Namo Cruise Delhi update: Delhi’s ‘Namo Cruise’ is set to launch on the Yamuna this May. Experience river tourism between Sonia Vihar and Jagatpur for Rs
Latest News

Namo Cruise Delhi update: Delhi’s ‘Namo Cruise’ is set to launch on the Yamuna this May. Experience river tourism between Sonia Vihar and Jagatpur for Rs 500. Know the latest on timings, booking counters, and future water sports plans. Namo Cruise Delhi update: After rigorous efforts by Delhi

<h4 class=
Latest News

Young woman cricketer, 19, dies by suicide after selection heartbreak in Puducherry trials: ReportA 19-year-old cricketer died by suicide after attending selection trials for the Puducherry T20 women's cricket team. She wasn't named on the final list. Updated on: May 02

Punjab Police is learnt to have booked Rajya Sabha MP Sandeep Pathak, who recently defected to the BJP, sources said on Saturday (May 2, 2026)
Politics

Punjab Police is learnt to have booked Rajya Sabha MP Sandeep Pathak, who recently defected to the BJP, sources said on Saturday (May 2, 2026). Two FIRs have been lodged against Mr. Pathak under non-bailable sections, they said. No further details about the FIRs have been disclosed yet

Seems like ‘The Special One’ is firm on staying put. Benfica boss Jose Mourinho has shut down speculation linking him with a return to Real Madrid
Sports

Seems like ‘The Special One’ is firm on staying put. Benfica boss Jose Mourinho has shut down speculation linking him with a return to Real Madrid, insisting he has had “no contact" with the Spanish giants. Reports had suggested that club president Florentino Perez views Mourinho as a leading

The wellness tourism industry has experienced rapid growth in recent years. India’s wellness offerings too have developed beyond fitness studios
Latest News

The wellness tourism industry has experienced rapid growth in recent years. India’s wellness offerings too have developed beyond fitness studios, luxury retreats and self-care programmes. Now, we are seeing a growth of spiritual travel as a new trend

There’s been plenty of noise around Formula 1 potentially returning to India. Timelines like 2027 have been floated, though they feel optimistic at best
Latest News

There’s been plenty of noise around Formula 1 potentially returning to India. Timelines like 2027 have been floated, though they feel optimistic at best. Still, the conversation refuses to die. Jenson Button is firmly in favour of seeing F1 back in India

The noise was getting louder around the Los Angeles Lakers. Blow a 3-0 lead? Against a depleted Houston Rockets side missing Kevin Durant? It felt unthinkable
Sports

The noise was getting louder around the Los Angeles Lakers. Blow a 3-0 lead? Against a depleted Houston Rockets side missing Kevin Durant? It felt unthinkable, until it didn’t. And then LeBron James stepped in and reminded everyone how these stories usually end

<strong>“</strong>You have to embrace getting older. Life is precious, and when you've lost a lot of people, you realize each day is a gift
Latest News

“You have to embrace getting older. Life is precious, and when you've lost a lot of people, you realize each day is a gift.” — Meryl Streep LiveMint's quote of the day by Meryl Streep carries a profound weight that feels uniquely necessary today.“You have to embrace getting older

If AIFF accepts the proposal for a new agreement in its current form, it could have a lot to answer for, says Dhiman in this issue. As draft documents go, it is heavy on promise for All India Football Federation (AIFF) and clubs in the Indian Super League (ISL). It pitches alignment with global best practices – and that alone should be why AIFF and clubs must go for it – but then gives another reason: compliance with the new draft constitution.

Posted By: Jaydatt Chaudhary Posted On: Aug 31, 2025Share Article
If AIFF accepts the proposal for a new agreement in its current form, it could have a lot to answer for, says Dhiman in this issue. As draft documents go, it is heavy on promise for All India Football Federation (AIFF) and clubs in the Indian Super League (ISL). It pitches alignment with global best practices – and that alone should be why AIFF and clubs must go for it – but then gives another reason: compliance with the new draft constitution.

As draft documents go, it is heavy on promise for All India Football Federation (AIFF) and clubs in the Indian Super League (ISL). It pitches alignment with global best practices — and that alone should be why AIFF and clubs must go for it — but then gives another reason: compliance with the new draft constitution.

So, what's not to like? A lot as it turns out. No promotion and relegation in ISL for the next 10 years for one. Apart from what's-in-it-for-us for I-League clubs, it is not in line with what was proposed and accepted in 2019 by Asia's apex body. And since, as part of the proposal, it is AIFF's responsibility to deal with Asian Football Confederation and FIFA, I am guessing the onus will be on the federation to explain why.

After allowing promotion for two seasons, ISL proposes to be a closed league again, the difference being that this time it will also be India's top tier competition.

The argument that I-League clubs have not helped improve the standard is complicated. True, Mohammedan Sporting hit a new high in abjection and have been beset by financial problems but Punjab FC also qualified through that route and have shown they can compete. In their second season, Punjab FC finished above two teams that have been in ISL way longer.

Ten of the last 15 teams promoted to the Premier League went down the next season but that has not got the world's most watched league to stop relegation. For the second successive Premier League season, all three promoted teams have gone down. Surviving in the top tier is difficult — Nottingham Forest needed 57 signings and some £125m to make an impact — everywhere but how can clubs not be allowed to dream of doing what Ipswich Town (1961-62), Forest (1977-78) and Kaiserslautern (1997-98) did? All three won the top league in the season they were promoted.

And if off-the-field problems worry those who conceived ISL, well, it would be difficult to look beyond what hit Hyderabad FC in 2023-24. Financial problems led to the club being hit with transfer bans and a host of players leaving months after head coach Manolo Marquez did.

Clubs formed with ISL have had protection from relegation for 11 seasons. Granted, it takes time to grow the culture but how much have they done to suggest they are on the right path and would need insulation for another 10 years?

The plan to form a company to run ISL is in line with global best practices and the document lists the Big Five in Europe and the Asian countries doing it. As far as I know, the document or its contents was shared with clubs before being sent to AIFF. And that they had agreed in principle with the proposals. But should five ISL clubs failing the Premier 1 licence test not come in the way of them being co-owners of ISL? More so, because this was hardly the first time ISL clubs flunked licensing tests.

Should NorthEast United, Odisha FC, Hyderabad FC, Kerala Blasters and Mohammedan Sporting therefore be allowed to own a stake in a joint-venture company despite not meeting all the licensing requirements? ISL double winners, Mohun Bagan Super Giant, FC Goa, Mumbai City FC, Bengaluru FC, Jamshedpur FC, Chennayin FC and East Bengal made the grade after paying fines. The only club to have ticked all the boxes? Punjab FC.

While it is indeed best practice to allow clubs to have a say in the running of a competition that is about them, what is not clear is why that company should also get to own rights for national team matches in perpetuity? As per the draft document, national team matches will be the property of a company where AIFF, technically sole guardians of all India teams, has only 14% stake.

The document was sent to AIFF in March. It was read out in the next executive committee meeting but why were copies not circulated? Wouldn't that have given the members a chance to better engage with ideas meant to shape the future of ISL, India teams and AIFF's responsibilities? Also, when it was known to all that the current agreement ends in 2025, why was the conversation over the future of AIFF-FSDL relationship stalled after it began in 2023? It was sub-judice then, it is sub-judice now.

And if AIFF has an answer to Bhaichung Bhutia's question, we are yet to hear it. They went, listened and had pizza, Bhutia said in his latest salvo on AIFF. Accepted in this form, AIFF could have a lot to answer for.

For now, though reports of ISL not happening seem somewhat exaggerated, as are claims that clubs are not working the transfer market, it is likely the 2025-26 season will not start in September. That has hit the Durand Cup. Clubs have pulled out of the world's third oldest tournament because it makes no sense to start pre-seasons as usual when the start of the season is likely to be delayed.

Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


<strong>Kolkata:</strong> On recently, in late February, India’s forex reserves reached an all-time high of $728.49 billion
Business
India’s forex reserves decline $4

Kolkata: On recently, in late February, India’s forex reserves reached an all-time high of $728.49 billion. According to data released by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) on Friday, India’s foreign exchange reserves declined by $4.82 billion to $698.49 billion in the week ending April 24

1 days ago

<strong>This article was originally published in Rest of World, which covers technology’s impact outside the West.</strong> The pandemic’s
Education
Edtech funding collapses after pandemic high

This article was originally published in Rest of World, which covers technology’s impact outside the West. The pandemic’s biggest bet on online learning has gone bust. Global edtech investment peaked at $16.7 billion in 2021, fueled by lockdowns that kept millions of children out of classrooms

1 days ago

Germany faces a potential 15 billion euro output loss due to US President Donald Trump's planned tariff increase on European cars and trucks
World
Trump auto tariff hike could cost Germany nearly $18 billion in output

Germany faces a potential 15 billion euro output loss due to US President Donald Trump's planned tariff increase on European cars and trucks. The Kiel Institute for the World Economy warns of substantial economic impact. This move highlights Germany's automotive sector's vulnerability to US trade

1 days ago

“This haveli is at least a hundred years old, so are the frescos in your room,” the bellman tells me proudly as he opens the low-hung wooden door that
Life Style
Exploring Shekhawati

“This haveli is at least a hundred years old, so are the frescos in your room,” the bellman tells me proudly as he opens the low-hung wooden door that requires you to bow to enter. After five hours on the road from Delhi, I am eager to rest before heading out to explore Churu

1 days ago

Junaid Khan and Sai Pallavi’s film Ek Din was theatrically released on May 1. The romantic drama clashed with Riteish Deshmukh’s historical drama Raja
Latest News
Ek Din Box Office Collection Day 1

Junaid Khan and Sai Pallavi’s film Ek Din was theatrically released on May 1. The romantic drama clashed with Riteish Deshmukh’s historical drama Raja Shivaji at the box office. Ek Din Box Office Collection: Junaid Khan and Sai Pallavi’s romantic drama opened to mixed reviews upon its

1 days ago

ISRO held technical discussions with Russia's Roscosmos in Moscow for semi-cryogenic engines, crucial for India's heavy-lift launch vehicles
Science
ISRO, Roscosmos discuss delivery of semi-cryogenic engines in Moscow

ISRO held technical discussions with Russia's Roscosmos in Moscow for semi-cryogenic engines, crucial for India's heavy-lift launch vehicles. A draft contract is under approval, potentially accelerating ISRO's indigenous engine development. This collaboration aligns with ISRO's broader

1 days ago

The West Bengal Police has imposed prohibitory orders for 60 days, starting Sunday, in parts of Kolkata’s central business district, PTI reported on Saturday
World
Prohibitory orders imposed in parts of Kolkata for 60 days

The West Bengal Police has imposed prohibitory orders for 60 days, starting Sunday, in parts of Kolkata’s central business district, PTI reported on Saturday. Citing an official order from Friday, the news agency reported that the action was taken after the police received inputs about possible

1 days ago

Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla has reconstituted four key parliamentary committees for the 2026-27 financial year. Notable reappointments include Faggan Singh
Politics
Lok Sabha reconstitutes three Financial

Lok Sabha Speaker Om Birla has reconstituted four key parliamentary committees for the 2026-27 financial year. Notable reappointments include Faggan Singh Kulaste as Chairperson of the Committee on the Welfare of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes

1 days ago

U.S. President Donald Trump said on Friday (May 1, 2026) he was “not satisfied” with Iran's latest proposal in negotiations to end war between the
World
Trump 'not satisfied' with Iran's latest proposal to end war with U

U.S. President Donald Trump said on Friday (May 1, 2026) he was “not satisfied” with Iran's latest proposal in negotiations to end war between the countries, rejecting the plan almost as soon as it was delivered. “They want to make a deal, I'm not satisfied with it, so we'll see what happen

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Tanur boat accident

Tanur boat accident: Justice V K Mohanan Commission submits final report with safety recommendationsTanur boat accident: Justice V K Mohanan Commission submits final report with safety recommendations Published on: May 02, 2026 2:26 PM IST PTI Share via Copy link Kochi

1 days ago

People living in a housing society in Noida were left upset after facing a water shortage for two straight days. A resident shared his experience online and
Latest News
Noida Man Complains About Water Shortage In Society

People living in a housing society in Noida were left upset after facing a water shortage for two straight days. A resident shared his experience online and questioned why basic facilities were missing despite residents paying maintenance charges regularly

1 days ago

Actor-turned-politician Vijay enjoys a massive fan following and there is no doubt about it. He is currently on a spiritual tour, seeking blessings for his
Entertainment
Vijay Fans Gather At Velankanni Church

Actor-turned-politician Vijay enjoys a massive fan following and there is no doubt about it. He is currently on a spiritual tour, seeking blessings for his Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam (TVK) ahead of the Tamil Nadu elections results, scheduled to be announced on May 4

1 days ago

<h4 class=
World
Trump is an idiot

'Trump is an idiot': Californians fume over soaring petrol pricesThe war launched by Donald Trump is unpopular all over the US, with polls showing a clear majority disapprove of a conflict whose aims they think are unclear. Updated on: May 02

1 days ago

The Trinamool Congress has lodged a complaint with the Election Commission. Allegations involve the unauthorized sorting of postal ballot covers at an EVM
Politics
Alleging unauthorised sorting of postal ballot covers

The Trinamool Congress has lodged a complaint with the Election Commission. Allegations involve the unauthorized sorting of postal ballot covers at an EVM strongroom in Kolkata. TMC workers claim trunks of ballots were moved to an unmonitored room. Similar incidents occurred in North 24 Parganas

1 days ago

The Supreme Court on Saturday declined to pass an order in a petition moved by the Trinamool Congress against the Election Commission’s decision to deploy
World
SC closes TMC plea after EC says state nominees will be present during vote counting

The Supreme Court on Saturday declined to pass an order in a petition moved by the Trinamool Congress against the Election Commission’s decision to deploy Union government employees as counting supervisors during the West Bengal Assembly election results, reported Live Law

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Internet reacts as emergency alert system test sends loud beep to mobile users

‘What just happened?’: Internet reacts as emergency alert system test sends loud beep to mobile usersInternet reacted after mobile users received a loud government test alert on their phones on Saturday morning. Published on: May 02, 2026 1:06 PM IST By Mahipal Singh Chouhan Share via Copy link

1 days ago

Union Road Transport & Highways Minister Nitin Gadkari on Friday announced the launch of India’s first Multi-Lane Free Flow (MLFF) barrier-less tolling
Home
India's First Barrier-Free Toll Plaza Goes Live On Mumbai-Delhi National Highway Near Surat

Union Road Transport & Highways Minister Nitin Gadkari on Friday announced the launch of India’s first Multi-Lane Free Flow (MLFF) barrier-less tolling system at the Chorayasi Toll Plaza on the Surat-Bharuch section of the Delhi-Mumbai NH-48 in Gujarat

1 days ago

This year’s JEE Main results saw 12 students score a perfect 100 percentile, including Rajasthan’s Arnav Gautam. Remarkably, Arnav achieved this in his
Education
Meet Arnav Gautam

This year’s JEE Main results saw 12 students score a perfect 100 percentile, including Rajasthan’s Arnav Gautam. Remarkably, Arnav achieved this in his very first attempt, scoring 295 out of 300 in the January session. Despite his parents coming from a humanities background

1 days ago

A Bengaluru-based software engineer working at Google has gone viral after sharing a video from Macau and talking about the perks of working at a top tech
Latest News
Bengaluru Google Software Engineer Shares Excitement Over Company Trip To Macau

A Bengaluru-based software engineer working at Google has gone viral after sharing a video from Macau and talking about the perks of working at a top tech company. In the clip, he tells students to take studies seriously, saying hard work can completely change someone’s life

1 days ago

Spirit Airlines, an impish upstart that shook the industry with its irreverent ads and deep discount fares, announced on Saturday (May 2
World
Spirit Airlines says it’s going out of business after 34 years and is ending operations

Spirit Airlines, an impish upstart that shook the industry with its irreverent ads and deep discount fares, announced on Saturday (May 2, 2026) that it has gone out of business after 34 years. The airlines said it had begun orderly wind-down of operations. It added all flights have been cancelled

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Life Style
When and where to watch Karan Johar

Met Gala 2026: When and where to watch Karan Johar, Isha Ambani and others walk the red carpet in India; know the themeThe Met Gala 2026 will take place on May 4, featuring stars from various industries to support the Metropolitan Museum of Art. The dress code of Fashion Is Art

1 days ago

Yash will soon be seen essaying the role of Ravan in Nitesh Tiwari’s Ramayana, scheduled to hit theatres on Diwali this year. While everyone is excited about
Entertainment
Yash Calls Ramayana

Yash will soon be seen essaying the role of Ravan in Nitesh Tiwari’s Ramayana, scheduled to hit theatres on Diwali this year. While everyone is excited about the upcoming movie, the pan-India star has now opened up about why he agreed to be a part of the project

1 days ago

Offered by the University of Gloucestershire, the U.K.  university  /  universities and colleges  /  students  /  careers  /  higher education  /  The Hindu
Education
May 2, 2026

Offered by the University of Gloucestershire, the U.K. university / universities and colleges / students / careers / higher education / The Hindu Education PlusSports Global Excellence ScholarshipOffered by the University of Gloucestershire, the U.K.Published - May 02

1 days ago

<h4 class=
World
Singapore mission chief calls for public-private support for ageing population in Asia-Pacific

Singapore mission chief calls for public-private support for ageing population in Asia-PacificSingapore mission chief calls for public-private support for ageing population in Asia-Pacific Published on: May 02, 2026 1:35 PM IST PTI Share via Copy link Singapore

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Five members of a Tamil family among nine killed in Bargi Dam boat tragedy

Five members of a Tamil family among nine killed in Bargi Dam boat tragedyA senior government official in Tiruppur said arrangements were being made to transport the bodies back to Tamil Nadu. Published on: May 02, 2026 2:33 PM IST By S Vijay Karthik Share via Copy link Five of the nine people

1 days ago

Chettinad is undergoing a revival. Its mansions are paying the price. As travellers, architects and designers discover the region’s unique aesthetic via
Life Style
Chettinad’s revival fuels both restoration and dismantling of historic mansions

Chettinad is undergoing a revival. Its mansions are paying the price. As travellers, architects and designers discover the region’s unique aesthetic via festivals and curated holidays, luxury homes and hotels across the country are increasingly being outfitted with Burmese teak doors

1 days ago

Thousands of fans were left disappointed as actor and TVK leader Vijay cancelled his scheduled visit to Velankanni Church on Saturday
Politics
TVK leader Vijay cancels Velankanni trip

Thousands of fans were left disappointed as actor and TVK leader Vijay cancelled his scheduled visit to Velankanni Church on Saturday. The actor had planned to visit the famous Christian pilgrimage centre early Saturday morning. Sources from TVK stated that the cancellation was due to personal

1 days ago


Sing Up