For a long time people dreamt of having a Nokia phone on Android, which did happen. We also got the Windows Phone a while back, which now is part of people's memories. But what if we tell you about a phone that not only runs Android and Linux but Windows 11 as well? Yes
Brooklyn Beckham vs Family Controversy: The video references Brooklyn Beckham's recent Instagram post, in which he broke his silence about his estrangement from his parents. Los Angeles: Cruz Beckham has publicly acknowledged his family's ongoing rift by liking an Instagram Reel that pokes fun at
There is a distinct rhythm to the evolution of Silicon Valley unicorns, a trajectory as predictable as a Greek tragedy. Act One is the Promethean phase: a charismatic founder offers fire to the masses, promising that this time, the technology is too pure, too transformative
KERALA LOTTERY RESULT Friday 23-01-2026 LIVE: Suvarna keralam SK-37 lottery is one of the 7 lucky draws held once in a week. The Kerala Lottery "Suvarna Keralam SK-37" lottery draw is conducted today on January 23. Every lottery has an alphanumeric code to identify it
Since the end of World War II, the U.S. has established a global military network consisting of around 750 bases in roughly 80 countries. While the U.S. government has characterised this presence as a stabilising force, the local populations have often paid for the military's presence with
From compliance to courage: bell hooks and the politics of teaching to transgress
From compliance to courage: bell hooks and the politics of teaching to transgress Premium
The idea that classrooms can be radical spaces—where solidarity, critique, and consciousness take root—was, for me, the most appealing promise of becoming a teacher. I first encountered bell hooks's Teaching to Transgress at the start of my academic career in India, while grappling with a question-how might Sociology be taught to students who have been trained to see ‘the social' either as an abstract entity in need of policy, infrastructure and governance fixes, or as a set of ‘problems' happening to others. The challenge was heightened by hooks's insistence that classrooms could also be spaces of joy, humor, and deep critique—because that, she argued, is what freedom looks like.
hooks was convinced that transgressions in classroom spaces are a movement against and beyond boundaries–where critique, excitement, and pleasure can co-exist. For her, true learning required students and professors to resist complicity in fear: fear of extra work, fear of risk, or fear of non-compliance when unorthodox teaching methods break away from rigid lesson plans and prescribed course goals.
hooks emphasized that for classrooms to become spaces of freedom, students are not the only ones burdened with the responsibility of sharing, learning, and growing; rather, it is far more productive when professors bring narratives of their experiences into classroom discussions to illuminate the understanding of academic material. This shared sense of vulnerability, according to hooks, is crucial in building students as conscientious thinkers who are unafraid to live life fully and deeply.
More importantly, a transgressive pedagogical approach exposes the insidious logic underlying neoliberal, market-driven education systems. As such, neoliberalism, as scholars argue, is an economic system marked by increased privatisation, polarisation of wealth, shrinking public institutions, and aggressive individualism. One of the most powerful terms legitimising the corporatisation of universities in the neoliberal regime is the business notion of stakeholders—those who are assumed to have a stake in education. Framed this way, students are positioned as stakeholders, or more precisely, powerful consumers, rather than co-creators of knowledge.
The implications are stark: low student enrolment in a course, or waning interest in an entire discipline, is quickly read as evidence of its irrelevance. Universities operating on stakeholder logics are thus swift to declare disciplines as dead, often leading to their demise or, in more optimistic cases, their merger with numerically buoyant and profitable fields (for example, think of Sociology or History being folded into Psychology). This same logic, however, also strips students of their cultural and critical citizenship. In such systems, student-led protests are not seen as democratic expressions but as disruptions to the market order, and are therefore suppressed, disallowing young people from enacting their democratic rights within a supposedly free country.
Why is this a problem, one may ask? First, it assaults the freedoms of both students and professors who dare to break away from the stakeholder mould. Second, it renders intellectual risk-taking—a hallmark of free, radical thought—a sunk cost, where compliance is rewarded and courage disavowed. It ushers in a misdirected higher education system dominated by education entrepreneurs and corporate-inspired administrators, whose priorities are governed by evidence-based metrics of enrolment and profit. In such cultures, the obsession with approvals—whether for course design, evaluations, or even learning goals—ends up trading genuine academic freedom for corporate efficiency, breeding mistrust and mediocrity.
This is no minor concern. Since private higher education institutions currently make up over 40% of the Indian higher education sector. If the ethical task of questioning inequalities—a responsibility that lies at the heart of several non-profitable disciplines—continues to be undermined, must we conclude that higher education in the country has suffered a frontal blow?
How might we overcome this travesty? Remembering bell hooks and Paulo Freire—both revolutionary thinkers of pedagogy—offers a path forward. They compel us to move, in both theory and practice, beyond reformist fixes. Instead, they call on students and professors alike to remain politically conscious and vigilant, so that our liberatory dreams are not flattened by market logics and performance metrics. This is not a nostalgic plea to return to some imagined good old days—for there is no such thing.
To be sure, academic jobs in privatised university systems are no longer the comfortable havens of free thought and coffee-house debates. Instead, academic life is increasingly defined by precarious transactions: crushing workloads, the devaluation of teaching in favor of ever-narrower visions of research excellence, tenure and appraisal decisions tethered to student evaluations, the casualisation of labor through low-paid adjunct positions, and an expectation of total allegiance to institutional norms and work practices.
How, then, can one practice the liberatory logic of education as freedom within such institutions? Would this not risk turning us into what Sara Ahmed, in her compelling feminist critique of killjoys, calls “willful bad subjects”—those non-compliant figures willing to unsettle other people's (false) happiness by exposing oppressive structures? The answer, I believe, lies in embracing a process that is necessarily slow, messy, and yet urgent.
Since resisting the brute force of neoliberalism in education is not an endpoint but an ongoing, unfinished process, summoning the courage to transgress becomes a necessary starting point. Positioned on the front lines of the classroom, professors are uniquely situated to practice radical pedagogy—through teach-ins, debates, public syllabi, collaborative zines, and even hashtags. But transgression also extends beyond classroom walls: it calls for creating spaces of knowledge production with the wider public, as writers, poets, and innovators, and in the ordinary rhythms of everyday life, in kitchens, clinics, hair salons, and bookstores. And more importantly, bringing unapologetic joy back into the classrooms.
In hooks' radical imagination of the classroom, joy is not an antithesis of discipline and serious scholarship. Rather, it is a step towards liberation. She urged us to place eros at the heart of classroom interactions. This eros is not sexual, but an attentiveness to the body as part of the whole self—voice, tone, touch, posture, glance—valued alongside the mind. To truly imagine classrooms as spaces of freedom, we must move beyond the traditional mind–body dualism and embrace eros as a vital, enlivening force that shapes pedagogical relationships.
It is no easy task. The path to transformative pedagogies will be met with institutional resistance stemming largely from the heavy weight of market-driven logics of education, the tyranny of ranking metrics, and an entrenched tendency to gag critiques of prescribed structures. As the country marked its cherished August 15th with promises and viral tweets, it became more urgent than ever to summon the courage to transgress. To cancel the very possibility of transgression within our universities and classrooms is to wield a weapon of mass subjugation in the hands of suffocating mediocrity. The question is: can we afford such a risk?
(Tannistha Samanta is an academic based out of Pune. She is currently a Senior Research Fellow with the College for Social Sciences and the Humanities, Universitäts-Allianz Ruhr, Germany.)
Published - August 20, 2025 06:39 pm IST
education / teaching and learning / students / teachers / teacher training
Source: The Hindu
Related Posts: Vodafone Idea shares tank 15% from 52-week high Vodafone Idea Receives GST Penalty Order Of Rs 637 ITC, Devyani International, Vodafone Idea, HUDCO, Tata Steel, Zomato, And Others Vodafone Idea gets Rs 638 crore GST penalty order Vodafone Idea gets ₹638 crore GST penalty order Good idea' or taking 'massive chance' - is Rosenior ready for Chelsea World central bank chiefs 'stand in solidarity' with US Fed chair Powell Pakistan May Withdraw from T20 World Cup In Solidarity With Bangladesh Of trends, lifestyle, living spaces Vodafone Idea rolls out 5G services in all 14 districts of Kerala
The BNP-led alliance has fielded candidates in 272 constituencies, leaving 28 seats to smaller partners, while Jamaat-e-Islami is contesting independently in 226 constituencies Bangladesh's 2026 parliamentary election is shaping up to be an unusually polarised contest
1 days ago
SBI Outage: State Bank of India (SBI) on Friday said it was facing intermittent technical issues affecting its UPI services, leading to temporary transaction declines for some customers. The country's largest public sector bank shared the update through a post on X
1 days ago
America's control over Venezuela's oil exports diverts crude shipments previously used to repay China. Venezuela owes China billions, with estimates varying widely. China continued receiving payments even after Venezuela's default through oil-backed loans. The U.S. now controls oil sale proceeds
1 days ago
New Zealand have been dealt an injury blow ahead of the ICC Men's T20 World Cup 2026, with pacer Adam Milne ruled out of the tournament due to a torn left hamstring. New Zealand have been dealt an injury blow ahead of the ICC Men's T20 World Cup 2026
1 days ago
Aston Villa manager Unai Emery played down a heated touchline incident with midfielder Youri Tielemans after substituting him during the Europa League win at Fenerbahce. Tielemans was replaced in the 92nd minute as Villa hung on to a 1-0 lead in Istanbul
1 days ago
The Karnataka High Court on Friday lifted the ban imposed by the State Government on bike taxi operations in the State.A division bench of Chief Justice Vibhu Bakhru and Justice CM Joshi allowed appeals filed by ride-hailing services including ANI Technologies (Ola), Uber and Rapido
1 days ago
The decision will benefit more than 93,000 employees, pensioners and family pensioners, reaffirming the government's focus on social security and financial stability for public sector workers. New Delhi: The Central Government has approved major wage and pension revisions for employees and retirees
1 days ago
The Delhi High Court reportedly set aside the bail granted to an accused who was allegedly part of the mob that indulged in stone-pelting during a demolition exercise near Faiz-e-Elahi mosque in Turkman Gate in the national capital early this month. According to news agency PTI
1 days ago
A long weekend makes for a perfect time to catch up on the latest releases. This Republic Day, watch hit titles on OTT platforms this week, including Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, Zee 5, and JioCinema (formerly JioHotstar). Plot: Touted as a spiritual sequel to Rai's 2013 film Raanjhanaa
1 days ago
The Vande Bharat trains are known for speed, comfort and a premium travel experience. But even the newest trains can face unexpected problems. During the inaugural run of Bihar's Vande Bharat, a video showed several people without tickets crowding the train, acting as if it was a regular service
1 days ago
Every minute aspect about World Wrestling Entertainment (WWE) wrestlers, ranging from their signature moves to their individual body dimensions, is imprinted in the memories of a generation that grew up in the 1990s. Debutant filmmaker Adhvaith Nayar's Chatha Pacha attempts to tap into this
1 days ago
Mark Carney responded to Donald Trump's Davos remarks by saying Canada does not live because of the US, while acknowledging a strong economic and security partnership with the US. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney has struck back at US President Donald Trump after the American leader claimed at
1 days ago
Google DeepMind CEO and Co-founder Demis Hassabis confirmed his participation in the upcoming AI Impact Summit in New Delhi following a meeting with Union Minister of Electronics and Information Technology Ashwini Vaishnaw at the World Economic Forum in Davos.The summit, scheduled for February 2026
1 days ago
Silver and Gold ETFs: Silver ETFs (Exchange Traded Fund) on Friday jumped almost 10 per cent amid the record high prices of physical silver. Gold ETFs also saw a sharp jump of 3.35 per cent, reflecting a strong inflow of money. Tata Silver ETF surged 10 per cent on January 23, trading at Rs 30
1 days ago
Gold prices in Mumbai hit Rs 1,59,710 per 10 grams for 24K and Rs 1,46,400 for 22K, while silver soared to Rs 3,40,000 per kg amid geopolitical uncertainty. Gold and Silver Prices In India, January 23: Gold and silver prices in India climbed to a record high on Friday
1 days ago
YSRCP MP P V Mithun Reddy appeared before Enforcement Directorate officials. This is in connection with a Rs 3,500-crore liquor scam money-laundering case. The alleged scam took place during the previous YSRCP regime. Mithun Reddy was named an accused and arrested by the SIT in July 2025
1 days ago
The Union Budget for 2026 will be presented at 11 AM on February 1. This time, the healthcare sector will be closely watching the budget in order to understand whether government policies will address the growing pressure on India's health system
1 days ago
The Jammu-Srinagar National Highway (NH-44) was closed on Friday due to heavy rain and snowfall, with movement also stopped at Jakhani Chowk in Udhampur. Snowfall also disrupted air travel, with Srinagar Airport and IndiGo Airlines announcing temporary suspension and cancellation of several flights
1 days ago
Carlos Alcaraz dominated Corentin Moutet in straight sets to reach the Australian Open last 16, marking his 100th Grand Slam match with a commanding performance. The top seed's victory sets up a clash with Tommy Paul for a quarter-final spot
1 days ago
One in seven people in the world use TikTok. Yet for the company behind such a cultural phenomenon, the last few years have been a rollercoaster. Concerns over the app first surfaced more than five years ago, prompting President Trump, in his first term
1 days ago
Currently, STCG applies when shares or equity mutual fund units are sold within one year of purchase. New Delhi: Retail investors could finally see tax relief in Union Budget 2026, as the government is reportedly considering changes to the short-term capital gains (STCG) tax on listed equities and
1 days ago
The focus shifts to Raipur as the India national cricket team and the New Zealand national cricket team gear up for the second T20I of their multi-format series. The focus shifts to Raipur as the India national cricket team and the New Zealand national cricket team gear up for the second T20I of
1 days ago
The Karnataka High Court on Friday permitted the operation of bike taxis in the state, allowing a batch of petitions filed by cab aggregators ANI Technologies, Uber and Rapido against the ban on the service, The Hindu reported. On April 2, a single-judge bench ordered all bike taxi services to stop
1 days ago
Parkinson's is a chronic and progressive neurological disorder that affects muscle control, movement, and balance, which is why people often think that tremors are its first symptom. It is essential to recognise that it doesn't always begin with shaking hands; in many cases
1 days ago
Driven by K-pop stars and social media buzz, Dubai-style cookies are selling out across South Korea. South Korea has a new food obsession, and it is sweet, rich and hard to find. Dubai-style cookies, locally known as Dujjonku, have become the country's latest viral dessert
1 days ago
Graphic design requires tools that support creativity, accuracy, and efficiency. A top-rated touchscreen laptop for graphic designers meets these expectations by combining traditional computing power with intuitive input methods. Touchscreen laptops allow designers to draw, edit
1 days ago
A 5-year-old boy arriving home from pre-school in Minnesota was taken by federal agents along with his father to a detention facility in Texas, school officials and the family's lawyer said, making him the fourth student from his Minneapolis suburb to be detained by immigration officers in recent
1 days ago
