The call to prayer echoes across the neighbourhood as people congregate under the sweeping domes and tall minarets of Ghana’s National Mosque in Accra. For many, it is a place of faith, community and national pride. Yet, few pause to consider that this landmark – now firmly part of Accra’s
PM Modi’s work-from-home appeal has revived the debate over whether hybrid offices can ease Delhi-NCR pollution by reducing traffic, fuel use and daily commutes With two work-from-home appeals within 24 hours, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has reignited the debate around hybrid and remote working
A federal appeals court has put a hold on a ruling that found President Donald Trump's global tariffs unlawful. This means importers will continue to pay the 10% tariffs for now. The court is considering the administration's request to keep collecting the levies while it appeals the decision
Nahid Rana's career-best 5-40 powered Bangladesh to a commanding 104-run victory over Pakistan in the first test. Chasing 268, Pakistan crumbled to 163 all out, with Rana's devastating spell after tea proving decisive. Bangladesh had earlier declared their second innings at 240-9
Sebastian Muñoz-Najar has only just finished primary school. The 13-year-old is still years away from learning how to drive. He cannot legally work. He's too young to even have a social media account. But he's already despairing about his future housing prospects
Modi’s austerity appeals are a misplaced solution for India’s economic woes
Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s seven-point austerity appeal to citizens on Sunday has revived an old question: apart from budgets and policies, can governments steer economies by also shaping public behaviour and collective psychology?
Indians were urged to revive work-from-home practices to reduce fuel consumption, avoid unnecessary foreign travel and destination weddings abroad, postpone gold purchases, use public transport and electric vehicles, reduce edible oil consumption, support locally made products, and adopt farming practices that are less fertiliser-intensive.
There is an obvious economic rationale behind these suggestions. India faces a difficult global environment marked by geopolitical instability in West Asia, volatile crude oil prices, supply-chain disruptions and growing pressures on trade balances and foreign exchange reserves.
Yet these appeals are about more than conservation. They are an attempt to invoke economic patriotism: the idea that citizens can contribute to national economic resilience through voluntary changes in everyday behaviour.
History offers several examples. During the Second World War, Britain introduced rationing in 1940, covering essentials ranging from fuel to food, and sustained many of those controls well into the mid-1950s. In the United States, “Buy American” campaigns intensified during periods of industrial slowdown and external competition, particularly during the 1970s and 1980s.
South Korea, during the Asian financial crisis of 1997-’98, launched its famous national gold collection campaign in which citizens donated jewellery and household gold to help stabilise the country’s foreign exchange reserves.
India itself witnessed the Swadeshi movement during the freedom struggle, where economic choices became political acts tied to national self-reliance.
Governments often turn to behavioral mobilisation during moments of economic uncertainty. But such mobilisation works best when it is accompanied by public confidence, institutional credibility and a sense of shared sacrifice.
While economic patriotism seeks to mobilise sacrifice during difficult times, Keynesian economics reminds us that caution alone falls short. Economies are also sustained by confidence, trust, optimism and the willingness of individuals and businesses to act despite uncertainty.
Economist John Maynard Keynes famously described these psychological impulses as “animal spirits” He used the phrase to describe the emotions, instincts, confidence, fears, and psychological impulses that shape economic behavior.
Contrary to classical economics, which assumed that individuals are largely rational calculators, Keynes argued that investment, spending, and economic decisions are frequently driven by moods, expectations, stories and gut instinct.
Decades later, Nobel laureates George Akerlof and Robert Shiller revived this idea in their influential book, Animal Spirits. They argued that confidence, fairness, trust, corruption, and public narratives are central to understanding how modern capitalist economies function. Economies rise and fall not merely because of fiscal deficits or interest rates, but because collective confidence expands or contracts.
Seen through this lens, Modi’s appeals are psychological interventions to encourage behavioral coordination during a period of uncertainty. But can economic patriotism succeed if the broader climate of confidence and fairness itself appears fragile?
Aside from inflationary concerns, India’s economic climate also faces deeper uncertainties of employment, household purchasing power, private investment and opportunities.
India’s current account deficit widened to nearly $13.2 billion in late 2025, amid US tariffs and the decline in the value of the rupee. At the same time, growth projections, while still relatively strong by global standards, have moderated amid concerns about external demand, global trade fragmentation and geopolitical tensions.
More significantly, Modi’s appeals arrive at a moment when the gap between the rich and poor in India is increasingly stark. Recent inequality assessments suggest that the richest 1% of Indians control more than 40% of the country’s wealth, while the bottom 50% own barely 3%. Oxfam has repeatedly highlighted how wealth concentration has accelerated sharply over the last decade even as large sections continue to struggle with healthcare costs, insecure employment and stagnant incomes.
Behavioral economics repeatedly demonstrates that people cooperate more readily when sacrifices appear fairly distributed. Citizens are often willing to embrace restraint during difficult periods, but participation depends heavily on whether institutions themselves appear prudent, equitable and forward-looking. That is where the present discourse becomes more complicated.
Even before the crisis in West Asia began, there were opportunities to cushion the economic impact on households. Fuel prices have remained elevated despite periods that permitted some relief. Oil marketing companies reported substantial profits during certain phases, only to speak of mounting losses later. Questions naturally arise as to whether earlier interventions could have mitigated some of the present pressures.
Similarly, if the nation is now being called upon to embrace restraint, shouldn’t the austerity also extend to the visibly more affluent sections of society? Appeals to reduce foreign travel, luxury consumption or non-essential imports resonate more strongly when citizens perceive that economic burdens are being shared rather than selectively moralised.
Many of the suggestions are prudent in themselves. But the larger issue is whether behavioral appeals alone can substitute for deeper structural preparedness and credible long-term economic management.
Governments, Keynes believed, must sometimes intervene in markets, but also in moods. Yet such interventions succeed only when confidence itself is nurtured through credible policy action.
India today perhaps requires more than merely appeals for restraint: renewed confidence in economic direction and institutional foresight. Economies cannot conserve their way into optimism. Investment, entrepreneurship, and consumption ultimately depend on whether citizens and businesses feel secure enough about the future to act.
The debate triggered by Modi’s appeals concerns the evolving relationship between citizens, markets, and the state. Increasingly, governments across the world are attempting to convert economic behaviour into civic behaviour, where consumption choices are much more than private decisions but acts that have national consequences.
Modern economies are deeply interconnected, and collective behavioral shifts can indeed influence macroeconomic outcomes. Yet behavioral mobilisation cannot permanently compensate for weak confidence, delayed responses or widening perceptions of inequality.
Keynes understood long ago that economies move in numbers, but also narratives. Governments may legitimately ask citizens for restraint during turbulent times. But enduring economic resilience emerges only when sacrifice is matched by trust, fairness, and confidence in the direction of economic policy itself.
Freddy Thomas teaches Economic Analysis of Law at the School of Law, Christ University, Bengaluru, and writes on the intersection of law, economics and public policy.
Source: Scroll
Related Posts: World Economic Forum economists expect global economic conditions to weaken in 2026 Pune woman says misplaced mouse query drew cat and dog emoji replies Indian professionals cheer PM Modi’s WFH suggestion amid austerity call RSS-affiliate says PM's austerity push will help save India’s foreign reserves Argentina's Milei wins big in midterms with 'chainsaw' austerity Pakistan extends countrywide austerity drive after U Austerity appeal "India is demonstrating highest economic growth rates under PM Modi's leadership" PM Modi, Japan’s new PM Takaichi discuss economic security in warm conversation The Modi myth and the false binary of Hindutva vs economic development
Prateek Yadav, son of Mulayam Singh Yadav and husband of BJP leader Aparna Bisht Yadav, has passed away. He was 38 years old. He was taken to Civil Hospital in Lucknow. Doctors there pronounced him brought dead. The news of his passing has been confirmed. This is a developing story.Prateek Yadav
Just now
Vacations are the time for unplugging from your daily life and focusing on the experiences at hand and not checking your phone constantly to check if that motion alert from your home's CCTV camera was your neighbour's dog or swaying curtains. Yet a lot of home owners
Just now
Sugar-free products with sugar. ‘Real’ juices with artificial ingredients. Misleading food ads are fuelling a public health crisis in India. Help Scroll expose the systemic failure. Support our investigation.Sugar-free products with sugar. ‘Real’ juices with artificial ingredients
Just now
NEET 2026 cancelled over 'paper leak', new date to be notifiedNEET 2026 cancelled: NEET (UG) is the nationwide entrance examination conducted by the NTA for admission in undergraduate medical programmes. Updated on: May 12, 2026 2:42 PM IST By HT Education Desk Share via Copy link The National
Just now
Prime Minister Narendra Modi has appealed to citizens to pause gold buying for a year. Jewellery associations will meet officials of the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) tomorrow, Tuesday, May 12, sources have told CNBC-TV18. It comes after Prime Minister Narendra Modi has appealed to citizens to
Just now
Google lines up premium laptops push, and Android Auto gets a Gemini layerA more premium set of laptops and a refreshed Android Auto iteration, find themselves underlined by Gemini Intelligence Published on: May 12, 2026 10:42 PM IST By Vishal Mathur Share via Copy link It is immediately clear
Just now
Chandigarh: 24-year-old ‘gangraped’, two bookedAccording to the victim, the accused took her to their flat in Amazon City in Kharar where she was confined and raped; raids are being conducted to arrest them, say police Published on: May 13, 2026 7:46 AM IST By HT Correspondent
Just now
Prateek Yadav, Mulayam Singh Yadav's younger son, dies at 38Civil Hospital's director said prima facie the case appeared to involve suspected poisoning, though exact cause would only be clear after autopsy. Updated on: May 13, 2026 7:59 AM IST By HT Correspondent Share via Copy link Prateek Yadav
Just now
Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Why more buyers are ditching ACs and switching to smart ‘Air Coolers’ this summerSmart air coolers now offer app controls, lower power use and easier cooling management
Just now
'Aur kuch chahiye?': Swiggy Instamart makes ‘emergency delivery’ at wedding venue, company responds with witty replyA viral video showed a Swiggy Instamart delivery arriving inside a wedding venue for a last minute ceremony need. Updated on: May 12
Just now
Did Air India cancel international flights till July? Airline issues clarificationAir India issued a clarification after a post went viral claiming the airline had cancelled all its flights till July due to a fuel shortage. Published on: May 13
Just now
Canara Bank has revised its Marginal Cost of Funds Based Lending Rate (MCLR) across all loan tenors. The bank has increased MCLR rates by 5 basis points (bps) for all maturities, as per a BSE filing from the bank. The new Canara Bank MCRLs are effective from May 12, 2026
Just now
A man who broke into a car and stole hard drives containing unreleased music by Beyoncé has been sentenced to two years in prison. Kelvin Evans, 41, pleaded guilty to charges including entering an automobile and criminal trespass last year in Atlanta, Georgia
Just now
Spotify is back online after suffering a major outage that seemingly affected its services for hours. According to the outage-tracking platform Downdetector, outage reports spiked at around 12:26 pm Eastern Time (ET) on 12 May, with over 15,000 complaints registered at the peak of the disruption
Just now
Donald Gibb cause of death: How did Revenge of the Nerds, Bloodsport actor die? All about ongoing health issuesDonald Gibb, known for his roles in Revenge of the Nerds and Bloodsport, died on Tuesday at the age of 71, as per son, Travis. May 13, 2026
Just now
Elon Musk tried to take control of OpenAI, even suggesting it could pass to his children when he dies, Sam Altman said on Tuesday. Altman is co-founder and chief executive of the artificial intelligence (AI) company behind ChatGPT. He is being sued by Musk
Just now
Alia Bhatt questions why Indian cinema still caters largely to men at the box office: ‘What happens to the women?’According to actor Alia Bhatt, storytelling should take centre stage rather than gender, as she believes films ought to be “gender-agnostic.” May 13, 2026
Just now
Amid split, both factions claim to be real AIADMK in Tamil NaduThe crisis within the AIADMK is the latest political drama to roil Tamil Nadu, where Vijay smashed five decades of Dravidian duopoly. Updated on: May 13, 2026 7:47 AM IST By S Vijay Karthik Share via Copy link The All India Anna Dravida
Just now
Centre rolls out $1.5 billion maritime insurance poolThe pool covers all maritime risks such as hull and machinery, cargo and war risks for Indian flagged or controlled vessels or vessels destined to or starting from India. Published on: May 13
Just now
Who is Aliyah Boston’s boyfriend, Tre-Vaughn Minott? What Fever star has said about relationshipAliyah Boston's relationship with boyfriend Tre-Vaughn Minott has been a major topic of discussion among Indiana Fever fans. Published on: May 13
Just now
President Trump stated that Americans' financial struggles are not a factor in his decision-making regarding Iran, emphasizing that preventing Tehran from acquiring a nuclear weapon is his sole priority. This stance comes as rising energy costs linked to the conflict contribute to inflation and
Just now
SAN FRANCISCO (AP) — The American obsession with the iPhone is complicated, as most love-hate relationships are. It sometimes seems like a talisman so magical that we can't fathom living without all the pleasures and conveniences that it bestows almost anytime or anywhere. The iPhone
Just now
Veteran BJP leader Tapas Roy took oath as the pro-tem Speaker of the West Bengal Assembly. Governor R.N. Ravi administered the oath. Roy will oversee the oath ceremony for newly elected legislators. This marks a significant moment for the BJP in the state
Just now
Fifty years old this month, Kraftwerk's single Radioactivity was a groundbreaking track that morphed into the German electronic pioneers' most political protest song. From the tremulous opening seconds of Kraftwerk's Radioactivity – a pulsing Geiger counter; escalating synths; shrill morse code
Just now
A consultation about excessive grappling in the penalty area and how to deal with it will take place at the end of the season, referees' chief Howard Webb says. Webb confirmed the move after explaining why disallowing West Ham's last-ditch equaliser against Arsenal on Sunday was the correct
Just now
Tamil Nadu CM Vijay orders closure of 717 TASMAC liquor shops near temples, schools and bus stands within two weeks, citing public welfare and safety concerns Tamil Nadu Chief Minister Vijay has ordered the closure of 717 TASMAC liquor shops operating near temples
Just now
Steel scrap has become an increasingly strategic resource for countries and their steelmakers as a key input for emissions reductions. India, the world’s second largest steel producer, has set ambitious targets to double the share of scrap use in its total steel output in the coming decades
Just now
