Ask a sixteen-year-old about a social media ban, and you get an answer sharper than most adults arguing about bans. She says, “It doesn’t prepare us for the real world when we will have to deal with these distractions in our life”. The teenager’s response strikes at the core of the ban vs
How I got hooked on chasing solar eclipses Traveling the globe for celestial events may seem downright loony—until you get a taste of the addictive world of ‘eclipse chasing’ Published on: Aug 23, 2026, 18:30:10 IST WSJ Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link ‘It was glorious
Made-in-India semiconductor chips are now powering key Indian space missions. These domestically manufactured components support lunar and solar exploration efforts. Specialized chips from Mohali's Semiconductor Laboratory are used in Chandrayaan-3 and Aditya-L1
India's space program began with a small rocket range in 1962. It progressed to launching its first satellite and developing indigenous launch vehicles. Chandrayaan-3's lunar landing marked a significant achievement for the nation. The program now includes private sector involvement and ambitious
India plans to establish its own space station by the year 2035. The first module for the Bharatiya Antariksha Station has already received approval. This ambitious project aligns with the nation's growing space capabilities and aspirations. National Space Day celebrates India's achievements and
India observed its third National Space Day, commemorating the Chandrayaan-3 lunar landing. ISRO Chairman Dr. V. Narayanan recalled the agency's humble beginnings and current global standing. He highlighted Chandrayaan-3's soft landing near the Moon's south pole in August 2023
The Indian government created the Indian Institutes of Science Education and Research (IISERs) to offer students an intellectually vibrant research environment and to bring them into research at a relatively — vis-à-vis the Indian milieu — early stage
Prime Minister Narendra Modi aims to lure global expertise to India's expanding space landscape. He identifies the private sector's potential as a crucial asset for global competition. Key advantages include India’s affordability and its appetite for innovation
What’s the status of the rare earth hypothesis? | Explained
What’s the status of the rare earth hypothesis? | Explained Premium
The rare earth hypothesis was proposed in a 2000 book by palaeontologist Peter Ward and astronomer Donald Brownlee. It argues that while simple, microbial life may be common in the universe, complex, multicellular life is likely uncommon. The idea is rooted in a particular place in the universe meeting a chain of successive conditions.
While we often talk about life as ranging from simple (e.g. bacteria and yeast) to complex (e.g. humans and octopuses), life itself is a complex phenomenon and the product of many factors falling in place. Studying these factors on the earth itself has been an arduous and even now an unfinished task; and looking for them on planets located several light years away remains extraordinarily fraught. Scientists studying the possibility of life on other planets have busied themselves with particular aspects over time. Some focus on planetary ingredients such as a rocky world with surface water in the habitable zone of the host star. Other scientists have been concerned with system-level architectures such as giant planets in particular places in the universe. Still others have been looking into long-term climate regulation and a persistent atmosphere. And so on.
Since 2000, we have accumulated significantly more data about exoplanets and planetary science. And the big picture that has emerged is mixed: several conditions required for life look less restrictive than scientists once feared whereas many others look harder to meet than scientists had hoped.
Let's consider how often potentially habitable earth-sized planets occur. Studies based on early data from the NASA Kepler telescope (2009-2018) suggested that a significant fraction of sun-like stars in the Milky Way galaxy hosts small planets receiving starlight comparable to what the earth receives. One study even found that roughly a fifth of sun-like stars may harbour earth-sized planets in their habitable zones, although the data had many uncertainties.
More recent work has concluded, based on Kepler data, that there's a non-negligible rate at which rocky planets occur in the habitable zones of stars called GK dwarfs. These and similar findings have concluded that worlds of roughly the right size at roughly the right distance from a suitable star are not rare, thus weakening the most sweeping claim in the hypothesis. The question has thus shifted from ‘where a planet is' to ‘what a planet is like'. In the solar system, Mercury is too close to the sun to host earth-like life whereas Pluto is too far away. But while both the earth and Venus are in the sun's habitable zone, Venus's atmosphere renders it deadly for earth-like life.
One important open issue is whether small planets around cool, active M-dwarf stars can retain their atmospheres and surface water over billions of years. Modelling studies have indicated that planets that spend millions of years exposed to intense stellar radiation — like that M-dwarf stars are known to emit — tend to lose water and build up false-positive oxygen atmospheres.
Say intense ultraviolet radiation from an M-dwarf star breaks up water molecules on the planet: H2O → H+ + OH–. Further breakdown leads to O and H atoms accumulating in the atmosphere. Over time, the H escapes to space more easily than O, and the O atoms left behind pair up to form O2. If there aren't enough surface ‘sinks' that can absorb this oxygen fast enough — the way rocks and oceans do on the earth — the O2 will accumulate. When a telescope looks at this planet and finds an excess of oxygen in its atmosphere, scientists may think the planet's surface has photosynthesis, which is how the earth's atmosphere has lots of oxygen. But it's actually due to the M-dwarf star's radiation.
On the other hand, some planets around M-dwarf stars can keep their air for a long time, even if most can't. If the star's magnetic outflows — streams of charged particles blown off the star by its magnetic field — are weak or shaped in such a way that they don't hit the planet hard, and if the planet is farther out and cooler, its atmosphere will be eroded more slowly. A strong planetary magnetic field can also deflect a part of the stellar wind, while a massive planet with ongoing volcanic activity can replace some of the lost gases.
These are all system-specific conditions that require a specific mix of star activity, magnetic fields, orbit, planet mass, rotation, and internal heat. When they line up well, a planet can retain its atmosphere for billions of years. However, such planets are in the minority because M-dwarf stars often produce strong flares and many close-in planets lack strong magnetic shields.
Scientists can directly test these observations today. Using NASA's James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), astronomers have started measuring the heat emitted from nearby rocky exoplanets. In TRAPPIST-1c, which is located near the inner edge of its system's habitable zone 40.7 lightyears away, the JWST has ruled out a thick atmosphere rich in carbon dioxide. Previously, scientists using JWST data had also found that the innermost planet, TRAPPIST-1b, likely lacked a substantial atmosphere.
These are only two worlds in one system, yet they show that earth-sized isn't synonymous with earth-like. Scientists still need more measurements of cooler, more temperate planets to understand how often atmospheres survive where earth-like life could plausibly persist.
Another pillar of the rare earth hypothesis is long-term climate stabilisation. On the earth, the weathering of continental rocks and the recycling of carbon between the earth's interior and the atmosphere have buffered the climate over geologic time. Many researchers have linked this buffering to plate tectonics, which subduct a carbonated crust and build new surface rocks. This said, the interiors of planets behave in different ways. Rocky planets can have one stiff shell that barely moves, long quiet times broken by short bursts of crust movement or plate-like tectonics (as on the earth). A planet can even switch between these modes over time. Some models also show that without modern plate tectonics, a planet might still keep a habitable climate by balancing volcanism (which adds gases), weathering (removes gases), burial (traps materials), and crustal foundering (sinks the crust). Scientists don't have consensus either: while plate tectonics could help maintain a stable climate that in turn can support complex life, it may not be strictly required for life to begin.
A third line of debate is the role of giant planets like Jupiter. The old intuition was that Jupiter ‘shields' the earth by deflecting comets and asteroids. Subsequent studies have complicated this story, however. Depending on a giant planet's mass and orbit, scientists have found that it can reduce or increase the flux of impactors to the inner system and it can also deliver water-rich bodies early on. In other words, there seems to be no universal ‘filter' on this front; it all depends on the system's architecture. This conclusion has weakened the claim that a Jupiter-like planet is a necessary precondition for complex life on a rocky planet in the same system.
Thus, on the question of finding small, temperate planets, many scientists today argue that the occurrence rate of earth-sized planets in the habitable zones of sun-like stars is non-zero and may be a few tens of percent, per Kepler data, depending on the definitions and extrapolations. That undermines the notion that the earth's basic orbital and size configuration is vanishingly uncommon. On the other hand, on the question of planets' ability to retain atmospheres, have long climate cycles, be able to avoid catastrophic events, and so on, the data has become more sobering. The results keep open the possibility that truly earth-like surface environments supporting complex biospheres are less common than the count of earth-sized planets in the habitable zone would suggest.
Two more threads bear on the rare versus common debate. First, a recent effort to place an upper limit on the number of earth-like planets emphasised that a lot hinges on atmospheric processes that scientists can't yet survey at scale. Second, searches for technosignatures — signs of technology made by extra-terrestrial life, especially things nature is unlikely to produce on its own — have sharpened the limits on the prevalence of civilisations whose activities emit radio waves (such ‘radio-loud' activities on the earth include broadcasting for TV and radio and air traffic control). Multi-year surveys of thousands of stars by the Breakthrough Listen project haven't found any convincing signals so far. While not detecting something doesn't prove that it's absent, it sets upper limits on how common it could be in the cosmos.
Taken together, the rare earth hypothesis remains plausible for complex life but it can't be said to be demonstrably true. At this juncture, three developments could change the picture: (i) if scientists detect atmospheres on rocky, temperate planets, preferably around sun-like stars, showing gases consistent with active surface water cycles; (ii) if scientists place stronger better constraints on tectonic regimes on exoplanets (even indirectly), indicating whether long-term climate stabilisers are widespread or rare; and (iii) scientists detect biosignatures or technosignatures. The first steps are already underway. Extremely large ground telescopes currently under construction as well as future space missions are aimed squarely at planets with temperate atmospheres.
Until their observations mature, however, a fair summary seems to be: while microbial life could be common, long-lived ecosystems straddling land and ocean and capable of producing complex life may still be scarce. This seems to be as far as the data can take us today.
Published - November 12, 2025 08:30 am IST
Text and Context / The Hindu Explains
Source: The Hindu
Related Posts: Science
The Northeast India Space Workshop 2026 will convene in Guwahati to explore regional transformation. This event aims to leverage space technology for global reach and economic growth. Stakeholders will discuss Northeast India becoming a developer and testbed for space solutions
1 days ago
The dramatic 1° Celsius rise in global temperatures since industrialisation has already proved to have upended the lives of wild flora and fauna: that of at least 15,801 species on the Red List of Threatened Species, according to IUCN (International Union for Conservation of Nature)
2 days ago
India faces a substantial cost gap with the United States for launching payloads. A recent study estimates India's cost at over $13,000 per kilogram by 2025. This contrasts with the United States' estimated cost of $3,225 per kilogram. The study highlights scale and experience as key factors for
2 days ago
Prime Minister Narendra Modi encouraged young space entrepreneurs to innovate for agriculture and daily life. He highlighted the potential of India's private space sector for global impact. Startups were urged to engage with schools and inspire future generations
2 days ago
Rock-solid evidence for the origins of birds Stones in dinosaur stomachs may help understanding of avian evolution Published on: Aug 20, 2026, 21:09:09 IST The Economist Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link How do you know what a dinosaur ate? Guts rot away after death
3 days ago
Was it meat or glucose that fueled the growth of the human brain? If evolutionary science told us, hitherto, that human brain expansion relied on meat to grow, a new study has an interesting addition to this theory. Published in a recent issue of Science
4 days ago
The Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) is set to launch the GISAT-1A satellite in September, in a mission that will be watched closely for many important reasons. Since the two successive PSLV mission failures, in 2025 and early 2026, ISRO had paused launches as it investigated the reason
4 days ago
The Hara forests are a vital ecological treasure of the Persian Gulf. Spanning the Strait of Hormuz, these mangrove forests consist mainly of grey mangrove trees (Avicennia marina), which have a special filtration system in their roots that allows them to thrive in saline conditions
5 days ago
India spends more to put a kilogram of payload into orbit than any other major spacefaring nation, marring its public image as a cost-effective launcher, according to a new peer-reviewed analysis of more than six decades of rocket launches published in Economics Letters
7 days ago
“The past is a foreign country; they do things differently there,” the English novelist L.P. Hartley wrote famously in his 1953 novel The Go-Between. In a peculiar twist, the same cannot be said of the Moon. It is not a foreign country, or even a foreign world: the U.S
7 days ago
The computer did not create a virus. It did not touch a test tube or handle a living cell. What it did may ultimately be more consequential: it helped decide what the virus’s genome should be. Researchers at Stanford University and the Arc Institute used artificial intelligence (AI) to design
8 days ago
Spectators across Spain watched in wonder, some whipping off their protective glasses and rising to their feet in unison, as a rare total solar eclipse swept across the north of the country on Wednesday (August 12, 2026) evening, plunging it into darkness
8 days ago
Japan's MMX mission will blast off soon to collect Martian moon samples. The spacecraft will orbit Mars for three years and land on Phobos. This mission aims to understand Solar System origins and life's emergence. A rival Chinese mission also plans to return Mars samples around 2031
8 days ago
Draft rules for the SHANTI Act, 2025, mandate financial security for nuclear damage. Operators must maintain insurance or financial security until spent fuel removal. Foreign reactor designs require certification by their country of origin's regulatory body
9 days ago
As a total solar eclipse will be visible in parts of Europe on August 12 for the first time since 1999, solar physicists at the Raman Research Institute (RRI) in Bengaluru, along with collaborators, have predicted the magnetic structure of the Sun’s outer atmosphere, or its ‘crown’
9 days ago
When a young man was brought to my clinic after his first episode of psychosis, his parents wanted to know when he could return to college. This is not an atypical first interaction. However, in many instances, after a few consultations later and especially once the immediate crisis had settled
11 days ago
Some people can live apparently ordinary lives even when both copies of a gene (one inherited from the mother and the other from the father) have stopped working. Until their DNA is sequenced, they may never know that this has happened. A large study from Pakistan, published in Nature (June 2026)
11 days ago
Physicist Deepak Dhar received the 2026 Dirac Medal for his statistical mechanics work. He shares the award with three other scientists for their complex systems research. Their contributions span biology, finance, computer science, and artificial intelligence
12 days ago
Colombia and Venezuela experienced deadly earthquakes due to tectonic plate friction. The Nazca plate sliding beneath the South American plate caused tremors. Earthquake magnitude and depth significantly influenced the destructive impact. Building codes and terrain also played crucial roles in the
12 days ago
India has been invited to join NASA's Moon Base program. Discussions focused on expanding civil and commercial space cooperation. Both nations agreed to advance open scientific data sharing under Artemis Accords. They also reaffirmed commitment to UN guidelines for outer space sustainability
12 days ago
A team led by researchers at the Johns Hopkins School of Medicine has found that several inherited traits in the mouse genome break the rules Gregor Mendel laid down in the 19th century about how genes work. This is not because the genes mutate but because of chemical modifications of the genome
13 days ago
Urban India’s water emergency will not be fixed by better crisis management alone. Over the coming decades, hundreds of millions more people will live and work in Indian cities, driving a sharp increase in the urban water demand. And unless we change how we design, finance
15 days ago
IN-SPACe seeks private partners to manage ISRO's new launch complex. This facility will support small rocket launches and enhance launch efficiency. Private entities will handle end-to-end operations and maintenance of the complex. ISRO will provide initial technical and operational support for
15 days ago
NASA astronauts Anil Menon and Jessica Meir on Friday (August 6, 2026) concluded their spacewalk outside the International Space Station to assemble the modification kit for its power channel that would allow addition of solar arrays. The spacewalk – 281st in support of the space station –
15 days ago
The gut microbiomes of eight tribal populations across India have a unique diversity shaped by their traditional diets, and are distinct from those observed in industrialised settings, researchers have reported in Gut Microbes. The effects of probiotics depend on a population’s diet and gut
15 days ago
Five minutes past noon on July 18, the launch pad of Satish Dhawan Space Centre in Sriharikota roared back to life after a gap of 187 days. The last launch from the space port was on January 12, 2026, involving the PSLV-C62 mission carrying the EOS-N1 earth observation satellite
15 days ago
A lettuce that makes meat protein: The science behind engineering plants to grow an animal molecule & why it matters The study established proof of concept, but lettuce with meat protein is still some distance from ending up in your burger. Updated on: Aug 7, 2026
16 days ago
