<h4 class=
Latest News

BJP minister Nandita Garlosa joins Congress day before Assam nomination deadline; to contest from HalflongHaflong's sitting MLA Nandita Garlosa was denied a ticket by the BJP, which fielded Rupali Langthasa from the seat after dropping several sitting legislators. Updated on: Mar 23

People in Kashmir are showing solidarity with Iran. They are donating cars, jewelry, and even land. This response comes after calls for support from the
World

People in Kashmir are showing solidarity with Iran. They are donating cars, jewelry, and even land. This response comes after calls for support from the Iranian Embassy. Donations are being made directly or exchanged for cash. This gesture highlights a strong humanitarian response from the region

Germany is continuing to struggle with a shortage of skilled workers, as elderly staff retire, and there are not enough young candidates to fill their roles
World

Germany is continuing to struggle with a shortage of skilled workers, as elderly staff retire, and there are not enough young candidates to fill their roles. To try to alleviate the problem the country is increasingly turning to workers from India. For Handirk von Ungern-Sternberg

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.<h4 class=
Technology

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.I tested the Infinix Note Edge 5G: Great display and battery, but performance left me wanting moreThe Infinix Note Edge 5G is trying to shake up the mid-range market with a slim design

Pep Guardiola's wild run and dance down Wembley's touchline demonstrated the hunger for success remains and his competitive fire still burns as fiercely as
Sports

Pep Guardiola's wild run and dance down Wembley's touchline demonstrated the hunger for success remains and his competitive fire still burns as fiercely as ever. It came after Nico O'Reilly's second header in four minutes effectively sealed Manchester City's 2-0 Carabao Cup final victory against

If AIFF accepts the proposal for a new agreement in its current form, it could have a lot to answer for, says Dhiman in this issue. As draft documents go, it is heavy on promise for All India Football Federation (AIFF) and clubs in the Indian Super League (ISL). It pitches alignment with global best practices – and that alone should be why AIFF and clubs must go for it – but then gives another reason: compliance with the new draft constitution.

Posted By: Jaydatt Chaudhary Posted On: Aug 31, 2025Share Article
If AIFF accepts the proposal for a new agreement in its current form, it could have a lot to answer for, says Dhiman in this issue. As draft documents go, it is heavy on promise for All India Football Federation (AIFF) and clubs in the Indian Super League (ISL). It pitches alignment with global best practices – and that alone should be why AIFF and clubs must go for it – but then gives another reason: compliance with the new draft constitution.

As draft documents go, it is heavy on promise for All India Football Federation (AIFF) and clubs in the Indian Super League (ISL). It pitches alignment with global best practices — and that alone should be why AIFF and clubs must go for it — but then gives another reason: compliance with the new draft constitution.

So, what's not to like? A lot as it turns out. No promotion and relegation in ISL for the next 10 years for one. Apart from what's-in-it-for-us for I-League clubs, it is not in line with what was proposed and accepted in 2019 by Asia's apex body. And since, as part of the proposal, it is AIFF's responsibility to deal with Asian Football Confederation and FIFA, I am guessing the onus will be on the federation to explain why.

After allowing promotion for two seasons, ISL proposes to be a closed league again, the difference being that this time it will also be India's top tier competition.

The argument that I-League clubs have not helped improve the standard is complicated. True, Mohammedan Sporting hit a new high in abjection and have been beset by financial problems but Punjab FC also qualified through that route and have shown they can compete. In their second season, Punjab FC finished above two teams that have been in ISL way longer.

Ten of the last 15 teams promoted to the Premier League went down the next season but that has not got the world's most watched league to stop relegation. For the second successive Premier League season, all three promoted teams have gone down. Surviving in the top tier is difficult — Nottingham Forest needed 57 signings and some £125m to make an impact — everywhere but how can clubs not be allowed to dream of doing what Ipswich Town (1961-62), Forest (1977-78) and Kaiserslautern (1997-98) did? All three won the top league in the season they were promoted.

And if off-the-field problems worry those who conceived ISL, well, it would be difficult to look beyond what hit Hyderabad FC in 2023-24. Financial problems led to the club being hit with transfer bans and a host of players leaving months after head coach Manolo Marquez did.

Clubs formed with ISL have had protection from relegation for 11 seasons. Granted, it takes time to grow the culture but how much have they done to suggest they are on the right path and would need insulation for another 10 years?

The plan to form a company to run ISL is in line with global best practices and the document lists the Big Five in Europe and the Asian countries doing it. As far as I know, the document or its contents was shared with clubs before being sent to AIFF. And that they had agreed in principle with the proposals. But should five ISL clubs failing the Premier 1 licence test not come in the way of them being co-owners of ISL? More so, because this was hardly the first time ISL clubs flunked licensing tests.

Should NorthEast United, Odisha FC, Hyderabad FC, Kerala Blasters and Mohammedan Sporting therefore be allowed to own a stake in a joint-venture company despite not meeting all the licensing requirements? ISL double winners, Mohun Bagan Super Giant, FC Goa, Mumbai City FC, Bengaluru FC, Jamshedpur FC, Chennayin FC and East Bengal made the grade after paying fines. The only club to have ticked all the boxes? Punjab FC.

While it is indeed best practice to allow clubs to have a say in the running of a competition that is about them, what is not clear is why that company should also get to own rights for national team matches in perpetuity? As per the draft document, national team matches will be the property of a company where AIFF, technically sole guardians of all India teams, has only 14% stake.

The document was sent to AIFF in March. It was read out in the next executive committee meeting but why were copies not circulated? Wouldn't that have given the members a chance to better engage with ideas meant to shape the future of ISL, India teams and AIFF's responsibilities? Also, when it was known to all that the current agreement ends in 2025, why was the conversation over the future of AIFF-FSDL relationship stalled after it began in 2023? It was sub-judice then, it is sub-judice now.

And if AIFF has an answer to Bhaichung Bhutia's question, we are yet to hear it. They went, listened and had pizza, Bhutia said in his latest salvo on AIFF. Accepted in this form, AIFF could have a lot to answer for.

For now, though reports of ISL not happening seem somewhat exaggerated, as are claims that clubs are not working the transfer market, it is likely the 2025-26 season will not start in September. That has hit the Durand Cup. Clubs have pulled out of the world's third oldest tournament because it makes no sense to start pre-seasons as usual when the start of the season is likely to be delayed.

Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


A viral thread describing chaotic behaviour by a section of Indian tourists at Brazil’s Iguaçu Falls has once again put the spotlight on a recurring—and
Latest News
Aap Log Duniya Ko Delhi Banakar Hi Maanoge

A viral thread describing chaotic behaviour by a section of Indian tourists at Brazil’s Iguaçu Falls has once again put the spotlight on a recurring—and uncomfortable—conversation: why do Indian travellers often get a bad reputation abroad? An Indian traveller by the name Gaurav Sabnis

1 days ago

Indian Grandmaster Koneru Humpy on Sunday announced her withdrawal from the FIDE Women’s Candidates Tournament, citing concerns over her personal safety
Sports
Koneru Humpy Withdraws From FIDE Candidates

Indian Grandmaster Koneru Humpy on Sunday announced her withdrawal from the FIDE Women’s Candidates Tournament, citing concerns over her personal safety despite assurances from the organisers amid the ongoing West Asia conflict. The Candidates

1 days ago

Senior BJP leaders are actively addressing internal party disagreements following the announcement of candidates for the upcoming 2026 assembly elections
Politics
After ticket snub

Senior BJP leaders are actively addressing internal party disagreements following the announcement of candidates for the upcoming 2026 assembly elections. Efforts are underway to pacify disgruntled leaders and supporters. Discussions are happening with those denied tickets to ensure party unity

1 days ago

The Election Commission will deploy approximately 200,000 cameras for 100% webcasting of voting in West Bengal, with sensitive booths receiving three cameras
Politics
Cameras, GPS, control rooms

The Election Commission will deploy approximately 200,000 cameras for 100% webcasting of voting in West Bengal, with sensitive booths receiving three cameras. New initiatives like a control command center and a dedicated complaint cell aim for a violence-free and fair election. These measures

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Amid growing war with Iran

Amid growing war with Iran, US treasury secretary says Trump is ‘defanging Iranian regime’Scott Bessent said that Trump is using ‘the only language the Iranians understand” by threatening to destroy its power plants over Hormuz stalemate. Published on: Mar 23

1 days ago

Janhvi Kapoor’s recent move from Karan Johar-led Dharma Cornerstone Artist Agency (DCAA) to Collective Artist Network has once again highlighted a growing
Entertainment
Karan Johar Reveals He Will ‘Prioritise’ In-House Talent After Janhvi Kapoor’s Exit From DCAA

Janhvi Kapoor’s recent move from Karan Johar-led Dharma Cornerstone Artist Agency (DCAA) to Collective Artist Network has once again highlighted a growing trend in the film industry—actors frequently switching talent management teams. With names like Ranveer Singh and Parineeti Chopra also

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Horoscope
Weekly Love Horoscope for March 23-29

Weekly Love Horoscope for March 23-29, 2026: Set clear goals to eliminate confusionWeekly Love Horoscope for March 23-29, 2026: This week, Mars provides all of the energy you need to take your current romantic connection to the next level. Published on: Mar 23

1 days ago

The first episode of Saturday Night Live UK has hit our screens - 50 years after the US original - and largely got a warm welcome from critics
Life Style
What did critics think of Saturday Night Live UK's debut

The first episode of Saturday Night Live UK has hit our screens - 50 years after the US original - and largely got a warm welcome from critics, but it failed to raise a smile with some. When it was announced, there was wariness about how the comedy sketch show would translate for a British audience

1 days ago

Craving cake but avoiding consuming egg this Navratri? You can make individual size chocolate cake portions in the air fryer. By swaping the all-purpose flour
Life Style
Try This Recipe For Chocolate Cake At Home In An Air Fryer

Craving cake but avoiding consuming egg this Navratri? You can make individual size chocolate cake portions in the air fryer. By swaping the all-purpose flour (aka maida), for wheat flour, this can also make for a healthier dessert. For many people in India who do not have an oven

1 days ago

For years, one of India’s oldest English newspapers, The Statesman, was in financial distress. Its revenues were dwindling, and it had struggled to settle
World
How a loan from a mysterious lender helped a distressed newspaper take over UNI

For years, one of India’s oldest English newspapers, The Statesman, was in financial distress. Its revenues were dwindling, and it had struggled to settle dues with lenders like the State Bank of India. Yet, in June 2025, the newspaper pulled off a corporate miracle

1 days ago

Prime Minister Narendra Modi chaired a Cabinet Committee on Security meeting to review the West Asia conflict's impact on India. The committee assessed
World
CCS reviews situation arising due to West Asia conflict

Prime Minister Narendra Modi chaired a Cabinet Committee on Security meeting to review the West Asia conflict's impact on India. The committee assessed critical needs like food, energy, and fuel security, directing a dedicated group to manage the effects. Measures for short, medium

1 days ago

On Wednesday, the war in West Asia shifted significant gears when Israel struck Iran’s South Pars gas field. In retaliation on early Thursday
Business
How the war in West Asia could change India’s energy calculus

On Wednesday, the war in West Asia shifted significant gears when Israel struck Iran’s South Pars gas field. In retaliation on early Thursday, Iran attacked Qatar’s Ras Laffan plant – the world’s largest liquified natural gas plant from where one-fifth of the global natural gas is exported

1 days ago

On Friday, MCX gold April futures added 0.23 per cent while MCX silver May futures declined 1.72 per cent. Currently gold futures stand at Rs 1,44,825
Latest News
Gold plummets 5

On Friday, MCX gold April futures added 0.23 per cent while MCX silver May futures declined 1.72 per cent. Currently gold futures stand at Rs 1,44,825, while silver futures at Rs 2,27,470 per kg. Also Read :City gas firms advised to prioritise PNG connections for commercial entitiesOn Friday

1 days ago

<strong>GATE 2026 Mechanical Engineering Safe Score:</strong> As per the Official schedule released, IIT Guwahati will release the GATE 2026 result
Education
GATE 2026 result 2026

GATE 2026 Mechanical Engineering Safe Score: As per the Official schedule released, IIT Guwahati will release the GATE 2026 result on March 19, 2026. Candidates who appeared for the Graduate Aptitude Test in Engineering on Feb 7, 8, 14, and 15 can check their qualifying status on the given GATE

1 days ago

The Kerala Congress has much to chew on, and the “food for thought
Politics
Denied But Not Defeated

The Kerala Congress has much to chew on, and the “food for thought" has been served by former dentist and national spokesperson, Dr Shama Mohamed. After being denied a ticket for the Kannur assembly seat, Shama took to social media site X to declare herself “denied but not defeated". However

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
IIT grad quits high-paying job in US

IIT graduate quits high-paying job in US, sells house to travel the world with family: 'I traded 4 BHK for entire world'The man described how he spent years in a well-paying job in the US but felt unfulfilled despite professional achievements. Updated on: Mar 22

1 days ago

New ATM rules are set to become effective from April 01, marking as an attempt to standardize the process of withdrawing cash from the machines
Business
ATM Rules Revamp

New ATM rules are set to become effective from April 01, marking as an attempt to standardize the process of withdrawing cash from the machines. Several banks have announced major changes in the process that will direct impact customers. Some of the big changes are reducing the limit of withdrawal

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Light rain likely in Gurugram as temperatures set to rise this week

Light rain likely in Gurugram as temperatures set to rise this weekIMD forecasts partly cloudy weather, isolated showers Monday. Temperatures set to rise 4–7°C; gusty winds up to 41 kmph recorded. Updated on: Mar 23, 2026 7:55 AM IST By Abhishek Bhatia Share via Copy link Gurugram recorded clear

1 days ago

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Sunday called on world leaders to join the Israel-US war on Iran. “I’m happy to say that I can see some of
World
Netanyahu calls on world leaders to join Israel-US’ war on Iran

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Sunday called on world leaders to join the Israel-US war on Iran. “I’m happy to say that I can see some of them beginning to move in that direction, but more is needed,” Netanyahu added, without naming any country

1 days ago

As the days stretch longer and the heat begins to settle in, the way we unwind naturally shifts – lighter meals, slower evenings, and drinks that feel as
Life Style
5 Easy Summer Cocktail Recipes That Are Perfect For Warm Weather Hosting

As the days stretch longer and the heat begins to settle in, the way we unwind naturally shifts – lighter meals, slower evenings, and drinks that feel as refreshing as the season itself. Summer, after all, is less about indulgence and more about ease

1 days ago

<strong>Stock Market Tomorrow:</strong> The Indian equities market is expected to remain volatile tomorrow, Monday, March 23 amid a cluster of
Business
Sensex, Nifty Prediction Tomorrow

Stock Market Tomorrow: The Indian equities market is expected to remain volatile tomorrow, Monday, March 23 amid a cluster of factors, including the ongoing Middle East crisis, the rising crude oil prices, the strengthening US dollar and weakening rupee and weaker investing sentiment

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Horoscope
Pisces Daily Horoscope Today for March 23

Pisces Horoscope Today for March 23, 2026: Avoid making promises you cannot keepPisces Horoscope Today: A calm conversation with a colleague clears confusion and shows your teamwork. Published on: Mar 23, 2026 5:49 AM IST By Dr J.N Pandey Share via Copy link Pisces (Feb 20-Mar 20) Daily Horoscope

1 days ago

The Biju Janata Dal on Saturday suspended six MLAs for cross-voting in favour of a Bharatiya Janata Party-backed Independent candidate in the March 16 Rajya
Politics
BJD suspends six MLAs for cross-voting in Rajya Sabha polls

The Biju Janata Dal on Saturday suspended six MLAs for cross-voting in favour of a Bharatiya Janata Party-backed Independent candidate in the March 16 Rajya Sabha elections in Odisha. The suspended MLAs are Chakramani Kanhar (Baliguda), Naba Kishor Mallick (Jayadev)

1 days ago

Iran launched two intermediate-range ballistic missiles targeting the US-UK military base Diego Garcia in the Indian Ocean on Saturday
World
No US Base Out Of Range

Iran launched two intermediate-range ballistic missiles targeting the US-UK military base Diego Garcia in the Indian Ocean on Saturday, in what appears to be a sharp escalation of the already volatile situation in West Asia. While neither missile struck the target — one malfunctioned mid-flight

1 days ago

Sri Lanka's Dasun Shanaka is set to join Rajasthan Royals for the upcoming Indian Premier League. He will replace the injured Sam Curran
Sports
Another blow to PSL

Sri Lanka's Dasun Shanaka is set to join Rajasthan Royals for the upcoming Indian Premier League. He will replace the injured Sam Curran. Shanaka was previously with Lahore Qalandars in the Pakistan Super League. This move follows Blessing Muzarabani's switch from PSL to IPL

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Piyush Goyal to finalise seat-sharing for Tamil Nadu elections today

Piyush Goyal to finalise seat-sharing for Tamil Nadu elections today: BJPThe announcement comes amid intensifying verbal volleys between the BJP and the ruling DMK. Updated on: Mar 23, 2026 7:54 AM IST PTI Share via Copy link Union minister Piyush Goyal is scheduled to arrive in Chennai on Monday

1 days ago

Hair loss is no longer a concern reserved for men in their 30s or 40s. Increasingly, it is showing up much earlier, sometimes even before the age of 25
Life Style
Gen Z Men Are Losing Hair In Their 20s And Experts Say Lifestyle Is To Blame

Hair loss is no longer a concern reserved for men in their 30s or 40s. Increasingly, it is showing up much earlier, sometimes even before the age of 25. And while genetics has long been seen as the primary cause, experts say the real driver today is far more immediate: lifestyle

1 days ago


Sing Up