<h4 class=
Latest News

Newly installed charging station in Manali turns into garbage dump within hoursA newly installed charging station quickly became a trash dumping point in Manali, sparking a wider conversation online about civic sense and public amenities Updated on: May 04

Our study looked at teens’ social media behaviour in 43 countries – those from disadvantaged backgrounds face greater harms
World

Our study looked at teens’ social media behaviour in 43 countries – those from disadvantaged backgrounds face greater harmsOur study looked at teens’ social media behaviour in 43 countries – those from disadvantaged backgrounds face greater harms Published on: May 04

Actor-turned-politician Vijay’s Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam (TVK) has dramatically altered Tamil Nadu’s political arithmetic, surging into pole position in
Latest News

Actor-turned-politician Vijay’s Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam (TVK) has dramatically altered Tamil Nadu’s political arithmetic, surging into pole position in the 2026 assembly election trends and sparking intense speculation over the state’s post-result alliance possibilities

India’s is seeing a revival as geopolitical tensions and volatility in Dubai’s property market push investors away.<br> Assembly Elections 2026
World

India’s is seeing a revival as geopolitical tensions and volatility in Dubai’s property market push investors away. Assembly Elections 2026 Markets such as Goa, Alibaug, the hill regions of Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand, and holiday destinations in southern India are witnessing increased

“I am over the moon excited about ,” said ’s outgoing chief executive officer (CEO) during the company’s second quarter earnings call
Technology

“I am over the moon excited about ,” said ’s outgoing chief executive officer (CEO) during the company’s second quarter earnings call, which runs from January to March. Assembly Elections 2026 “There are a lot of people moving into the middle class there

<h4 class=
Latest News

From defeats to three wins: Samir Kumar Jana’s Patharpratima storySamir Kumar Jana is a three-time MLA from Patharpratima constituency in West Bengal, representing the Trinamool Congress. Published on: May 04, 2026 11:26 AM IST By HT News Desk Share via Copy link Indian politician Samir Kumar

Film sets across Tamil cinema saw an unexpected pause this weekend, leaving crews waiting and projects suddenly on hold. On May 2
Latest News

Film sets across Tamil cinema saw an unexpected pause this weekend, leaving crews waiting and projects suddenly on hold. On May 2, the Tamil Film Producers Council (TFPC) called for a token strike, bringing shooting schedules to a halt for several ongoing films

After losing some momentum in March due to the West Asia conflict, growth across India's private sector expanded at a quicker rate at the start of the new
Latest News

After losing some momentum in March due to the West Asia conflict, growth across India's private sector expanded at a quicker rate at the start of the new fiscal year in April, with survey data indicating a quicker upturn for manufacturers and improvement in both new orders and production

New Delhi, The Supreme Court on Friday deleted its observations criticising Allahabad High Court judge Prashant Kumar for allowing criminal proceedings in a civil dispute case, making it clear that its intention was not embarrass or cast aspersions on him.

Posted By: Preeti Dabar Posted On: Aug 30, 2025Share Article
New Delhi, The Supreme Court on Friday deleted its observations criticising Allahabad High Court judge Prashant Kumar for allowing criminal proceedings in a civil dispute case, making it clear that its intention was not embarrass or cast aspersions on him.

New Delhi, The Supreme Court on Friday deleted its observations criticising Allahabad High Court judge Prashant Kumar for allowing criminal proceedings in a civil dispute case, making it clear that its intention was not embarrass or cast aspersions on him.

On August 4, A bench of Justice J B Pardiwala and R Mahadevan observed it was expected of the high court to know the well-settled position of law that in cases of civil disputes a complainant cannot be permitted to resort to criminal proceedings as the same would amount to abuse of process of the law.

"We request the the Chief Justice of the High Court of Allahabad to assign this matter to any other Judge of the High Court as he may deem fit. The Chief Justice of High Court shall immediately withdraw the present criminal determination from the concerned Judge. The Chief Justice shall make the concerned judge sit in a Division Bench with a seasoned senior judge of the High Court ," the top court order said.

The bench on Friday said the observations were meant to ensure the dignity of the judiciary was maintained.

"We reiterate, whatever we said in our order was to ensure that the dignity and the authority of the judiciary as a whole is maintained high in the minds of the people of this country. It is not just a matter of error or mistake by the judge concerned in appreciating the legal points or facts. We were concerned about the appropriate direction to be issued in the interest of justice and to protect the honour and dignity of the institution," the bench said.

The bench clarified it was not its intention to cause embarrassment or cast aspersions on the judge concerned.

"We would not even think of doing so. However, when the matters cross a threshold and the dignity of the institution is imperilled, it becomes the constitutional responsibility of this court to intervene even when acting under its appellate jurisdiction under Article 136 of the Constitution," the top court said.

The bench explained it was deleting the observations after a request was made by Chief Justice B R Gavai to reconsider the matter.

"We have received an undated letter from the Chief Justice of India requesting the reconsideration of the observations... In such circumstances, we directed the Registry to re-notify the main matter for considering the request made by the Chief Justice of India," the bench said.

The top court further noted high courts were not "separate islands" that could be disassociated from this institution.

Acknowledging the high court chief justice was the master of the roster, the top court left it to him to take call in the matter.

"We fully acknowledge that the Chief Justice of a High Court is the master of the roster. The directions are absolutely not interfering with the administrative power of the Chief Justice of the High Court. When matters raise institutional concerns affecting the rule of law, this court may be compelled to step in and take corrective step," the order added.

The apex court further hoped not to come across such "perverse and unjust" order from any high court.

"The endeavour of the high court should always be to uphold the rule of law and to maintain institutional credibility. If the rule of law is not maintained or protected within the court itself, then that would be the end of the entire justice system of the country," the bench said.

The order underlined the responsibilities of judges who were expected to work "efficiently, discharge their duties diligently and always try and endeavour to fulfil their constituional oath".

On August 4, the same top court bench stripped criminal matters of the roster of the Allahabad High Court judge till he demitted office after observing he "erroneously" upheld summons of criminal nature in a civil dispute.

A group of judges of the Allahabad High Court wrote to Chief Justice Arun Bhansali urging him to convene a full court meeting in response to the Supreme Court's unprecedented order.

The letter was written by Justice Arindam Sinha and seven judges signed the letter.

In its order, the top court made strong observations against Justice Kumar's judicial reasoning and further directed the high court administration to remove him from the criminal roster.

It further directed for him to be assigned a division bench alongside a senior judge until his retirement.

The high court judge had refused to quash a magistrate's summoning order against a company which was accused of not paying the balance monetary sum in a business transaction of civil nature.

He said asking the complainant to pursue civil remedy for recovering the amount was unreasonable being time intensive.

Calling the high court judge's order "erroneous", the top court, which was hearing a challenge against it, said the judge went ahead to the extent of saying the complainant should be permitted to institute criminal proceedings for the purpose of recovery of the balance amount.

The top court said the high court order was one of the "worst and most erroneous" orders that it came across in their respective tenures as judges of the top court.

The high court had dismissed an application filed by one M/S Shikhar Chemicals seeking to quash summoning order in a case of commercial transaction.

In the case, the complainant delivered goods in the form of threads to Shikhar Chemicals worth ₹52.34 lakh of which an amount of ₹47.75 lakh came to be paid, however, the balance amount has not been paid, till date.

Lalita Textiles filed a criminal complaint for the recovery of the balance amount.

Thereafter, the complainant's statement was recorded and a magisterial court issued summons against the applicant.

The company moved the high court against the order, contending the dispute was purely civil in nature.

The high court, however, rejected the plea. PKS AMK AMK

This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.

Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


<b>Disclaimer: This column is merely a guiding voice and provides advice and suggestions on education and careers. </b> The writer is a practising
Education
You need a strategy

Disclaimer: This column is merely a guiding voice and provides advice and suggestions on education and careers. The writer is a practising counsellor and a trainer. Send your questions to eduplus.thehindu@gmail.com with the subject line Off the EdgeDisclaimer: This column is merely a guiding voice

1 hours ago

Iran has received a US response to its latest peace proposal, Iranian state-linked media have said. Iran's foreign ministry spokesperson said the response
World
Iran says US has responded to its latest peace proposal

Iran has received a US response to its latest peace proposal, Iranian state-linked media have said. Iran's foreign ministry spokesperson said the response, delivered via Pakistan, was now being reviewed, according to Tasnim news agency. The US is yet to formally confirm it has replied to Tehran

1 hours ago

A trial beginning in New Mexico on Monday could prompt a judge to order sweeping changes to how , Instagram and WhatsApp operate - a move Platforms has warned
Technology
Meta faces New Mexico trial that could force changes to Facebook

A trial beginning in New Mexico on Monday could prompt a judge to order sweeping changes to how , Instagram and WhatsApp operate - a move Platforms has warned could force it to withdraw from the state. Assembly Elections 2026 The case, which will be tried before a judge in Santa Fe

1 hours ago

Tamil Nadu Elections 2026 Live News: The counting of votes is currently underway in all 234 Assembly constituencies of Tamil Nadu
Politics
Tamil Nadu Elections 2026 Result News Live

Tamil Nadu Elections 2026 Live News: The counting of votes is currently underway in all 234 Assembly constituencies of Tamil Nadu. Preliminary data indicates a tight competition between the DMK-led alliance and the AIADMK-led NDA. Meanwhile, Vijay's Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam is emerging as a

1 hours ago

A slower heart rate is often associated with good cardiovascular fitness. However, as Dr. Naveen Bhamri, MD (Medicine), DM (Cardiology)
Life Style
Slow Heart Rate

A slower heart rate is often associated with good cardiovascular fitness. However, as Dr. Naveen Bhamri, MD (Medicine), DM (Cardiology), and Vice Chairman of Interventional Cardiology, Max Super Speciality Hospital, New Delhi, explains, “A low resting pulse can reflect endurance and efficiency

1 hours ago

A commanding 2-0 win over Parma sealed their third Serie A title in six seasons, sparking wild celebrations at the San Siro and across the city
Sports
Inter Milan Crowned Serie A Champions As Scudetto Returns To San Siro

A commanding 2-0 win over Parma sealed their third Serie A title in six seasons, sparking wild celebrations at the San Siro and across the city. The moment Inter secured their 21st Scudetto! 🙌 pic.twitter.com/I2pUCn7paN— Football on TNT Sports (@footballontnt) May 3

1 hours ago

Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri’s upcoming visit to Nepal came under shadow on Sunday (May 3, 2026) with Nepal expressing “concerns” to both India and
World
Ahead of Misri’s expected Nepal visit

Foreign Secretary Vikram Misri’s upcoming visit to Nepal came under shadow on Sunday (May 3, 2026) with Nepal expressing “concerns” to both India and China regarding the next season of Kailash Manasarovar Yatra through the Kalapani-Limpiyadhura-Lipulekh region reiterating that the region is

1 hours ago

They are still there. There is no evading the simple fact. Everywhere the people walk. Wherever they drive. Whenever they switch on the television
Latest News
Some Iranians fear the regime is now more entrenched - and ready for revenge

They are still there. There is no evading the simple fact. Everywhere the people walk. Wherever they drive. Whenever they switch on the television. The faces of assassinated leaders, and those of new rulers, dominate the public space. Protests have come and gone. A war. Then a ceasefire

1 hours ago

Rajya Sabha MP Sandeep Pathak, who recently resigned from the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) and joined the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), responded to the Punjab police
Politics
Will Continue To Adhere To My Principles

Rajya Sabha MP Sandeep Pathak, who recently resigned from the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) and joined the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), responded to the Punjab police filing two FIRs against him on charges of corruption and harassment. The police action came after Pathak, a key AAP strategist

1 hours ago

As the Israel-Lebanon war continues, Hezbollah has chosen to use fibre-optic drones to get a high-resolution view of the target without emitting any signal
World
After Russia, Hezbollah Deploys Fibre-Optic Drones Designed To Evade Israeli Detection

As the Israel-Lebanon war continues, Hezbollah has chosen to use fibre-optic drones to get a high-resolution view of the target without emitting any signal that could be jammed. The drones are “immune to communication jamming, and in the absence of an electronic signature

1 hours ago

Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma was leading in the Jalukbari constituency in early trends, as the counting of votes in the 2026 Assam Assembly
Politics
Himanta Biswa Sarma leads in Jalukbari

Assam Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma was leading in the Jalukbari constituency in early trends, as the counting of votes in the 2026 Assam Assembly elections was underway on Monday. After two rounds of counting, Sarma, the Bharatiya Janata Party’s candidate

1 hours ago

Two security staff members have been arrested for thrashing a tribal man at the Nigahi coal handling plant of the Northern Coalfields Ltd (NCL) in Singrauli
Politics
Two security staff members arrested after video shows them assaulting tribal man at Madhya Pradesh coal plant

Two security staff members have been arrested for thrashing a tribal man at the Nigahi coal handling plant of the Northern Coalfields Ltd (NCL) in Singrauli district in Madhya Pradesh, a day after a video of the assault went viral on the Internet, police said on Sunday (May 3, 2026)

1 hours ago

The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has taken an early lead and has crossed 92 seats in West Bengal, while Mamata Banerjee-led Trinamool Congress is leading on
Latest News
First-ever BJP government in Bengal

The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) has taken an early lead and has crossed 92 seats in West Bengal, while Mamata Banerjee-led Trinamool Congress is leading on over 52 seats, as per trends the Election Commission of India. The saffron party has crossed half way mark of 148 seats as per early trends

1 hours ago

West Bengal: Election 2026 Analysis Takeaways: West Bengal’s early assembly election trends show a sharp political shift, with the BJP taking a clear lead
Politics
West Bengal Assembly Elections Results 2026

West Bengal: Election 2026 Analysis Takeaways: West Bengal’s early assembly election trends show a sharp political shift, with the BJP taking a clear lead over the ruling Trinamool Congress (TMC) in initial counting rounds. Early television trends indicate BJP has crossed the 150-seat mark in the

1 hours ago

<h4 class=
World
United Airlines jet with 231 passengers

United Airlines jet with 231 passengers and crew escapes a major disaster in New JerseyA United Airlines flight with 231 onboard narrowly avoided disaster as a landing wheel struck a lamppost and truck in New Jersey. Published on: May 04, 2026 10:58 AM IST AFP | By HT News Desk Share via Copy link

1 hours ago

<h4 class=
Business
Markets start May strong

Markets start May strong: NIFTY 50 tops 24,000; BSE Sensex gains 300 points amid voting results of 5 statesThe domestic stock markets began the month of May on a positive note as investors tracked state election results and global developments. Published on: May 04

1 hours ago

If you grew up during the wild west of Web 1.0, grab a tissue. Ask.com—the search engine formerly known as Ask Jeeves—has officially shuttered its search
Latest News
Ask.com Shuts Down After 30 Years

If you grew up during the wild west of Web 1.0, grab a tissue. Ask.com—the search engine formerly known as Ask Jeeves—has officially shuttered its search business as of May 1, 2026. After 30 years of trying to answer our most bizarre natural-language queries

1 hours ago

As Spain eyes a greener future, the Almaraz nuclear plant stands at a crossroads. Set for closure by 2028, the facility's fate is now up in the air due to
World
Village braces for closure of Spain's largest nuclear plant

As Spain eyes a greener future, the Almaraz nuclear plant stands at a crossroads. Set for closure by 2028, the facility's fate is now up in the air due to recent energy shortages that have ignited intense discussions. Almaraz: In the western Spanish village of Almaraz

1 hours ago

<h4 class=
Sports
Patrick Mahomes injury

Patrick Mahomes injury update: Positive news as Chiefs QB prepares for OTAs this monthKansas City Chiefs QB Patrick Mahomes may join OTAs this month after knee surgery in December. Updated on: May 04, 2026 10:16 AM IST Edited by HT Global Sports Desk Share via Copy link After a knee surgery in

1 hours ago

Canada’s intelligence agency has declared Khalistani extremists a “national security threat”, adding that the group uses institutions to promote its
World
Canada declares Khalistan extremists as ‘national security threat’

Canada’s intelligence agency has declared Khalistani extremists a “national security threat”, adding that the group uses institutions to promote its “violent extremist agenda” in the country. Canadian Security Intelligence Service, in its 2025 Public Report

1 hours ago

<h4 class=
Entertainment
Didn't think I deserved to be in Hollywood

Didn't think I deserved to be in Hollywood: Jon M ChuDidn't think I deserved to be in Hollywood: Jon M Chu May 4, 2026, 11:15:09 IST PTI Share via Copy link London, Filmmaker Jon M Chu says he didn't think he deserved to be in Hollywood until his film "Crazy Rich Asians" turned out to be a hit

1 hours ago

<h4 class=
Entertainment
What is wrong with propaganda films

'What is wrong with propaganda films': Javed Akhtar defends films 'propagating ideas', admits he loved DhurandharJaved Akhtar has defended 'propaganda' movies, saying everyone has a right to tell their story. The writer also praised Aditya Dhar's Dhurandhar. May 4, 2026

1 hours ago

If there were still doubters, Kimi Antonelli just silenced them… emphatically. At just 19, the Mercedes prodigy stormed to his third consecutive Grand Prix
Sports
Antonelli Scripts Unprecedented F1 History With Miami GP Win

If there were still doubters, Kimi Antonelli just silenced them… emphatically. At just 19, the Mercedes prodigy stormed to his third consecutive Grand Prix win at the Miami Grand Prix, continuing a start to the season that’s gone from promising to downright historic.If there were still doubters

1 hours ago

The family behind the South Korean corporate giant Samsung has completed its payment of a 12 trillion won (£6bn; $8bn) inheritance tax bill
World
Samsung family pays off record $8bn inheritance tax bill

The family behind the South Korean corporate giant Samsung has completed its payment of a 12 trillion won (£6bn; $8bn) inheritance tax bill, the largest such settlement in the country's history. Chairman Lee Jae-yong and other members of the family

1 hours ago

<h4 class=
Education
GSEB HSC Result 2026

GSEB HSC Result 2026: Gujarat Board Class 12 results declared for Science, General streams at gseb.org, direct link hereGSEB HSC Result 2026 has been declared. The direct link to check Gujarat Board Class 12 results is given here. Updated on: May 04

1 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Kohli, bruh, you might need to call me

‘Virat Kohli, bruh, you might need to call me’: Cricket-crazy Speed tries to reach out to the Indian legendThe popular gamer hit the bull’s eye and immediately launched an impassioned appeal to Virat Kohli. Updated on: May 04, 2026 11:01 AM IST Written by Prateek Srivastava Share via Copy

1 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
NCLAT rejects Vedanta plea

NCLAT rejects Vedanta plea, clears Adani bid for Jaiprakash AssociatesNCLAT chairperson justice Ashok Bhushan and technical member Barun Mitra held that there was no merit in the appeals filed by Vedanta. Published on: May 04, 2026 11:02 AM IST By Ayesha Arvind Share via Copy link The National

1 hours ago


Sing Up