Shivam Sharma from Nagaula, a small village in Khair tehsil of Aligarh district, has achieved a remarkable milestone. He has brought pride to his family, village, and region by becoming a lieutenant in the Indian Army. Shivam Sharma has successfully completed a year of intensive military training
The Enforcement Directorate (ED) on Monday carried out raids at multiple locations in Chhattisgarh in a money laundering case related to alleged irregularities in the payment of land acquisition compensation for a Bharatmala project road between Raipur and Visakhapatnam
A new political alliance has formed in Nepal ahead of the March elections. Rapper-turned-mayor Balen Shah has joined forces with former TV host Rabi Lamichhane's Rastriya Swatantra Party. This partnership aims to challenge the long-standing dominance of older political parties
Setting up a new Android phone often feels exciting, but it is also easy to miss a few important features that can significantly improve daily use. Many of Android's most helpful tools are not switched on by default, leaving users unaware of what their devices can really do
Do you eat breakfast cereals or other high-carb breakfasts? It may seem like a staple and convenient option, just pour in milk and cereals and eat. But this handy option may not be healthy for your blood sugar levels. Since breakfast is vital
Australia backs experience for T20 World Cup 2026 as Pat Cummins and Josh Hazlewood near squad selection despite injury concerns, with Tim David also under fitness watch. Australia's approach to the ICC Men's T20 World Cup 2026 is clear and deliberate. Back proven match-winners
You spot an iPhone deal that fits your budget, the phone appears to be in good condition, and the seller promises it works well. Before you pay, there is one detail that can tell you the phone's real story in seconds - the first letter of its model number
A devastating fire at a nursing home in Manado, North Sulawesi, Indonesia, has claimed the lives of at least 16 elderly residents, with three others sustaining burn injuries. Firefighters responded to the blaze Sunday evening, finding many victims in their rooms
Toxic air, broken roads and unpicked rubbish - why India's big cities are becoming unliveable
Toxic air, broken roads and unpicked rubbish - why India's big cities are becoming unliveable
"Want the royal charm of Jaipur? Don't come here, just buy a postcard," a local taxi driver quipped during my recent visit to the north-western Indian city.
I had asked him why Rajasthan's amber-hued capital - thriving with tourists drawn to its opulent palaces and majestic forts - looked so ramshackle.
His answer reflected a resigned hopelessness about the urban decay that plagues not just Jaipur but many Indian cities: choked with traffic, shrouded in foul air, littered with heaps of uncleared rubbish, and indifferent to the remnants of their glorious heritage.
In Jaipur, you will find the most sublime examples of centuries-old architecture defaced by tobacco stains and jostling for space with a car mechanic's workshop.
This raises a question: why are Indian cities becoming increasingly unliveable, even as hundreds of billions are spent on a national facelift?
India's rapid growth, despite high tariffs, weak private spending, and stagnant manufacturing, has been driven largely by the Modi government's focus on state-funded infrastructure upgrades.
Over the past few years, India has built shiny airports, multi-lane national highways and metro train networks. And yet, many of its cities rank at the bottom of liveability indexes. Over the past year, frustrations have reached a boiling point.
In Bengaluru - often called India's Silicon Valley for its many IT companies and start-up headquarters - there were public outbursts from citizens and billionaire entrepreneurs alike, fed up with its traffic snarls and garbage piles.
In Mumbai, the financial capital, citizens staged a rare protest against worsening pothole problem, as clogged sewage lines dumped garbage onto flooded roads during the extended monsoon.
In Delhi's annual winter of discontent, toxic smog left children and the elderly gasping, with doctors advising some to leave the city. Even footballer Lionel Messi's visit this month was overshadowed by fans chanting against the capital's poor air quality.
So why, unlike China during its boom years, isn't India's blazing GDP growth leading to a regeneration of its decrepit cities?
For instance, why is Mumbai - which publicly harboured dreams of becoming another Shanghai in the 1990s - unable to realise that ambition?
"The root cause is historical - our cities don't have a credible governance model," Vinayak Chatterjee, a veteran infrastructure expert, told the BBC.
"When India's constitution was written, it spoke of the devolution of power to the central and state governments - but it did not imagine that our cities would grow to become so massive that they would need a separate governance structure," he says.
The World Bank estimates that over half a billion Indians, or nearly 40% of the country's population, now live in urban areas - a staggering rise from 1960 when merely 70 million Indians lived in cities.
An attempt was made in 1992 to "finally allow cities to take charge of their own destinies" through the 74th amendment of the Constitution. Local bodies were granted constitutional status and urban governance was decentralised - but many of the provisions have never been fully implemented, says Mr Chatterjee.
Vested interests don't allow bureaucrats and the higher levels of government to devolve power and empower local bodies.
This is quite unlike China where city mayors wield substantial executive powers controlling urban planning, infrastructure and even investment approvals.
China follows a highly centralised planning model, but local governments have freedom of implementation and are centrally monitored, with rewards and penalties, says Ramanath Jha, Distinguished Fellow at the Observer Research Foundation think tank.
"There are strong national mandates in terms of direction and physical targets that cities are tasked to achieve," Mr Jha writes.
Mayors of China's major cities have powerful patrons in the Communist Party's top committee and strong performance incentives, making these posts "important stepping stones for further promotions", according to Brookings Institution.
"How many names of mayors of major Indian cities do we even know?" asks Mr Chatterjee.
Ankur Bisen, author of Wasted, a book about the history of India's sanitation issues, says that mayors and local councils that run Indian cities are "the weakest organs of the state, closest to the citizenry, but tasked with the toughest problems to solve".
They are absolutely emaciated - and have limited powers to raise revenue, appoint people, allocate funds. Instead, it is the chief ministers of the states who act like super mayors and call the shots.
There have been exceptional cases - like Surat city after the plague in the 1990s, or Indore in Madhya Pradesh state - where bureaucrats, empowered by the political class, have made transformative changes.
"But these were exceptions to the rule - relying on individual brilliance rather than a system that will function even after the bureaucrat is long gone," says Mr Bisen.
Beyond fractured governance, India faces deeper challenges. Its last census, over 15 years ago, recorded 30% urban population. Informally, nearly half the country is now thought to have taken on an urban character, with the next census delayed until 2026.
"But how do you even begin to solve a problem if you don't have data on the extent and nature of urbanisation?" asks Mr Bisen.
The data vacuum, and the non-implementation of the frameworks to transform Indian cities, well-articulated in the 74th constitutional amendment, reflect a weakening of India's grassroots democracy, experts say.
"It is strange that there is no outcry about our cities, like there was against corruption a few years ago," said Mr Chatterjee.
India will have to go through a natural "cycle of realisation", says Mr Bisen, giving the example of the Great Stink in London in 1858 which prompted the government to construct a new sewerage system for the city and marked the end of significant cholera outbreaks.
It's usually [during] events like these when things reach a boiling point, that issues gain political currency.
Follow BBC News India on Instagram, YouTube, X and Facebook.
Source: BBC
Related Posts: How India’s oil basket has changed over the years Bangladesh sidesteps India's concerns over Hindu minorities after lynching case Dhaka rejects India's remarks over hostilities against minorities in Bangladesh Is Gautam Gambhir's future as India head coach on the line Which Countries India Lends To The year the crusade to define India as a Hindu rashtra intensified India, Russia And China Team Up RBI Gold Accumulation Lifts India’s Forex Reserves By $4 From iPhone Air to Galaxy Z tri-fold Dense Smog Engulfs Delhi As Air Quality Nears ‘Severe’
The Congress party has accused the "double-engine government" of opening up real estate development in Rajasthan's Aravallis, claiming it will further devastate the ecosystem. This move, they allege, is being made against the Forest Survey of India's recommendations
1 minutes ago
Hindustan Copper Share Price: Hindustan Copper shares extended their strong December rally, attracting heightened trader and investor interest. The stock jumped as much as 14.8% in early trade on Monday to touch a fresh lifetime high of Rs 545.95, compared with its previous close of Rs 475.45
1 minutes ago
The Delhi government is considering raising the maximum age limit for the exam. Consequently, the exams scheduled for March have been postponed until the changes are finalised. Education Minister Ashish Sood has issued an order regarding the same
1 minutes ago
Andhra Pradesh CM Revanth Reddy highlighted Sonia Gandhi's role in elevating leaders like P.V. Narasimha Rao and Manmohan Singh to Prime Minister, emphasizing the Congress's contribution to modern India. This statement follows Digvijaya Singh's remarks on RSS/BJP organizational strength and his
1 minutes ago
A simple act of kindness aboard an Etihad flight has struck a chord with social media users, after a woman shared a touching video of a cabin crew member lovingly caring for her toddler during the journey. Divya, who posted the clip on Instagram
1 minutes ago
Former England cricketer Monty Panesar believes Ravi Shastri could lead England's cricket team to success. Shastri's proven track record in building winning units, especially against Australia, makes him a strong candidate. Panesar highlighted India's Border-Gavaskar Trophy wins under Shastri's
1 minutes ago
In a thoughtful move to tackle plastic pollution, Ooty has introduced water ATMs across the city. The initiative aims to cut down the excessive use of single-use plastic bottles, especially among tourists who visit the town in large numbers throughout the year. Much like conventional ATMs
1 minutes ago
China will on January 1 launch an "action plan" for boosting management and operations of its digital currency, a deputy governor of the country's central bank said Monday."The future digital yuan will be a modern digital payment and circulation means issued and circulated within the financial
1 minutes ago
Former Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Digvijaya Singh met Rahul Gandhi in person at the Congress headquarters, Indira Bhavan, on Sunday during the party's Foundation Day celebrations. Their brief exchange soon became a talking point within party circles
1 minutes ago
Ashes 2025-26 Boxing Day Test ended in two days as bowlers dominated at the MCG, with Ravichandran Ashwin praising the thriller-like contest and urging adaptability over pitch criticism. The fourth Test of the Ashes 2025-26 at the Melbourne Cricket Ground will be remembered less for towering
1 minutes ago
Political analyst and former Bigg Boss contestant Tehseen Poonawalla has strongly come out in support of Salman Khan after the actor faced online trolling over a brief smile seen in the teaser of his upcoming film Battle of Galwan. A section of social media users questioned whether the expression
1 minutes ago
Andhra Pradesh Train Tragedy: Two coaches of the Tatanagar-Ernakulam Express caught fire near Elamanchili in Anakapalli early Monday. Meanwhile, one passenger reportedly died in the incident. The deceased was identified as Chandrasekhar Sundar (70), a resident of Vijayawada
1 minutes ago
India has two spots in the AFC Champions League Two -- one in group stage for ISL Shield winners and another in playoff round for Super Cup winners. The All India Football Federation (AIFF) is waiting for a response from the continental body regarding whether Indian Super League (ISL) clubs will
1 minutes ago
The combined market valuation of seven of the top-ten most valued firms declined by ₹35,439.36 crore in a holiday-shortened last week, with State Bank of India (SBI) taking the biggest hit, in line with a muted trend in equities. Last week, the BSE benchmark climbed to 112.09 points or 0
1 minutes ago
All India Mobile Retailers Association (AIMRA) expects a further 10–15% hike in smartphone prices in 2026, which has already gone up by 10% due to rising memory component prices coupled with USD-INR fluctuation, and has created an unsustainable cost environment for manufacturers
1 minutes ago
During the festive season, the residents of the Sarojini Nagar Assembly constituency in Lucknow received a very special gift. BJP MLA Rajeshwar Singh booked an entire cinema hall at Phoenix United Mall for a special screening of Aditya Dhar-directed Dhurandhar. The film
1 minutes ago
Former Indian Premier League (IPL) chairman Lalit Modi offered "deepest apologies" to the Indian government for a video showing him partying with fugitive businessman Vijay Mallya in London and introducing themselves as the “biggest fugitives of India
1 minutes ago
Apple's product roadmap for 2026 is shaping up to be one of its most ambitious in years. While 2025 focused on refining existing lines with fresh designs and powerful silicon, the coming year looks set to introduce genuinely new form factors and long-anticipated upgrades across multiple categories
1 minutes ago
Team India will play a 3-match ODI series against New Zealand, starting on 11 January. The ODI series will be followed by 5 T20Is as preparation for the 2026 T20 World Cup. The ODI team, under Shubman Gill's captaincy, will reportedly have a major change
1 minutes ago
Pakistani international kabaddi player, Ubaidullah Rajput, has been banned indefinitely by the national federation after he appeared for an Indian team in a private tournament in Bahrain earlier this month (December, 2025). Also Read I Pakistani kabbadi player faces disciplinary action for
1 minutes ago
You tear open the plastic, lift the lid, and slide the earbuds into your ears. For many people, that is where the AirPods Pro experience stops. But Apple designed these earbuds to do far more than play songs or take calls. A few minutes in the settings can turn them into tools that adjust to your
1 minutes ago
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Sunday raised concerns over the misuse of antibiotics in his Mann Ki Baat radio address, warning that consumption without medical supervision is making these life-saving drugs ineffective and even dangerous, particularly in illnesses such as pneumonia and urinary
2 minutes ago
Women who regularly work night shifts or experience frequent time-zone changes may be putting their health at risk without realising it. A new study reveals that disrupted sleep cycles can weaken immune defences and accelerate aggressive breast cancer development
1 minutes ago
A senior management executive in a pharma company based in Delhi was forced to resign due to rising air pollution in the capital, leading to health issues. Even though many readers wonder if the above news is correct due to its rarity, they should know that this actually happened
2 minutes ago
Mumbai's Aqua Line, also known as Metro Line 3, is now fully operational after the final stretch opened in October 2025. Running underground from Cuffe Parade to Aarey Colony, it is the city's first metro line to be completely below the surface
2 minutes ago
China is holding military drills around Taiwan simulating the seizure and blockade of the island's key areas, as a warning against "separatist forces". The army, navy, air force and rocket force have been dispatched for the drills which include live-fire exercises, the Chinese military said
2 minutes ago
U.S. President Donald Trump said Sunday (December 28, 2025) that a deal was closer than ever to end Russia's invasion of Ukraine but reported no apparent breakthrough on the flashpoint issue of territory after new talks with the warring countries' leaders.U.S
2 minutes ago
