Delhi University has completed three regular rounds of undergraduate admissions, but 13,433 UG seats are still vacant. According to the university’s latest
Education

Delhi University has completed three regular rounds of undergraduate admissions, but 13,433 UG seats are still vacant. According to the university’s latest spot-round vacancy list, the unfilled seats are spread across 1,160 college-course combinations

“We have a history of renowned political leaders; we hail from the lands of intellect. This university has nurtured multiple leaders
Education

“We have a history of renowned political leaders; we hail from the lands of intellect. This university has nurtured multiple leaders, including Gulzarilal Nanda, Madan Lal Khurana, Mahadevi Varma, and many Chief Justices,” 23-year-old Priyanshu Vidrohi said

In Bihar’s Gaya district lies Patwa Toli, a village popularly known as the “Village of IITians.
Education

In Bihar’s Gaya district lies Patwa Toli, a village popularly known as the “Village of IITians." What makes it remarkable is the presence of IIT-educated engineers in almost every household. Every year, more than a dozen students from the village qualify for the IIT-JEE examinations

Jammu-born entrepreneur Onkar Singh Batra has added another remarkable achievement to an already extraordinary journey. From creating a website at the age of
Education

Jammu-born entrepreneur Onkar Singh Batra has added another remarkable achievement to an already extraordinary journey. From creating a website at the age of seven to developing a satellite at 16, Batra has spent much of his childhood exploring technology, entrepreneurship, and space

I have passed Class 12 (PCMB) with a state rank of 10 and have taken NEET 2026 and KCET. I want to pursue B.Sc. Chemistry but people say I should not do so
Education

I have passed Class 12 (PCMB) with a state rank of 10 and have taken NEET 2026 and KCET. I want to pursue B.Sc. Chemistry but people say I should not do so because I have such good marks. I am also considering BDS or a B.Sc. Paramedical course

In a new book of essays, scholar GN Devy asks whether India risks becoming an anti-knowledge nation

Posted By: Tarun Kumar Posted On: Nov 28, 2025Share Article
In a new book of essays
Author G N Devy.

One of the recurring themes in the BJP government's discourse is that of making India “vishwaguru”. The government's policy for education, its restructuring of higher education regulators, its wishful depiction of ancient India's past and its cultural politics – all are oriented towards claiming for India the status of a “knowledge-country”. On the face of it, the idea sounds alluring, but it cannot be accomplished through self-glorification or through mere propaganda. Unless the deep incompatibility between the Sanskrit universe of knowledge and the “universal knowledge” by which the world lives is understood, all adventurist steps taken are likely to result in the exact opposite of what is desired. And in the process, India may be pushed into becoming an anti-knowledge nation.

During the transition from the use of Latin to modern European languages for intellectual and imaginative expression – in the 17th century – the obsession to invent a symbolic method for “stating knowledge” made it possible for European scholars to arrive at sorting ideas in terms of what came to be accepted as “universal science”. Earlier, in 1582, Giordano Bruno had come up with the idea that combining “associations of ideas” in manageable symbolic strings would help hold a vast amount of knowledge in a relatively small band of human memory. A century later, in 1675, Leibniz proposed his celebrated “logical calculi”, stated in the aphorism “existere nihil aliud esse quam harmonicum esse” (to exist is nothing other than to be harmonious). In that span of a century and a half from Bruno to Leibniz, Europe had discovered the ability of the human mind to reduce diverse perceptions to a “harmonised understanding”, capable of being stated in abstract terms. This ability is described in philosophical terms as “rationality”.

If René Déscartes (1595–1650) gave Europe the philosophical basis for its rationality, often highlighted through his claim “je pense, donc je suis” (I am, because I think), Bruno, Leibniz and their contemporaries gave Europe the “method” of stabilising knowledge on the bedrock of rationality. The history of ‘sorting out and storing ideas' in Europe should be of interest to India as well, for, in the process, memory started getting transmuted from being just a commonly shared heritage of human societies to a higher order platform for commanding and canonising the cerebral acts of humans, resulting in the idea of a “universal knowledge”, which is the real business of universities.

However, the fundamental difference between the turn that the 17th-century use of memory took in Europe and the fixation with memory in India was that here, the idea of a “science of knowledge” or a “universal knowledge” did not find favour with those who were expected to cultivate knowledge. The idea of knowledge as “knowing”, bringing in a subjective intuition as the horizon of intellect, together with the seasoned use of memory for a flawless reproduction of the texts from the past, had resulted in “guru-parmapara” and “apprenticeship” becoming the privileged mode of education in India. This was a challenge.

It became even more menacing when combined with the stringent gender and caste segregation that besieged the Indian society more than two thousand years ago. The gender-exclusionary and clan or caste-based apprenticeship mode of knowledge transmission became a formidable hindrance in producing any genuine “universal science”. While high-accuracy memorisation continued to be the tool for storing developments in ideas, access to such memorisation was restricted according to the caste origin of the learners.

During precolonial times, two broad streams of memory-based knowledge emerged in India without the possibility for mutual exchange and cross-fertilisation: one, the memory traditions of those with access to abstract symbols, including writing; and two, the memory traditions of those who were denied symbolic abstractions. The latter continued as “knowledge-workers” within their limited confines. The possibility of India devising a grand scheme of classifying “all that was known” in the diverse knowledge traditions with the help of a single and unified symbolic grid – all memory – did not take shape.

It is with the wound of a deeply divided “memory field” that India has been trying to internalise the idea of a “universal knowledge” over the last two centuries. The 19th-century attempts to modernise society had to launch upon the project of creating access to a shared band of abstract signs, opening the transition to new fields of knowledge that qualified to be “universal” science. Similar, perhaps far more difficult, was the struggle to get girls into formal education.

After a century and a half of that difficult struggle, the BJP education policy is trying to prioritise and privilege the “sanatan vidyas”, and coaxing scientists to revisit long forgotten theories, giving them preference over what is described in the RSS terminology as “the pollution caused by Western knowledge”. The sheepish Vice Chancellors and boards of studies are propagating the mood in order to safeguard their funding. If the project succeeds, we may soon find ourselves becoming an anti-knowledge nation. If the education policy imposed on universities asks for an unquestioning acceptance of all that was ancient, the result will be a fatal loss of the ability to ask meaningful questions, the primary task for which universities exist.

Excerpted with permission from Citizen Under Siege: Essays (2014–2025), GN Devy, Westland.

Source: Scroll
Related Posts: Books and Ideas, Citizen Under Siege, Citizen Under Siege GN devy, GN Devy Citizen Under Siege, GN Devy, GN Devy books, essays, education in india, BJP

Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


Me: Lalitha, you’ve been colouring all this time. Do you enjoy colouring? This was an informal conversation I had with two young British-Indian children —
Education
Teaching students to think in the age of ChatGPT

Me: Lalitha, you’ve been colouring all this time. Do you enjoy colouring? This was an informal conversation I had with two young British-Indian children — a seven-year-old boy and his four-year-old sister, Lalitha — during a train journey from Coimbatore to Chennai.Me: Lalitha

12 hours ago

The National Testing Agency (NTA) has been grounded in controversy since the NEET UG paper leak row. The central agency, which was envisaged in November 2017
Education
NTA must be scrapped or reformed

The National Testing Agency (NTA) has been grounded in controversy since the NEET UG paper leak row. The central agency, which was envisaged in November 2017 as a single agency for conducting all higher education entrance exams, is under scanner after cancellation of UGC NET exam for three subjects

15 hours ago

An estimated 8.7 crore Indians aged 15 to 29 are not studying, working or undergoing training, said a report by the NITI Aayog, the main public policy think
Education
8.7 crore young Indians are ‘NEET’ – not in education

An estimated 8.7 crore Indians aged 15 to 29 are not studying, working or undergoing training, said a report by the NITI Aayog, the main public policy think tank of the Union government. The report, titled Reimagining Skilling for Viksit Bharat@2047

15 hours ago

Over the past decade, India’s finance talent pool has expanded rapidly. Access to education has improved, certifications are more widely pursued
Education
Why finance education needs to connect to the real world

Over the past decade, India’s finance talent pool has expanded rapidly. Access to education has improved, certifications are more widely pursued, and exposure to financial concepts has increased. But the biggest concern in finance education today is the shift towards attention-driven learning

1 days ago

<b>Eligibility:</b> Indian nationals in school (Class 9 to 12), UG or PG courses with at least 75% or 7.9 CGPA (10% relaxation for SC/ST students)
Education
August 22, 2026

Eligibility: Indian nationals in school (Class 9 to 12), UG or PG courses with at least 75% or 7.9 CGPA (10% relaxation for SC/ST students) and an annual family income not exceeding ₹300,000 (School students) and ₹600,000 (other categories). Eligibility: Indian nationals in school (Class 1 to

1 days ago

The National Testing Agency (NTA) on Saturday issued a show-cause notice to M/s Eduquity Career Technologies Pvt. Ltd. over lapses in the conduct of the All
Education
NTA Suspends Eduquity's Empanelment Over Jaipur AIAPGET Lapses

The National Testing Agency (NTA) on Saturday issued a show-cause notice to M/s Eduquity Career Technologies Pvt. Ltd. over lapses in the conduct of the All India AYUSH Post Graduate Entrance Test (AIAPGET) at an examination centre in Jaipur

1 days ago

For several decades, AutoCAD has remained the foundational tool in Civil Engineering practice. It has shaped how design documentation is produced, reviewed
Education
The new tech stack every civil engineer must master

For several decades, AutoCAD has remained the foundational tool in Civil Engineering practice. It has shaped how design documentation is produced, reviewed, and executed across projects of varying scales. However, in the current trajectory of the Architecture, Engineering

1 days ago

Having read several of Saikat Majumdar’s novels and a couple of his non-fiction books, I consider him one of those rare contemporary writers who move
Education
Writing to dazzle can be a fatal mistake of the preoccupation with writerly craft

Having read several of Saikat Majumdar’s novels and a couple of his non-fiction books, I consider him one of those rare contemporary writers who move seamlessly across fiction, nonfiction, and academia – embodying the spirit of a true literary polymath

1 days ago

Ausa police in Maharashtra’s Latur district have registered a First Information Report (FIR) against Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) founder Abhijeet Dipke
Education
Cockroach Janta Party's Abhijeet Dipke Booked By Maharashtra Police Over 'Illegal' School Check

Ausa police in Maharashtra’s Latur district have registered a First Information Report (FIR) against Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) founder Abhijeet Dipke, associate Ajinkya Shinde, and three to four unidentified individuals following allegations of unorganised intrusion, filming

1 days ago

For generations, the pursuit of grades or marks has ruled Indian academia. Teachers quite often lament that this socially constructed obsession with high
Education
How assignments can be converted into a socio-economic asset

For generations, the pursuit of grades or marks has ruled Indian academia. Teachers quite often lament that this socially constructed obsession with high scores impedes authentic contextual learning. Yet the contemporary learner is moving away from a test-oriented approach to ask: What will I get

2 days ago

A moving note reading “I will become a doctor in my next life
Education
I Will Become A Doctor In My Next Life

A moving note reading “I will become a doctor in my next life" was recovered after a 19-year-old NEET aspirant died by suicide at his residence in Maharashtra’s Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar district. The deceased, identified as Krishna Subhash Sonawane

2 days ago

The National Testing Agency (NTA) on Thursday night defended its Rs 200 fee for challenging an answer key, saying the system is “designed to be fair
Education
Designed To Be Fair

The National Testing Agency (NTA) on Thursday night defended its Rs 200 fee for challenging an answer key, saying the system is “designed to be fair" to all students. The agency also rejected concerns that the charge is “too expensive". The NTA’s answer key challenge process allows candidates

2 days ago

The President of India, Droupadi Murmu, will confer the National Teachers Awards on 48 school teachers at Vigyan Bhawan, in New Delhi, on September 5, 2026
Education
48 teachers to be honoured by President on September 5

The President of India, Droupadi Murmu, will confer the National Teachers Awards on 48 school teachers at Vigyan Bhawan, in New Delhi, on September 5, 2026. The purpose of the National Teachers Award is to celebrate the unique contribution of some of the finest teachers in the country and to honour

2 days ago

The COVID-19 pandemic permanently reshaped how colleges and universities deliver coursework, conduct exams, and share resources. The shift toward hybrid and
Education
Why India’s colleges need to build accessibility into digital learning systems

The COVID-19 pandemic permanently reshaped how colleges and universities deliver coursework, conduct exams, and share resources. The shift toward hybrid and blended learning that it accelerated has become the new standard. For many students, this transformation has unlocked greater flexibility and

2 days ago

<strong>AP ICET Counselling 2026</strong>: The Andhra Pradesh State Council of Higher Education (APSCHE) has officially announced the schedule for
Education
AP ICET Counselling 2026 OUT

AP ICET Counselling 2026 : The Andhra Pradesh State Council of Higher Education (APSCHE) has officially announced the schedule for the AP ICET 2026 centralised web counselling. Candidates seeking admission to MBA and MCA programmes at universities and affiliated colleges in the state can commence

2 days ago

The Centre on Thursday (August 20, 2026) told the Supreme Court that the 2026 University Grants Commission equity regulations on preventing caste-based
Education
UGC equity regulations 2026 under reconsideration

The Centre on Thursday (August 20, 2026) told the Supreme Court that the 2026 University Grants Commission equity regulations on preventing caste-based discrimination on campuses is under reconsideration. On January 29, the apex court had directed that the University Grants Commission (Promotion of

4 days ago

In June 2026, thousands of students gathered at Delhi’s Jantar Mantar after the National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (NEET-UG) was cancelled following a
Education
India’s rush to expand medical education may put patient safety at risk

In June 2026, thousands of students gathered at Delhi’s Jantar Mantar after the National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (NEET-UG) was cancelled following a paper leak, demanding accountability from the government. The protests, which culminated in the resignation of Union Education Minister

4 days ago

Following NEET UG, irregularities have also come to light in the UGC NET June 2026 examination. However, the Central Government told the Supreme Court on
Education
NTA Faces Supreme Court Heat Over NEET Reforms

Following NEET UG, irregularities have also come to light in the UGC NET June 2026 examination. However, the Central Government told the Supreme Court on Wednesday that the system used to conduct NEET UG is foolproof and difficult to breach. The government explained that several moderators are

4 days ago

The NCERT has reconstituted the textbook development team for classes 11 and 12 political science with a mandate to integrate cultural rootedness
Education
RSS-linked academics in NCERT textbook panel

The NCERT has reconstituted the textbook development team for classes 11 and 12 political science with a mandate to integrate cultural rootedness, Indian knowledge systems and inclusion, with at least four of the members having direct or indirect links with the RSS

4 days ago

The Delhi High Court has put JNU’s postgraduate admissions on hold. The court has stopped the university from finalising any admissions that use extra
Education
Delhi HC Halts JNU's 'Deprivation Points' System

The Delhi High Court has put JNU’s postgraduate admissions on hold. The court has stopped the university from finalising any admissions that use extra “deprivation points." The court said adding bonus marks to scores from a big national exam like CUET is unfair

4 days ago

In many Maths classrooms, a student encounters a challenging question, pauses for a moment, and almost immediately looks towards the teacher for assistance
Education
The power of productive struggle in Maths learning

In many Maths classrooms, a student encounters a challenging question, pauses for a moment, and almost immediately looks towards the teacher for assistance. Within seconds, a method is demonstrated, the solution is revealed, and the class moves on. The problem is solved

5 days ago

A university convocation is traditionally a rite of passage—a solemn initiation where the next generation of legal minds are welcomed into the fold of
Education
The NALSAR standoff and the BCI’s crisis of authority

A university convocation is traditionally a rite of passage—a solemn initiation where the next generation of legal minds are welcomed into the fold of justice. However, this month, the halls of NALSAR University of Law became the site of a regulatory tantrum that threatened to undermine the very

5 days ago

IIT Kharagpur will begin the registration process for the Joint Admission Test for Masters (JAM) 2027 on September 5, 2026. The application window will remain
Education
IIT JAM 2027 registration date announced

IIT Kharagpur will begin the registration process for the Joint Admission Test for Masters (JAM) 2027 on September 5, 2026. The application window will remain open until October 12, 2026. The institute, which is organising the examination this year

6 days ago

Mumbai: The Karnataka High Court admitted a fresh plea by Qatar Holding LLC against debt-laden edtech firm Byju’s, seeking to enforce a SGD 7
Education
Karnataka HC admits Qatar Holding plea for enforcement of award against Byju’s

Mumbai: The Karnataka High Court admitted a fresh plea by Qatar Holding LLC against debt-laden edtech firm Byju’s, seeking to enforce a SGD 7.2 million ( ₹53 crore) arbitration award against founder Byju Raveendran and his company Byju’s Investments Pvt. Ltd (BIPL) in July

6 days ago

The Jharkhand government, led by Chief Minister Hemant Soren, announced on August 17, 2026, that the JSSC Combined Graduate Level (JSSC-CGL) examination held
Education
JSSC CGL 2024 Cancelled

The Jharkhand government, led by Chief Minister Hemant Soren, announced on August 17, 2026, that the JSSC Combined Graduate Level (JSSC-CGL) examination held in 2024 has been cancelled. The government has also ordered a detailed investigation into alleged irregularities in government recruitment

6 days ago

The Enforcement Directorate (ED) on Tuesday carried out searches at 21 locations in Karnataka and Ahmedabad over alleged irregularities in the Karnataka Public
Education
Karnataka Exam Paper Leak

The Enforcement Directorate (ED) on Tuesday carried out searches at 21 locations in Karnataka and Ahmedabad over alleged irregularities in the Karnataka Public Service Commission’s (KPSC) Veterinary Officers recruitment examination, ANI reported

6 days ago

For decades, India’s school education policy pursued a simple objective: to bring a school within reach of every child. The neighborhood school became an
Education
Misfortune or a step towards holistic development

For decades, India’s school education policy pursued a simple objective: to bring a school within reach of every child. The neighborhood school became an instrument of social justice, particularly for poor and rural families. However, many such schools have limited infrastructure and serve very

6 days ago