

PM Narendra Modi arrived in Kerala to inaugurate development projects, flag off Amrit Bharat Express trains, and address a BJP-NDA public meeting in Thiruvananthapuram. Prime Minister Narendra Modi arrived in Kerala on Friday morning to inaugurate and lay the foundation stone for a series of

Just now

Former Bangladeshi Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina on Friday accused Muhammad Yunus, the head of the country's interim government, of being a “murderous
Latest News
Yunus a murderous fascist

Former Bangladeshi Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina on Friday accused Muhammad Yunus, the head of the country's interim government, of being a “murderous fascist” and called for a United Nations investigation into the unrest and political developments since she was ousted

Just now

Nepal captain Rohit Paudel says his side have
Sports
Nepal skipper eyes new summit with nothing to lose at T20 World Cup

Nepal captain Rohit Paudel says his side have "nothing to lose" in next month's T20 World Cup as they target more famous upsets and a place in the tournament's Super Eight second phase. The Himalayan nation stunned the two-time T20 World Cup winners West Indies last year for their first series win

Just now

Celebrity couple Prince Narula and Yuvika Chaudhary have officially confirmed their participation in the upcoming reality show 'The 50'
Entertainment
Celebrity couple Prince Narula and Yuvika Chaudhary set to join reality show

Celebrity couple Prince Narula and Yuvika Chaudhary have officially confirmed their participation in the upcoming reality show 'The 50'. Mumbai: The celebrity couple, Prince Narula and Yuvika Chaudhary, are set to enter the upcoming reality show 'The 50' together

Just now

<strong>Upcoming Bank Holidays:</strong> With no resort seemingly on the horizon for the all-India bank strike to be scheduled to demand a five-day
Business
Banks Likely Shut For Four Days From Tomorrow Due To Holidays

Upcoming Bank Holidays: With no resort seemingly on the horizon for the all-India bank strike to be scheduled to demand a five-day work week, banks are likely to shut down for four continuous days from tomorrow, January 24 to Tuesday, January 27

Just now

Sumit reflected on how Karan Johar worked hard on the campaign. Despite intense campaigning and glorious reviews, Neeraj Ghaywan and Karan Johar's Homebound is
Latest News
Homebound Writer Says Oscars Campaign Can Be ‘Very

Sumit reflected on how Karan Johar worked hard on the campaign. Despite intense campaigning and glorious reviews, Neeraj Ghaywan and Karan Johar's Homebound is out of the Oscars race. However, the film's writer, Sumit Roy, is convinced that nothing more could be done to campaign for the film

Just now

Top defense officials from 34 countries will reportedly meet in February to discuss common security priorities in the Western Hemisphere
Latest News
US to host meeting of Western Hemisphere military heads

Top defense officials from 34 countries will reportedly meet in February to discuss common security priorities in the Western Hemisphere, the US military said on Friday, as per Reuters. US Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Dan Caine will host the inaugural Western Hemisphere Chiefs of Defense

Just now

The Centre should push the private sector to invest in R&D and hold it accountable, Sridhar Vembu, cofounder and chief scientist of software firm Zoho
Technology
Govt should give a strong push for private sector investment in R&D in the Budget

The Centre should push the private sector to invest in R&D and hold it accountable, Sridhar Vembu, cofounder and chief scientist of software firm Zoho, said Friday, ahead of the upcoming Budget.He said the combination of the 'carrot and stick' approach could do the trick to supercharge such

Just now

Border 2, which is slated for a theatrical release on January 23, has recently received its certification from the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC)
Entertainment
CBFC clears Sunny Deol and Varun Dhawan’s Border 2 with no cuts

Border 2, which is slated for a theatrical release on January 23, has recently received its certification from the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC). According to a report by Bollywood Hungama, the certification process went smoothly

Just now

Apple is going to bring its new-look Siri AI version in the next few months but the company seems to be planning for something bigger which we could see when
Technology
Big iOS 27 Changes

Apple is going to bring its new-look Siri AI version in the next few months but the company seems to be planning for something bigger which we could see when the iOS 27 update rolls out later this year. A new report claims Apple will use the AI Siri version as a placeholder for a few months and it

Just now

Tata Motors has expanded its fleet-only lineup with the launch of the XPRES sedan in Petrol and CNG versions. Earlier, this Tigor-based fleet-only sedan was
Latest News
Tata Motors launches Xpres sedan in CNG

Tata Motors has expanded its fleet-only lineup with the launch of the XPRES sedan in Petrol and CNG versions. Earlier, this Tigor-based fleet-only sedan was available only in its electric avatar. Bookings for the new Tata XPRES Petrol and CNG are now open across authorised fleet dealerships

Just now

Israel's Economy Minister Nir Barkat ruled out the participation of Qatar, Turkey and Pakistan in any international peacekeeping force
Latest News
Israel rejects Sharif’s Gaza peace bid

Israel's Economy Minister Nir Barkat ruled out the participation of Qatar, Turkey and Pakistan in any international peacekeeping force, accusing them of supporting militant groups in Gaza. Pakistan faced a stinging double humiliation at the World Economic Forum in Davos after Prime Minister Shehbaz

Just now

It's
World
Four attacks in 48 hours

It's "extraordinary", says shark researcher Chris Pepin-Neff: four shark bites within 48 hours, and three of them within a 15-kilometre stretch of Australia's east coast. On 18 January, a 12-year-old boy was taken to hospital with critical injuries after being attacked while swimming in Sydney

Just now

The past eight Grand Slam titles have been shared between Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner.</b> They have contested the past three finals
Sports
Is Sinner-Alcaraz in danger of making majors boring

The past eight Grand Slam titles have been shared between Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner. They have contested the past three finals, and thrilled us - especially at Roland Garros last June, when Alcaraz saved three championship points on his way to a stunning win

Just now

With the ICC Under-19 Men's Cricket World Cup 2026 drawing closer, excitement is building around the possibility of another high-voltage India vs Pakistan
Sports
Will India face Pakistan in U19 World Cup 2026

With the ICC Under-19 Men's Cricket World Cup 2026 drawing closer, excitement is building around the possibility of another high-voltage India vs Pakistan clash at the junior level. Fans searching for the date of this much-anticipated encounter, however, may have to wait a little longer

Just now

Minimum temperatures are likely to fall by 3 degrees to 5 degrees Celsius in northwestern India, including Delhi, over the next 24 hours
Latest News
Northwestern India temperatures to drop by 3-5 degrees Celsius

Minimum temperatures are likely to fall by 3 degrees to 5 degrees Celsius in northwestern India, including Delhi, over the next 24 hours, the India Meteorological Department said on Friday. The drop in temperatures came after rainfall and snowfall in the northern parts of the country

Just now

As part of the measures, the central bank will conduct a 90-day variable rate repo (VRR) operation for an amount of Rs 25,000 crore on January 30
Business
RBI To Inject Over Rs 2 Lakh Crore In Banking System To Ease Liquidity

As part of the measures, the central bank will conduct a 90-day variable rate repo (VRR) operation for an amount of Rs 25,000 crore on January 30, allowing banks to borrow funds at market-determined rates against collateral assets to be provided by them.As part of the measures

Just now

Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Friday emphasised that Tamil Nadu is ready for change and seeks to replace the corrupt DMK government
Politics
Corruption, Mafia, Crime

Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Friday emphasised that Tamil Nadu is ready for change and seeks to replace the corrupt DMK government. He said the countdown for the MK Stalin-led government has begun, and the state wants a BJP-NDA government. Addressing a massive rally in Madhuranthakam, Tamil Nadu

Just now

Smartphone weather apps that summarize their forecasts with eye-popping numbers and bright icons may be handy during mild weather
Technology
The coming winter storm

Smartphone weather apps that summarize their forecasts with eye-popping numbers and bright icons may be handy during mild weather, but meteorologists say it's better to listen to human expertise during multi-faceted, dangerous winter storms like the one blowing through the U.S

Just now

PM Svanidhi Scheme 2026: Great news for small traders! Under the PM Svanidhi scheme, you can now get a loan of up to ₹90,000 without any collateral
Latest News
Get up to ₹90

PM Svanidhi Scheme 2026: Great news for small traders! Under the PM Svanidhi scheme, you can now get a loan of up to ₹90,000 without any collateral. You can raise your capital in three easy installments using just your Aadhaar card. Timely repayment will also entitle you to significant

Just now


Sing Up