One of the defining characteristics of mature consumer markets is not simply the abundance of products, but the quality of consumer decision-making. Across sectors, rising financial awareness, easier access to information and digital discovery are changing what people choose to buy and how they
Imagine reaching retirement with a bond portfolio that works like a staircase. One bond matures this year, another next year, and another the year after, giving you access to money at different points instead of having to unlock the entire investment at once
Augmont Enterprises IPO Day 2: The initial public offering (IPO) of integrated gold and silver platform Augmont Enterprises Ltd is witnessing its second day of bidding today, August 24. So far, the public issue has been subscribed 2.88 times. The Rs 825-crore IPO
Gold prices remain high in India; check 22K, 24K rates in Mumbai, Delhi, Bengaluru International gold prices also climbed to a more than three-month high on Monday. Published on: Aug 24, 2026, 13:46:24 IST By HT News Desk Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Gold prices remained high in India on
Nearly three-fourth of large-cap active funds underperformed a blended (LargeMidCap) benchmark over a 10-year period, according to the 2025 report by SPIVA (S&P Indices Versus Active). In this article, we discuss two reasons that could, perhaps
Indian Stock Market Today, August 24: The domestic equity markets opened higher on Monday, but gains remained measured as investors continued to track elevated crude oil prices and geopolitical tensions in West Asia. At 9:16 am, the BSE Sensex was up 205 points, or 0.26%, at 77,746.06
Businesses from India and the U.S. have expressed interest in investing in Bangladesh and made proposals to improve the country's investment climate, Commerce Minister Khandakar Abdul Muktadir has said. Mr. Muktadir’s remarks on Saturday (August 22
Minimalistic retractable door handles became a signature feature of electric vehicles (EVs), but the controversial designs are now at the centre of China's biggest car recall, affecting more than 4 million vehicles. The recall, which includes 2.98 million Chinese-made Teslas
Why India’s semiconductor dreams rest on rethinking labour policy
To prepare for the predicted dominance of artificial intelligence, the Indian government – supported by industry bodies and experts – is leaning heavily on the idea of “upskilling” India's workforce.
“History has shown that work does not disappear due to technology. Its nature changes and new types of jobs are created,” said Prime Minister Narendra Modi at the AI Action Summit in February 2025. “We need to invest in skilling and re-skilling our people for an AI-driven future.”
From attempts to train Indian workers in semiconductor production processes to declaring India the “skills capital” of the world in technology, the government is pitching skilling as the key route for the country to participate in the promised “AI revolution”.
It is important to examine the assumptions underpinning these notions, particularly those related to how a Global South country can effectively participate in global supply chains. By reframing the idea of skills and skilling – for instance, through the co-production of skill-notions and value-capture, and through the idea of collective skills – India can open up policy options that are not visible when it only views skills as individual, objective, and comparable.
Any assessment of skill policy in relation to technological change needs to ask what skill even is, if it can be defined, and why this matters. Some approaches to studying skill, as described by the sociologist Paul Attewell, assume that skills are objective and can be quantified and compared with one another. Work that is seen as non-routine, abstract, or subject to uncertainty, is seen as complex, and people think of skill as the ability to do complex work.
But skill cannot be an objective attribute because there are social dimensions to which activities are recognised as skillful or complex. The historian Nina Lerman shows that social categories like race and gender come to be concretised along with ideas about skills: tasks performed predominantly by women, like tailoring, are not seen as analogous to “technical” activities like engineering. The recognition of work as skillful also affects and is affected by caste, class, and migration status.
There are patterns to how skill is defined at given places and times, and those patterns are co-produced with economic shifts. How then are notions of skills in AI policy co-produced with the pattern of economic value-capture along the semiconductor value chain? What work is recognised as skilled and under which conditions?
Today's semiconductor supply chain is globalised and concentrated across the design, manufacturing, and assembly of chips. US firms like NVIDIA and Intel dominate chip design, while manufacturing is led by Taiwan's TSMC using machines exclusively made by ASML in the Netherlands. The assembly stage is less capital-intensive than other stages and is often outsourced to the Global South.
One assumption in India's upskilling and reskilling policies is that adjusting to AI-affected roles represents a type of upskilling rather than potentially deskilling, and that a change in skills can be compared ordinally. Another assumption is that if workers in India were to upskill and reskill, it would be able to secure an acceptable existence in a global economy where AI is the dominant technology.
These assumptions frame skill as both the reason and the solution to problems arising from AI. For instance, an expert group on skills constituted by the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, states, “Job losses due to AI-driven automation are more likely to affect low-skilled workers.” And in the words of a Deloitte executive, “By reskilling the existing workforce...we can ensure a steady pipeline of professionals ready to lead AI-driven innovation.” It is also no surprise that the people who run “skilling centers” in India refer to students as engineering and “below engineering.”
Ironically, when a large number of people are “upskilled” – enough to drive the cost of such skilled labour down in a segmented global labour market – those skills are no longer seen as valuable because they are so easily available, and therefore no longer “above” other skills.
One study of the semiconductor supply chain captures this effect spectacularly when it says, “Worker skill requirements go down along the value chain (that is, design is more skill-intensive than manufacturing, which is more skill-intensive than assembly).”
It is not that the more skilled activities capture more value, but that the activities that capture more value are seen as being more skilled. This effect can be seen when Global North firms refuse to transfer knowledge or skills while operating in the Global South, because if those skills became too diffuse, that work would no longer capture as much value and be considered as skilled.
This effect might stymie India's hopes to achieve skill transfers by attracting semiconductor assembly investments; in Vietnam, the same strategy came up against foreign-owned companies' unwillingness to transfer any skills to the domestic Vietnamese industry, instead drawing Vietnamese engineers away from the domestic industry.
In 1980s Brazil, foreign electronics companies employed far fewer workers in skilled positions than domestic electronics companies; the absence of foreign firms in the computer industry might even have contributed to the creation of domestic expertise in this industry.
Additionally, higher pay scales helped divert Brazilian engineers away from domestic firms where they worked in R&D activities, to foreign firms where they worked primarily in marketing, quality control, and equipment testing. A 2008 study of the electronics industry in Mexico also reveals low levels of knowledge transfer to local entities by foreign companies and regional differences in such transfers.
These diffusion-devaluation dynamics are visible in other industries and are felt more by socially disadvantaged groups. For instance, in Mexico, foreign companies employed educated and skilled women workers in repetitive manufacturing and assembly work for decades.
When these workers responded to changing industrial demands by demonstrating flexibility and performing complex production activities, the companies still classified their work as unskilled, depressing their wages. Similarly, a number of scholars have studied how the idea of women's “nimble fingers” is used to devalue rather than value their work in the electronics industry.
While success in the electronics and information technology industries often follows the international mobility of engineers including in India, Ireland, Argentina, and Taiwan, the counter-examples above show that this knowledge mobility is not automatically a precursor to skills-transfer across all segments of work in the industry.
In India, a similar dynamic is evident in the chip design sector. It is often stated in policy documents and media reports that India is home to 20% of all semiconductor design engineers in the world. Many chip design firms have established design centres in India, and new foreign investments in design have been announced. The government also established a design-linked incentive scheme to subsidise semiconductor design activities in India.
However, foreign companies tend to outsource primarily the labour-intensive parts of research and development activities to India because of the lower compensation that researchers can bargain for in India. There are also inadequate linkages between the needs and wants of the Indian market and more “advanced” chip design activities.
Due to this mix of factors, foreign firms then accrue intellectual property for innovations developed in centres in India. Against this background, India's inability to capture value in the chip design sector is attributed to a lack of workers' skills in “new product conceptualisation and product marketing” although these workers are highly skilled in chip design. For a Global South country, a skill is always that which is just beyond reach, a convenient scapegoat that obscures the subjugation of the country in global supply chains.
Another pervasive assumption about skills is that they reside in individuals. Some studies have developed arguments about collective skills and information. For instance, Edwin Hutchins and Tove Klausen argue, through a study of work in airline cockpits, that cognition in this setting is not individual but is rather distributed across a system of people and artifacts.
Perhaps carrying out certain productive activities at scale can be seen as a skill developed and maintained collectively by all the people who enable the functioning of large-scale productive activity. This skill is held, for instance, by bureaucrats, labour brokers, intermediaries between firms, intermediaries between firms and governments, etc., in regions where production at scale is widespread and functions relatively routinely. This is a collective skill because it is only meaningful when held along with other people. It is a skill because human interactions and understandings are necessary for large-scale and complex production systems to function.
Collective skill may consist in knowledge about the law and how it works in the given region, intuitions about how infrastructure requirements scale, experience managing large groups of migrant workers, or tacit knowledge about decision-makers in institutions.
Collective skill has been visible in the critical role labour brokers and other intermediary networks have played in the growth of app-based work in India, the Philippines, and elsewhere. It is also visible in the role that labour brokers play in managing migrant labour supply for electronics manufacturing in Taiwan.
India's semiconductor policy hinges on positioning India as an alternative to China amid US-China tensions. Often, US firms have been reluctant to move out of China, partially because of the cost of movement, but also because India is unable to provide the kind of plug-and-play atmosphere that China can for businesses. For companies that do want to move out of China, Vietnam is seen as a preferable alternative to India because Vietnam has experience with large-scale electronics manufacturing – an indication, perhaps, that there is a dimension of collective skill in this context missing in India.
The descriptor of collective skill is not entirely correspondent with the idea of state capacity or “ease of doing business” for two reasons. First, collective skill relies on non-state actors including entrepreneurs, business managers, factory supervisors, labour brokers, industry associations, and logistics service providers. Some of these actors might even work in legal gray areas while being critical to production and state approval processes. Second, collective skill emphasises the tacit knowledge of people that makes processes work, rather than the design of the administrative, policy, or production processes themselves.
Thus, a mere focus on augmenting the capacity of the state or reorienting the bureaucracy toward becoming more permissive and efficient might not be sufficient. It might even be counterproductive when it over-regulates actors who work in gray areas, like labour brokers, and deregulates activities that require regulation for building trust among all important actors for the stability of investments.
Such often-deregulated activities include especially the treatment of workers and the consideration of local environmental impacts. The notion of collective skills orients us toward trying to build knowledge and practice among all relevant actors for large-scale production. Stakeholder consultations on AI, international and national AI summits, and investment events bring together state and some commercial actors, but rarely, if ever, serve as opportunities to bring together all the actors that make large-scale electronics production possible.
It is not that India must create an economic environment that is above all conducive for foreign technology producers, but rather that while planning to develop a semiconductor industry domestically, India has chosen to focus on skill as an objective, comparable, individual, and therefore easily scapegoat-able attribute. If India were to view skill as collective and co-produced with value capture, new policy questions would open up.
Jai Vipra is a PhD student at the Department of Science & Technology Studies, Cornell University and a non-resident CyberBRICS fellow at the Center for Technology and Society, Fundação Getulio Vargas.
The article was first published in India in Transition, a publication of the Center for the Advanced Study of India, University of Pennsylvania.
Also read: US-China tech rivalry spurs semiconductor ambitions
Source: Scroll
Related Posts: Business and Economy, Science and Technology, india semiconductor mission, skill india semiconductor course, skill india semiconductor, skill india artificial intelligence
Tempsens Instruments India IPO Day 3: The initial public offering (IPO) of temperature sensing and heating solutions provider Tempsens Instruments Ltd is witnessing its final day of bidding today, August 24. So far, the public issue has been subscribed by a strong 31.34 times. The Rs 650-crore IPO
12 hours ago
S&P 500 just hit a level seen only once before in 155 years — could a market crash be next? The S&P 500 CAPE ratio hit 40 for only the second time in 155 years, raising concerns about valuations, future returns and a possible market correction. Updated on: Aug 23, 2026
15 hours ago
Anthropic $2 trillion IPO: Why investors think it could be worth more than SpaceX Anthropic could reach a $2 trillion IPO valuation as revenue surges, raising questions about whether the AI company can be worth more than SpaceX. Published on: Aug 23, 2026
15 hours ago
US President Donald Trump has said Canada wants "the benefits of being a State, without being one" after trade talks between the two countries collapsed late on Friday. In his first comments since negotiations broke down, triggering new 50% US tariffs on a range of Canadian goods
1 days ago
India’s payments sector has raised $5.8 billion across 371 equity funding rounds since January 2021, while producing eight initial public offerings (IPOs) and triggering 25 acquisitions, as the industry increasingly consolidates around a handful of well-funded players
1 days ago
Can Reddit survive in the AI era? It wants more cash for its data—and more of people’s time Published on: Aug 22, 2026, 16:40:48 IST The Economist Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Earlier this summer “Backrooms”, a horror flick, became one of the most successful independent films ever
1 days ago
What with a 250th birthday, Taylor Swift's wedding and the football World Cup, Americans could be forgiven for taking their eye off the ball this summer. But signs of economic trouble have been building. This week they hit the headlines when US national debt passed the $40tn (£29.4tn) mark
1 days ago
Insurance regulator IRDAI has directed Edelweiss Life Insurance and Pramerica Life Insurance, in separate orders on August 20, not to open new place of business for six months for non-compliance with Expenses of Management (EoM) limits in 2024-25
2 days ago
India remains a very attractive destination for global investments and its economic fundamentals form the basis for strong investor confidence, Jyoti Jeetun, the Minister of Financial Services and Economic Planning of Mauritius told The Hindu in an interview
2 days ago
A fresh wave of US tariffs on a wide array of Canadian goods has come into effect as of midnight on Saturday after a last minute break down in trade talks. Announcing the suspension of negotiations shortly before the Friday night deadline, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney said he would impose
2 days ago
TCS Employee Surveillance Row: Tata Consultancy Services (TCS), India’s largest IT services company, on Friday denied reports that it is using monitoring tools to track individual employee activity on company-issued laptops. The IT giant said the purpose of the tools is to monitor the overall
2 days ago
Walmart stock falls 9% as retailer finally brings Apple Pay, Google Pay Walmart stock fell 9% after earnings despite beating estimates and raising guidance. The retailer will add Apple Pay and Google Pay Tap to Pay from August 24. Updated on: Aug 21, 2026
2 days ago
TikTok has agreed to pay $400m (£293m) to the US to end a lawsuit alleging its platform violated children‘s privacy, marking one of the largest ever settlements over the issue. The deal stems from a 2024 suit by the Department of Justice under former President Joe Biden alleging TikTok and its
2 days ago
What’s next for Nvidia after the AI chip boom? Wall Street wants more—here’s what investors need to know Nvidia stock faces high expectations ahead of August 26 earnings as Wall Street watches AI growth, valuation, open-source models and Nvidia's next big story. Updated on: Aug 22, 2026
2 days ago
Costco dividend rises: Why a $10,000 investment pays only $61 yearly A $10,000 Costco investment earns only about $61 a year in regular dividends. Here’s why investors still buy COST for growth and special dividends. Updated on: Aug 20, 2026
3 days ago
Leaving education, getting a job, buying a home and perhaps starting a family: the path previous generations followed may seem a distant dream to many now. But is it getting a bit easier - at least when it comes to getting on the housing ladder? Today's prospective first-time buyers may well feel
3 days ago
Nearly six months after US President Donald Trump vowed a swift victory over Iran, the conflict appears to be at a standstill, with prospects of a military victory or negotiated settlement growing dimmer. To break the deadlock, Trump has vowed an "economic D-Day" under which any country that does
3 days ago
Why US stocks fell today: Dow, S&P 500, Nasdaq drop as oil and bond yields rise US stocks fell as oil prices and Treasury yields rose. Dow, S&P 500 and Nasdaq dropped as Trump's Iran threat, Walmart and the bond market hit Wall Street. Published on: Aug 20, 2026
3 days ago
Crypto stocks surge as Trump backs Clarity Act: Coinbase, Circle, miners rise Crypto stocks surge as Trump backs the Clarity Act. Coinbase, Circle, Bitcoin miners and other crypto shares rise as investors expect clearer US crypto rules. Updated on: Aug 20, 2026
4 days ago
Stock Market Today, August 20: The domestic equity market snapped its seven-day losing streak and ended sharply higher on Thursday, August 20, as broad-based buying lifted sentiment across sectors after the US Treasury stepped in to contain the surge in global bond yields
4 days ago
The Reserve Bank of India RBI has accorded its approval to Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) for acquiring an aggregate holding of up to 9.99% of the paid-up share capital or voting rights in HDFC Bank Ltd., the bank said in a filing with the exchanges on Wednesday (August 19, 2026) night
4 days ago
Customers have shared their outrage after an app used by many businesses to track timesheets and produce invoices hiked bills by as much as 1500%, with one person calling it "daylight robbery". Richard Haldenby, head of UK consultancy firm Salentis
4 days ago
Bitcoin Price Today, August 20: Bitcoin surged to the $70,000 mark on Thursday, recording one of its sharpest gains in recent months as a combination of lower US Treasury yields, a weaker dollar, strong institutional demand and large-scale short liquidations pushed the broader cryptocurrency market
4 days ago
US President Donald Trump has said he will launch tougher economic measures against Iran, as well as any country and that helps or does business with the country. He wrote in all capital letters on Truth Social that he was launching "the most crushing economic operation ever taken against any
4 days ago
The domestic equity markets were trading firmly higher on Thursday, August 20, with buying visible across large-cap, mid-cap and small-cap stocks. The gains strengthened through the session, with the benchmark Sensex rising more than 600 points by 1:20 pm
4 days ago
U.S. President Donald Trump will host cryptocurrency executives at the White House on Wednesday as U.S. financial regulators this week prepare to advance their framework for certain digital assets. Trump, who has earned more than $1.4 billion from his family’s crypto ventures
4 days ago
Telecom inflation, chargers and the number 45, and Small Talk ASL app Beyond the regular noise, a closer look at personal technology. 20 August 2026. Published on: Aug 20, 2026, 08:00:58 IST By Vishal Mathur Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Opening thoughts. Josh Staub
4 days ago
