<h4 class=
Life Style

From glazed skin to soft eye makeup: 5 easy makeup trends taking over summer evening beauty looksMakeup trends have significantly changed in the past few years. Here are some of the easy trends you can consider for summer evenings. Updated on: May 19

<h4 class=
Life Style

Summer vacation started and kids want to play outside? Paediatrician warns of 12 dangerous signs of heat exhaustionParents need to monitor children during summer vacation to prevent heat exhaustion. Know which are the observable signs which indicate medical emergency. Updated on: May 19

U.S. President Donald Trump said he was planning a major new assault on Iran on Tuesday (May 19, 2026), but held off as he saw hope for securing a so far
World

U.S. President Donald Trump said he was planning a major new assault on Iran on Tuesday (May 19, 2026), but held off as he saw hope for securing a so far elusive agreement to end the war. Mr. Trump said that he stopped his purported attack plan at the urging of Gulf Arab allies

The Ministry of External Affairs defended India’s record on democracy on Monday (May 18 2026), for the second time during Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s
World

The Ministry of External Affairs defended India’s record on democracy on Monday (May 18 2026), for the second time during Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s European tour, over the PM’s decision not to take questions from the press. During the joint press appearance with Norwegian Prime Minister

<h4 class=
Latest News

Noida CEO says he fired senior employee for asking him ‘Sir, tell me what to do?’The Noida-based founder and CEO of InstaAstro has revealed that he once fired a senior employee over lack of ‘ownership’ Updated on: May 19, 2026 2:04 PM IST By Sanya Jain Share via Copy link The Noida-based

Instagram and the paradox of illusory truth

Posted By: Hari Ram Posted On: Oct 19, 2025Share Article
Instagram and the paradox of illusory truth
On social media visual feeds, what is repressed gets revealed in the very act of repression (REUTERS)

There's a lot of dissing the ‘Gram' (Instagram) these days. Let me, therefore, be contrarian and begin with a scandalous proposition: To truly know a person today, you must study their Instagram. The real diary of the 21st century is the curated feed. The very superficial nature of Instagram makes it the truest revelation of the subject. What we choose to display is not what we are, but what we want others to believe we are. And therein lies the deep secret of our desire.

To paraphrase Karl Marx (or perhaps Jacques Lacan, or maybe both because it doesn't matter here), ideology reveals itself in its very concealment. Can we then posit the following: Instagram, or another similar platform, is not the opposite of authenticity; it's authenticity on steroids. And Freud would chime in thus: it is where the Id posts selfies.

There's too much Marx and Lacan going on in this author's mind these days, owing to some academic compulsions, stymying her ‘fun' takes. But, using them extensively in her essays, maybe she wants to convince others that she loves theory more than sarcasm. (She doesn't. But the charade of erudition must continue as bills need to be paid.) Curating an authorial voice.

Full disclosure: A conversation with a dear friend about my Instagram feed has triggered this essay. “I know all about your struggles, but your feed is all about a fabulous life.” It's funny as well as revealing because another friend recently shared something opposite. That they got to know of the health situation of my family — that includes three troublesome canine members — and my sudden, unhealthy weight and hair loss through social media, and figured out I was struggling and wanted to know if there was anything they could do to help.

Two people picked two different clues from the same feed that I don't even care to caption elaborately anymore. So, yay, maybe I'm not curating it well! It's got bright, shiny travel pictures as well as the improperly lit photos betraying the grimy corners of my house that I've learnt to ignore. I'm not having them cleaned even for Diwali because it's too much hassle.

On social media visual feeds, what is repressed gets revealed in the very act of repression. A kind of Streisand Effect. For example, the person who carefully constructs a persona of effortless natural beauty has, in fact, admitted, through this very construction, that a certain kind of beauty is effortful and performative. The photo grid becomes a psychoanalytic Rorschach test. The viewer can piece together a picture through the inkblots of filters.

What is fascinating is that most people believe they can control this process. “I curate my feed carefully.” But in curation lies exposure. The gap between the post and the life becomes the space of truth. What does this mean? That even rebellion becomes style. The person who posts their acne proudly in the era of hundred-step skincare regimens has not escaped capitalism. They have simply found a new niche market for it. We should not underestimate the economy of this exposure.

Instagram is not merely a socio-cultural and psychological space but a marketplace of selves. Theodor Adorno would have recognised it as the perfect commodity culture. The self-conscious branding of individuals by themselves as products. Curated fragments of life as consumable aesthetics. Even the so-called “anti-influencer,” who posts unfiltered selfies and messy bedrooms or writes long my-life-is-not-perfect captions, is merely participating in a different aesthetic regime: the commodification of authenticity.

Michel Foucault spoke of “technologies of the self,” the techniques employed by individuals to fashion their subjectivity. We do not have secret selves anymore. We have aesthetic selves. But the aesthetics, like all art, betray the artist. We choose only those authentic versions that suit our aesthetic narratives. Our non-urbane and unfashionable parents, for example, may have no space on our digital mantelpiece. Our pre-makeover looks from decades ago must be carefully hidden unless they fit our present aesthetic. Garish bed sheets from our hometown houses can't be allowed to slip out; that status is reserved only for our grandmother's hand embroidered sarees, real or mythical.

A friend once shared how she figures out people's marital health through the tone of their social media visuals. Over-the-top captions on togetherness under cutesy photos or the slow, steady disappearance of the spouse both signal trouble in paradise. It may or may not be true, but it establishes one general rule for today: visuals on social media are not a mask. Maybe the wearer doesn't know it yet.

Instagram, for example, doesn't really deceive us. It only allows us to deceive ourselves knowingly. We produce and consume lies. We are too lazy or unbothered to call out the lies we consume, and as producers, we take other consumers' lethargy of calling the lies out for granted. To “trust” someone's Instagram, therefore, does not mean to take it at face value. Maybe just read it symptomatically and trust the lie to tell the truth.

Just like Goddess Lakshmi's Maya avatar, the paradoxically illusory Truth.

Nishtha Gautam is an academic and author. The views expressed are personal

Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


In a bizarre twist that left the internet buzzing, a young boy’s bike was caught sounding like a local express train, thanks to a train horn he had illegally
Latest News
Honking Is The National Hobby Of India

In a bizarre twist that left the internet buzzing, a young boy’s bike was caught sounding like a local express train, thanks to a train horn he had illegally installed. The unusual stunt turned heads on the streets, startling pedestrians and confusing motorists who couldn’t believe a

1 days ago

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.<h4 class=
Technology
Amazon Fire TV Stick HD launched in India with Wi-Fi 6 and cloud gaming support

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Amazon Fire TV Stick HD launched: Why this streaming device is more than a TV upgradeAmazon has launched a new Fire TV Stick HD in India with Wi-Fi 6, Xbox cloud gaming support

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Who is Helle Lyng

Who is Helle Lyng, the Norway journalist who wanted to ask PM Modi a question?Helle Lyng grabbed headlines after calling out to PM Modi at the end of a joint press appearance with Norwegian Prime Minister Jonas Gahr Store in Oslo. Updated on: May 19

1 days ago

Rising US bond yields are once again emerging as a major concern for global financial markets, with investors increasingly worried that elevated crude oil
Latest News
Rising US bond yields trigger global jitters

Rising US bond yields are once again emerging as a major concern for global financial markets, with investors increasingly worried that elevated crude oil prices, sticky inflation and geopolitical tensions could force central banks to keep interest rates higher for longer

1 days ago

<strong>School Summer Vacation 2026:</strong> The sun’s heat is at its peak across northern and central India, and the Meteorological Department
Education
UP To Begin Summer Vacation Tomorrow

School Summer Vacation 2026: The sun’s heat is at its peak across northern and central India, and the Meteorological Department has warned of a more intense heat wave from mid-May to June. Temperatures have reached around 45 degrees Celsius in several states, including Delhi, Uttar Pradesh

1 days ago

Imtiaz Ali’s upcoming project, Main Vaapas Aaunga, is one of the most-awaited films of the year. It stars Diljit Dosanjh, Naseeruddin Shah, Vedang Raina
Latest News
Main Vaapas Aaunga's Sharvari Calls Herself

Imtiaz Ali’s upcoming project, Main Vaapas Aaunga, is one of the most-awaited films of the year. It stars Diljit Dosanjh, Naseeruddin Shah, Vedang Raina, and Sharvari in key roles. On May 18, the entire team was seen gracing the trailer launch event in the city

1 days ago

For many years, Sameer Gurung, who grew up in the village of Mangzing in Sikkim, did not realise that conservation was something that he could do himself
Life Style
A new fellowship that reimagines conservation in Northeast India

For many years, Sameer Gurung, who grew up in the village of Mangzing in Sikkim, did not realise that conservation was something that he could do himself. “I would just hear about it in papers and other media,” he says. Then, in 2024, he came across and got selected for a responsible tourism

1 days ago

Supreme Court asks MeitY to examine PIL seeking recovery or destruction of stolen personal data of citizens on foreign servers
Politics
Supreme Court asks MeitY to examine PIL seeking recovery or destruction of stolen personal data of citizens on foreign servers

The Supreme Court on Tuesday (May 19, 2026) asked the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) to consider a PIL as a representation seeking a robust mechanism to recover or destroy the personal data of Indians allegedly stolen and stored on foreign servers

1 days ago

Employees in the B band reportedly get hikes in the range of 1%-3.5%, while many workers in the C band claims their salary revisions were either negligible or
Business
Average 5% Increment

Employees in the B band reportedly get hikes in the range of 1%-3.5%, while many workers in the C band claims their salary revisions were either negligible or negative. IT major Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) has rolled out an average salary hike of around 5% in its latest appraisal cycle

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Education
Monthly Plans

Monthly Plans, Mock Tests and NCERT: Gurgaon's Nysa Singh shares secret behind 99.2% score in CBSE class 12 result 202699.2% scorer Nysa Singh of Gurgaon shares her preparation journey, study tips and future aspirations as she talks to HT Digital about her success. Updated on: May 19

1 days ago

Alireza Firouzja was quite literally forced to make moves without moving on Monday. In one of the most bizarre scenes seen in elite chess
Sports
Firouzja Staves Off Sindarov From Hotel Room After Ankle Injury

Alireza Firouzja was quite literally forced to make moves without moving on Monday. In one of the most bizarre scenes seen in elite chess, the French GM played his fifth-round game at the Superbet Chess Classic Romania from a hotel bed after suffering an ankle injury earlier in the tournament

1 days ago

Negotiators have reached a tentative deal that will end a strike at the busiest rail system in North America, which had caused travel chaos for thousands of
Business
Strike at busiest rail system in North America ends after day of chaotic commutes

Negotiators have reached a tentative deal that will end a strike at the busiest rail system in North America, which had caused travel chaos for thousands of commuters during rush hour on Monday. New York Governor Kathy Hochul said Monday evening that the deal between unions and the Metropolitan

1 days ago

Bakrid is around the corner, and that means family gatherings, festive feasts, and of course, a delicious plate of biryani. But if you don’t want to spend
Life Style
Make Delicious Biryani In Just 10 Minutes With Chef Kunal Kapur’s Quick Recipe

Bakrid is around the corner, and that means family gatherings, festive feasts, and of course, a delicious plate of biryani. But if you don’t want to spend hours in the kitchen this Eid, celebrity chef Kunal Kapur has the perfect solution. His quick 10-minute biryani rice recipe promises all the

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Business
Tech Tonic | Musk v

Tech Tonic | Musk v. Altman, and a reality of bickering adults holding AI’s keysAn unfortunate aside of this legal wrangle is where one is left wondering just how little trust AI’s leaders actually inspire Published on: May 19, 2026 12:06 PM IST By Vishal Mathur Share via Copy link Absolute

1 days ago

The Supreme Court on Tuesday refused to recall its directions issued last year that stray dogs picked by municipal authorities from public places must not be
World
SC refuses to recall order to remove stray dogs from public places

The Supreme Court on Tuesday refused to recall its directions issued last year that stray dogs picked by municipal authorities from public places must not be released back into the same area after they are vaccinated or sterilised, Live Law reported. As per the directions issued in November

1 days ago

Jana Small Finance Bank’s board of directors, have approved a preferential warrant issue, on Monday, May 18, to raise up to ₹728.5 crore from six
Business
Jana Small Finance Bank approves ₹728 crore fund raise via preferential issue

Jana Small Finance Bank’s board of directors, have approved a preferential warrant issue, on Monday, May 18, to raise up to ₹728.5 crore from six institutional and individual investors. The transaction, first reported by CNBC-TV18 last week, has now been formally disclosed to both NSE and BSE

1 days ago

Latest News
Indian techie outlines hidden financial

Bengaluru-born techie outlines hidden financial, emotional struggles of chasing the NRI dreamA techie tells HT.com about the raw reality of the NRI dream, from a $70k student loan to battling extreme homesickness. Published on: May 19, 2026 1:31 PM IST By Trisha Sengupta Share via Copy link Moving

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Raghava Lawrence defends CM Vijay for picking Rajmohan in film ministry

Raghava Lawrence defends Tamil Nadu CM Vijay for picking Rajmohan as Minister for Film Technology and Cinematograph ActTamil Nadu CM Vijay's decision to appoint Rajmohan as the Minister for Film Technology and Cinematograph Act in Tamil Nadu was questioned by Vishal. May 19, 2026

1 days ago

Much like his personal life, Saif Ali Khan’s professional journey is marked by both highs and lows. His debut outing Parampara may have released in 1993 but
Entertainment
Saif Ali Khan Says Senior Actor Told Him To Hide Marriage With Amrita Singh

Much like his personal life, Saif Ali Khan’s professional journey is marked by both highs and lows. His debut outing Parampara may have released in 1993 but he had begun shooting for Bekhudi in 1991, which was supposed to launch him in Bollywood

1 days ago

The story of Soonwoo Kwon sounds less like a tennis career and more like the plot of a sports movie. One moment, he was South Korea’s top tennis hope
Sports
Rifles And Rackets

The story of Soonwoo Kwon sounds less like a tennis career and more like the plot of a sports movie. One moment, he was South Korea’s top tennis hope, climbing to a career-high ranking of World No. 52. The next, he was forced to put his career on hold to fulfill mandatory military service back

1 days ago

The death of 33-year-old Twisha Sharma in Bhopal has triggered a bitter and emotional battle between her family and in-laws, with both sides making serious and
Latest News
Torture, Dowry Harassment, Psychiatric Treatment

The death of 33-year-old Twisha Sharma in Bhopal has triggered a bitter and emotional battle between her family and in-laws, with both sides making serious and conflicting allegations as the police investigation continues. Twisha, a resident of Noida

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Sports
Flawed, not finished

Flawed, not finished: Why Brazil still needs Neymar 2.0 for World Cup 2026Neymar returns to Brazil's World Cup squad despite injury concerns, as Carlo Ancelotti aims for balance following key player absences. Updated on: May 19, 2026 1:02 PM IST By Probuddha Bhattacharjee Share via Copy link Neymar

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
SC allows euthanasia for rabid

SC allows euthanasia for rabid, incurably ill stray dogsSC allows euthanasia for rabid, incurably ill stray dogs Published on: May 19, 2026 1:45 PM IST PTI Share via Copy link New Delhi, The Supreme Court for the first time on Tuesday allowed euthanasia for rabid, incurably ill

1 days ago

and deeptech platform has appointed as its managing director and .<br><br>Kumar joins Moglix's central leadership team with a mandate to build and
Technology
Moglix appoints Amit Kumar as MD and chief business officer

and deeptech platform has appointed as its managing director and .Kumar joins Moglix's central leadership team with a mandate to build and scale the company's emerging business segments and new opportunity areas. He brings over two decades of experience across business leadership

1 days ago

When was the last time you walked through centuries in a single afternoon? As Hyderabad’s Salar Jung Museum marks its diamond jubilee
Life Style
Salar Jung museum turns 75

When was the last time you walked through centuries in a single afternoon? As Hyderabad’s Salar Jung Museum marks its diamond jubilee, this is a good time to revisit its vast, globally sourced collection. Established in 1951 by Nawab Mir Yousuf Ali Khan, Salar Jung III at Dewan Devdi

1 days ago

Ever stopped to think about the spoon of oil you pour into your pan every day? That familiar drizzle into the kadhai, so routine it barely registers
Life Style
The Hidden Truth About Cooking Oils And Everyday Health

Ever stopped to think about the spoon of oil you pour into your pan every day? That familiar drizzle into the kadhai, so routine it barely registers, may be one of the most overlooked elements of our daily diet. For decades, cooking oil has quietly played a supporting role in our kitchens

1 days ago

Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge has strongly criticised Prime Minister Narendra Modi regarding recent fuel price increases. Kharge alleged that the
Politics
Lack of foresight

Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge has strongly criticised Prime Minister Narendra Modi regarding recent fuel price increases. Kharge alleged that the government is burdening common citizens while allegedly giving industrialist Gautam Adani a 'free pass'

1 days ago


Sing Up