<strong>Stock market today:</strong> The Indian stock market posted sharp declines on Wednesday, 23 April, snapping a three-day gaining streak
Latest News

Stock market today: The Indian stock market posted sharp declines on Wednesday, 23 April, snapping a three-day gaining streak. The Sensex plunged 756.84 points, or 0.95%, to close at 78,516.49, while the Nifty 50 dropped 198.50 points, or 0.81%, to settle at 24,378.10

It took just five minutes for chants of
Sports

It took just five minutes for chants of "we are top of the league" to ring out around Turf Moor from the visiting supporters. Manchester City beat Burnley 1-0 to hit the summit of the Premier League for the first time in eight months, when they led the way after thrashing Wolves in the opening week

Rising temperatures can worsen migraines and chronic pain. A neurologist explains how heatwaves affect the nervous system, warning signs to watch
Latest News

Rising temperatures can worsen migraines and chronic pain. A neurologist explains how heatwaves affect the nervous system, warning signs to watch, and how to prevent flare-ups. “As a neurologist, I’ve seen a noticeable rise in patients reporting worsening migraines and chronic pain during

<strong>This article was originally published in Rest of World, which covers technology’s impact outside the West.</strong> The drone strikes on
Technology

This article was originally published in Rest of World, which covers technology’s impact outside the West. The drone strikes on Amazon Web Services data centres in the Persian Gulf, and Iran’s threats to target tech firms for their involvement in US attacks

Congress MP TN Prathapan has moved the Supreme Court against Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s national address on April 18 which was aired by public service
Politics

Congress MP TN Prathapan has moved the Supreme Court against Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s national address on April 18 which was aired by public service broadcaster Doordarshan, Bar and Bench reported on Wednesday. The petition has alleged misuse of government-controlled television channels to

<h4 class=
Latest News

Love Horoscope Today for April 23, 2026: The love life of these zodiacs may improve through cooperation and effortLove Horoscope Today: Find daily astrological predictions for all sun signs. Published on: Apr 23, 2026 7:34 AM IST By Kishori Sud Share via Copy link Aries Love Energy: Honest

<h4 class=
Latest News

Third language papers in SSLC 2026 in Karnataka will be marked, not gradedKarnataka students will receive marks for third language subjects in SSLC exams, following a court ruling against the government's grading policy change. Published on: Apr 23, 2026 7:36 AM IST By Arun Dev

Rajasthan Royals achieved a significant 40-run victory over Lucknow Super Giants. Rajasthan Royals batted first and scored 159 for 6
Sports

Rajasthan Royals achieved a significant 40-run victory over Lucknow Super Giants. Rajasthan Royals batted first and scored 159 for 6. Lucknow Super Giants struggled in their chase and were all out for 119. Jofra Archer was the standout performer with the ball for Rajasthan Royals

Opinion | When AI Platforms Blame Users, Who Is Responsible For The Harm?

Posted By: Hemant Kumar Posted On: Jan 05, 2026Share Article
Opinion | When AI Platforms Blame Users
Grok was marketed as a looser, less restricted chatbot, and fewer guardrails were part of the pitch.

Opinion | When AI Platforms Blame Users, Who Is Responsible For The Harm?

Grok's response to illegal and abusive content points to a larger problem. Artifiicial intelligence (AI) companies want the power of generation without the responsibility that comes with it.

The argument over harmful content online is old. Platforms have long claimed they are not responsible for what appears on their services. That fight has mostly revolved around users. Generative AI breaks that logic. Elon Musk's handling of Grok makes that clear. Over the past few weeks, Musk and X have repeated the same defence.

If Grok produces illegal or abusive content, the fault lies with the user who prompted it, not the system or the company that built it. The claim echoes the logic social media companies once used to avoid responsibility for user posts. That logic does not survive contact with generative AI. AI systems do not merely host speech; they produce it and do so at scale, using data, rules, and limits chosen by the company behind them. Treating that output as if it were ordinary user speech is a convenient fiction.

Grok was marketed as a looser, less restricted chatbot, and fewer guardrails were part of the pitch. When the system began generating content that crossed legal and ethical lines, the response was predictable. The system was not redesigned, the incentives were not questioned, and responsibility was pushed outward. The user became the shield. This approach is not accidental; it allows companies to keep control while avoiding blame. Platforms decide how models are trained, how they respond, and where limits are set.

When harm follows, the person typing the prompt is left holding the bag. That description does not match how these systems actually work. Generative AI relies on probability. Outputs are shaped by training data, model architecture, and product decisions. Users do not control those inputs; suggesting otherwise is misleading.

Most rules governing online speech were written before machines could generate text, images, and instructions on demand. In the United States, Section 230 assumed platforms that hosted content created by people. It did not anticipate systems that actively produce content themselves. That gap now sits at the centre of the AI debate.

When an AI system generates defamatory claims or illegal instructions, responsibility becomes blurred. Is it the prompt that matters most, the data used to train the system, the safeguards that were never added, or the commercial pressure to release products quickly?

Blaming the user answers none of those questions; it simply shuts them down. As regulators struggle to keep pace, companies are deciding these questions on their own. They do so through internal policies that are opaque and unenforceable. Those policies often change only after public backlash.

This lack of accountability does not affect users alone; it creates problems for journalism. Newsrooms now report regularly on AI outputs. They quote them, embed them, and even debate them. When an AI system produces false or harmful material, journalists face a choice. Ignore it and risk missing a story, or report on it and risk spreading the harm.

Attribution is no longer straightforward. When an AI output is quoted, who is the source? Is it the user, the company, or the system itself? Journalistic standards were built around human actors. AI complicates verification, attribution, and responsibility all at once. When platforms refuse to own the output of their systems, journalists are left operating without clear guardrails.

Over time, this normalises a dangerous idea: harmful AI content becomes nobody's problem.

Musk's role sharpens the stakes. X plays an outsized role in political conversation and crisis reporting. Decisions about how Grok operates have consequences far beyond the platform. Avoiding responsibility allows AI companies to move fast. It also allows them to avoid consequences. Power remains concentrated, and liability does not follow.

This imbalance is familiar: media regulation has faced it before. AI brings it back under conditions that are harder to control and easier to exploit.

The issue is not whether users should bear any responsibility; they should. The issue is whether they should bear all of it. So far, regulators have offered little clarity. Laws lag behind deployment, oversight remains reactive, and companies continue to operate in a grey zone that suits them well. Until that changes, platforms will keep drawing the boundaries themselves. Journalists will keep reporting without clear rules.

The Grok controversy is a preview of conflicts that will repeat across platforms and countries.

Swipe Left For Next Video

If companies can deny responsibility for what their systems generate, the consequences will spill into politics, law, and public trust. Decisions about harm and accountability will be made by the same actors who benefit from avoiding both. Those rules are being written now; they are not being written in the public interest.

Views expressed in the above piece are personal and solely those of the author. They do not necessarily reflect News18's views.

Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


NASA has revealed the Roman space telescope. This new instrument will search the universe for planets beyond our solar system. It will also investigate the
Science
NASA unveils new space telescope to give

NASA has revealed the Roman space telescope. This new instrument will search the universe for planets beyond our solar system. It will also investigate the mysteries of dark matter and dark energy. The telescope is set to launch in September

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Education
Final selective edit window closes today at natboard

NEET MDS 2026: Final selective edit window closes today at natboard.edu.inNEET MDS 2026 final selective edit window closes today, April 22. The steps to make changes is given here. Published on: Apr 22, 2026 3:04 PM IST By HT Education Desk | Edited by Papri Chanda Share via Copy link National

3 hours ago

Artificial intelligence (AI) is flattening the jobs market for young people and governments should eliminate National Insurance to make hiring workers more
Business
AI is flattening the jobs market for young people

Artificial intelligence (AI) is flattening the jobs market for young people and governments should eliminate National Insurance to make hiring workers more attractive, former prime minister Rishi Sunak has told the BBC. Sunak, now an adviser to AI firm Anthropic and Microsoft

3 hours ago

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.<h4 class=
Technology
OnePlus Nord 6 vs Nothing 4a Pro

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.OnePlus Nord 6 vs Nothing 4a Pro: Don’t buy before reading this comparisonWhile the OnePlus Nord 6 targets performance hungry gamers

3 hours ago

Voting for Assembly elections in Tamil Nadu and West Bengal Phase 1 is underway. Polling concludes today at 6 PM. Over 5.73 crore voters are participating in
Politics
Assembly Elections

Voting for Assembly elections in Tamil Nadu and West Bengal Phase 1 is underway. Polling concludes today at 6 PM. Over 5.73 crore voters are participating in Tamil Nadu. West Bengal sees a contest between TMC and BJP. By-elections in Gujarat and Maharashtra are also happening

3 hours ago

After months of speculation and delays, officials have announced that the teen girl found in the trunk of singer D4vd's car died from
Life Style
Officials release cause of death for teen found dead in singer D4vd's car

After months of speculation and delays, officials have announced that the teen girl found in the trunk of singer D4vd's car died from "multiple penetrating injuries". The Los Angeles County medical examiner's office on Wednesday announced that they'd ruled Celeste Rivas Hernandez's death a homicide

3 hours ago

India's government has confirmed that Indian ships have not paid any tolls to Iran or other groups for passage through the Strait of Hormuz
World
Amid West Asia crisis

India's government has confirmed that Indian ships have not paid any tolls to Iran or other groups for passage through the Strait of Hormuz. This statement addresses claims about the captain of the Sanmar Herald making a payment. The captain reportedly fell victim to cyber criminals after an

3 hours ago

More than 20 years on from the release of the first The Devil Wears Prada film, the stars reunited on a remarkably sunny evening in London to celebrate the
Life Style
Stars line red carpet at London premiere of Devil Wears Prada 2

More than 20 years on from the release of the first The Devil Wears Prada film, the stars reunited on a remarkably sunny evening in London to celebrate the release of its sequel. The original cast members Meryl Streep, Anne Hathaway, Emily Blunt and Stanley Tucci all reprise their roles in the film

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Business
75% of all new code at Google is AI-generated

75% of all new code at Google is AI-generated, Sundar Pichai saysWe're now shifting to truly agentic workflows, Google CEO Sundar Pichai says in a post on ‘The Keyword’. Published on: Apr 22, 2026 8:54 PM IST By Tushar Deep Singh Share via Copy link Google is doubling down for the agentic era

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Sports
Kane and Diaz send Bayern past Leverkusen into German Cup final

Kane and Diaz send Bayern past Leverkusen into German Cup finalKane and Diaz send Bayern past Leverkusen into German Cup final Published on: Apr 23, 2026 2:46 AM IST AFP Share via Copy link Harry Kane and Luis Diaz scored as Bayern Munich won 2-0 at Bayer Leverkusen on Wednesday to reach the German

3 hours ago

Tesla has expanded the lineup of the Model Y with the introduction of the new L variant. It is a long-wheelbase version of the standard Model Y and gets a
Auto
Tesla Model Y L launched in India at ₹61

Tesla has expanded the lineup of the Model Y with the introduction of the new L variant. It is a long-wheelbase version of the standard Model Y and gets a six-seater configuration. There are also other changes that have been made to the electric vehicle to make it more comfortable

3 hours ago

SoftBank Group is seeking a substantial $10 billion loan. This loan is backed by its shares in ChatGPT-maker OpenAI. The move signals SoftBank's aggressive
World
SoftBank seeks $10 billion margin loan backed by OpenAI shares

SoftBank Group is seeking a substantial $10 billion loan. This loan is backed by its shares in ChatGPT-maker OpenAI. The move signals SoftBank's aggressive push into artificial intelligence. This follows previous significant investments and loans for the AI firm

3 hours ago

Iran war news: The White House states President Donald Trump will decide the West Asia conflict's end. This decision hinges on American national interests
World
President Trump will dictate the timeline

Iran war news: The White House states President Donald Trump will decide the West Asia conflict's end. This decision hinges on American national interests. No fixed timeline exists for the conflict or the Strait of Hormuz blockade. President Trump is satisfied with the ongoing naval blockade

3 hours ago

Jason Holder achieved a record 97 wickets in global T20 cricket last year. He is now with Gujarat Titans in the IPL but yet to play
Sports
Gujarat Titans’ Jason Holder on record 97 wickets in 2025

Jason Holder achieved a record 97 wickets in global T20 cricket last year. He is now with Gujarat Titans in the IPL but yet to play. Holder discusses his T20 success, adapting his game, and managing his body. He emphasizes mental preparation and his role supporting the team from the bench

3 hours ago

New Delhi, Apr 22 (PTI) Commuters trapped inside elevators at Namo Bharat stations may soon get faster assistance, with the NCRTC introducing an AI-powered
Technology
Trapped in an elevator

New Delhi, Apr 22 (PTI) Commuters trapped inside elevators at Namo Bharat stations may soon get faster assistance, with the NCRTC introducing an AI-powered system that can detect entrapment within 60 seconds and trigger an emergency response

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
As mercury soars

As mercury soars, power demand surges past 27,000 mw before peak summer in Uttar PradeshThe state government has planned availability of around 34,000 mw to meet peak requirements, according to a UPPCL spokesman Published on: Apr 23, 2026 7:34 AM IST By Brajendra K Parashar

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Entertainment
Haryanvi actor Divyanka Sirohi dies of heart attack at 29

Haryanvi actor Divyanka Sirohi dies of heart attack at 29, film workers' body expresses shock: ‘Gone far too soon’On Wednesday, it was reported that Divyanka Sirohi died on April 21 at her home in Ghaziabad. However, the cause of her death is not known yet. Apr 23, 2026

3 hours ago

The Suzuki Avenis Special Edition has received a new dual-tone colour option with no change in price or hardware. This matters for buyers looking to buy a new
Latest News
Suzuki Avenis special edition updated in India – check what’s new

The Suzuki Avenis Special Edition has received a new dual-tone colour option with no change in price or hardware. This matters for buyers looking to buy a new scooter because it adds a fresh visual choice in the competitive 125cc scooter segment without increasing ownership cost

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Technology
Asus ExpertBook Ultra laptop launched in India

Asus ExpertBook Ultra laptop launched in India with built-in AI processing capabilitiesAsus has launched the ExpertBook Ultra in India, bringing a business laptop focused on on-device AI and more for professional workflows. Published on: Apr 22

3 hours ago

Less than four months after he signed a five-and-a-half-year deal with </b>Chelsea</b>, Liam Rosenior's stint at Stamford Bridge has come to an
Sports
Respecting the ball

Less than four months after he signed a five-and-a-half-year deal with Chelsea, Liam Rosenior's stint at Stamford Bridge has come to an abrupt end. The 41-year-old replaced Enzo Maresca in January. Ten defeats in 23 matches later, he has gone

3 hours ago

West Bengal politics remains a high-stakes battle between the long-standing dominance of the Trinamool Congress (TMC) under Mamata Banerjee and the rising
Politics
Why BJP has found it hard to break Mamata Banerjee’s bastion

West Bengal politics remains a high-stakes battle between the long-standing dominance of the Trinamool Congress (TMC) under Mamata Banerjee and the rising challenge from the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). Despite BJP’s rapid growth and strong national presence

3 hours ago

Nepal’s Home Minister Sudan Gurung resigned on Wednesday, less than a month after taking charge, following questions about his financial conduct
Latest News
Nepal Home Minister Sudan Gurung resigns after row about financial conduct

Nepal’s Home Minister Sudan Gurung resigned on Wednesday, less than a month after taking charge, following questions about his financial conduct. “I have resigned from the post of home minister, effective from today, to ensure an impartial investigation into matters related to me and to ensure

3 hours ago

It's a sombre gathering in the backstreets of one of China's biggest manufacturing hubs, where workers are smoking under a tree in front of storefronts
World
China weathered Trump's tariffs - but the Iran war is taking a toll

It's a sombre gathering in the backstreets of one of China's biggest manufacturing hubs, where workers are smoking under a tree in front of storefronts advertising temporary factory jobs. "No-one understands what our life is like," says one man who is unwilling to be named

3 hours ago

The Uttar Pradesh Madhyamik Shiksha Parishad (UPMSP) is all set to announce UP Board Class 10 and 12 results 2026 today, 23 April
Education
UP Board 10th

The Uttar Pradesh Madhyamik Shiksha Parishad (UPMSP) is all set to announce UP Board Class 10 and 12 results 2026 today, 23 April. In a press release issued on 22 April, the education board said that the results will be announced in a press conference from Madhyamik Shiksha Parishad office in

3 hours ago

Tesla plans to introduce its humanoid robot, Optimus, to India when the time is right, according to a senior company official. The electric carmaker also
Science
Tesla will bring humanoid robot Optimus to India at appropriate time

Tesla plans to introduce its humanoid robot, Optimus, to India when the time is right, according to a senior company official. The electric carmaker also intends to bring its integrated energy solutions business to the country in the future. This announcement was made during the launch of Tesla's

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Indian student in US considers return after failing to secure permanent job

Indian student in US considers return after failing to secure permanent job: ‘I have a loan to pay off’The student moved to the US less than two years ago for a master’s degree. Published on: Apr 23, 2026 6:49 AM IST By Sakshi Sah Share via Copy link An Indian student in the United States has

3 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
HR rejects candidate for over WFH query

HR rejects candidate for asking about WFH, wants employees with ‘CEO-level attitude’In an Instagram video, a job seeker claimed that her request for Saturday flexibility was met with a lecture on corporate devotion from HR. Published on: Apr 23

3 hours ago


Sing Up