Among all crops, sunflower seed saw the highest absolute increase in MSP at Rs 622 per quintal, followed by cotton at Rs 557, nigerseed at Rs 515 and sesamum
Business

Among all crops, sunflower seed saw the highest absolute increase in MSP at Rs 622 per quintal, followed by cotton at Rs 557, nigerseed at Rs 515 and sesamum at Rs 500. The Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA), chaired by Prime Minister Narendra Modi

Israel's ruling coalition on Wednesday submitted a proposal to dissolve parliament to pave the way for early elections as Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu
World

Israel's ruling coalition on Wednesday submitted a proposal to dissolve parliament to pave the way for early elections as Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu came under mounting attack from ultra-Orthodox parties. Netanyahu has governed Israel longer than any other prime minister -- more than 18

<strong>Sugar-free products with sugar. ‘Real’ juices with artificial ingredients. Misleading food ads are fuelling a public health crisis in India
Latest News

Sugar-free products with sugar. ‘Real’ juices with artificial ingredients. Misleading food ads are fuelling a public health crisis in India. Help Scroll expose the systemic failure. Support our investigation.Sugar-free products with sugar. ‘Real’ juices with artificial ingredients

A court in Kolkata on Wednesday sent Bangla Pokkho chief Garga Chatterjee to three days in police custody till May 16, Kausik Maiti
World

A court in Kolkata on Wednesday sent Bangla Pokkho chief Garga Chatterjee to three days in police custody till May 16, Kausik Maiti, a member of the pro-Bengali advocacy group, told Scroll. This came a day after Chatterjee was arrested by the Kolkata Police for allegedly spreading misinformation

<h4 class=
Entertainment

'Everyone was doubtful': Saif Ali Khan says Omkara convinced Bollywood folks 'who otherwise think I can't do it'Saif Ali Khan won awards and acclaim for his portrayal of rustic gangster Langda Tyagi in Vishal Bhardwaj's Omkara. May 14, 2026, 07:47:59 IST Written by Abhimanyu Mathur Share via Copy

Hearts' McInnes rages at 'disgusting' Celtic penalty

Posted By: Anita Mamgai Posted On: May 14, 2026Share Article
Hearts' McInnes rages at 'disgusting' Celtic penalty
Figure caption, Late VAR penalty denies Hearts

Hearts' McInnes rages at 'disgusting' Celtic penalty

Hearts head coach Derek McInnes says his side are "up against everybody" after a "disgusting" 99th-minute penalty winner for Celtic ensured the Scottish Premiership title race would go to a final-day decider on Saturday.

With league leaders Hearts cruising to a 3-0 win over Falkirk, the concession of a late equaliser at Motherwell looked like leaving Celtic three points back before Hearts go to Glasgow on Saturday.

However, deep into injury time, video assistant referee (VAR) Andrew Dallas called referee John Beaton to the pitchside monitor after Motherwell's Sam Nicholson challenged for a high ball.

Replays seemed to show the ball hitting Nicholson's head, rather than his raised hand, but Beaton awarded a spot-kick which Kelechi Iheanacho converted to snatch a 3-2 win.

Former England striker Gary Lineker wrote on X that it "might be the worst VAR decision I've seen... extraordinary given the significance" and McInnes fumed at the call afterwards.

"When you heard Celtic had a 96th-minute penalty going to VAR, you just assume they get it," the incandescent Hearts head coach told Sky Sports.

It's disgusting. We're up against it, we're up against everybody. I don't think it's a penalty. It's so poor and it looks as though [Celtic] have been given it. They have been very fortunate.

Had Celtic dropped points, Hearts could have afforded to lose by two goals at Celtic Park on Saturday and still be crowned champions for the first time since 1960.

Now, though, they must avoid defeat if they are to become the first side outside Celtic or Rangers to win the Scottish top flight in four decades.

"It's going to the last game. We're delighted to be part of it," McInnes added.

To do it, we're going to have to go and get a positive result. I'm looking forward to it already, there'll be no feeling sorry for ourselves. What a game it's going to be.

The handball law is confusing at the best of times, but one factor has always outweighed any other.

If the arm is above shoulder height, a player is considered to be taking a massive risk and there is a much greater chance of being penalised.

As Nicholson found out on Wednesday, if the VAR thinks the ball has touched his hand or arm at head height, then it is likely to be given as a penalty.

Some will argue that the arm was in that position only because he was in a duel with Celtic's Auston Trusty, but that would carry minimal weight.

But there is one big problem.

Can we be certain it did hit the arm at all? And if there is doubt, how could it be a clear and obvious error for the VAR to tell the referee he should award a match-winning penalty?

The way the ball flew back out of play for a throw-in had to suggest it came off Nicholson's head, so the VAR must think it came off his hand at the same time too.

It just seems exceptionally harsh to punish this with a penalty as the ball brushing the arm had no material effect on where the ball ended up. That was all about the power generated by the head.

The angles shown to referee John Beaton at the monitor looked far from conclusive, yet he only needed 20 seconds to make his decision. The VAR, Andrew Dallas, must have spoken with great certainty.

But it leaves a sour taste at a crucial moment in the title race.

Suddenly, it is tilted into Celtic's favour thanks to a questionable, stoppage-time VAR intervention.

While McInnes was enraged, Motherwell counterpart Jen Berthel Askou was bemused at the award against his team.

"The big question is what are we even doing here," the Dane said when asked about the incident. "I'm in total shock. I thought I had seen it all this year, but apparently I haven't. It's shocking and it's a shame for the game.

Seeing the footage, I can't see any way that can be a penalty. I can't see it touch his hand and, even if it has, it's because his arm has been pushed into it. It's a crazy thing to be part of and the game deserved better than that.

Perhaps unsurpringly, Celtic manager Martin O'Neill didn't agree with their assessment.

I have seen it back very, very briefly... it's a handball," he said. "It looks as if it's also an elbow to the side of the head as well. VAR have asked the referee to come over and he had no hesitation in giving the penalty.

Similarly to Lineker, former Scotland striker Don Hutchison deemed it "the worst decision of all time". Not many disagreed.

Former Rangers striker Kris Boyd pointed to the failure not to award Hearts a penalty in their draw against Motherwell on Saturday despite a VAR review, as well as the the decision not to send off Celtic's Alistair Johnston during their derby win over Rangers the following day.

It clearly hits his head," Boyd said on Sky Sports. "Another dubious call that goes in Celtic's favour. There will be serious questions asked about it.

Former Hearts midfielder Michael Stewart said on Sportscene that to overturn the on-field decision of no penalty was "extraordinary" and Hearts' record goalscorer John Robertson added: "His hand is up, but look at the power he gets on it - that's a head."

A VAR intervention in England has been a talking point for the past few days after West Ham were denied a late equaliser against Arsenal after a lengthy check.

"It's a disgrace," former Hearts striker Ryan Stevenson said, referring to the Celtic penalty. "VAR took six minutes in the West Ham game because everyone understood how big a decision it was.

John Beaton was at the monitor for what, 20 seconds?

There were some dissenting voices, albeit from those with Celtic allegiences.

Former Celtic captain Scott Brown conceded on Sportscene it was "harsh" but said Nicholson "runs the risk as soon as his hand is up there".

And ex-Celtic goalkeeper Pat Bonner was even more explicit. "The defender jumps with his left arm up and his fist is right on his head as the ball lands," he said.

Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


For two successive years, Gujarat’s peak fishing season has been struck by war. Last summer, the conflict between India and Pakistan prompted the Gujarat
World
Gujarat fisherfolk in crisis after two summers of war

For two successive years, Gujarat’s peak fishing season has been struck by war. Last summer, the conflict between India and Pakistan prompted the Gujarat fisheries department to recall boats out at sea. This summer, as fishermen race to haul up catch before the monsoon fishing ban kicks in

Just now

Sharing files between Android and iPhone is set to get easier, with Google announcing support for more devices getting Quick Share support for iPhones
Technology
Google confirms OnePlus

Sharing files between Android and iPhone is set to get easier, with Google announcing support for more devices getting Quick Share support for iPhones. The feature, which was first announced by Google last year, was only available to Pixel 10 users in the beginning but is now moving to OnePlus

Just now

India raises gold and silver import duty to 15 percent from 6 percent, jewellery stocks like Kalyan Jewellers and Titan fall, MCX gold and silver hit upper
Latest News
Gold Duty Hike Hits Jewellery Shares

India raises gold and silver import duty to 15 percent from 6 percent, jewellery stocks like Kalyan Jewellers and Titan fall, MCX gold and silver hit upper circuits Jewellery stocks came under selling pressure on Wednesday after the Centre raised import duty on gold

Just now

Amazon has announced an expansion of health and insurance benefits for nearly 90,000 delivery associates across its operations network in India
Business
Amazon expands health coverage for 90

Amazon has announced an expansion of health and insurance benefits for nearly 90,000 delivery associates across its operations network in India. The benefits provide Outpatient Department (OPD) coverage for routine medical expenses, hospitalization support for inpatient care

Just now

<h4 class=
Latest News
Will regularise 2

Will regularise 2.3 million plots in B’luru: Dy CMKarnataka launches "Bhoo Guarantee" to regularize properties in Bengaluru, reducing conversion fees and easing building violations for 100 days. Published on: May 14, 2026 7:54 AM IST By Arun Dev

Just now

Phil Foden's magical first-half assist and welcome return to form was the catalyst that </b>Manchester City</b> desperately needed to maintain
Sports
Assist of the season

Phil Foden's magical first-half assist and welcome return to form was the catalyst that Manchester City desperately needed to maintain their challenge in this season's fascinating Premier League title race. The 25-year-old set up the first two goals in Wednesday night's comfortable 3-0 victory over

Just now

The United States Department of Justice on Tuesday filed a criminal case against two firms based in Chennai and Singapore, and an Indian citizen
World
Baltimore ship crash

The United States Department of Justice on Tuesday filed a criminal case against two firms based in Chennai and Singapore, and an Indian citizen, in connection with six deaths caused by a cargo ship colliding with a bridge in Baltimore in March 2024

Just now

<h4 class=
Latest News
HC questions ‘unofficial’ deployment of 15 cops for Harbhajan’s security

HC questions ‘unofficial’ deployment of 15 cops for Harbhajan’s securityThe court reiterated its April 30 order and directed the Punjab government to ensure the safety of the former cricketer and his family members residing in Jalandhar. Published on: May 14

Just now

<h4 class=
Sports
Brandon Clarke parents

Brandon Clarke parents: 5 things to know about ex-Grizzlies star's family amid sudden deathThe NBA mourns Brandon Clarke, who died at 29. His supportive family includes mother Whitney and stepfather Bryan. His birth father is Steve Clarke. Updated on: May 14

Just now

Google has unveiled Gemini Intelligence, a new AI-powered experience designed to make Android devices smarter, more proactive, and deeply personalised
Technology
Google introduces Gemini intelligence to make android more proactive and personal

Google has unveiled Gemini Intelligence, a new AI-powered experience designed to make Android devices smarter, more proactive, and deeply personalised. The update brings advanced automation, intelligent form filling, natural voice refinement, and custom widget creation directly into Android devices

Just now

The CBSE Class 12 board exam results were announced on Wednesday, with a senior official confirming that more than 85 per cent of students passed this year
Education
How does CBSE's digital evaluation system OSM differ from traditional approach

The CBSE Class 12 board exam results were announced on Wednesday, with a senior official confirming that more than 85 per cent of students passed this year. However, the overall pass percentage declined by more than three percentage points compared to the previous year

Just now

<h4 class=
Education
CBSE Class 12 Supplementary Exam 2026 date announced

CBSE Class 12 Supplementary Exam 2026 date announced, LOC submission begins on June 2CBSE Class 12 Supplementary Exam 2026 date has been announced. The exam will be held in July. The LOC submission will begin on June 2, 2026. Updated on: May 13

Just now

<h4 class=
Business
Top-up vs Super Top-up

Existing health insurance cover is inadequate? Top-up vs Super Top-up – Which one should you take?With a top-up or super top-up plan, an individual can significantly increase their health insurance cover without a substantial increase in premium amount. Updated on: May 13

Just now

CBSE Class 12 Rechecking Process 2026: Are you not satisfied with your scores in Class 12th results. Students unhappy with their scores in the Central Board of
Latest News
CBSE Class 12 rechecking 2026

CBSE Class 12 Rechecking Process 2026: Are you not satisfied with your scores in Class 12th results. Students unhappy with their scores in the Central Board of Secondary Education Class 12 board exams will soon get a chance to request a fresh review of their answer sheets. Under the revised process

Just now

Buying a smartwatch in 2026 is no longer about choosing between Apple and “everything else.” Battery life, fitness tracking, offline features
Latest News
5 Feature-packed smartwatches that cost less than Apple Watch Ultra

Buying a smartwatch in 2026 is no longer about choosing between Apple and “everything else.” Battery life, fitness tracking, offline features, and cross-platform support now matter more than logo loyalty. That shift is pushing many buyers to look beyond the Apple Watch Ultra series

Just now

<h4 class=
Business
Flexi-cap or multi-cap funds

Flexi-cap funds lead equity category for 8th month: How do they differ from multi-cap funds, and which one to choose?Flexi-cap and multi-cap funds give investors exposure to all market categories across market capitalisation. Updated on: May 13

Just now

<h4 class=
Latest News
Pune woman says restaurant staff sent late-night texts after visit

Pune woman claims restaurant staff got her number through QR menu, sent late-night texts: 'Serious harassment'The woman shared her experience on Instagram, claiming the incident took place after she visited a restaurant on Pune’s FC Road on April 28. Updated on: May 13

Just now

Higher ticket prices for air travellers in Europe are
Business
Higher Europe air fares

Higher ticket prices for air travellers in Europe are "inevitable" because of the high cost of jet fuel, according to the head of the International Air Transport Association. Although some airlines have cut their European fares recently because of a lack of demand

Just now

<h4 class=
Horoscope
Love Horoscope Today for May 14

Love Horoscope Today for May 14, 2026: Letting go of emotional chaos might be the very thing that invites real stabilityToday, a softer emotional energy surrounds your heart, highlighting the importance of small moments. Embrace tenderness rather than overthinking feelings. Published on: May 14

Just now

Chief Ministers of Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) ruled states have come forward and followed Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s austerity call by reducing the
Latest News
BJP CMs follow PM Modi’s appeal – CM Yogi

Chief Ministers of Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) ruled states have come forward and followed Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s austerity call by reducing the number of vehicles in their cavalcade, in a bid to save energy resources. PM Modi, in a public address on Sunday

Just now

<h4 class=
Latest News
Supreme Court petition seeks court-monitored re-test

NEET 2026 leak: Supreme Court petition seeks court-monitored re-test, replace exam conducting agencyThe petition also requests replacing the exam conducting agency and bringing reforms to conduct future competitive examinations. Published on: May 14, 2026 7:38 AM IST By Abraham Thomas

Just now

HPCL says its board has recommended a final dividend of Rs 19.25 per equity share having a face value of Rs 10 each for FY26. <strong>HPCL Dividend
Latest News
HPCL Announces Final Dividend Of Rs 19

HPCL says its board has recommended a final dividend of Rs 19.25 per equity share having a face value of Rs 10 each for FY26. HPCL Dividend FY26: Shares of Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd (HPCL) climbed over 2 per cent during Wednesday’s trade after the state-run oil marketing company

Just now

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.<h4 class=
Technology
7 Powerful mixer grinders under ₹7

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Tired of slow grinding? These 1000W mixer grinders under ₹7,000 deliver better resultsLooking for a powerful mixer grinder under ₹7,000? These 1000W picks handle tough grinding

Just now

Tamil Nadu Chief Minister C Joseph Vijay secured a trust vote on Wednesday. His government received 144 votes in favour. The opposition DMK staged a walkout
Politics
Vijay government wins Tamil Nadu trust vote with 144 ayes amid Opposition walkout

Tamil Nadu Chief Minister C Joseph Vijay secured a trust vote on Wednesday. His government received 144 votes in favour. The opposition DMK staged a walkout, criticising the TVK government's functioning. Udhayanidhi Stalin questioned the TVK's majority and alleged outside support

Just now

Hearts head coach Derek McInnes says his side are
Sports
Hearts' McInnes rages at 'disgusting' Celtic penalty

Hearts head coach Derek McInnes says his side are "up against everybody" after a "disgusting" 99th-minute penalty winner for Celtic ensured the Scottish Premiership title race would go to a final-day decider on Saturday. With league leaders Hearts cruising to a 3-0 win over Falkirk

Just now

The Congress party will announce its Kerala chief minister on Thursday. This decision follows a meeting between party president Mallikarjun Kharge and Rahul
Politics
Mallikarjun Kharge and Rahul Gandhi hold talks

The Congress party will announce its Kerala chief minister on Thursday. This decision follows a meeting between party president Mallikarjun Kharge and Rahul Gandhi. The announcement comes amid internal discussions and pressure from allies. A poster campaign in Wayanad has added to the political

Just now

Odd-looking shoes that are hybrids of the practical and the fashionable are everywhere. From the five-toed sneaker to the snoafer
Life Style
Why 'ugly shoes' are taking 2026 by storm

Odd-looking shoes that are hybrids of the practical and the fashionable are everywhere. From the five-toed sneaker to the snoafer, footwear never looked so awkward. What's the appeal? For some people shoes are an afterthought. The more inconspicuous the better. For others

Just now


Sing Up