When the story of Harish Rana captured the collective prayers of an entire nation, people paused, empathised, and watched the Supreme Court judgement unfold as it passed a historic decision allowing passive euthanasia for Rana, who was in a vegetative state for over 13 years
Oil prices rose above $110 (£82.78) a barrel after Iranian media reported an airstrike hitting a facility on the world's largest natural gas field. The Brent crude oil benchmark hit $112 a barrel in early Thursday trade in Asia, more than 5% higher than Tuesday's prices
US Vice President JD Vance and Energy Secretary Chris Wright will meet with oil industry leaders. The administration plans to announce measures to lower gas prices. These include releasing oil from emergency reserves and easing shipping regulations
Milk has long been a cornerstone of Indian diets, simple, familiar, and deeply rooted in tradition. But in urban India, that narrative is rapidly evolving. Today’s consumers are no longer satisfied with just a glass of milk; they are seeking products that align with their fast-paced lifestyles
On March 14, the Narendra Modi government announced that it had decided to end Ladakhi climate activist Sonam Wangchuk’s detention under the National Security Act – nearly six months after his arrest. The Union home ministry is not known to have made such a concession for any detainee held
SC says 1947 Act repeal no bar to defining ‘industry’
SC says 1947 Act repeal no bar to defining ‘industry’
SC says 1947 Act repeal no bar to defining ‘industry’
The Supreme Court ruled that the repeal of the Industrial Disputes Act won't change how "industry" is defined, impacting ongoing disputes in courts.
Published on: Mar 19, 2026 7:46 AM IST By Abraham Thomas, New Delhi Share via Copy link A Supreme Court constitution bench on Wednesday said that the repeal of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, in February this year will not affect how “industry” is defined under the law, as its interpretation will remain central to deciding pending industrial dispute pending across courts. SC says 1947 Act repeal no bar to defining ‘industry’ The nine-judge bench which is examining the correctness of a 1978 ruling that gave an expansive definition to the term, said: “There is no question of the repeal (of the Act) coming in our way….Our interpretation of the Act will apply to cases which have arisen under the Industrial Disputes Act (IDA). They are still pending in various courts and we are re-defining that.” The court was hearing arguments for and against the 1978 judgment in Bangalore Water Supply case which said that section 2(j) of the 1947 Act should be worker-oriented and should include all industrial activities, including hospitals, universities, clubs and charitable institutions. Hearing trade unions and workers supporting the judgment and urging the court to dismiss the present reference for reconsideration of the 48-year old ruling, the bench headed by Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant said, “If we find that the 1978 judgment laid down the correct law, then this question will not arise. It is only if we find there is something wrong in that judgment, then the doctrine of prospectivity has to be applied. We have applied it in hundreds of cases.” Senior advocate CU Singh representing federation of trade unions said that on February 2 this year, the 1947 Act was repealed under section 104 of the Industrial Relations Code, which has come into effect from November 2025. He raised a concern that following the 1978 decision, cases of workmen and labourers were decided as per this 48-year old judgment. “The consequence of any interpretation by the court at this stage will set the clock back in cases where evidence was led and judgments rendered. The doctrine of prospectivity cannot apply to repealed statutes except revenue statutes.” The bench, also comprising justices BV Nagarathna, PS Narasimha, Dipankar Datta, Ujjal Bhuyan, SC Sharma, Joymalya Bagchi, Alok Aradhe and Vipul M Pancholi, said, “We have taken note that the labourers and workers have got hopes, reliefs and benefits for decades and we should not take it away.” Senior advocate Indira Jaising who also argued in favour of sustaining the 1978 judgment said that it is strange that state governments, hospitals, state universities, temples have sought review of the Bangalore Water Supply judgment with no private entity having approached the court. She said that the judgment gives a broad definition of industry to all activities which necessarily involved an employer-employee relationship while carving out certain exceptions. She said that on one hand, the Centre represented by Attorney General R Venkataramani argued against giving a broad definition to the term industry as held in 1978, while the new definition of industry adopts more or less what was laid down by the same judgment. She insisted the court should seek data from states on the cases pending before industrial tribunals to know what are the nature and scope of these disputes and which establishments, whether public or private, does it involve. Jasing said that while the new Code enforced in 2025 is not under challenge yet, the court may be required to hold whether charitable institutions can be brought within the fold of industry as they have been excluded specifically under the Code along with social, philanthropic institutions, which have not been defined in the Code. The bench told Jaising that the 1978 judgment was meant to be a “stop gap exposition” as they anticipated a legislative response, which has now come after 50 odd years. “We are not looking at the definition of industry under the new Act at all as this would mean we are commenting upon it. This, however, does not prevent us from interpreting the Bangalore Water Supply judgment in the light of today’s perspective. We are only examining whether the judgment was correctly decided in the context of the definition under the 1947 Act and not the 2025 law.” Further, the court clarified that it will not entertain arguments on whether the reference to the nine-judge bench to determine the correctness of the 1978 judgment was rightly done and asked lawyers opposing such a reference to argue on merits. CJI Kant said, “Since nine of us are sitting, we are hopeful that we will do some meaningful job.” As of now, two nine-judge bench matters and 21 seven-judge bench matters are pending in the top court. He said, “As CJI, my endeavour is to see all cases are heard on the question of law. It is because of these large bench cases, matters have been pending in the high courts and district courts.” The court posted the matter for further hearing on Thursday hoping to conclude arguments and reserve judgments after hearing arguments from other stakeholders and the amicus curiae appointed by the court -- senior advocates JP Cama and PS Sengupta. The outcome of the case could significantly reshape the scope of labour protections under industrial law. A narrower definition of “industry” would exclude a wide range of institutions and government-linked bodies from industrial dispute mechanisms, while reaffirming the earlier ruling would retain the broad sweep of labour adjudication into non-commercial sectors. Supreme Court Check India news real-time updates, latest news from India, latest at HindustanTime News / India News / SC Says 1947 Act Repeal No Bar To Defining ‘industry’ See LessA Supreme Court constitution bench on Wednesday said that the repeal of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947, in February this year will not affect how “industry” is defined under the law, as its interpretation will remain central to deciding pending industrial dispute pending across courts.
The nine-judge bench which is examining the correctness of a 1978 ruling that gave an expansive definition to the term, said: “There is no question of the repeal (of the Act) coming in our way….Our interpretation of the Act will apply to cases which have arisen under the Industrial Disputes Act (IDA). They are still pending in various courts and we are re-defining that.”
The court was hearing arguments for and against the 1978 judgment in Bangalore Water Supply case which said that section 2(j) of the 1947 Act should be worker-oriented and should include all industrial activities, including hospitals, universities, clubs and charitable institutions.
Hearing trade unions and workers supporting the judgment and urging the court to dismiss the present reference for reconsideration of the 48-year old ruling, the bench headed by Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant said, “If we find that the 1978 judgment laid down the correct law, then this question will not arise. It is only if we find there is something wrong in that judgment, then the doctrine of prospectivity has to be applied. We have applied it in hundreds of cases.”
Senior advocate CU Singh representing federation of trade unions said that on February 2 this year, the 1947 Act was repealed under section 104 of the Industrial Relations Code, which has come into effect from November 2025. He raised a concern that following the 1978 decision, cases of workmen and labourers were decided as per this 48-year old judgment. “The consequence of any interpretation by the court at this stage will set the clock back in cases where evidence was led and judgments rendered. The doctrine of prospectivity cannot apply to repealed statutes except revenue statutes.”
The bench, also comprising justices BV Nagarathna, PS Narasimha, Dipankar Datta, Ujjal Bhuyan, SC Sharma, Joymalya Bagchi, Alok Aradhe and Vipul M Pancholi, said, “We have taken note that the labourers and workers have got hopes, reliefs and benefits for decades and we should not take it away.”
Senior advocate Indira Jaising who also argued in favour of sustaining the 1978 judgment said that it is strange that state governments, hospitals, state universities, temples have sought review of the Bangalore Water Supply judgment with no private entity having approached the court. She said that the judgment gives a broad definition of industry to all activities which necessarily involved an employer-employee relationship while carving out certain exceptions. She said that on one hand, the Centre represented by Attorney General R Venkataramani argued against giving a broad definition to the term industry as held in 1978, while the new definition of industry adopts more or less what was laid down by the same judgment.
She insisted the court should seek data from states on the cases pending before industrial tribunals to know what are the nature and scope of these disputes and which establishments, whether public or private, does it involve.
Jasing said that while the new Code enforced in 2025 is not under challenge yet, the court may be required to hold whether charitable institutions can be brought within the fold of industry as they have been excluded specifically under the Code along with social, philanthropic institutions, which have not been defined in the Code.
The bench told Jaising that the 1978 judgment was meant to be a “stop gap exposition” as they anticipated a legislative response, which has now come after 50 odd years. “We are not looking at the definition of industry under the new Act at all as this would mean we are commenting upon it. This, however, does not prevent us from interpreting the Bangalore Water Supply judgment in the light of today’s perspective. We are only examining whether the judgment was correctly decided in the context of the definition under the 1947 Act and not the 2025 law.”
Further, the court clarified that it will not entertain arguments on whether the reference to the nine-judge bench to determine the correctness of the 1978 judgment was rightly done and asked lawyers opposing such a reference to argue on merits.
CJI Kant said, “Since nine of us are sitting, we are hopeful that we will do some meaningful job.” As of now, two nine-judge bench matters and 21 seven-judge bench matters are pending in the top court. He said, “As CJI, my endeavour is to see all cases are heard on the question of law. It is because of these large bench cases, matters have been pending in the high courts and district courts.”
The court posted the matter for further hearing on Thursday hoping to conclude arguments and reserve judgments after hearing arguments from other stakeholders and the amicus curiae appointed by the court -- senior advocates JP Cama and PS Sengupta.
The outcome of the case could significantly reshape the scope of labour protections under industrial law. A narrower definition of “industry” would exclude a wide range of institutions and government-linked bodies from industrial dispute mechanisms, while reaffirming the earlier ruling would retain the broad sweep of labour adjudication into non-commercial sectors.
Source: HindustanTimes
Related Posts: Uttarakhand clears bill to repeal Madrasa Act Uttarakhand passes bill to repeal Madrasa Act Revealed ! How Sachin Proved To Be An Inspiration For Shafali's Defining Knock Russell heads into what could be defining year Defining moment for law on passive euthanasia in India Canelo v Crawford - the defining battle for legacy A defining moment India’s Free HPV Vaccination Rollout Marks A Defining Moment In Cervical Cancer Prevention Why Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella Sees 2026 As A Defining Year For AI Govt to repeal MGNREGA
What had long been a well-known reality of Indian football — one that fans had pointed out for years, often to no avail due to the ineptitude of the AIFF — was once again thrown into the spotlight. Former Bengaluru FC stalwart Erik Paartalu opened up about his life in India
Just now
Lionel Messi smashes Cristiano Ronaldo record with fastest 900 goals, but Inter Miami crash out in brutal twist Updated on: Mar 19, 2026 7:58 AM IST Written by Aratrick Mondal Share via Copy link Inter Miami forward Lionel Messi walks to kick a corner kick in heavy rain during the first half of a
Just now
India’s environment ministry notified the new solid waste management rules of 2026 on January 27, superseding the 2016 rules. The new rules signal a shift towards a more systematic compliance architecture, with a clearer outline of duties for waste generators
Just now
The sun shone brightly across Liverpool on Wednesday and, come the evening, Liverpool delivered one of their performances of the season. "It was almost the perfect game for us, but definitely our fans," said Arne Slot, after his side secured a first Champions League quarter-final since 2022 with a
Just now
SC says 1947 Act repeal no bar to defining ‘industry’The Supreme Court ruled that the repeal of the Industrial Disputes Act won't change how "industry" is defined, impacting ongoing disputes in courts. Published on: Mar 19, 2026 7:46 AM IST By Abraham Thomas
Just now
China has long braced for a Gulf oil supply shock - but the Iran war's disruption of a key global shipping route is now putting its resilience to the test. Energy shipments from the Middle East have been at a standstill following Iran's threats to attack vessels that pass through a critical trade
Just now
The Income-tax Act, 2025 will come into force, replacing the Income-tax Act, 1961 that has been in place for over 60 years. Instead of tinkering with tax rates, the government has focused on rewriting the law in a clearer, more structured manner. Over time
Just now
The Donald Trump-led US administration has taken the rare step of preparing a temporary waiver for the Merchant Marine Act of 1920, commonly known as the Jones Act. This move comes as the United States grapples with a historic surge in fuel prices triggered by the escalating conflict between the US
Just now
Players from the Iran women’s national football team have reportedly returned home after a dramatic and politically charged episode during the AFC Women’s Asian Cup. According to Fars News Agency, the squad crossed back into Iran via the Bazargan border
Just now
US Fed holds interest rate steady at 3.5-3.75% despite higher inflationUS Federal Reserve has guided for a single interest rate cut in 2026 as officials took stock of economic impact of Iran war on US economy. Updated on: Mar 18, 2026 11:39 PM IST Reuters Share via Copy link The US Federal Reserve
Just now
Indian man wanted by FBI for defrauding victims in the US: What did Kalpeshkumar Rasikbhai Patel do?The Federal Bureau of Investigation has launched a hunt for an India national named Kalpeshkumar Rasikbhai Patel Published on: Mar 19, 2026 6:20 AM IST By Sanya Jain Share via Copy link The Federal
Just now
Kerala's UDF, led by Congress and IUML, will contest 95 and 27 seats respectively in the upcoming assembly polls. The alliance aims to leverage recent electoral successes and anti-incumbency against the ruling LDF. Nominations close March 23, with voting on April 9 and results on May 4.Kerala's UDF
Just now
Sc tells courts to notify convicts before appointing an amicus curiaeThe Supreme Court mandates notification to convicts before appointing amicus curiae to ensure fairness in appeals and prevent claims of unfair hearings. Published on: Mar 19, 2026 7:50 AM IST By Utkarsh Anand
Just now
The Union Cabinet has approved a ₹33,660-crore scheme to establish 100 plug-and-play industrial parks nationwide, aiming to boost manufacturing and create 15 lakh direct jobs. Additionally, a ₹2,585-crore plan for small hydro power development and a national highway project in Uttar Pradesh
Just now
Aditya Dhar’s Dhurandhar fever continues as the next instalment in the franchise, Dhurandhar: The Revenge, was released on Wednesday evening. Many queued up to watch the film on the first day itself, including Allu Arjun, who then took to X to share his review of the film. Now
Just now
The Delhi High Court has halted legal proceedings against Bina Modi, chairperson of Godfrey Phillips India, and others. This action follows a complaint by former executive director Samir Modi alleging assault. Samir Modi claims he was physically attacked by his mother's security officer
Just now
La Liga champions Barcelona moved into the quarterfinals of the UEFA Champions League with a commanding 7-2 win over Newcastle in the second leg of their Round of 16 at the Nou Camp on Wednesday. Robert Lewandowski and Raphinha netted a brace each, while Lamine Yamal
Just now
The hugely popular Labubu dolls will soon star in their own feature film, Chinese toy company Pop Mart and Sony Pictures have announced. A Labubu movie that will combine live action and computer-generated animation is in "early development", the two companies said in a statement
Just now
Obstructing demolition at hotel: Ex-MP Rinku, former MLAs Angural, Beri among 24 bookedThe Jalandhar MC on Tuesday evening demolished a portion of the hotel owned by Chopra Hotels Private Limited, an entity associated with the Punjab Kesari group Published on: Mar 19
Just now
Love Horoscope March 19, 2026: A thoughtful Gesture Could Brighten Your DayDaily Love Horoscope for Feb 1, 2026: Explore relationship insights and emotional guidance for all sun signs today. Published on: Mar 19, 2026 6:02 AM IST By Neeraj Dhankher Share via Copy link Aries: Today
Just now
Atanu Chakraborty resigns as HDFC Bank's part-time chairman due to ‘ethical concerns’Keki Mistry, who serves on the HDFC Bank board, is taking charge as interim part-time chairman immediately, for a period of three months. Updated on: Mar 19
Just now
The Artesh, officially the Islamic Republic of Iran Army, is the conventional military of Iran, separate from the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC). While the IRGC focuses on safeguarding the ideological system, the Artesh is tasked with defending Iran’s territorial integrity and borders
Just now
Prem Chopra recalls why he couldn't attend weddings, family functions without scaring female guests: Dad had to explain…Prem Chopra also said that Amitabh Bachchan's son-in-law Nikhil Nanda once got petrified and refused to enter his grandaunt's home for this reason. Mar 19, 2026
Just now
Just a day after resigning from Congress, Assam Lok Sabha MP Pradyut Bordoloi on Wednesday joined the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in the presence of Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma and state BJP president Dilip Saikia. The development came after Bordoloi on Tuesday tendered his
Just now
The Union government directed airlines to allocate a minimum of 60% of the seats on every flight without selection charges to ensure fair access. Airlines are also required to seat passengers travelling on the same Passenger Name Record together “preferably in adjacent seats”
Just now
Humour and science fiction may not seem obvious bedfellows but a history of cinema will tell you different. Think Spaceballs, Mars Attacks! and Everything Everwhere All At Once to name but a few. And now Ryan Gosling is hopping on board. The 45-year-old is both the lead actor and producer of
Just now
Even as the 8th Pay Commission (8th CPC) has extended the deadline to submit responses to its 18-question document related to pay, allowances and other job-related conditions of central government employees, Indian Railways Technical Supervisors’ Association (IRTSA) wants more elements to be
Just now
