A PAN card is a key document required for financial and banking transactions, while Aadhaar is a 12-digit unique identification number issued by the Unique Identification Authority of India. New Delhi: The government has announced changes to the Permanent Account Number (PAN) application process
Who will challenge D Gukesh? Vishy Anand names 3 contenders; Magnus Carlsen backs Caruana, Nakamura for Candidates 2026 Published on: Mar 18, 2026 5:34 PM IST Written by Neelav Chakravarti Share via Copy link Vishy Anand and Magnus Carlsen named their top contenders for the Candidates title
Stock Market Live Updates: Indian equity markets ended higher on Tuesday, with broader markets outperforming frontline indices as investors showed renewed interest in midcap and technology stocks. The NSE Nifty jumped 0.83 per cent or 196.65 points to close at 23,777.80
The automobile sector in the country may face near-term production disruptions due to constraints in industrial gas supply arising from ongoing disruptions in the energy market amid the West Asia conflict, according to a report. New Delhi: The automobile sector in the country may face near-term
A father in India has shut down the internet with a smooth Michael Jackson-style moonwalk performed in simple rubber slippers. Watch the viral video that has racked up 15 million views and left Gen Z stunned by "Uncleji's" 80s swag. Move over
Illinois Lieutenant Governor Juliana Stratton is the predicted winner of the Democratic primary for US Senate, edging out her opponents after a late surge of support in a highly competitive, expensive race. Stratton was leading her main opponent, congressman Raja Krishnamoorthi
Israel's Defense Minister Katz has announced a significant development. The Israeli military has killed Iranian Intelligence Minister Esmail Khatib. This follows yesterday's reported killings of other top Iranian security officials. More surprises are anticipated today across all fronts
Happy Chaitra Navratri 2026 wishes: Celebrate the divine energy of Goddess Durga with heartfelt words and blessings this Chaitra Navratri. Share these beautiful wishes, messages, and quotes to spread positivity, strength, and devotion.Happy Chaitra Navratri 2026 wishes: Celebrate the divine energy
Two ancient Athenian ideals of free speech for today’s dangerously loud social media era
In ancient Athens, the agora was a public forum where citizens could gather to deliberate, disagree and decide together. It was governed by deep-rooted social principles that ensured lively, inclusive, healthy debate.
Today, our public squares have moved online to the digital feeds and forums of social media. These spaces mostly lack communal rules and codes – instead, algorithms decide which voices rise above the clamour, and which are buried beneath it.
The optimistic idea of the internet being a radically democratic space feels like a distant memory. Our conversations are now shaped by opaque systems designed to maximise engagement, not understanding. Algorithmic popularity, not accuracy or fairness, determines reach.
This has created a paradox. We enjoy unprecedented freedom to speak, yet our speech is constrained by forces beyond our control. Loud voices dominate. Nuanced voices fade. Outrage travels faster than reflection. In this landscape, equal participation is all but unattainable, and honest speech can carry a very genuine risk.
Somewhere between the stone steps of Athens and the screens of today, we have lost something essential to our democratic life and dialogue: the balance between equality of voice and the courage to speak the truth, even when it is dangerous. Two ancient Athenian ideals of free speech, isegoria and parrhesia, can help us find it again.
In Athens, isegoria referred to the right to speak, but it did not stop at mere entitlement or access. It signalled a shared responsibility, a commitment to fairness, and the idea that public life should not be governed by the powerful alone.
The term parrhesia can be defined as boldness or freedom in speaking. Again, there is nuance; parrhesia is not reckless candour, but ethical courage. It referred to the duty to speak truthfully, even when that truth provoked discomfort or danger.
These ideals were not abstract principles. They were civic practices, learned and reinforced through participation. Athenians understood that democratic speech was both a right and a responsibility, and that the quality of public life depended on the character of its citizens.
The digital sphere has changed the context but not the importance of these virtues. Access alone is insufficient. Without norms that support equality of voice and encourage truth-telling, free speech becomes vulnerable to distortion, intimidation and manipulation.
The emergence of AI-generated content intensifies these pressures. Citizens must now navigate not only human voices, but also machine-produced ones that blur the boundaries of credibility and intent.
On contemporary platforms, visibility is distributed unequally and often unpredictably. Algorithms tend to amplify ideas that trigger strong emotions, regardless of their value. Communities that already face marginalisation can find themselves unheard, while those who thrive on provocation can dominate the conversation.
On the internet, isegoria is challenged in a new way. Few people are formally excluded from it, but many are structurally invisible. The right to speak remains, but the opportunity to be heard is uneven.
At the same time, parrhesia becomes more precarious. Speaking with honesty, especially about contested issues, may expose individuals to harassment, misrepresentation or reputational harm. The cost of courage has increased, while the incentives to remain silent, or to retreat into echo chambers, have grown.
The Athenians understood that democratic virtues do not emerge on their own. Isegoria and parrhesia were sustained through habits learned over time: listening as a civic duty, speaking as a shared responsibility, and recognising that public life depended on the character of its participants. In our era, the closest equivalent is civic education, the space where citizens practise the dispositions that democratic speech requires.
By making classrooms into small-scale agoras, students can learn to inhabit the ethical tension between equality of voice and integrity in speech. Activities that invite shared dialogue, equitable turn-taking and attention to quieter voices help them experience isegoria, not as an abstract right but as a lived practice of fairness.
In practice, this means holding discussions and debates where students have to verify information, articulate and justify arguments, revise their views publicly, or engage respectfully with opposing arguments. These skills all cultivate the intellectual courage associated with parrhesia.
Importantly, these experiences do not prescribe what students should believe. Instead, they rehearse the habits that make belief accountable to others: the discipline of listening, the willingness to offer reasons, and the readiness to refine a position in light of new understanding. Such practices restore a sense that democratic participation is not merely expressive, but relational and built through shared effort.
What civic education ultimately offers is practice. It creates miniature agoras where students rehearse the skills they need as citizens: speaking clearly, listening generously, questioning assumptions and engaging with those who think differently.
These habits counter the pressures of the digital world. They slow down conversation in spaces designed for speed. They introduce reflection into environments engineered for reaction. They remind us that democratic discourse is not a performance, but a shared responsibility.
The challenge of our era is not only technological but educational. No algorithm can teach responsibility, courage or fairness. These are qualities formed through experience, reflection and practice. Athenians understood this intuitively, because their democracy relied on ordinary citizens learning how to speak as equals and with integrity.
We face the same challenge today. If we want digital public squares that support democratic life, we must prepare citizens who know how to inhabit them wisely. Civic education is not optional enrichment – it is the training ground for the habits that sustain freedom.
The agora may have changed form, but its purpose endures. To speak and listen as equals, with honesty, courage and care, is still the heart of democracy. And this is something we can teach.
Sara Kells is Director of Program Management at IE Digital Learning and Adjunct Professor of Humanities, IE University.
This article was first published on The Conversation.
Source: Scroll
Related Posts: Greece, Ukraine sign US gas supply deal as Zelenskyy visits Athens Djokovic wins 101st title after marathon final with Musetti in Athens The powerful, gender-diverse courtiers and religious leaders of ancient Mesopotamia How ancient India spread its culture without conquest Ancient monuments at risk amid neglect Egyptians outraged after ancient pharaoh’s bracelet was stolen from Cairo museum and melted down Did Birth Control Exist In Ancient India 2 Egyptians outraged after ancient pharaoh’s bracelet was stolen from Cairo museum and melted down Egyptians outraged after ancient pharaoh’s bracelet was stolen from Cairo museum and melted down
Senator Markwayne Mullin, who has been tapped by US President Donald Trump to lead the Department of Homeland Security, will appear on Wednesday in front of a congressional committee. The Republican lawmaker from Oklahoma will testify before the Senate Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs
2 hours ago
Given the current fuel shortage in the country and the increasing pressure on imports, the Petroleum Ministry has significantly tightened the rules for domestic gas use. Now, not only possessing a cylinder, but even having a “double” connection at home will be a crime
2 hours ago
Eight members of a family were killed when a fire broke out in a three-storey house after an explosion at an Electric Vehicle (EV) charging point outside the building in Indore early on Wednesday (March 18, 2026), officials said. The deceased included two minor children and three women, they said
2 hours ago
Life in Kalghatgi town and nearby villages in Dharwad district was thrown into disarray on Tuesday (March 18) evening after a sudden and intense hailstorm lashed the region. The unexpected weather event left residents panicked, forcing many to seek shelter immediately
2 hours ago
Hospitals are meant to heal. Yet, for millions of patients globally, they can also become sites of new illness often preventable, often overlooked. Hospital-Acquired Infections (HAIs) represent one of the most persistent paradoxes in modern healthcare. Even as medical technology advances
2 hours ago
Dilip Ghosh, a prominent figure in the BJP, asserts that the party has successfully put Trinamool Congress leader Mamata Banerjee on the defensive within her Bhabanipur stronghold. He pointed out that Suvendu Adhikari's candidacy is a tactical choice aimed at strengthening BJP's foothold
2 hours ago
The Allahabad High Court on Monday said that the state must ensure that security is provided to persons facing threats for congregating to hold prayers at private properties in Uttar Pradesh, Bar and Bench reported. A bench of Justices Atul Sreedharan and Siddharth Nandan added that Article 25 of
2 hours ago
BSEB Class 10th Result 2026: The Bihar School Examination Board will announce the 10th matric exam results on March 20, 2026, in Patna on March 20, 2026. Students are advised to keep themselves updated with their roll number and other necessary details
2 hours ago
The fire and fury that is consuming the MAGA (Make America Great Again) fraternity that had rallied behind Donald J. Trump’s anti-war rhetoric for a decade touched the administration on Tuesday (March 17, 2026) when Joe Kent, a long-term acolyte
2 hours ago
Kylian Mbappe vs Balance: Real Madrid’s rhythm without Frenchman turns heads as Vinicius back to his best Updated on: Mar 18, 2026 5:58 PM IST By Aditya Maheshwari Share via Copy link Real Madrid find rhythm without Kylian Mbappe. (Reuters) Beating Manchester City so convincingly is never easy
2 hours ago
In television comedy shows such as The Kapil Sharma Show and Comedy Nights with Kapil, Kiku Sharda has portrayed many popular female characters, including Palak, Bumper, and Santosh. Mumbai: Actor-comedian Kiku Sharda is widely loved for slipping into multiple female avatars on-screen
2 hours ago
A woman stands on a rooftop listening to the sounds of the city below. There is only the dull hum of traffic tonight. But she knows how easily that can change. It is usually the dogs who notice the sound first and begin to bark furiously. The noise of aircraft
2 hours ago
In fiscal year 2026, Dell Technologies reduced its workforce by approximately 11,000 employees, representing about 10% of its staff, as detailed in its 10-K filing. The employee count decreased from 108,000 in January 2025 to nearly 97,000 by January 2026.In fiscal year 2026
2 hours ago
New Delhi, Mar 18 (PTI) Uranium Corporation of India Ltd (UCIL) is set to establish a uranium mining and processing plant with a capacity of 2,500 tonnes per day (TPD) at Rohil in Rajasthan’s Sikar district and Jajwal, Chhattisgarh, said Union Minister Jitendra Singh on Wednesday.New Delhi
2 hours ago
India on Tuesday denied holding negotiations with Iran about releasing three vessels New Delhi had seized in February in return for the safe passage of Indian ships through the Strait of Hormuz. The denial by the Ministry of External Affairs came during an inter-ministerial press briefing on the
2 hours ago
If you are an EPFO member or are associated with it, this news is for you. This is because everything—from pensions to claims and account transfers—is now becoming faster and easier than ever before. In the Lok Sabha, Shobha Karandlaje, the Minister of State for Labour and Employment
2 hours ago
According to the NXT Foundation’s India Progress Report 2025-26, India has surpassed Japan with a nominal GDP of $4.8 trillion. It maintains the fastest growth rate of 8.2% in the world. New Delhi: India has overtaken Japan to become the world’s fourth-largest economy
2 hours ago
Ugadi Pachadi, the traditional festive offering prepared during Ugadi, is more than just a dish; it is a symbolic representation of life itself. Known as a blend of Shadruchulu (six tastes), this special preparation holds deep cultural, spiritual, and health significance.Ugadi Pachadi
2 hours ago
Nora Fatehi has addressed the controversy around her and Sanjay Dutt’s viral song Sarke Chunar, saying she was unaware of the Hindi lyrics and never approved the final version. The actor’s reaction comes after the track drew backlash for allegedly inappropriate lyrics.Explaining her side
2 hours ago
Watch: Dad's moonwalk in chappals gets 17 million views, internet says 'MJ is clapping happily in his grave'A father's surprise moonwalk in chappals during his daughter's dance video has gone viral, crossing 17 million views in a day. Published on: Mar 18
2 hours ago
Mumbai woman paying ₹1.2 lakh rent for Andheri West flat says she's a 'stay at home daughter', internet reactsA self-described “stay-at-home daughter” says she pays ₹1.2 lakh rent. Her viral video has sparked a discussion online. Published on: Mar 18
2 hours ago
Fitness coach recommends walking after heavy meals, shares key benefits for digestion and overall healthEnsure you walk after every meal, that way your blood sugar stays stable, along with improved weight management. Published on: Mar 18, 2026 5:58 PM IST By Adrija Dey Share via Copy link After
2 hours ago
In the video, the father can be seen holding his old phone, its screen damaged, with a rubber band around it, and worn out from years of use. Despite its condition, he appears to have continued using it. The son surprises him with a new smartphone
2 hours ago
Uttarakhand resident Deepak Kumar has moved the High Court challenging the case against him and requesting a departmental inquiry against police officers who allegedly failed to act against hate crimes, The Indian Express reported on Wednesday. Kumar and another person booked in the matter
2 hours ago
Waaree Energies Limited is the new Title Sponsor for Rajasthan Royals in the upcoming Indian Premier League. Their branding will be on the team's kits. This partnership aims to promote clean energy across India. Limited has joined as the Title Sponsor for the upcoming (IPL)
2 hours ago
Senegal say the "fight is far from over" after the Confederation of African Football stripped them of the 2025 Africa Cup of Nations title and awarded it to Morocco. Senegal beat Morocco 1-0 in January's final but Caf overturned the result because Senegal's players walked off the pitch in protest
2 hours ago
Two-time MLA Rampada Jamatia takes over as Tripura assembly speakerJamatia is the second indigenous leader to hold the Tripura assembly speaker’s post after Left Front veteran Sudhanya Debbarma in 1978 Published on: Mar 18, 2026 5:52 PM IST By Priyanka Deb Barman
2 hours ago
