Real Madrid midfielder Federico Valverde sustained a head injury after an on-field altercation with teammate Aurelien Tchouameni. The club has opened disciplinary proceedings against both players. Valverde downplayed the incident, stating no punches were thrown and he accidentally hit a table
Like a ray of sunshine on a cloudy day, the 2026 Eurovision Song Contest has arrived to dispel the gloom of a weary world. With 35 countries taking part, it's the most compact competition since 2003 - due to a partial boycott over Israel's presence
AMOLED smartwatches have become much more popular thanks to their vibrant displays, sleek designs and premium feel. These smartwatches offer better visibility outdoors while also being more battery efficient. It is no longer just premium brands like Apple and Samsung using AMOLED displays in their
Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Worried about water quality? These high-rated RO purifiers now start at just ₹5,999Stop worrying about water safety. These high-rated RO purifiers from Kent, Aquaguard
Suvendu Adhikari will be sworn in as West Bengal's first BJP Chief Minister on Saturday after the party's decisive victory in the Assembly elections, securing 207 seats. Union Ministers and Chief Ministers from other BJP-ruled states arrived in Kolkata for the ceremony
How Indian states are using FIRs to reframe wage-related workers’ disputes as crimes
In April, a series of protests by contract workers in the industrial belts of Manesar and Noida in the National Capital Region were met with a wave of First Information Reports that list several provisions of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita.
At first glance, these FIRs appear to document incidents of disorder – unlawful assembly, rioting, damage to property and attacks on police personnel. A closer reading reveals that they do far more than describe events. They actively reframe a wage-related labour dispute as a matter of public order and criminality.
Labour protests and strikes have been rolling across India since early this year – from Barauni in Bihar, to Panipat, Faridabad and Manesar in Haryana and Noida in Uttar Pradesh.
Different industries, different states, different employers but the same complaints: workers pushed to a breaking point by stagnant wages, rising prices, 12-hour shifts paid as eight, precarious employment conditions and a cost-of-living crisis sharpened by the cooking gas shortage.
What connects the protests is the condition of being a contract worker in India in 2026 – formally employed, substantively unprotected, and now, when they protest, criminally liable.
In Noida, protests by workers in April were first ignored and then met with prohibitory orders and mass detentions under Section 170 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. Nearly 1,100 workers were detained between April 11 and April 16. They were held in Luksar jail for several days, even though the provision is meant for preventive detention, not punishment.
Alongside this, at least ten FIRs were registered, invoking a wide range of serious criminal charges. The workers’ protests were not negotiated. They were policed out of existence.
In the FIRs, wage protest becomes unlawful assembly. Collective bargaining becomes rioting. Workers become a mob engaged in stone-pelting, whipped up by outside instigators. A demand for fair wages becomes a threat.
This is not sloppy drafting. It is intentional. The moment a labour action is classified as a public order problem, an entirely different state machinery becomes available. Labour law requires conciliation, adjudication, a process. Criminal law requires none of that. It only requires an FIR.
A careful reading of the ten FIRs in Noida makes clear what is missing.
There is no mention of the state’s failure to implement or revise minimum wages, despite a legal obligation to revise them every five years. There is nothing about women earning Rs 6,000-Rs 9,000 a month for ten- to 12-hour shifts in garment factories without basic facilities such as toilets. The LPG crisis does not find mention, nor does the fact that workers often arrive at their factories having eaten nothing.
These omissions are not an oversight. A worker who is responding rationally to hunger, fuel poverty and wage theft is not a rioter. To make her a rioter, you must first make her material conditions invisible. That’s the function of the FIRs.
What the FIRs cannot say – and what mainstream narratives of labour unrest have consistently refused to say is the obvious thing: that when the industrial relations system provides no space for workers to articulate and resolve their grievances, what you get is a pressure-cooker bursting. The FIR criminalises the explosion. It says nothing about the cause.
The FIR attributes the strikes to unions and external organisations, implying that without this outside agitation, workers would have stayed quiet. This is false and deliberately so.
The protests in April were, by all accounts, spontaneous, spreading factory by factory. But the instigation framing strips workers of political agency – recasting them as manipulated rather than aggrieved. This provides the authorities with a legal handle. If unions organised this, you can go after organisers. They can be arrested at protest sites, picked up from their homes at night or placed under house arrest. That is precisely what happened.
Trade union activity in response to a workers’ crisis is a democratic right that remains protected in Indian law. The FIR does not acknowledge this. Long before any court reaches a conclusion, the strike has been broken, the workers have gone back, lives have been destroyed and the lesson delivered forcefully.
The FIR narrative sequence runs: workers assemble → police warn → workers disobey → force is used. It reads like a neutral account of events. It is not. It is a pre-emptive justification for everything that comes after – the lathi-charge, the detentions, the arrests from homes, the FIRs.
By the time anyone asks whether the force was proportionate, whether management or police had escalated first, whether the workers who were beaten and arrested had done anything beyond standing in the street, the answer has already been written. They disobeyed. Therefore, what happened to them was restoration of order.
The FIRs in Manesar and Noida did not emerge from nowhere. They emerged from a decade-long restructuring of the relationship between Indian labour law and Indian capital, a restructuring that reached its logical conclusion in November 2025, when four Labour Codes replaced 29 older laws and were implemented nationwide. Those codes weakened collective bargaining, expanded contractualisation and made hire-and-fire easier. What they took away from workers in legal protection, criminal law is now being asked to enforce in its place.
This is the pattern. Weaken the labour court, strengthen the police station.
This analysis is not new. In 2015, I had noted the same pattern during the unionisation battle of Maruti Suzuki workers in Manesar – industrial disputes being converted into law-and-order problems through deliberate management provocation, police deployed before any violence had occurred, and a labour department that recused itself while the criminal machinery moved in.
The FIRs at Manesar and Noida in 2026 are the Maruti Manesar protest playbook, updated.
Collective labour action is first rendered unlawful through assembly provisions, then escalated into violence through rioting and injury charges, then consolidated as organised criminality through conspiracy – and, in the most serious FIRs, attempt to murder and mischief by fire, carrying life imprisonment.
The material conditions that precipitate protest appear nowhere in the legal record. The workers’ demands do not appear. Their names, often, do not appear. What appears is the crowd, the mob, the unnamed mass, the conspiracy.
The result, taken together, is a shift in how labour itself is governed, less as a subject of rights and negotiation, and more as an object of surveillance, control, and, when necessary, criminal sanction. The FIR is the instrument of that shift. That is what the FIRs do not say – and that is exactly why they matter.
Rakhi Sehgal is an independent labour researcher with over two decades of association with the trade union movement.
Source: Scroll
Related Posts: Can a homebuyer approach the Karnataka RERA for apartment rental disputes Workers should receive minimum wage of Rs 800 Factory workers protest over wage hike in Noida How India’s landscape architects reframe nature NHRC issues notice to 3 states in cough syrup related death case Chhattisgarh women’s panel seeks FIRs against Bajrang Dal workers for ‘harassing’ nuns Wage-weighted Trump Administration Plans Wage-Based H-1B Visa Selection TMC MP O'Brien demands legally enforceable basic minimum wage for workers UK minimum wage is raising youth unemployment
The launch event was simultaneously observed across 11 other locations of the Employees’ State Insurance Corporation (ESIC) hospitals nationwide. New Delhi: Labour Minister Dr Mansukh Mandaviya on Thursday launched a nationwide annual health check-up initiative for all workers aged 40 and above
Just now
Ameesha Patel takes dig at Bollywood’s ‘fake PR games’, slams younger actresses for buying ‘number 1’ tagAmeesha Patel took to social media to criticise the growing PR culture among the younger generation of female actors in the film industry. May 9, 2026
Just now
The Directorate of Education (DoE), Delhi, has released an academic plan for government schools during the upcoming summer vacation. As per the official circular, all government schools will observe summer holidays from May 11 to June 30, 2026, spanning 51 days.The Directorate of Education (DoE)
Just now
William Golding's story of boys descending into violence is a 20th-Century classic. Now Adolescence writer Jack Thorne is behind a new TV version speaking to a rancorous world. William Golding's Lord of the Flies, his classic novel about boys who turn to savage violence after a plane crash strands
Just now
Arsenal manager Mikel Arteta has told his players and fans to "stay present and live the moment" as the club prepare for a huge month in which they could secure a Premier League and Champions League double. The Gunners are five points clear of second-placed Manchester City, who have a game in hand
Just now
Latchiya Jananayaga Katchi (LJK) Party has submitted a letter to the Lieutenant Governor backing NR Congress chief N Rangaswamy for the Chief Ministerial post in Puducherry. Rangaswamy, who has emerged victorious in the assembly polls, met the Lieutenant Governor and staked his claim to form the
Just now
The US economy created 115,000 jobs in April as businesses kept hiring despite the economic fallout from the US-Israel war in Iran. The increase was stronger than expected, with the total almost twice as much as economists had forecast. The data, published by the US Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS)
Just now
India is actively seeking a greater influence in setting international standards for the burgeoning space sector. As global experts convened in New Delhi for a crucial ISO meeting, officials highlighted India's policy reforms and the establishment of IN-SPACe as key drivers for its enhanced role
Just now
In April, a series of protests by contract workers in the industrial belts of Manesar and Noida in the National Capital Region were met with a wave of First Information Reports that list several provisions of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. At first glance
Just now
European airlines can use US-grade jet fuel to ease potential shortages caused by the US-Israel war with Iran, the EU and two major international airline bodies have suggested. The International Air Transport Association (IATA) has suggested that wider international acceptance of US-grade jet fuel
Just now
Nintendo reportedly raised the price of its Switch 2 console, even as its financial outlook had come in weaker than expected. Nintendo has set pricing for its next-generation console and outlined a softer sales outlook in its latest earnings statement, according to CNBC
Just now
Sugar-free products with sugar. ‘Real’ juices with artificial ingredients. Misleading food ads are fuelling a public health crisis in India. Help Scroll expose the systemic failure. Support our investigation.Sugar-free products with sugar. ‘Real’ juices with artificial ingredients
Just now
Indian seafarer dies in ‘unfortunate’ incident in the Gulf, says Dubai consulateThe consulate said that they are in touch with the owner of the ship and are ascertaining further details. Updated on: May 09, 2026 7:36 AM IST ANI Share via Copy link The Consulate General of India in Dubai on
Just now
Accidentally recharged the wrong number on Jio? Don’t worry, users can now request a refund through the MyJio app within a limited time, and the money may be returned within hours after verification. Accidentally recharging the wrong mobile number is a common mistake
Just now
China has acknowledged for the first time that it extended technical support to Pakistan during its four-day conflict with India in May 2025, the South China Morning Post reported. In an interview with Chinese state broadcaster CCTV aired on Thursday, Zhang Heng
Just now
Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Top load vs. front load washing machines in 2026: The ultimate guide to not regret your purchaseThink a Front Load is always better? In 2026
Just now
Canada’s immigration point system was established in 1967 to respond to historic racism and nationality bias. Granting points for age, education, official language skills, Canadian work experience and family ties, the current Comprehensive Ranking System (CRS) grades applicants for permanent
Just now
Christian McCaffrey, Olivia Culpo share big personal news on her 34th birthday: 'Best gift'"Best birthday gift. Baby #2 coming soon,” Olivia Culpo wrote in the caption. Updated on: May 09, 2026 6:05 AM IST By Vaishnavi Vaidyanathan Share via Copy link Olivia Culpo and Christian McCaffrey have
Just now
Finn Allen's sensational unbeaten century powered Kolkata Knight Riders to their fourth consecutive victory, defeating Delhi Capitals by eight wickets. Chasing 143, Allen anchored the innings with a blistering 100 off 47 balls, guiding Kolkata to an easy win
Just now
Tenant says ‘actual cost of finding a flat in Gurgaon was ₹3,52,000’, explains whyThe tenant shared a list of costs incurred in searching for a house. It included everything from brokerage fees to security deposits. Published on: May 09, 2026 6:50 AM IST By Trisha Sengupta Share via Copy link
Just now
Manchester United captain Bruno Fernandes has not come close to winning the Premier League or Champions League since joining the club in 2020. He did lift a couple of domestic cups under Erik ten Hag - and if United finish third this season, it will be a position they have only bettered once during
Just now
‘Fun and stressful’ is how singer Dhee describes her working relationship with music composer stepdad Santhosh NarayananIn an interview with Hindustan Times, Dhee talks about her stepfather, music composer Santhosh Narayanan, growing her career with him and more. May 9, 2026
Just now
Love Horoscope Today for May 9, 2026: This is a beautiful time for softness, healing, and emotional honestyLove Horoscope Today: This week emphasizes observation and honest communication in love. Published on: May 09, 2026 7:30 AM IST By Kishori Sud Share via Copy link Aries Love Energy: Slow love
Just now
IShowSpeed randomly meets Fanum in Dominican Republic; viral video sparks chaosWhile touring the Dominican Republic, IShowSpeed accidentally runs into fellow streamer Fanum, creating a viral moment. Published on: May 09, 2026 7:34 AM IST Edited by HT US Desk Share via Copy link Viral streamer
Just now
Lionel Messi finally breaks silence on long-standing 'sporting rivalry' with Cristiano Ronaldo: 'Nothing personal'Messi describes his rivalry with Ronaldo as a beautiful sporting rivalry, born from their competition at Barcelona and Real Madrid. Updated on: May 09
Just now
U.S. and Iran's efforts to end their conflict stall amid renewed clashes in the Gulf. A U.S. intelligence assessment suggests Iran can withstand a naval blockade for months, while Tehran accuses Washington of breaching a ceasefire. The U.S. also imposed new sanctions on individuals and companies
Just now
As innovation evolves beyond industry boundaries, the AI Special Product / Innovation category at the ET Most Innovative AI Product Awards 2026 recognises breakthrough solutions creating cross-industry impact through originality, scalability, transformative thinking
Just now
