Gurgaon woman busts myth of ‘lavish corporate life’, says salary disappears after paydayA Gurgaon woman shared how bills and daily expenses left her with little of her salary soon after payday. Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 14:24:23 IST By Mahipal Singh Chouhan Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy
Founder who survived on bread, water at 18 thinks everyone should go ‘completely broke’ onceA Mumbai-based founder claimed that surviving on bread and water at 18 removed his fear of startup failure and financial losses. Updated on: Sep 1, 2026
The US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and 22 states sued Amazon on Monday for allegedly "manipulating" online auctions for digital advertising, resulting in more than $20 billion in overcharges for 1.2 million customers. Amazon "has secretly and systematically overcharged its approximately 1
Always looking for a sweet treat after dinner? Fitness coach Eric Roberts shares 3 reasons for late-night sugar cravings Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 14:09:20 IST By Eshana Saha Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Read more to find out why your sugar cravings intensify at the end of the day!
3-year-old kidnapped from Delhi found 1,000 km away in Bihar; accused woman had 6 daughters, wanted a sonThe child went missing while he was playing near his mother, who had gone to the hospital to collect medicines, police said. Updated on: Sep 1, 2026
Opinion: India’s Productivity Crisis & How It Can Be Solved
Opinion: India’s Productivity Crisis & How It Can Be Solved
In conversations about economic growth, usually only two components of growth are talked about. Those are capital and labour. Capital is the investment in land, machinery and tools that labour then uses to produce output. The greater the output, the higher the GDP and hence, richer the country.
There's a third variable here that's arguably more important but completely ignored in the discourse — Total Factor Productivity (TFP). For instance, agricultural output depends on how much land is available (capital) and how many workers can be hired (labour). But farming techniques play an important role in output. Drip irrigation allowed the same yields without a commensurate increase in water costs. TFP refers to all such improvements in output that are achieved without increase in either capital or labour.
As late as 1880, 50% of the US workforce was employed in agriculture. In 2025, that figure is less 2%. Yet, the US is able to grow much more food today than in the 19th century. All of these are possible due to improvements in productivity.
The same story repeats in India. Prior to the Green Revolution, food shortages were common. As is well known, India famously imported wheat in the 1960s from the US's “PL 480" aid programme. High Yielding Variety (HYV) seeds were later adopted by farmers starting in 1966-67. The outcome was a tripling in yields of cereals, with only a 30% increase in land area cultivated. Wheat and rice also saw their yields increase. In general, modern farming techniques use less land and labour while producing more food than humanity has ever produced.
This is the very definition of abundance and wealth. Everyone has access to as much food as they wish to consume. So much so that we have GLP-1 pills to help the obese lose weight by reducing their hunger levels.
This occurs across the world. Due to the Industrial Revolution, Britain was able to produce huge quantities of textiles. In fact, it was so dominant, that by 1850 it was producing more than half the world's cotton. Only those countries that put up heavy protective tariffs against British cotton imports were able to have cotton spinning industries survive. With such an advantage across many industries, Britain was able to rapidly industrialise and provide an abundance of material wealth to its citizens. I'm not denying that colonization had an impact. But that wouldn't have been possible without the superior productivity provided by the Industrial Revolution.
TFP in Colombia has stagnated over the past three decades. Consequently, this puts a cap on the amount of economic growth possible. There is mounting evidence to show that the “middle-income trap" is often due to a stagnation in productivity growth.
India's TFP growth. 1955-2019. 2017 is indexed at 1.0. Source: St. Louis Fed.
The above graph shows the growth in India's TFP over the decades, from 1955 to 2019. 2017 is indexed at 1.0. Relative to that, productivity in 2019 was at 1.017. That implies a TFP growth rate of approximately 0.8% per year.
USA's TFP growth. 1955-2019. 2017 is indexed at 1.0. Source: St. Louis Fed.
This graph now shows the US's TFP growth from 1955-2019. 2017 is again indexed at 1. The index of productivity in 2019 is 1.016. That implies a yearly TFP growth rate only a tad lower than India's.
This should be ringing alarm bells. There are three concerns here:
Starting approximately in 2012, India had a boost in TFP growth. For a variety of reasons, that has petered out and now TFP is growing more slowly.
For a rough comparison, India's GDP is roughly at the size where the US was in the late 1980s to early 1990s. As can be seen from the graph, the growth in TFP was much stronger for the US in that timespan.
Growth in productivity gets much harder when you're at the technological frontier. Every improvement gets harder to eke out. Countries that have yet to reach the frontiers of tech, can get this productivity boost for “free" by just copying what has worked for countries higher up the tech ladder. Keeping this in mind, it is worrying that India's TFP growth is similar to the US. This would lead to divergent outcomes and the gap in nominal dollar terms would remain huge.
To understand the stagnation in productivity, let's understand the factors that are causing stagnation.
A useful question to ask is why does the US have such higher productivity? An economy is more productive because firms within its borders efficiently and maximally use its capital and labour. Firms are incentivised to produce goods cheaper than their competitors. As a result, there will be some firms that are more productive with their inputs than others.
If additional capital and labour could be directed towards such firms in proportion to their productivity, we would call it an appropriate allocation of resources. Within the Indian economy, more productive firms often fail to get more resources. That's what is called resource misallocation.
India's political class has an unhealthy obsession with MSMEs. Smaller firms are provided with credit support, regulation holidays and other perks. Naturally some of them will be successful and start to grow big. That's when the benefits cliff kicks in. Growing beyond a point invites regulatory costs far bigger than the marginal value of the product. Given this calculation, these productive firms choose to stay small.
Let's look at some examples of policies that are unfriendly towards large businesses:
The Code on Wages requires a company to seek government permission for layoffs if it employs more than 300 workers. And this is an improvement over prior laws that put the limit at only 100 workers.
India's Priority Sector Lending (PSL) policy enforced by the RBI requires banks to lend a percentage of their portfolio to sectors like agriculture or MSMEs. This is double whammy. First, PSL forces banks to artificially limit loans to the most productive firms. Second, it redirects them to small scale businesses. When these businesses grow big, they'll lose these benefits. Because PSL sectors are inherently more risky and underperforming, banks compensate by charging higher rates from other debtors.
Many electricity utilities in India are under financial distress. The root cause is usually highly subsidised electricity for agriculture. Free resources incentivize indiscriminate use. The costs for the electricity have to be recovered from somewhere. Charging consumers more is a political non-starter. So commercial and industry users bear the brunt of the charges. That causes more wastage of capital that could be more productively used elsewhere.
It would be good to have a comparative measure to know the extent of what the economy is losing out on. Hsieh and Klenow set out to measure it for the manufacturing sector. Using plant-level data from India's Annual Survey of Industries (ASI) and the US Census of Manufacturing, they try to compute the TFP growth that India could have if resource allocation were as efficient as the US. They estimate that India's TFP could increase by 30-50% if resources were allocated as efficiently as the US.
To drive home the impact of this, consider a contrived example. If making 10 cars cost Rs 1,00,000, this increase in productivity would make 13-15 cars in Rs 1,00,000. That means the retail price drops too. The purchase power of the Indian consumer increases significantly. And that's what wealth ultimately is — the ability to purchase more stuff!
It is important to note that it isn't India that uniquely faces these issues. Mexico has been struggling with negative TFP growth for some time. The IMF estimates that correcting its resource misallocation could more than double its productivity!
India's red lines on agriculture came to the forefront during the scuttled India-US trade deal talks. Reportedly, India was reluctant to open up its agricultural sector to the market. There are various political and economic reasons why. I want to focus on the productivity aspect of this.
Agricultural value added per worker. Source: Our World In Data.
Agricultural value added for developed countries like Canada and Australia are $120,000 per worker. That number is $1,500 for India. Practically, that means fewer workers are needed to grow food. The implication is that food is cheaper because it is grown so efficiently.
Barriers to agricultural productivity in India are many. Electricity subsidies allow farmers to pump out groundwater cheaply. Judicious use is disincentivized. Massive fertilizer subsidies deter farmers from looking for efficient ways of using crops.
Another big problem is unclear land titles. 66% of pending civil cases in courts across India involve land issues. While clogged courts affect productivity in their own way, the proximate impact is that farmers are reluctant to invest in improvements for the long term.
Rice yields compared to some developed countries and China. Source: Our World In Data.
Crop yields are a good way to show the disparity in productivity. I've chosen to show only rice yields here, but the story repeats itself in many crops. India produces 4t/ha of rice, the US produces about 8t/ha and China produces about 7t/ha. So both of these countries need approximately half as much land to produce the same amount of rice as India.
It would be wrong to pigeonhole this as an agricultural issue only. In a densely populated country as India, land is a precious resource. More land for agriculture implies less land for industry and housing. Consequently, because demand stays the same, prices have to rise, contributing to the rising inputs in those sectors. In turn, that has second order effects on productivity.
Cities carry immense benefits. They're agglomeration engines. Multiple firms and workers are close to each other. Knowledge spillovers lead to exchange of ideas increasing innovation. Innovation is the only way to increase productivity.
Cities also offer large and diverse labour pools. Specialised skills are easily available. That's one reason why, despite increasing costs, firms still find it hard to leave the San Francisco Bay Area. For employees, there's minimal frictional unemployment and switching costs. Involuntary unemployment being low, workers can continue being productive longer.
As a result of higher density, cities have better infrastructure. Infrastructure provides more returns on investment as the density of a city increases. Supply chains are also easier to setup locally which reduces logistics costs for many companies.
And this is just a partial list of benefits. In light of this, it seems odd that local governments across the country seem intent on enforcing low density norms.
New York City allows a Floor Area Ratio (FAR) of up to 15 in some areas. London doesn't have a maximum FAR. Instead it bases its permission on access to public transport. Tokyo allows an FAR of up to 5 for residential areas while commercial areas can go up to 16.
Other than Hyderabad, no other Indian city has FARs that come even close to these levels. Sparse cities force residents into ever longer commutes affecting productivity. They force industries to pay higher prices for land. And they force residents and firms to disperse which nullifies the biggest benefit of cities.
For firms, the most productive ones should be able to accrue more factors of production to produce more output. That's a fancy way of saying that the most efficient firms should be able to get more land if they want to. A study from the World Bank covering the period 1989-2010 concluded that the most productive firms weren't able to do so. It estimated that improving this constraint could increase worker output by 25%.
There's a common fear that high productivity will kill jobs and lead to unemployment. France put a cap of 35 hours/week of work because of this misguided belief. This is just the lump of labour fallacy.
Productive firms and workers create goods and services cheaply. Cheaper products cause higher demand. So that productivity growth itself created new opportunities. Also, if output itself is high enough, that less hours are needed to produce necessities, new sectors are often created. The entertainment industry is a good example where more leisure contributes to increasing entertainment output. In turn, the entertainment industry is generating demand for workers.
Historically, industrialisation increases productivity and also makes some jobs redundant. But it does so gradually while creating new industries. Automation in factories would have probably contributed to jobs in design. Firms could afford to hire designers to ensure that their products would stand out in the marketplace.
The core proposition is that high productivity increases the size of the economic pie. Effectively, there's more of everything to go around.
I often find it useful to use agriculture as an intuition pump. When a given piece of land could grow only enough food for one family, it would be hard for the family to be generous and give away food. Someone would have to go to bed on a hungry stomach. But higher productivity could allow them to grow more food than their immediate need. Which would allow them to give away food to mendicants.
Swipe Left For Next Video
Across the economy, higher productivity works similarly. A rising tide lifts all boats.
Rohit Shinde is a US-based software engineer interested in economics and India's policy challenges. He writes at The Indic Prism on Substack and posts on X as @rohitshinde121. Views expressed in the above piece are personal and solely that of the author. They do not necessarily reflect News18's views.
Source: News18
Related Posts: ITP Aero breaks ground for Rs 453 crore aerospace components facility in Hyderabad Government okays 22 proposals under electronics components manufacturing scheme US targets Chinese companies over drone components used by Hamas Electronics Components Manufacturing Fitness coach shares 6 components he needs in every meal for a balanced plate Looking for conversations around tech development without losing value system OpenAI can finally stop saving deleted ChatGPT conversations Why More Conversations Didn’t Always Translate Into Healing OpenAI routes sensitive conversations to GPT-5 Instant— What users need to know Does Instagram spy on private conversations with your phone mic
63-year-old grandmother shares 1 exercise senior citizens must do to stay independent as they age: 'Knee pain is tricky' Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 14:05:05 IST By Sanya Panwar Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Think you should skip squats due to knee pain? This 63-year-old fitness coach says
5 hours ago
India’s economy grew 7.8% year-on-year in the April-June quarter of FY27, significantly stronger than the market expectation of around 7.1% and above the Reserve Bank of India’s 7% projection. The latest number is particularly important because it came at a time when the global economy was
5 hours ago
Like many Gen Zs in Kozhikode, Athira K.B. enjoys eating out and spends much of her free time watching short food videos on Instagram. “If a restaurant regularly pops up on my feed, I instantly feel like checking out what makes it so special,” the 22-year-old college student says
5 hours ago
As Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh Mohan Bhagwat took the stage at New York City’s Madison Square Garden on Saturday to deliver a message of “universal oneness”, a group of nearly 90 American politicians was preparing a different memo: they would not accept political contributions from entities
5 hours ago
A five-member bench of the National Company Law Tribunal on Tuesday stayed the approval of a repayment plan under which media baron Subhash Chandra was allowed to pay Rs 6.2 crore to creditors against admitted claims of about Rs 22,006 crore in his personal insolvency resolution process
5 hours ago
US President Donald Trump’s tenure has vindicated many in the Indian foreign policy establishment prone to reflexive anti-Americanism. However, the recent history of intensified engagement between India and the US, the ongoing bureaucratic collaboration
8 hours ago
Sensex, Nifty open flat amid renewed crude oil price rally, global tensionsThe 30-share BSE Sensex declined 307.24 points, or 0.40 per cent, to close at 76,957.27 with 20 of its constituents ending lower and 10 with gains on Monday Updated on: Sep 1, 2026
8 hours ago
U.S. President Donald Trump threatened on Monday (August 31, 2026) to hit Iran “hard” after the two foes traded fire for the first time in weeks, as his Treasury secretary vowed to keep up a pressure campaign aimed at hobbling Tehran’s economy. After six months of war
8 hours ago
Step inside Mouni Roy’s beautiful 4 BHK apartment in Mumbai featuring minimal décor and a cosy library Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 11:30:03 IST By Anukriti Srivastava Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Mouni Roy gave a house tour of her Mumbai 4 BHK apartment
8 hours ago
OpenAI denied Apple's allegations of trade secret theft on Monday, saying the iPhone maker failed to show any confidential information was stolen by former employees."This dispute is a mess of Apple's own making, and it is trying to blame everyone else
8 hours ago
The toll in the flash flood and mudslide in Nepal and China, which occurred on August 26, rose to 1,003 on Tuesday. Of these, 987 deaths were reported in Nepal. The remaining 16 deaths were on the Chinese side of the border, AFP reported. More than 3
8 hours ago
September 1, 2026, Birthday Horoscope: Don't let fear overpower you from experiencing something genuine todayYour birthday falls on September 1, 2026 here’s what your year ahead looks like, as per Tarot. Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 11:01:25 IST By Kishori Sud Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link
8 hours ago
Toxic worldwide box office collection day 6: Yash film crashes, crawls past ₹300 crore; yet to surpass Adipurush, PeddiToxic worldwide box office collection day 6: Yash's pan-India film is now earning less than ₹10 crore per day worldwide after bad word-of-mouth. Updated on: Sep 1, 2026
8 hours ago
Naseeruddin Shah wishes 'more strength' to student protestorsFrom backing student protests to praising theatre behind bars, Naseeruddin Shah speaks up on protest, performance and the power of truth Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 11:33:59 IST By Aadrika Sominder Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link
8 hours ago
The families of more than 600 workers believed to be trapped in a vast network of mud-filled tunnels along Nepal's Trishuli River are clinging to hope their loved ones can be found alive. Rescuers continued battling to reach them on Monday, using explosives to blast into the hillside before pumping
8 hours ago
Maharashtra, Assam, Bengal, Bihar join Centre in SC bid to quash FIRs against CJP protestersThe move came a day after the Centre moved the court seeking quashing of FIRs registered in connection with the CJP-led protests Updated on: Sep 1, 2026
8 hours ago
European traveller says he was scared to visit India due to 'bad image, stereotypes': 'I found more kindness than chaos' Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 10:51:25 IST By Sanya Panwar Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Expecting chaos, he found kindness: Robert says India changed how he judges places
8 hours ago
Over 200 Zomato employees in 'customer delight' section in Hyderabad to be laid offEmployees impacted by the layoffs will also be helped in their search for relevant opportunities. Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 09:36:24 IST By HT Business Desk Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Zomato is expected
8 hours ago
Refrain from sharing the Universal Account Number (UAN), password, One-Time Password (OTP), and Aadhaar details. New Delhi: EPFO has issued a cyber awareness advisory to stay alert against frauds. Cases of fraud are becoming increasingly prevalent, particularly through digital modes
8 hours ago
Meta is fixing a loophole that allowed wearers of its AI smart glasses to secretly record others without consent. Meta’s new AI smart glasses feature a white light sensor that starts blinking when the wearer is taking a photo or video through their device
8 hours ago
‘Bengaluru Metro discipline deserves appreciation’: Woman praises commuters for orderly queues, offering seatsA woman lauded Bengaluru Metro commuters for disciplined boarding, respectful behaviour and offering seats to women. Published on: Sep 1, 2026
8 hours ago
Manchester City have opened talks with Chelsea in their bid to sign midfielder Enzo Fernandez. In what is set to be one of the key narratives on transfer deadline day, City have set the wheels in motion towards what would be one of the most expensive deals of the summer
8 hours ago
PM Modi hails ‘herculean feat’, Congress asks ‘where are jobs?’: GDP figures draw mixed responseTaking a jab at his critics, Modi said some people in India, “drowned in an atmosphere of despair”, were spreading “lies” across the country. Published on: Sep 1, 2026
8 hours ago
The company said the move is aimed at strengthening transparency and food quality for consumers, and warned that restaurants failing to comply with its requirements could be removed from the platform. New Delhi: Food delivery platform Zomato on Monday said it has adopted a zero-tolerance policy on
8 hours ago
As Janmashtami approaches, homes begin to take on a festive glow. Laddu Gopal gets a new outfit, the little cradle is beautifully decorated, flowers are brought in and preparations begin for the midnight celebration. Amid all these preparations
8 hours ago
The company said Shipsy Brain draws on data linked to more than five billion shipments. This includes more than 50 billion operational events, 1.5 billion automated and human decisions, 100 billion GPS pings and over 5,000 logistics workflows. Enterprise firm on September 1 launched in beta
8 hours ago
A Singaporean diplomat who led the adoption of the UN Ocean Treaty, a Myanmar activist who put his freedom on the line for democracy, and a former Bangladeshi teacher who brought compassion to the poor were named on Monday as the winners of this year’s Ramon Magsaysay Awards
8 hours ago
