For decades, in vitro fertilisation (IVF) has largely been viewed as a solution for people struggling to conceive. However, modern reproductive medicine has expanded far beyond treating infertility alone. Today, assisted reproductive technologies play a crucial role in reducing miscarriages
Scotland are poised to replace Bangladesh in the T20 World Cup 2026 if the BCB withdraws after the January 21 ICC deadline, thanks to superior rankings, recent form, and logistical readiness. With the January 21 deadline looming, the ICC stands at a crossroads over Bangladesh's participation in the
BJP leader Prakash Reddy has reacted to Telangana Chief Minister Revanth Reddy's statement regarding Singareni Collieries. Reddy condemned personal attacks involving a woman IAS officer. He suggested internal Congress conflicts are fueling the controversy
OnePlus is gearing up to expand its flagship lineup in 2026 with a new smartphone the OnePlus 15T. While the company has not officially confirmed the device, multiple leaks are confirming the specifications of the device and its launch timeline
Ranchi, Jan 19 (PTI) Four people were arrested in connection with the firing during a clash over a land-related dispute in Jharkhand's Ranchi two days ago, police said on Monday. Three persons, including two brothers, suffered bullet injuries during the violent clash near Piska More on Saturday
India's jobs guarantee scheme: A global model under threat?
India's jobs guarantee scheme: A global model under threat?
India is home to one of the world's most ambitious social programmes - a jobs guarantee that gives every rural household the legal right to paid work.
Launched in 2005 by a Congress party government, the National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (NREGS) entitled every rural household to demand up to 100 days of paid manual work each year at a statutory minimum wage.
This mattered in a country where 65% of 1.4 billion people live in rural areas and nearly half rely on farming, which generates insufficient income, accounting for just 16% of India's GDP.
Providing unskilled public work across all but fully urban districts, the scheme has become a backbone of rural livelihoods, cushioning demand during economic shocks. It is also among the world's most studied anti-poverty programmes, with strong equity: over half of the estimated 126 million scheme workers are women, and around 40% come from "scheduled castes" or tribes, among the most deprived Indians
The ruling Narendra Modi government, initially critical and later inclined to pare it back, turned to the scheme in crises - most notably during the Covid pandemic, when mass return migration from cities to villages sharply drove up demand for work. Economists say the scheme lifted rural consumption, reduced poverty, improved school attendance, and in some regions pushed up private-sector wages.
Last week, the government introduced a new law that repeals and rebrands the scheme. The programme - renamed MGNREGA in 2009 to honour Mahatma Gandhi - has now dropped his name altogether.
While the renaming drew the political heat, the more consequential changes lie in what the new law - known as G RAM G for short - actually does.
It raises the annual employment guarantee from 100 to 125 days per rural household. It retains the provision that workers not given jobs within 15 days are entitled to an unemployment allowance.
Under the original scheme, the federal government paid all labour wages and most material costs - roughly a 90:10 split with the states.
Funding will now follow a 60:40 split between the federal government and most states. That could push states' contribution to 40% or more of total project cost. The federal government keeps control, including the power to notify the scheme and decide state-wise allocations.
States remain legally responsible for providing employment - or paying unemployment allowances, even as the central government allocates $9.5bn for the scheme in the current financial year, ending next March.
The government frames the reforms as a modernised, more effective, and corruption-free programme aimed at empowering the poor.
"This law stands firmly in favour of the poor, in support of progress, and in complete guarantee of employment for the workers," says federal agriculture minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan.
Critics - including opposition parties, academics, and some state governments - warn that capping funds and shifting costs to states could dilute a rare legal right in India's welfare system.
"It is the culmination of the long-standing drive for centralisation of the scheme under the Modi government. But it is more than centralisation. It is the reduction of employment guarantee to a discretionary scheme. A clause allows the federal government to decide where and when the scheme applies," Jean Dreze, a development economist, told me.
Prof Dreze says the increase to 125 guaranteed workdays per household may sound like a major revamp, but is a "red herring". A recent report by LibTech India, an advocacy group, found that only 7% of rural households working on the scheme received the 100 days of work in 2023-24.
"When the ceiling is not binding, how does it help to raise it? Raising wage rates, again, is a much better way of expanding benefits. Second, raising the ceiling is a cosmetic measure when financial restrictions pull the other way, " Prof Dreze notes.
These and other concerns appear to have prompted a group of international scholars to petition the Modi government in defence of the original scheme, warning that the new funding model could undermine its purpose.
"The [scheme] has captured the world's attention with its demonstrated achievements and innovative design. To dismantle it now would be a historic error," an open letter, led by Olivier De Schutter, UN special rapporteur on extreme poverty and human rights, warned.
To be sure, the scheme has faced persistent challenges, including underfunding and delays in wage payments. West Bengal's programme, for example, has faced deep cuts and funding freezes since 2022, with the federal government halting funds over alleged non-compliance.
Yet despite these challenges, the scheme appears to have delivered measurable impact.
An influential study by economists Karthik Muralidharan, Paul Niehaus, and Sandip Sukhtankar found that the broader, economy-wide impacts of the scheme boosted beneficiary households' earnings by 14% and cut poverty by 26%. Workers demanded higher wages, land returns fell, and job gains were larger in villages, the study found.
But many say the scheme's durability also underscores a deeper structural problem: India's chronic inability to generate enough non-farm jobs to absorb surplus rural labour.
Agriculture has consistently lagged behind the broader economy, growing just 3% annually since 2001–02, compared with 7% for the rest of the economy.
Critics such as Nitin Pai of the Takshashila Institution, a think-tank, argue that the scheme cushions distress but does little to raise long-term rural productivity, and may even blunt incentives for agricultural reform.
"With [the scheme] we're merely treating a serious underlying malaise with steroids," said Mr Pai in a post on X.
The government's Economic Survey 2023–24 questions whether demand under the scheme truly mirrors rural hardship.
If that was the case, data should show higher fund use and employment in poorer states with higher unemployment, the survey says.
Yet, it notes, Tamil Nadu, with under 1% of the country's poor, received nearly 15% of the scheme's funds, while Kerala, with just 0.1% of the poor, accounted for almost 4% of federal allocations.
The survey adds that the actual work generated depends largely on a state's administrative capacity: states with trained staff can process requests on time, directly influencing how much employment is provided.
Despite these anomalies, the case for the scheme remains strong in a country where many depend on low-income rural work and where the deeper challenge is the lack of quality employment.
Even headline figures on rising labour participation in India can be misleading: more people "working" does not always mean better or more productive jobs.
A recent paper by economists Maitreesh Ghatak, Mrinalini Jha and Jitendra Singh finds that the country's recent rise in labour force participation, especially among women, reflects economic distress rather than growth-driven job creation.
The authors say the increase is concentrated in the most vulnerable forms of work: unpaid family helpers and self-employed workers, who have very low productivity and falling real earnings.
"The recent expansion in employment reflects economic distress leading to subsistence work, rather than growth-driven better quality job creation," they say.
The evidence suggests people are driven into subsistence work by necessity, not drawn into better-quality jobs by a stronger economy.
This ensures that the world's largest jobs guarantee scheme will remain central to the livelihoods of hundreds of millions of Indians - whether the revamped version will strengthen it or undermine its impact remains to be seen.
Follow BBC News India on Instagram, YouTube, X and Facebook.
Source: BBC
Related Posts: Virat Kohli's ton in vain as NZ stun India by 41 runs to clinch series 2 Is India About To Join ‘Mediterranean Quad’ To Outplay ‘Islamic NATO’ India-US Trade Deal To Crumble Shubman Gill Makes Honest Admission After India's Loss Against New Zealand NZ beat India to claim historic ODI series win New Zealand Overcome Kohli’s Valiant 124 To Beat India By 41 Runs Davos under lockdown as World Economic Forum opens today India's thriving online delivery platforms face a year of reckoning US invites India Who Will Replace Bangladesh In T20 World Cup 2026 If BCB Pulls Out
British Prime Minister Keir Starmer has strongly criticised US President Donald Trump over his threat to impose tariffs on European allies amid a growing dispute over Greenland, calling such a move “completely wrong" and warning that it undermines NATO's collective security
3 hours ago
China's population fell for a fourth consecutive year in 2025 as the birthrate plunged to a record low, official data showed on Monday (January 19, 2026), with experts warning of further decline. The country's population dropped by 3.39 million to 1.405 billion
3 hours ago
A devastating train crash in southern Spain has claimed at least 21 lives. A high-speed train derailed late Sunday, striking another train. The accident occurred in Adamuz, Cordoba province. Hundreds of passengers were on board the trains. Emergency crews are continuing their search
3 hours ago
According to the National Centre for Seismology (NCS), the earthquake occurred at around 8:44 a.m., with its epicentre located in North Delhi at a shallow depth of 5 kilometres. A mild earthquake measuring 2.8 on the Richter scale struck New Delhi on Monday morning
3 hours ago
As of 9.30 am, Sensex lost 449 points, or 0.54 per cent to reach 83,120 and Nifty declined 148 points, or 0.58 per cent to 25,546. Mumbai: The Indian benchmark indices opened the week in the red zone on Monday, tracking weak global cues after geopolitical trade tensions rose due to US
3 hours ago
The United States has invited India and Pakistan to join President Donald Trump's proposed Board of Peace, which Washington has described as a global initiative aimed at resolving global conflicts, initially focusing on Gaza. It was not clear whether New Delhi had agreed to join the initiative
3 hours ago
An explosion at a steel plate factory in north China's Inner Mongolia region killed two people and left five missing, according to local emergency management and fire rescue departments, China's state broadcaster CCTV reported
5 hours ago
Last week, the Indian government asked e-commerce companies to stop 10-minute deliveries - drawing the curtain on a much-trumpeted promise by start-ups to provide groceries, food, grooming and even home repair services at lightning speeds in India
5 hours ago
![Davos [Switzerland], January 19 (ANI): Ahead of the World Economic Forum (WEF) 2026 beginning Monday, Davos had been intensifying its preparations for what has](http://newsorbit360.com/files/news/en/imgs/davos-under-lockdown-as-world-economic-forum-opens-today.webp?height=520)
Davos [Switzerland], January 19 (ANI): Ahead of the World Economic Forum (WEF) 2026 beginning Monday, Davos had been intensifying its preparations for what has come to be known as the world's most-talked-about gathering.Even before the official opening
5 hours ago
Chelsea head coach Liam Rosenior has said that he saw Enzo Fernandez play in the 2022 World Cup final for Argentina and knew about his talent, but it required him to see the latter up close at the English club to know how ‘magnificent' the Argentine midfielder was
5 hours ago
At least 18 people died and thousands were evacuated as wildfires raged across Chile, with Chilean President Gabriel Boric declaring a state of catastrophe in two southern regions of the country on Sunday. The fires, which caused rampage across central and southern Chile
5 hours ago
Kriti Sanon Boyfriend: Amid growing speculation, neither Kriti nor Kabir has officially confirmed their relationship. Mumbai: "Nazar na lage" -- This is how fans reacted to the viral pictures of actor Kriti Sanon with her rumoured boyfriend Kabir Bahia from her sister Nupur Sanon's wedding
5 hours ago
Gold, Silver Prices At Record High: Gold and silver prices hit a record high at the international spot market following the rising geopolitical uncertainty over US President Donald Trump's rhetoric to acquire Greenland, an autonomous territory of Denmark
5 hours ago
Air pollution can irritate your throat, causing dryness, pain, and discomfort in daily life. These simple home remedies can naturally soothe irritation and provide quick relief. With rising air pollution levels, especially in urban areas, sore throat has become a common complaint
5 hours ago
Play was halted during an Australian Open first-round match on Sunday (January 18, 2026) when a ball girl fainted as temperatures soared, with players Zeynep Sonmez and Ekaterina Alexandrova rushing to help her. The incident happened as Russian 11th seed Alexandrova was serving during the second
5 hours ago
Denmark's Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen says "Europe won't be blackmailed", as she and other European leaders continue to weigh their response to US President Donald Trump's tariff threats over Greenland. Trump says he will impose new taxes on eight US allies - Denmark, Finland, France, Germany
5 hours ago
White House Trade Adviser Peter Navarro has renewed his criticism of India, questioning why Americans are paying for Artificial Intelligence in India. Mr. Navarro's comments on Saturday (January 17, 2026) came amid a strain in India-U.S. ties, which began after U.S
5 hours ago
Weather Warning: Delhi and NCR woke up to a shivery morning amid dense fog conditions on Monday. Cold wave conditions persist in North India, including Punjab, Rajasthan, Haryana, and Uttar Pradesh. Snowfall, dense fog, and cold wave conditions are expected in parts of north and northwest India
5 hours ago
Soldiers are on standby for possible deployment to Minneapolis, a US defence official has told CBS News, the BBC's US partner. The official said the 1,500 soldiers, currently in Alaska, are an option for US President Donald Trump if he decided to use active duty military personnel
5 hours ago
As BJP's acting president Nitin Nabin prepares to file his nomination on Monday at 2pm—in a competition widely expected to be uncontested—the party is quietly turning a page on the tenure of JP Nadda, one of its most understated but structurally significant national presidents who
5 hours ago
Bigg Boss Tamil Season 9 grand finale saw wildcard entrant Divya Ganesh emerge as the winner, taking home the trophy and a cash prize of Rs. 50 lakh. Bigg Boss Tamil Season 9 Grand Finale Winner: Superstar Vijay Sethupathi hosted the grand finale of Bigg Boss Tamil Season 9
5 hours ago
Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister N. Chandrababu Naidu on January 17, 2026 (Saturday) announced that the Andhra Pradesh Government was preparing to develop a satellite launching facility as part of the Space City project on the Hope Island in the Kakinada Bay.Andhra Pradesh Chief Minister N
5 hours ago
A huge explosion at a factory in northern China has killed two people and injured 84 others, with eight people still missing, state media reported. The blast happened at around 15:00 local time (07:00 GMT) Sunday at Baogang United Steel plant in Inner Mongolia
5 hours ago
A software engineer tragically died after his SUV plunged into a deep, water-filled pit in Greater Noida's Sector 150 on a foggy night. Despite desperate pleas for help and a father's helpless proximity, rescue efforts were hampered by dense fog and the pit's depth
5 hours ago
China's economy grew by 5% last year, as record exports helped Beijing meet its annual growth target, according to Chinese government figures. But the data also showed economic growth slowed to a rate of 4.5% in the final three months of 2025 compared to a year earlier
5 hours ago
New Zealand 337-8 (50 overs): Mitchell 137, Phillips 106; Arshdeep 3-63, Harshit 3-84 India 296 all out (46 overs): Kohli 124, Reddy 53; Clarke 3-54, Foulkes 3-77 New Zealand clinched their first one-day international series win in India with a 41-run victory in the deciding third match
5 hours ago
OpenAI announced Friday it will begin testing advertisements on ChatGPT in the coming weeks, as the wildly popular artificial intelligence chatbot seeks to increase revenue to cover its soaring costs. The ads will initially appear in the United States for free and lower-tier subscribers
5 hours ago
