A routine delivery took an unexpectedly adorable turn when a Rapido driver ended up transporting a very unusual parcel, a calm and lovable dog
Latest News

A routine delivery took an unexpectedly adorable turn when a Rapido driver ended up transporting a very unusual parcel, a calm and lovable dog. The video of this heart-melting moment has since gone viral, leaving social media users grinning and dubbing it one of the most wholesome clips on the

<h4 class=
Latest News

Anne Hathaway dials up the heat in two designer looks for The Devil Wears Prada 2 London premiereAnne Hathaway dazzled London in not one, but two glamourous looks, courtesy of Versace and Louis Vuitton. Here's a breakdown of what she wore! Published on: Apr 23

<h4 class=
Latest News

SC stays former Chhattisgarh lawmaker Amit Jogi’s conviction in 2003 murder caseIn 2007, a trial court convicted 28 people for NCP leader Ramavtar Jaggi’s murder, but acquitted Amit Jogi, citing insufficient evidence Published on: Apr 23, 2026 1:14 PM IST By Abraham Thomas Share via Copy link

<h4 class=
Life Style

UK surgeon explains why yawning often results in a sudden improvement in hearingBeing able to hear better right after yawning is not imaginary feeling. Dr Rajan explains why the simple act boosts our auditory system. Updated on: Apr 23, 2026 1:58 PM IST By Debapriya Bhattacharya Share via Copy link

The National Investigation Agency on Wednesday alleged before the Delhi High Court that separatist leader Yasin Malik was in contact with the top leadership of
World

The National Investigation Agency on Wednesday alleged before the Delhi High Court that separatist leader Yasin Malik was in contact with the top leadership of Pakistan, including its prime minister and president, and used these links to propagate the secession of Jammu and Kashmir from India

Humayun Kabir phenomenon: Why Muslim mobilisations fail in Bengal polls math

Posted By: Hemant Kumar Posted On: Jan 06, 2026Share Article
Humayun Kabir phenomenon
Humayun Kabir

As assembly polls approach, West Bengal is experiencing a fresh wave of Muslim political activity. Yet, despite vibrant speeches and high-energy rallies, previous patterns indicate that such mobilizations may not significantly alter voting behavior. Key issues for voters revolve around selecting viable candidates and stopping the BJP's advance.

Kolkata: As suspended TMC MLA Humayun Kabir mounts a fresh challenge to the party's minority vote bank ahead of the assembly polls, West Bengal is once again witnessing a familiar surge in Muslim socio-political mobilisation, a phase that has generated noise in the past but couldn't alter electoral outcomes.

Despite such periodic churn, minority voting patterns in Bengal have remained largely stable over decades, shaped less by religious charisma or symbolic assertion than by organisation, alliances and vote consolidation.

With elections to the 294-member assembly just a few months away, episodes like Kabir's rebellion, marked by sharp rhetoric and emotive symbolism, trigger speculation about a division of the TMC's minority vote, long considered its electoral bulwark.

Similar phases in the past have dominated political discourse and media narratives, only to fade when electoral arithmetic reasserts itself on polling day.

Figures such as cleric Toha Siddiqui in 2016 and Abbas Siddiqui in 2021 drew crowds during campaign periods, while the current churn around Kabir reflects a comparable moment of political assertion. Each episode raised expectations of denting the TMC's minority vote base and the emergence of an alternative centre of Muslim political leadership.

In practice, these assertions have tended to plateau once campaigns end, with arithmetic prevailing over momentum.

From Abbas Siddiqui's political debut to Kabir's political venture, Muslim-focused initiatives in Bengal have followed a familiar trajectory, peaking before elections, intensifying debate, and stabilising without producing a corresponding shift in voting patterns across seats.

Pre-poll mobilisation driven by religious authority has struggled to convert sentiment into seats, as booth-level organisation, alliance management, and vote transferability have remained decisive.

Analysts and political leaders attribute this recurrence to structural constraints rather than leadership-specific failure.

"Religious figures can influence emotion, but they cannot transfer minority votes across constituencies. Voters ask a simpler question- who can win, and who can stop the BJP," political analyst Maidul Islam said.

The Indian Secular Front (ISF), floated by Abbas months before the 2021 polls and allied with the Left and Congress, was projected as a disruptor, "capable" of unsettling the TMC's arithmetic. Instead, it managed just one seat, reinforcing a recurring lesson in Bengal politics: visibility does not necessarily translate into electoral viability.

"People come to rallies with emotion, but votes are cast with fear and calculation. If people feel their vote might help the BJP, they step back," said Naushad Siddiqui, the ISF's lone MLA.

The Furfura Sharif shrine, linked to Siddiquis, in Hooghly remains a potent site of political signalling, but allegiance there has historically been fluid, often dissolving once electoral choices narrow.

The debate has returned with Kabir's rebellion against the TMC leadership. His criticism of the party's "pro-Hindu optics", the announcement of a Babri Masjid replica and the launch of the Janata Unayan Party have injected fresh volatility into Bengal's pre-poll atmosphere.

"I am not dividing votes; I am raising voices that have been suppressed," said Kabir, whose rallies in Murshidabad have drawn sizeable crowds, tapping into grievances over representation and perceived marginalisation. He has spoken of contesting over 135 seats and keeping channels open with the Left, the ISF and the AIMIM.

A CPI(M) leader said enthusiasm, without cadres, polling agents and booth-level machinery, rarely survives till polling day.

The BJP argues that identity-driven mobilisations sharpen polarisation and consolidate Hindu votes, a dynamic it believes works to its advantage in multi-cornered contests.

Analysts broadly identify three structural deficits that blunt such mobilisations: the absence of statewide organisation, lack of credible cross-community appeal and weight of political memory among voters.

Social researcher Sabir Ahamed noted that Bengal has not produced a universally accepted Muslim mass leader since Congress stalwart A B A Ghani Khan Choudhury.

"There is no minority leader today with a pan-Bengal appeal and both organisational depth and governing clout. Without that, religious mobilisation remains fragile," he said.

The minority electorate also carries a long political memory. Before Independence, Muslims were divided among the Congress, Krishak Praja Party and the Muslim League. After partition, Muslims moved to the Congress, then to the Left, and later to the TMC, driven less by theology than by political security.

That logic continues to shape voting behaviour, with minority support for the TMC coinciding with its emergence as the strongest bulwark against the BJP in Bengal.

"Muslims here have seen what vote-splitting did in other states. That fear acts as a deterrent," Ahamed said.

Dissent and churn do surface in minority-dominated pockets. But as polling nears, arithmetic tends to reassert itself.

State minister Firhad Hakim claimed minorities know only TMC can stop the BJP.

"In Bengal, charisma talks, arithmetic decides. Until a Muslim-led formation offers organisation, cross-community appeal and governing capacity, such mobilisations will shape narratives, not outcomes," Islam said.

As leaders rise and debates churn, the minority vote, older than the noise around it, settles where arithmetic, not rhetoric, still decides survival.
Add as a Reliable and Trusted News Source Add Now!


Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


<h4 class=
Latest News
Who is Arun Panwar

Who is Arun Panwar? YouTuber who got ₹71 lakh, gold from doctor wife’s familyArun Panwar, the YouTuber who faced public scrutiny after accepting ₹71 lakh as a gift from his bride’s family, is in the news again Updated on: Apr 23, 2026 1:11 PM IST By Sanya Jain Share via Copy link Arun

1 hours ago

Puneet Sharma, CEO and Fund Manager at Whitespace Alpha, CAT3 AIF, believes volatile markets creates larger trading opportunities as the range of price
Latest News
Consumption remains a long-term theme

Puneet Sharma, CEO and Fund Manager at Whitespace Alpha, CAT3 AIF, believes volatile markets creates larger trading opportunities as the range of price movement expands. "Whether markets go up or down becomes secondary. The focus is on how wide the move is and how efficiently we can capture it

1 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Woman walks every day but nearly falls washing her face

Woman walks 5 km every morning but nearly falls while washing her face: Neurologist explains the puzzling caseDr Sudhir linked a woman's balance issues to vitamin B12 deficiency, noting she walked fine in light but became unstable in darkness because of sensory ataxia. Updated on: Apr 23

1 hours ago

Artificial intelligence (AI) is flattening the jobs market for young people and governments should eliminate National Insurance to make hiring workers more
Business
AI is already leading to fewer jobs for young people

Artificial intelligence (AI) is flattening the jobs market for young people and governments should eliminate National Insurance to make hiring workers more attractive, former prime minister Rishi Sunak has told the BBC. Sunak, now an adviser to AI firm Anthropic and Microsoft

1 hours ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
India-Africa partnership will be message of stability in turbulent world

India-Africa partnership will be message of stability in turbulent world: JaishankarIndia-Africa partnership will be message of stability in turbulent world: Jaishankar Published on: Apr 23, 2026 1:20 PM IST PTI Share via Copy link New Delhi

1 hours ago

Two trains collided in Denmark early Thursday (April 23, 2026), prompting a massive emergency response for what police called a major accident
World
Two trains collide in Denmark

Two trains collided in Denmark early Thursday (April 23, 2026), prompting a massive emergency response for what police called a major accident. The collision occurred around 6.30 a.m. about 40 kilometres (25 miles) north of Copenhagen. It was not immediately clear how many people were injured

1 hours ago

An Indian techie’s viral Reddit post has sparked intense online discussion after he admitted he is considering leaving the US soon after securing a $120
Latest News
I Am Too Depressed

An Indian techie’s viral Reddit post has sparked intense online discussion after he admitted he is considering leaving the US soon after securing a $120,000 (over Rs 1 crore) job offer. While many see such opportunities as a dream come true, he revealed that his battle with depression and

1 hours ago

The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has drafted a new set of regulations for Prepaid Payment Instruments (PPIs)—specifically digital wallets and cards
Latest News
RBI’s major move

The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has drafted a new set of regulations for Prepaid Payment Instruments (PPIs)—specifically digital wallets and cards. A PPI is a payment system wherein funds are pre-loaded and subsequently utilized to make payments

1 hours ago

Voting in the Assembly elections was underway in Tamil Nadu and a part of West Bengal on Thursday. In Tamil Nadu, polling is being held in all of the state’s
Politics
62.1% voter turnout in West Bengal till 1 pm

Voting in the Assembly elections was underway in Tamil Nadu and a part of West Bengal on Thursday. In Tamil Nadu, polling is being held in all of the state’s 234 seats. In West Bengal, voting is being held in 152 of the state’s 294 constituencies. As of 1 pm

1 hours ago

<h4 class=
Life Style
A quick guide for young Indians before meeting someone for the first time

Dating safety 101: A quick guide for young Indians before meeting someone for the first timeMeeting someone new? Here’s what every young Indian should know before planning a date for the first time. Published on: Apr 23, 2026 1:50 PM IST By Anukriti Srivastava Share via Copy link Dating market

1 hours ago

Screens are everywhere. One cannot escape it. From the tiny screen on your wristwatch to phones being an extension of your arm and the laptop being
Latest News
Common Eye Problems Doctors Are Seeing More Frequently in Young Adults

Screens are everywhere. One cannot escape it. From the tiny screen on your wristwatch to phones being an extension of your arm and the laptop being indispensable for work. Binge watching sessions during the weekends are lauded, and ranking high on gaming systems is the newest way to relax

1 hours ago

Cash seizure in Erode sparks protests during Tamil Nadu elections, highlighting concerns over voter bribery and election integrity
Politics
Tamil Nadu elections 2026 live updates

Cash seizure in Erode sparks protests during Tamil Nadu elections, highlighting concerns over voter bribery and election integrity. Explore exclusive interviews with Tamil Nadu political leaders ahead of the 2026 Assembly election to aid informed voter decisions.Voter turnout hourly@2x (1)

1 hours ago

Heatwaves have become a persistent public health concern, especially in cities that retain heat. With rising temperatures and the impact of climate change
Life Style
Everyday Habits That Can Protect You From Dehydration And Heatstroke

Heatwaves have become a persistent public health concern, especially in cities that retain heat. With rising temperatures and the impact of climate change, prolonged exposure to extreme heat can lead to dehydration, heat exhaustion, and even heatstroke if not managed properly

1 hours ago

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.<h4 class=
Technology
boAt Aavante Prime X soundbar launched in India

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.boAt Aavante Prime X soundbar launched in India with 7.1.4 channel Dolby Atmos support - DetailsboAt has introduced the Aavante Prime X soundbar in India

1 hours ago

If you’ve ever looked at a celebrity’s dramatic weight loss and wondered, “How did they do it?
Life Style
Bariatric Surgery Explained

If you’ve ever looked at a celebrity’s dramatic weight loss and wondered, “How did they do it?", you’re not alone. From social media to lifestyle conversations, celebrity body transformations have become a constant talking point. Audiences often speculate about diet plans and fitness

1 hours ago

<h4 class=
World
Pak minister, US envoy discuss efforts for 2nd round of US-Iran talks

Pak minister, US envoy discuss efforts for 2nd round of US-Iran talksPak minister, US envoy discuss efforts for 2nd round of US-Iran talks Published on: Apr 23, 2026 1:57 PM IST PTI Share via Copy link Islamabad, Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi on Thursday met US Charge d'Affaires to Pakistan

1 hours ago

The government on Thursday dismissed media reports suggesting that petrol and diesel prices may be hiked by ₹25-28 a litre soon after assembly elections as
Latest News
Oil Ministry refutes fuel price hike buzz

The government on Thursday dismissed media reports suggesting that petrol and diesel prices may be hiked by ₹25-28 a litre soon after assembly elections as “mischievous and misleading” and said that there no such proposal was under consideration

1 hours ago

<h4 class=
Entertainment
Rajpal Yadav on 10-year age gap with wife Radha

Rajpal Yadav opens up on 10-year age gap with wife Radha: ‘Langoor ko hoor mil gayi…’Rajpal Yadav recently spoke about the over 10-year age difference between him and his wife Radha, saying communication has always been the key for them. Apr 23, 2026

1 hours ago

Gold and Silver Rates In India Today, April 23: In Mumbai, the price of 24-carat gold slips to Rs 1,53,550 per 10 grams, while 22k gold is available at Rs 1,40
Business
Gold, Silver Prices Fall

Gold and Silver Rates In India Today, April 23: In Mumbai, the price of 24-carat gold slips to Rs 1,53,550 per 10 grams, while 22k gold is available at Rs 1,40,750 per 10 grams. Gold and Silver Rates In India Today, April 23: Gold and silver prices fell on April 23

1 hours ago

South Korea pushed back on Thursday against criticism of its business environment by US lawmakers, as a rare spat deepens over Seoul's investigation into
Technology
South Korea ecommerce probe opens rift in US ties

South Korea pushed back on Thursday against criticism of its business environment by US lawmakers, as a rare spat deepens over Seoul's investigation into online retail company Coupang.US-listed Coupang's South Korean arm operates the country's most popular shopping platform

1 hours ago

Anthropic is seeing an extraordinary surge in in secondary markets, with its implied valuation nearing $1 trillion on private marketplace exchange
Technology
Anthropic valuation nears $1 trillion in secondary markets amid investor frenzy

Anthropic is seeing an extraordinary surge in in secondary markets, with its implied valuation nearing $1 trillion on private marketplace exchange , according to a report by digital media platform Business Insider Africa.That places it ahead of rival OpenAI

2 hours ago

The points table doesn’t lie. The correlation between a team’s league position and how well its openers have fared has become too obvious to disregard
Sports
IPL 2026 | Tale at the top — the crests and troughs of willow-wielders

The points table doesn’t lie. The correlation between a team’s league position and how well its openers have fared has become too obvious to disregard. The sides with the most explosive openers — Punjab Kings (strike-rate of 202.88), Sunrisers Hyderabad (182.90), Rajasthan Royals (182.78)

2 hours ago

Iran has hit back at claims made by United States President Donald Trump about saving the lives of women protesters. The response came after Trump said that
Latest News
Iran Takes Dig At US President Over Execution Claim

Iran has hit back at claims made by United States President Donald Trump about saving the lives of women protesters. The response came after Trump said that Iran had agreed not to carry out executions. Iranian officials reportedly denied this and said no such plan ever existed

2 hours ago

Polymarket West Bengal Election: US-based betting site is showing a neck and neck fight between BJP and TMC in the Assembly election
Politics
West Bengal Elections 2026 who will win

Polymarket West Bengal Election: US-based betting site is showing a neck and neck fight between BJP and TMC in the Assembly election. Over two million dollars have been wagered on prediction platforms, indicating global interest. While Indian users are prohibited from participating

2 hours ago

Indian women's cricket captain Harmanpreet Kaur believes the team's recent T20 series defeat to South Africa is a valuable learning experience
Sports
India's mistakes exposed at right time before T20 World Cup

Indian women's cricket captain Harmanpreet Kaur believes the team's recent T20 series defeat to South Africa is a valuable learning experience. This setback occurred before the upcoming T20 World Cup in June. Kaur stated the team can address shortcomings and return stronger

2 hours ago

Former US Secretary of State John Kerry has said that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu repeatedly proposed military action against Iran to successive
World
Netanyahu Proposed Iran War To 3 US Presidents Before Trump

Former US Secretary of State John Kerry has said that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu repeatedly proposed military action against Iran to successive American presidents, but each time, the idea was rejected. Speaking on The Late Show with Stephen Colbert

2 hours ago

Tamil Nadu's Assembly elections are underway. TVK chief Vijay has urged the Election Commission to extend polling by two hours until 8 PM
Politics
Extend polling hours till 8 PM

Tamil Nadu's Assembly elections are underway. TVK chief Vijay has urged the Election Commission to extend polling by two hours until 8 PM. He also requested emergency public transport services. Long queues are reported at polling stations, with the voting process being slow

2 hours ago


Sing Up