Newly installed charging station in Manali turns into garbage dump within hoursA newly installed charging station quickly became a trash dumping point in Manali, sparking a wider conversation online about civic sense and public amenities Updated on: May 04
Our study looked at teens’ social media behaviour in 43 countries – those from disadvantaged backgrounds face greater harmsOur study looked at teens’ social media behaviour in 43 countries – those from disadvantaged backgrounds face greater harms Published on: May 04
Actor-turned-politician Vijay’s Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam (TVK) has dramatically altered Tamil Nadu’s political arithmetic, surging into pole position in the 2026 assembly election trends and sparking intense speculation over the state’s post-result alliance possibilities
India’s is seeing a revival as geopolitical tensions and volatility in Dubai’s property market push investors away. Assembly Elections 2026 Markets such as Goa, Alibaug, the hill regions of Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand, and holiday destinations in southern India are witnessing increased
“I am over the moon excited about ,” said ’s outgoing chief executive officer (CEO) during the company’s second quarter earnings call, which runs from January to March. Assembly Elections 2026 “There are a lot of people moving into the middle class there
From defeats to three wins: Samir Kumar Jana’s Patharpratima storySamir Kumar Jana is a three-time MLA from Patharpratima constituency in West Bengal, representing the Trinamool Congress. Published on: May 04, 2026 11:26 AM IST By HT News Desk Share via Copy link Indian politician Samir Kumar
Film sets across Tamil cinema saw an unexpected pause this weekend, leaving crews waiting and projects suddenly on hold. On May 2, the Tamil Film Producers Council (TFPC) called for a token strike, bringing shooting schedules to a halt for several ongoing films
After losing some momentum in March due to the West Asia conflict, growth across India's private sector expanded at a quicker rate at the start of the new fiscal year in April, with survey data indicating a quicker upturn for manufacturers and improvement in both new orders and production
“Might not a bomb no bigger than an orange be found to possess a secret power to destroy a whole block of buildings—nay, to concentrate the force of a thousand tons of cordite and blast a township at a stroke?” So asked Winston Churchill in September 1924. Twenty-one years later he got something of an answer, as the U.S. bombed Japan, instantly killing as many as 70,000 people in Hiroshima on Aug. 6, 1945, and 40,000 in Nagasaki three days later.
“Might not a bomb no bigger than an orange be found to possess a secret power to destroy a whole block of buildings—nay, to concentrate the force of a thousand tons of cordite and blast a township at a stroke?” So asked Winston Churchill in September 1924. Twenty-one years later he got something of an answer, as the U.S. bombed Japan, instantly killing as many as 70,000 people in Hiroshima on Aug. 6, 1945, and 40,000 in Nagasaki three days later.
In the 80 years since, the world has debated whether President Harry Truman and Prime Minister Churchill were morally right to use the weapons against civilians, even if the direct result was to end the most terrible war in human history. The two men are regularly accused of being war criminals.
They certainly had no qualms. As Churchill recalled in the sixth volume of his World War II memoirs, “Triumph and Tragedy” (1953), the decision “was never even an issue.” “There was unanimous, automatic, unquestioned agreement around our table; nor did I ever hear the slightest suggestion that we should do otherwise.”
It is remarkable, moreover, how little Christian morality and the concept of a just war were invoked on either side of the debate. Such issues seem not to have entered the conscious thinking of the major Allied participants. The reason, it's easy to assume, is that they were so thoroughly Christianized that they hardly needed to invoke Augustine and Aquinas in their deliberations. A similar grouping in a pagan society wouldn't have bothered asking about civilian casualties at all—as for example Iran's leaders, intent on destroying Israel, don't bother to do today.
In the postwar world, however, some have argued that Japan was about to surrender and that it was therefore morally wrong to deploy this most destructive of weapons.
Yet Japan was preparing for a fanatical defense of its home islands once its empire was conquered. In his own memoirs, “Year of Decisions,” Truman wrote that he believed an invasion of Japan would have cost half a million American lives. Secretary of War Henry L. Stimson and Secretary of State James Byrnes judged that to be conservative, with both estimating the total casualties at one million. Such figures are supported by the U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff, whose August 1944 study reported that it would “cost half a million American lives and many more that number in wounded.” Even as late as July 1945, the Allies were suffering 7,000 casualties a week fighting the Japanese.
In addition to kamikaze pilots, the Japanese were planning to use flying bombs, suicide attack boats, midget suicide submarines and navy swimmers trained to be human mines, all of which had been used in battle at Okinawa and the Philippines. The U.S. 10th Army had taken nearly three months to capture Okinawa, and it cost the American ground forces 7,343 lives. Another 31,807 had been wounded and 239 were missing. Further, 36 ships were sunk and 368 were damaged, 763 aircraft were lost, 4,907 seamen were killed and another 4,824 were wounded. The Japanese meanwhile lost some 110,000.
With U.S. attrition rates that high for an outlying island, it is safe to assume that the invasion of the sacred Japanese mainland would have been far heavier. The assault on Iwo Jima in the Bonin Islands had killed nearly 7,000 U.S. Marines and wounded 20,000. On June 8, 1945, the Japanese government had pledged to Emperor Hirohito that “the nation would fight to the bitter end,” and Prime Minister Kantaro Suzuki supported the army's plan to carry this out, calling it “the way of the warrior and the path of the patriot.”
Even after several square miles of central Nagasaki were destroyed by the second bomb, army chief Yoshijiro Umezu concluded that Japan still had the “ability to deal a smashing blow to the enemy” and that “it would be inexcusable to surrender unconditionally.” The chief of the naval staff wrote: “We do not believe it possible that we will be defeated.” It took the emperor to state, in his Imperial Rescript on Aug. 14, that “the enemy has begun to employ a new and most cruel bomb, the power of which to do damage is indeed incalculable, taking the toll of many innocent lives.”
Some critics have argued that the U.S. should have demonstrated the awesome power of the weapons in some uninhabited region of the world. Yet the Allies only had two bombs, with several months before the next ones came into production. No number of scientists and other observers would have persuaded the hard men of the Japanese general staff, either. It took both devastated cities to convince the politicians and emperor.
Since Japan also had plans to kill Allied prisoners of war as the fighting approached the camps where they were being held, its swift surrender saved tens of thousands of American and British lives, military and civilian. Crucially, the bombs also saved hundreds of thousands of Japanese lives, because even more Japanese had died in the bombing of Tokyo than in the blast at either Hiroshima or Nagasaki. The Allied navies would have continued their blockade too, leading to mass starvation.
It took a brave former president of the Japanese Medical Association to state that “when one considers the possibility that the Japanese military would have sacrificed the entire nation if it were not for the atomic bomb attack, then this bomb might be described as having saved Japan.”
Mr. Roberts, a member of the House of Lords, is author of “Churchill: Walking With Destiny.”
Get 360° coverage—from daily headlines
to 100 year archives.
Source: HindustanTimes
Related Posts: What Weapons Does Qatar Possess 80-Year-Old WW2 Bomb Found In West Bengal Village Mumbai Police arrests Ashwin Kumar Supra over Ganesh Visarjan bomb scare Pakistan faces economic "inflation bomb" as fuel prices surge 20% Two DU colleges receive bomb threats Bomb blast kills 15 near political rally in Pakistan Delhi Serial Bomb Blasts 28 schools in Ahmedabad and Vadodara receive bomb threats Bengaluru airport gets bomb threat NIA arrests two in Villianur bomb blast case
Disclaimer: This column is merely a guiding voice and provides advice and suggestions on education and careers. The writer is a practising counsellor and a trainer. Send your questions to eduplus.thehindu@gmail.com with the subject line Off the EdgeDisclaimer: This column is merely a guiding voice
1 hours ago
Iran has received a US response to its latest peace proposal, Iranian state-linked media have said. Iran's foreign ministry spokesperson said the response, delivered via Pakistan, was now being reviewed, according to Tasnim news agency. The US is yet to formally confirm it has replied to Tehran
1 hours ago
A trial beginning in New Mexico on Monday could prompt a judge to order sweeping changes to how , Instagram and WhatsApp operate - a move Platforms has warned could force it to withdraw from the state. Assembly Elections 2026 The case, which will be tried before a judge in Santa Fe
1 hours ago
Tamil Nadu Elections 2026 Live News: The counting of votes is currently underway in all 234 Assembly constituencies of Tamil Nadu. Preliminary data indicates a tight competition between the DMK-led alliance and the AIADMK-led NDA. Meanwhile, Vijay's Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam is emerging as a
1 hours ago
A slower heart rate is often associated with good cardiovascular fitness. However, as Dr. Naveen Bhamri, MD (Medicine), DM (Cardiology), and Vice Chairman of Interventional Cardiology, Max Super Speciality Hospital, New Delhi, explains, “A low resting pulse can reflect endurance and efficiency
1 hours ago
A commanding 2-0 win over Parma sealed their third Serie A title in six seasons, sparking wild celebrations at the San Siro and across the city. The moment Inter secured their 21st Scudetto! 🙌 pic.twitter.com/I2pUCn7paN— Football on TNT Sports (@footballontnt) May 3
1 hours ago
Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri’s upcoming visit to Nepal came under shadow on Sunday (May 3, 2026) with Nepal expressing “concerns” to both India and China regarding the next season of Kailash Manasarovar Yatra through the Kalapani-Limpiyadhura-Lipulekh region reiterating that the region is
1 hours ago
They are still there. There is no evading the simple fact. Everywhere the people walk. Wherever they drive. Whenever they switch on the television. The faces of assassinated leaders, and those of new rulers, dominate the public space. Protests have come and gone. A war. Then a ceasefire
1 hours ago
Rajya Sabha MP Sandeep Pathak, who recently resigned from the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) and joined the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), responded to the Punjab police filing two FIRs against him on charges of corruption and harassment. The police action came after Pathak, a key AAP strategist
1 hours ago
As the Israel-Lebanon war continues, Hezbollah has chosen to use fibre-optic drones to get a high-resolution view of the target without emitting any signal that could be jammed. The drones are “immune to communication jamming, and in the absence of an electronic signature
1 hours ago
Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma was leading in the Jalukbari constituency in early trends, as the counting of votes in the 2026 Assam Assembly elections was underway on Monday. After two rounds of counting, Sarma, the Bharatiya Janata Party’s candidate
1 hours ago
Two security staff members have been arrested for thrashing a tribal man at the Nigahi coal handling plant of the Northern Coalfields Ltd (NCL) in Singrauli district in Madhya Pradesh, a day after a video of the assault went viral on the Internet, police said on Sunday (May 3, 2026)
1 hours ago
The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has taken an early lead and has crossed 92 seats in West Bengal, while Mamata Banerjee-led Trinamool Congress is leading on over 52 seats, as per trends the Election Commission of India. The saffron party has crossed half way mark of 148 seats as per early trends
1 hours ago
West Bengal: Election 2026 Analysis Takeaways: West Bengal’s early assembly election trends show a sharp political shift, with the BJP taking a clear lead over the ruling Trinamool Congress (TMC) in initial counting rounds. Early television trends indicate BJP has crossed the 150-seat mark in the
1 hours ago
United Airlines jet with 231 passengers and crew escapes a major disaster in New JerseyA United Airlines flight with 231 onboard narrowly avoided disaster as a landing wheel struck a lamppost and truck in New Jersey. Published on: May 04, 2026 10:58 AM IST AFP | By HT News Desk Share via Copy link
1 hours ago
Markets start May strong: NIFTY 50 tops 24,000; BSE Sensex gains 300 points amid voting results of 5 statesThe domestic stock markets began the month of May on a positive note as investors tracked state election results and global developments. Published on: May 04
1 hours ago
If you grew up during the wild west of Web 1.0, grab a tissue. Ask.com—the search engine formerly known as Ask Jeeves—has officially shuttered its search business as of May 1, 2026. After 30 years of trying to answer our most bizarre natural-language queries
1 hours ago
As Spain eyes a greener future, the Almaraz nuclear plant stands at a crossroads. Set for closure by 2028, the facility's fate is now up in the air due to recent energy shortages that have ignited intense discussions. Almaraz: In the western Spanish village of Almaraz
1 hours ago
Patrick Mahomes injury update: Positive news as Chiefs QB prepares for OTAs this monthKansas City Chiefs QB Patrick Mahomes may join OTAs this month after knee surgery in December. Updated on: May 04, 2026 10:16 AM IST Edited by HT Global Sports Desk Share via Copy link After a knee surgery in
1 hours ago
Canada’s intelligence agency has declared Khalistani extremists a “national security threat”, adding that the group uses institutions to promote its “violent extremist agenda” in the country. Canadian Security Intelligence Service, in its 2025 Public Report
1 hours ago
Didn't think I deserved to be in Hollywood: Jon M ChuDidn't think I deserved to be in Hollywood: Jon M Chu May 4, 2026, 11:15:09 IST PTI Share via Copy link London, Filmmaker Jon M Chu says he didn't think he deserved to be in Hollywood until his film "Crazy Rich Asians" turned out to be a hit
1 hours ago
'What is wrong with propaganda films': Javed Akhtar defends films 'propagating ideas', admits he loved DhurandharJaved Akhtar has defended 'propaganda' movies, saying everyone has a right to tell their story. The writer also praised Aditya Dhar's Dhurandhar. May 4, 2026
1 hours ago
If there were still doubters, Kimi Antonelli just silenced them… emphatically. At just 19, the Mercedes prodigy stormed to his third consecutive Grand Prix win at the Miami Grand Prix, continuing a start to the season that’s gone from promising to downright historic.If there were still doubters
1 hours ago
The family behind the South Korean corporate giant Samsung has completed its payment of a 12 trillion won (£6bn; $8bn) inheritance tax bill, the largest such settlement in the country's history. Chairman Lee Jae-yong and other members of the family
1 hours ago
GSEB HSC Result 2026: Gujarat Board Class 12 results declared for Science, General streams at gseb.org, direct link hereGSEB HSC Result 2026 has been declared. The direct link to check Gujarat Board Class 12 results is given here. Updated on: May 04
1 hours ago
‘Virat Kohli, bruh, you might need to call me’: Cricket-crazy Speed tries to reach out to the Indian legendThe popular gamer hit the bull’s eye and immediately launched an impassioned appeal to Virat Kohli. Updated on: May 04, 2026 11:01 AM IST Written by Prateek Srivastava Share via Copy
1 hours ago
NCLAT rejects Vedanta plea, clears Adani bid for Jaiprakash AssociatesNCLAT chairperson justice Ashok Bhushan and technical member Barun Mitra held that there was no merit in the appeals filed by Vedanta. Published on: May 04, 2026 11:02 AM IST By Ayesha Arvind Share via Copy link The National
1 hours ago
