German Chancellor Friedrich Merz stated that Europe must strengthen its unity and competitiveness to counter a new wave of “great-power politics” that has disrupted the transatlantic relationship. He welcomed US President Donald Trump's vow not to use force to take Greenland
The Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) and Bangladeshi authorities have announced a boycott of the ICC Men's T20 World Cup 2026. Why will Scotland replace the team in the T20 World Cup fixtures? The Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) and Bangladeshi authorities have announced a boycott of the ICC Men's T20
The Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) and Bangladeshi authorities have announced a boycott of the ICC Men's T20 World Cup 2026. The Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) and Bangladeshi authorities have announced a boycott of the ICC Men's T20 World Cup 2026
The National Board of Examinations in Medical Sciences (NBEMS) has announced the dates for the National Eligibility cum Entrance Test for Postgraduate (NEET-PG 2026) and the National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test for Master of Dental Surgery (NEET-MDS 2026)
New Delhi, Jan 22 (PTI) An 11-year-old girl, selling roses at traffic signals in central Delhi, was kidnapped, raped and left unconscious in a forest area by an e-rickshaw driver, police said on Thursday. After having analysed footage from nearly 300 CCTVs installed across multiple routes
Faced criticism from my own community for advocating creamy layer principle: former CJI Gavai
Faced criticism from my own community for advocating creamy layer principle: former CJI Gavai
Former Chief Justice of India B.R. Gavai has said he has been "widely criticised" by people from his own community for stating in a judgement that the creamy layer principle should be applied to reservation for the Scheduled Castes.
In Dr B.R. Ambedkar's view, affirmative action was like providing a bicycle to someone who is lagging behind, Gavai said, asking whether Ambedkar thought that such a person should never give up the bicycle. Ambedkar did not think so, he claimed.
The former CJI Gavai, who retired as CJI recently, was delivering a lecture on "Role of Affirmative Action in Promoting Equal Opportunity" at Mumbai University on Saturday.
Paying tributes to Ambedkar on his death anniversary, Justice Gavai said the iconic leader was the architect not only of the Indian Constitution but also of the affirmative action enshrined in it.
"Babasaheb, in so far affirmative action is concerned, was of the view that it is like providing a cycle to those who are lagging behind....suppose somebody is at tenth km and somebody at zero, he (the latter) should be provided a cycle, so that he reaches faster till the tenth km. From there, he joins the person who is already there and walks along with him. Did he (Ambedkar) think that the person should not leave the cycle and carry forward and thereby ask the people who are at zero km to continue to be there?" he asked.
"In my view, that was not the vision of social and economic justice as contemplated by Babasaheb Ambedkar. He wanted to bring social and economic justice in the real sense and not in a formal sense," the former CJI added.
The Indra Sawhney and Others Vs Union of India case enunciated the creamy layer principle, and in another case, he himself held that the creamy layer should also be made applicable to the Scheduled Castes, said Gavai.
The principle demands that those who are sufficiently advanced economically and socially should not get the benefit of affirmative action, even though they are members of the backward community for which it is meant.
He was "widely criticised" by the people of his own community for this judgement, Gavai said, adding that he was accused of taking benefit of the reservation himself to become a Supreme Court judge and then advocating the exclusion of those who fell in the creamy layer.
But these people did not even know that there is no reservation for the constitutional office of High Court or Supreme Court judge, former CJI Gavai said.
Can applying the same yardstick to the son of a chief justice of India or chief secretary and the son of a labourer who has studied in a gram panchayat school satisfy the test of equality as enshrined in the Constitution, he asked.
The former CJI Gavai, however, emphasised that in the last 75 years "no doubt affirmative action has played a positive role".
"I have travelled across the country, travelled across the world, I have seen many people belonging to the Scheduled Caste becoming chief secretary or director general of police or ambassadors and high commissioners," he said.
Maharashtra is a land of social reformers, and the "region can truly be described as the birthplace of the idea of modern India", Gavai said.
"We are all aware of Jyotirao Phule and Savitribai Phule's pioneering work in the eradication of inequalities in society," he said.
When women were among the most oppressed in society, it was the Phule couple who opened the door of education for them, he noted.
Published - December 07, 2025 10:00 am IST
judiciary (system of justice) / justice and rights
Source: TheHindu
Related Posts: India’s gold-loan NBFCs to see assets under management surge India’s First Vande Bharat Sleeper Begins Service US ranks way below India Apple Pay launch in India tipped for 2026 India stopped buying Russian oil after Washington’s punitive tariffs Bangladesh government takes Chinese ambassador near India’s ‘Chicken Neck’ 8 Heritage Restaurants In India Where History Is The Main Guest Refineries, textiles, petrochemicals join India’s carbon compliance scheme India’s Homebound fails to Secure a spot Air India passenger slams ‘rude’ crew for failing to provide non-veg meal
Le Travenues Technology, the parent company of online travel aggregator Ixigo, saw its operating revenue increase 31% year-on-year (YoY) to Rs 317 crore for the quarter ended December on account of growth across all lines of business.With increased revenue
1 hours ago
Punjab, under the AAP government, now becomes the first state in the country to guarantee free healthcare, free education, free electricity, and free bus travel for women, while Arvind Kejriwal asserts that power-hungry opposition parties remain consumed by internal battles
1 hours ago
It wasn't Naomi Osaka's tennis that had people talking at Melbourne Park on Thursday. A frosty handshake and an even frostier exchange stole the spotlight after the former World No.1 knocked out Sorana Cirstea in the second round of the 2026 Australian Open
1 hours ago
It's starting to feel like deja vu for Oscar Piastri, and not the good kind. As Formula 1 barrels toward 2026, McLaren have made one thing crystal clear: nothing is changing when it comes to their much-debated “Papaya Rules". For Piastri fans hoping McLaren might finally lean harder into a
1 hours ago
The government has formed a three-member committee to investigate student suicides at IIT-Kanpur. This panel will recommend measures to prevent such tragedies and improve mental health support. The committee, led by Anil Sahastrabuddhe, includes psychiatrist Jitendra Nagpal and a joint secretary
1 hours ago
MG Cyberster: JSW MG Motor India, through its luxury brand channel MG SELECT, today unveiled a new signature exterior finish for the Cyberster, called Irises Cyan. MG Cyberster gets new Irises Cyan paint: JSW MG Motor India, through its luxury brand channel MG SELECT
1 hours ago
Baba Vanga's spine-chilling 2026 predictions: As the world grapples with wars, tech breakthroughs and cosmic mysteries, an eerie name has resurfaced online, Baba Vanga. Her alleged predictions for 2026 are once again sending shivers across the internet
1 hours ago
India's net foreign direct investments (FDI) remained negative for the fourth consecutive month in November 2025, with outflows exceeding inflows by $446 million that month, an analysis of latest data from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) shows. The data
1 hours ago
There is a particular joy in seeing two veterans riff off each other, which The Riptaps into with efficiency. Matt Damon and Ben Affleck clearly had a lot of fun making this lean action movie, and it shows. The movie, based on true events, begins with a bang per Netflix instructions
1 hours ago
Protests erupted in the Karnataka Assembly after Governor Thaawarchand Gehlot only read out two lines from his customary address to the joint session of the state legislature. Gehlot objected to 11 paragraphs in the speech prepared by the Congress government in the state
1 hours ago
Melbourne, Jan 22 (AP) A gunman was at large after a shooting in a town in Australia's New South Wales state on Thursday left three people dead and another wounded, police said. Emergency services were called to two locations at Lake Cargelligo, a town of around 1,500 people, after 4 pm
1 hours ago
Tech mogul Elon Musk has promised major improvements to X's artificial intelligence-driven recommendation and advertising systems, claiming users will soon see more relevant content and far fewer unwanted ads on the platform. Musk outlines AI roadmap for XIn a post on Thursday
1 hours ago
PV Sindhu created badminton history on Thursday (January 22) by becoming the first Indian shuttler to achieve 500 career wins in women's singles. The two-time Olympic medallist accomplished this milestone during the Indonesia Masters Super 500 tournament in Jakarta
1 hours ago
Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese said on Thursday (January 22, 2026) he was “profoundly sorry” for his failure to prevent the Bondi Beach mass shooting, as the country observed a day of mourning for the victims of the attack
1 hours ago
Business tycoon Adar Poonawalla has officially confirmed that he would be bidding to acquire the Indian Premier League (IPL) franchise Royal Challengers Bengaluru (RCB). RCB are the defending champions of IPL, having won the title for the first time last time
1 hours ago
Artificial intelligence would not replace human jobs but can only reshape work by automating tasks, said leading business executives from technology companies at the ongoing World Economic Forum 2026 in Davos. Artificial intelligence would not replace human jobs but can only reshape work by
1 hours ago
US President Donald Trump unveiled the "Board of Peace" at the World Economic Forum in Davos on January 22, securing signatures from leaders from approximately 35 Nations. US President Donald Trump unveiled the "Board of Peace" at the World Economic Forum in Davos on January 22
1 hours ago
The robot is malfunctioning and in need of a reset. Erling Haaland made a blistering start to the season but that prolific run of form has suffered a glitch. Though the Manchester City and Norway striker has scored a remarkable 39 goals in just 36 games for club and country this season
1 hours ago
A passenger flying aboard a Bangkok–New Delhi flight operated by Tata-owned Air India has alleged misconduct by crew members after he asked for a non-vegetarian meal that was pre-booked on his ticket. Abhishek Chaudhry said he was travelling back to Delhi with his 22-year-old cousin when the
1 hours ago
Sameer Nigam and Rahul Chari, cofounders of digital payments firm PhonePe, sold shares worth Rs 3,937.3 crore (around $430 million) to US-based private equity firm General Atlantic in September 2025, as per IPO filings.As reported by ET, General Atlantic had done a secondary transaction worth $600
1 hours ago
In today's healthcare system, doctors and nurses often take the spotlight. But the real backbone is made up of paramedics and allied health professionals; the unsung people who connect emergency care to skilled treatment, diagnostics to delivery, and prevention to precision
1 hours ago
The National Testing Agency (NTA) has officially released admit cards for the JEE Main 2026 January session. Candidates who have registered for the exam can download their admit cards from the official website jeemain.nta.ac.in. The hall ticket is mandatory for entry into the examination centre
1 hours ago
Indian IT services companies are moving fast enough on artificial intelligence (AI) and are not lagging behind global peers, Rishad Premji, executive chairman of Wipro, said in a Moneycontrol report from the World Economic Forum (WEF) in Davos. Speaking to Moneycontrol on January 21
1 hours ago
The Indian Air Force on Thursday (January 22, 2026) expressed disappointment over fee being charged for the air show held in Nashik district earlier in the day. “It has come to notice that entrance fees are being charged for witnessing the Indian Air Force air show being held at Nashik
1 hours ago
Global trade patterns are changing. Nations are seeking new partners and strengthening regional ties. This shift is driven by U.S. tariff policies. Companies are diversifying supply chains. The world is becoming more expensive. Countries must adapt quickly to new trade realities
1 hours ago
EPFO 3.0 is being described as a complete technology overhaul of the retirement fund body, bringing it closer to a core banking-style system much like the way banks function today. Instead of small, gradual updates, this phase will introduce an entirely new digital architecture and backend system
1 hours ago
At least 15 Maoists, including top leader Anal Da carrying a Rs 1 crore bounty, were killed in a fierce encounter with security forces during an intelligence-based operation in Jharkhand's Saranda forest. At least 15 Maoists, including senior leader Patiram Manjhi alias Anal Da
1 hours ago
