Patanjali Foods Ltd., Sanofi India Ltd. and Mold‑Tek Technologies Ltd. are among the companies that will be on investor radar this week as they go
Latest News

Patanjali Foods Ltd., Sanofi India Ltd. and Mold‑Tek Technologies Ltd. are among the companies that will be on investor radar this week as they go ex-dividend. CIE Automotive India Ltd. and Sanofi India Ltd. will go ex‑dividend on April 22. CIE Automotive has announced a final dividend of Rs 7

<h4 class=
Sports

Dolphins HC's bold Micah Parsons prediction in focus amid uncertain ACL injury return timelineMicah Parsons prepares for a 2026 return with the Packers, as Jeff Hafley predicts a record-breaking sack season after his ACL injury comeback. Published on: Apr 20

<h4 class=
Sports

Brock Lesnar fuels retirement speculation after leaving gear in the ring post-loss to Oba Femi at WrestleMania 42Brock Lesnar left his gloves and wrestling boots inside the ring after losing to Oba Femi at WrestleMania 42. Updated on: Apr 20

Months ahead of the launch of the iPhone 18 Pro Max, rumours about Apple's flagship show no signs of slowing down. While Apple continues to stay mum on the
Technology

Months ahead of the launch of the iPhone 18 Pro Max, rumours about Apple's flagship show no signs of slowing down. While Apple continues to stay mum on the official presence or the features of the iPhone 18 Pro Max, leaks have given us a good hint of what upgrades to expect from the Apple flagship

The Enforcement Directorate on Sunday conducted searches at premises linked to Kolkata Police Deputy Commissioner Shantanu Sinha Biswas and a businessman in
Politics

The Enforcement Directorate on Sunday conducted searches at premises linked to Kolkata Police Deputy Commissioner Shantanu Sinha Biswas and a businessman in connection with a money laundering investigation in West Bengal, PTI quoted unidentified officials as saying

Questions pile up at Celtic but only some are for Nancy

Posted By: Anita Mamgai Posted On: Dec 18, 2025Share Article
Questions pile up at Celtic but only some are for Nancy
Media caption, Highlights: Dundee United 2-1 Celtic

At this point, it's not just Wilfried Nancy's Celtic team that's a hard watch, it's Nancy himself.

So many explanations and justifications, so many verbal contortions as he attempts to talk through his latest defeat. It's become painful, quickly.

"I think I am in a good direction with the players," he said after his fourth defeat in a row in his new job, a 2-1 loss at struggling Dundee United.

Today you saw we had a good performance," he stated. "We are improving," he insisted. "We were close to winning... keep the faith.

All around him now there are football atheists. There really can't be many believers left. As Nancy spoke, it was hard to avoid wincing and wincing and wincing again.

As he made his way through his post-match assessment, the temptation was to shout, 'Stop... stop talking... stop explaining because when you're explaining, you're losing, again'.

The bottom line in all of this is that between his nightmarish beginning with Celtic and his low-key ending with Columbus Crew, Nancy has won just three of his past 16 games as a manager.

The defeats by United, St Mirren, Roma and Hearts now joined the ones that went before in America - Cincinnati (twice), Chicago Fire, New York City and New England Revolution.

Nancy finished seventh in the regular season in MLS, won 14 of 34 games, ranking joint sixth in the league for goals scored and eighth for goals conceded. After being manager of the season the year before, it was all very blah.

His credentials for the Celtic job were, at best, thin, despite the excited rhetoric of some observers in America, who painted him as a special one and his capture as a coup.

There are questions here. Many of them. Is he already doomed? If not, how long has he got? Celtic host Aberdeen on Sunday. Can he survive if he loses again? How many is too many? Five? Six? Seven?

And, given his humdrum season with Columbus Crew, how did Nancy get this job in the first place? Arguably, that's the biggest question of all. He'd been a manager at Montreal and Columbus for a total of four years - then he's given the Celtic job?

We have been aware of Wilfried and his quality of work for some time," said Michael Nicholson, Celtic's chief executive. "He was our number one candidate when we began the process of appointing a new manager…

What, exactly, was that process? Who else did Celtic talk to? How rigorous was their search? We don't know. The number one candidate?

What we do know is that Nancy had Kwame Ampadu as his assistant in Columbus and that Ampadu and Celtic's director of football operations, Paul Tisdale, worked together at Exeter City more than a dozen years ago.

On the back of a CV that shows spells at Bath, Exeter, MK Dons, Bristol Rovers, Colchester United and Stevenage, Tisdale has become a very significant figure at Celtic, one of the most influential characters in the place.

How? Again, we're in the dark. Tisdale does not do interviews so there has been no chance to ask him anything.

If he suggested to the Celtic board that Nancy was their man, on what basis did he form that conclusion?

How thoroughly were Nancy's credentials interrogated? From this remove - four games played, four games lost, three goals scored and 10 goals conceded - not thoroughly enough.

From there to here was always going to be a mighty leap for Nancy, but nobody knew it was going to be Grand Canyonesque in a footballing sense.

It's understandable that sections of the fans have turned on him - he seems like a good man in the wrong movie, which makes this crash in slow motion all the harder to observe - but what of the people who appointed him?

What of Tisdale? He is as much to blame for the sorry mess that Celtic are in as Nancy is. More so, even.

Tisdale has powerful sway over the recruitment work that Celtic do and yet, in the main, he escapes the heat of the fans who have been fixated on principal shareholder Dermot Desmond and members of the board.

One of that board is leaving soon, of course. Peter Lawwell, a titan of the club for two decades, will depart at the end of the year, citing abuse and threats from a sinister element in the support that have impacted his family.

Lawwell is a big enough operator to take stick on the chin, as he has done for years. When his family are drawn into it then it's another matter entirely.

Celtic are in a dark place right now. Instead of more threats from zealots and incendiary statements from members of the Desmond family, it needs some healing, some understanding and some class.

It needs dignity to break out where now there's just dysfunction. On the pitch and off Wednesday was a grim day for the club.

Nancy must be wondering what the hell he's walked into and it's not hard to have some sympathy for him. He asked for context in the aftermath of Tannadice and, in his defence, there is some. Not a lot, but a little.

It wasn't Nancy's fault that Johnny Kenny missed an easy chance or that Daizen Maeda spurned a sitter.

The blame for having the inexperienced Kenny leading the Celtic line is not on Nancy. It lies with others way above him - the ones who orchestrated the club's slapstick transfer window in the summer.

The new manager is missing key players in Alistair Johnston, Cameron Carter-Vickers and Jota, but there is no evidence that he would get the best out of them even if they weren't injured.

He hasn't got the best out of the players he's had in four games now. Nothing like it. Amid a fog of tactical and selectorial confusion most of them have gone backwards.

Once again, Celtic faded when it became a fight in that second half at Tannadice. Once again, an opponent spotted weakness and exploited it. Once again, Nancy was out-coached.

Nancy talks about performance in the manner of a man who has time. He doesn't. The one unalienable truth about his job is that winning is everything, no matter how it happens.

Martin O'Neill would have spelled that out to him had Nancy spent more than 15 minutes picking the brains of a guy who knows Celtic's past and Celtic's present better than anybody.

It sounds like Nancy passed on the opportunity to mine the interim manager for information, which is incredible given he's a man at a new club in a new league in a new continent.

For how much longer, it's hard to tell. Logic would say that Nancy is already on borrowed time, but logic doesn't seem to be pervasive at the club at the moment.

Strange things are happening on the pitch and off. And at the weekend, Aberdeen are coming, sniffing points and smelling blood. There is no fear factor now.

For the rest, against the diminished champions, opportunity knocks.

Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


Throughout US President Donald Trump's second term in office, traders have been betting millions of dollars just before he makes major announcements
Business
The insider trading suspicions looming over Trump's presidency

Throughout US President Donald Trump's second term in office, traders have been betting millions of dollars just before he makes major announcements. The BBC has examined trade volume data on several financial markets and matched them to some of the president's most significant market-moving

1 minutes ago

Manchester City defeated Arsenal 2-1 in a crucial Premier League match. Erling Haaland scored the winning goal, ending his league goal drought
Sports
Haaland seals crucial win for Man City over Arsenal in title showdown

Manchester City defeated Arsenal 2-1 in a crucial Premier League match. Erling Haaland scored the winning goal, ending his league goal drought. This victory puts City three points behind leaders Arsenal with a game in hand. The win boosts City's title aspirations as they aim to overtake Arsenal in

1 minutes ago

Till a few months ago, he was patrolling Meitei villages near Manipur’s Moirang town. The 43-year-old had taken up arms and joined a cadre of 250 “village
World
We thought peace was coming

Till a few months ago, he was patrolling Meitei villages near Manipur’s Moirang town. The 43-year-old had taken up arms and joined a cadre of 250 “village volunteers” – armed civilians who “defended” their community’s territory as the conflict that erupted in Manipur in May 2023

1 minutes ago

Anthropic abruptly suspended more than 60 Claude AI accounts belonging to Belo, a Latin American fintech app focused on international transfers
Technology
Fintech CTO slams Anthropic over mass Claude suspensions

Anthropic abruptly suspended more than 60 Claude AI accounts belonging to Belo, a Latin American fintech app focused on international transfers, currency exchange, and prepaid cards, on 18 April. Belo CTO Pato Molina pressed the issue in a post on X

1 minutes ago

China has sent a group of warships to hold drills in the western Pacific Ocean, a move that comes as Japan for the first time joins massive exercises with the
Latest News
China Deploys Warships for Pacific Drills as Japan Tensions Rise

China has sent a group of warships to hold drills in the western Pacific Ocean, a move that comes as Japan for the first time joins massive exercises with the US and the Philippines, highlighting growing tensions between Tokyo and Beijing. The Chinese navy dispatched a naval task group led by the

1 minutes ago

A United States delegation will arrive in Pakistan’s Islamabad on Monday for the second round of negotiations with Iran, said US President Donald Trump in a
World
US delegation to visit Pakistan tomorrow for Iran negotiations

A United States delegation will arrive in Pakistan’s Islamabad on Monday for the second round of negotiations with Iran, said US President Donald Trump in a social media post. “We are offering a very fair and reasonable deal, and I hope they take it because, if they do not

1 minutes ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
K’taka CM, DyCM target Centre over women’s quota, delimitation bill

K’taka CM, DyCM target Centre over women’s quota, delimitation billCM Siddaramaiah accused PM Modi of politicizing women's reservation; Shivakumar criticized the bill's lack of consultation. BJP blamed Congress for its defeat. Published on: Apr 20, 2026 7:56 AM IST By Arun Dev

1 minutes ago

North Korea conducted its second ballistic missile test this month, featuring cluster bomb warheads, likely to enhance its ability to penetrate U.S
World
North Korea again tests cluster munitions in a launch observed by Kim Jong Un and his daughter Ju Ae

North Korea conducted its second ballistic missile test this month, featuring cluster bomb warheads, likely to enhance its ability to penetrate U.S. and South Korean defenses. Leader Kim Jong Un oversaw the launch of upgraded Hwasong-11 Ra missiles

1 minutes ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Indian founder turned down $525K job

Indian founder turned down $525K job, Stanford PhD to build $61-million AI startupVarun Vummadi is the co-founder and CEO of Giga, a San Francisco-based startup that builds voice-based AI agents for businesses. Updated on: Apr 20, 2026 6:43 AM IST By Sanya Jain Share via Copy link Y Combinator

1 minutes ago

Bengal's election campaign intensifies as Trinamool leader Abhishek Banerjee directs party workers to reach out to all voters. Cadres are instructed to explain
Politics
TMC ramps up campaign

Bengal's election campaign intensifies as Trinamool leader Abhishek Banerjee directs party workers to reach out to all voters. Cadres are instructed to explain government schemes and development work. They are also told to remain vigilant on polling day, monitor EVMs, and report any intimidation

1 minutes ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Ghost' waiter scares child at Varanasi restaurant

'Ghost' waiter scares child at Varanasi restaurant, viral video sparks outrage: 'Childhood trauma created successfully'A clip from a restaurant has sparked criticism online after a staff member dressed as a ghost was seen approaching diners to scare them. Updated on: Apr 19

1 minutes ago

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee has strongly criticized the BJP. She accused the party of intimidating her political consultancy firm, I-PAC
Politics
Won’t let employees lose jobs

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee has strongly criticized the BJP. She accused the party of intimidating her political consultancy firm, I-PAC. Banerjee also targeted Prime Minister Narendra Modi regarding women's reservation and delimitation

1 minutes ago

Punjab Kings secured a commanding 54-run victory over Lucknow Super Giants. Punjab Kings posted a record 254 runs, driven by exceptional batting performances
Sports
Cooper Connolly

Punjab Kings secured a commanding 54-run victory over Lucknow Super Giants. Punjab Kings posted a record 254 runs, driven by exceptional batting performances. Lucknow Super Giants' chase fell short despite some strong individual efforts. This win propels Punjab Kings to the top of the table

1 minutes ago

Global oil prices jumped in Monday morning trade in Asia after President Donald Trump said the US has intercepted and seized an Iran-flagged cargo ship
Business
Oil prices jump after Trump says Iranian ship seized

Global oil prices jumped in Monday morning trade in Asia after President Donald Trump said the US has intercepted and seized an Iran-flagged cargo ship. It came after Iran said on Saturday that it was closing the Strait of Hormuz waterway again to commercial vessels and that any ship that

1 minutes ago

With one more worker dying during treatment on Sunday, the toll in the blast at a power plant owned by Vedanta Limited in Chhattisgarh’s Sakti district rose
World
Toll in boiler blast at Vedanta power plant rises to 24

With one more worker dying during treatment on Sunday, the toll in the blast at a power plant owned by Vedanta Limited in Chhattisgarh’s Sakti district rose to 24, PTI reported, quoting officials. Eleven other persons are undergoing treatment. Two of them are in critical condition

2 minutes ago

At least 23 workers were killed and six others injured in an explosion at a fireworks factory in Virudhunagar on Sunday, reported The Hindu
Latest News
23 killed, six injured in blast at fireworks factory

At least 23 workers were killed and six others injured in an explosion at a fireworks factory in Virudhunagar on Sunday, reported The Hindu. Searches were being held at the spot amid concerns that additional workers could be trapped as parts of the building collapsed due to the blast

2 minutes ago

<strong>Lucknow-Kanpur Expressway: </strong>The upcoming Lucknow-Kanpur Expressway is set to ease travel between the two major cities in Uttar
Latest News
From hours to just minutes

Lucknow-Kanpur Expressway: The upcoming Lucknow-Kanpur Expressway is set to ease travel between the two major cities in Uttar Pradesh, offering faster and smoother connectivity across a 63 km stretch. Built as a six-lane, access-controlled corridor

2 minutes ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Cong, BJP trade barbs over women’s quota

Chandigarh: Cong, BJP trade barbs over women’s quotaAddressing a press conference at the BJP’s state office in Sector 33, Union minister of state for defence, Sanjay Seth, said the legislation was a “historic step” aimed at ensuring 33% reservation for women in legislatures Published on:

2 minutes ago

Bayern Munich clinched a 35th league title on Sunday by beating Stuttgart at the Allianz Arena - but could this prove to be the most impressive triumph of them
Sports
Record-breaking Bayern win Bundesliga - now for the Treble

Bayern Munich clinched a 35th league title on Sunday by beating Stuttgart at the Allianz Arena - but could this prove to be the most impressive triumph of them all? After nearest challengers Borussia Dortmund fell to defeat at Hoffenheim on Saturday

2 minutes ago

Jesus Christ stands at gunpoint, palms upturned, seven figures in a firing squad around him. The bronze riflemen are unmistakable in their likeness
World
Art on trial - a sculptor's arrest highlights new extremes for censorship in China

Jesus Christ stands at gunpoint, palms upturned, seven figures in a firing squad around him. The bronze riflemen are unmistakable in their likeness. They are Mao Zedong, the long-deceased dictator who founded the People's Republic of China, and presided over some of the most traumatic chapters in

2 minutes ago

<h4 class=
Entertainment
Dhurandhar singer Jasmine Sandlas opens up on alcoholism

Dhurandhar singer Jasmine Sandlas opens up on alcoholism, regrets choices she made: ‘I drank more than I should have’Jasmine Sandlas talked at length about her past and shared that she had a tough childhood, and holds on to some of the resentments. Apr 20, 2026

2 minutes ago

<h4 class=
Entertainment
Ryan Reynolds reacts to Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni's legal battle

Ryan Reynolds reacts to Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni's legal battle: ‘People have no idea what is really going on’Ryan Reynolds stepped forward to support Blake Lively when he was asked how his family was managing amid her high-profile legal battle against Justin Baldoni. Apr 20, 2026

2 minutes ago

The Enforcement Directorate has arrested a Kolkata businessman in a money laundering investigation. The probe targets a criminal syndicate operating in the
World
ED crackdown in Bengal

The Enforcement Directorate has arrested a Kolkata businessman in a money laundering investigation. The probe targets a criminal syndicate operating in the poll-bound state. Searches were conducted at the businessman's residence and that of a Kolkata Police Deputy Commissioner

2 minutes ago

<h4 class=
Horoscope
Love Horoscope Today for April 20

Love Horoscope Today for April 20, 2026: Avoid compromising your values just to maintain peaceLove Horoscope Today: Find daily astrological predictions for all sun signs. Updated on: Apr 20, 2026 7:30 AM IST By Kishori Sud Share via Copy link Aries Horoscope Today Love Energy: Passion with

2 minutes ago

<h4 class=
Technology
Humanoid robots race past humans in Beijing half-marathon

Humanoid robots race past humans in Beijing half-marathon, showing rapid advanceThis year, several robot frontrunners were noticeably faster than professional athletes, beating the human winners by more than 10 minutes. Updated on: Apr 19, 2026 8:21 PM IST Reuters | BEIJING Share via Copy link

2 minutes ago

Israel and Argentina have launched direct flights connecting the two nations. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Argentine President Javier Milei announced
World
For the First Time

Israel and Argentina have launched direct flights connecting the two nations. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Argentine President Javier Milei announced the new route. This initiative aims to deepen economic cooperation, facilitate business, and encourage tourism

2 minutes ago

The Central Bureau of Investigation has apprehended a senior Directorate General of Civil Aviation official and a consultant linked to Reliance Industries
World
CBI arrests DGCA official

The Central Bureau of Investigation has apprehended a senior Directorate General of Civil Aviation official and a consultant linked to Reliance Industries. The arrests stem from an alleged bribery case involving ₹2.5 lakh for drone import approvals

2 minutes ago


Sing Up