Delhi University has completed three regular rounds of undergraduate admissions, but 13,433 UG seats are still vacant. According to the university’s latest spot-round vacancy list, the unfilled seats are spread across 1,160 college-course combinations
“We have a history of renowned political leaders; we hail from the lands of intellect. This university has nurtured multiple leaders, including Gulzarilal Nanda, Madan Lal Khurana, Mahadevi Varma, and many Chief Justices,” 23-year-old Priyanshu Vidrohi said
In Bihar’s Gaya district lies Patwa Toli, a village popularly known as the “Village of IITians." What makes it remarkable is the presence of IIT-educated engineers in almost every household. Every year, more than a dozen students from the village qualify for the IIT-JEE examinations
Jammu-born entrepreneur Onkar Singh Batra has added another remarkable achievement to an already extraordinary journey. From creating a website at the age of seven to developing a satellite at 16, Batra has spent much of his childhood exploring technology, entrepreneurship, and space
I have passed Class 12 (PCMB) with a state rank of 10 and have taken NEET 2026 and KCET. I want to pursue B.Sc. Chemistry but people say I should not do so because I have such good marks. I am also considering BDS or a B.Sc. Paramedical course
How the traditional guru-shishya system undermined critical thinking in India
A student recently asked me for my opinion on the traditional guru-shishya system, in which teachers transmit knowledge to students (usually referred to as disciples), who often even live with them and are totally dedicated to them. In this system, the word of guru is final. Recalling a discussion we had in class, he wanted to know what relevance it might have now. Is it positive or entirely negative? He also inquired about its significance in the context of learning music.
Pondering over his question, I recalled an article written five years ago by musician TM Krishna. Krishna had argued that the guru-shishya tradition – or rather, the institution it represents – ought to be dismantled altogether.
The guru-disciple relationship, he said, is founded on a permanent imbalance of power. What is striking is that this imbalance is not merely tolerated: it is celebrated. Within this structure, the disciple is expected not only to submit to the guru's authority but to surrender herself entirely to him. The flaw lies in the very architecture of the institution. Questioning the guru is treated as a transgression. Dissent does not even enter the realm of possibility.
In music, as in certain other artistic fields, there is no shortage of stories recounting the severe trials imposed by gurus before they agree to accept someone as a student. These trials are rarely related to knowledge or aptitude. Instead, the aspirant is often required to perform domestic labour for weeks on end – washing the guru's utensils, cleaning the house, running errands. Only once loyalty and devotion have been sufficiently demonstrated does the guru agree to impart instruction.
The guru is frequently imagined as possessing divine attributes. The philosopher Aurobindo suggests that when one surrenders before the guru, one is not surrendering to the human being but to the divine element within him. But who certifies the presence of this divine element? By what signs is it to be recognised?
Krishna's article was written in the context of allegations of sexual abuse made by disciples against one of the the renowned Gundecha brothers in Hindustani classical music. He observed that whispers about such conduct have circulated for years within the worlds of music and dance, yet very few find the courage to speak openly.
The cost of going up against powerful gurus can be prohibitively high. Gurus may be rivals in professional matters, but when it comes to preserving the authority of the guru as an institution, they can close ranks. An unwritten pact of silence operates here – one that was clearly visible in the near-total silence of star musicians during the Gundecha controversy.
In the guru–shishya tradition, the guru is beyond question. His decisions cannot be challenged. Drawing inspiration from Krishna's essay, an officer of the Indian armed forces wrote an article in which he talked about an incident from his training days.
During a session, instead of responding to a trainee's question, the instructor summoned him to the front and said, “You want an answer? Here is your answer”, delivering a sharp slap across his face. The trainee returned to his seat clenching his teeth, his eyes filling with tears of humiliation. The entire class remained silent, because questioning the guru was unthinkable. There was no question of disciplinary action against the officer.
The writer later reflected that by remaining silent in the face of such violence, he too had been complicit in wrongdoing.
Krishna rightly notes that while individual experiences of this tradition may vary, our attention must be directed towards the institution itself. Within the guru-shishya system, the guru's authority is absolute. He is under no obligation to explain why he accepts one person as a disciple and rejects another. The moment at which a disciple is deemed worthy of initiation is determined entirely by the guru's will.
This institution cannot function without the guru's unchecked authority. Since the question is being raised in the Indian context, it is impossible to ignore its deep entanglement with the caste system. Who is entitled to be a guru? Whom does he consider worthy of discipleship? Hindu mythic memory preserves two particularly instructive stories.
One is that of Dronacharya, who demanded that Ekalavya cut off his thumb as guru-dakshina, a token of gratitude to the teacher, even though he had never taught him.
The other is the story of Parashurama, from whom Karna received instruction after concealing his caste. When his caste was revealed, Karna was cursed to forget the knowledge he had acquired at the moment he would need it most.
In both stories, the disciple's caste and lineage become insurmountable obstacles to their legitimate acceptance.
Ironically, India's highest sports award bears the name of Dronacharya and hardly anyone has ever objected to this. This silence itself testifies to how deeply caste is embedded in our cultural unconscious. If we examine calls today for reviving the guru-shishya tradition, it becomes evident that this demand is largely an expression of the desire of so-called upper castes to reassert control over education.
Such demands are unlikely to come from Scheduled Caste or Scheduled Tribe communities, for it was precisely the guru-shishya system that historically barred them from educational spaces. A revival of this tradition would once again confine cultural capital to upper-caste groups. It is not difficult to imagine which gurus from which castes would be deemed worthy of producing disciples.
Modern education, by contrast, rests on the principle of equality. No one is barred from entry, at least theoretically. Indeed, special measures are taken to ensure access for those who were historically excluded from educational institutions. Admission does not depend on the discretion of an individual; it is governed by impersonal procedures.
In the guru-shishya tradition, however, the guru's will is supreme. Were such a system to be implemented today, there would be no need to speculate about which sections of the population would be excluded from education.
Equality in modern education is not limited to access alone. One of its broader aims is to establish the principle of equality within society itself. With the advent of modernity, the idea of universal access to education has gained steady acceptance. Knowledge is understood as a right, and it is the responsibility of the state to ensure that this right is realised.
Alongside this is the recognition that no domain of knowledge or skill belongs exclusively to any one community. Every field must remain open to all. Military education, for example, is not meant for a particular caste or for the defence of a royal lineage; it exists to protect society as a whole and is therefore open to everyone.
In today's educational system, curricula are shaped through collective deliberation rather than by the will of a single authority. A student is expected to work not with one teacher alone but with many. There are numerous ways of thinking and analysing, many modes of knowledge. Students cannot remain bound to a single individual; they must retain the freedom to choose. Their loyalty is not to a particular guru but to their field of inquiry.
Moreover, no field of knowledge exists in isolation; a wider intellectual horizon is essential. Such breadth cannot be achieved merely by being the disciple of one guru. Yet, as Aurobindo suggests, the Indian tradition insists that a disciple's loyalty must be directed to one guru alone.
The purpose of modern education is not to preserve the status quo but to transform it – and such transformation does not move in a single direction. The guru–shishya tradition, by contrast, functions to preserve social dominance rather than to unsettle it.
Modern education is founded on the freedom to question. The guru-shishya tradition does not permit this freedom. Within it, the disciple is expected to renounce her ego, efface herself entirely, and accept the guru's word as final.
The aim of modern education, however, is to cultivate an independent voice and autonomy. This often requires rejecting what is widely accepted.
A central objective of education is to expand the space for democratic thought and democratic feeling. Does the guru-shishya tradition help achieve this aim?
The reason the guru-shishya tradition is being celebrated so insistently in India today is that those in power no longer desire independent, critical minds. They seek obedient subjects, individuals trained to surrender before authority. The task of education is to warn against this tendency and to nurture a critical outlook. In this long walk, the guru-shishya tradition is not a support but an obstacle.
Apoorvanand teaches Hindi in Delhi University.
Source: Scroll
Related Posts: India, TM Krishna, Music education in India, What is the guru shishya tradition, Why guru shishya tradition must be revived
Me: Lalitha, you’ve been colouring all this time. Do you enjoy colouring? This was an informal conversation I had with two young British-Indian children — a seven-year-old boy and his four-year-old sister, Lalitha — during a train journey from Coimbatore to Chennai.Me: Lalitha
11 hours ago
The National Testing Agency (NTA) has been grounded in controversy since the NEET UG paper leak row. The central agency, which was envisaged in November 2017 as a single agency for conducting all higher education entrance exams, is under scanner after cancellation of UGC NET exam for three subjects
14 hours ago
An estimated 8.7 crore Indians aged 15 to 29 are not studying, working or undergoing training, said a report by the NITI Aayog, the main public policy think tank of the Union government. The report, titled Reimagining Skilling for Viksit Bharat@2047
14 hours ago
Over the past decade, India’s finance talent pool has expanded rapidly. Access to education has improved, certifications are more widely pursued, and exposure to financial concepts has increased. But the biggest concern in finance education today is the shift towards attention-driven learning
1 days ago
Eligibility: Indian nationals in school (Class 9 to 12), UG or PG courses with at least 75% or 7.9 CGPA (10% relaxation for SC/ST students) and an annual family income not exceeding ₹300,000 (School students) and ₹600,000 (other categories). Eligibility: Indian nationals in school (Class 1 to
1 days ago
The National Testing Agency (NTA) on Saturday issued a show-cause notice to M/s Eduquity Career Technologies Pvt. Ltd. over lapses in the conduct of the All India AYUSH Post Graduate Entrance Test (AIAPGET) at an examination centre in Jaipur
1 days ago
For several decades, AutoCAD has remained the foundational tool in Civil Engineering practice. It has shaped how design documentation is produced, reviewed, and executed across projects of varying scales. However, in the current trajectory of the Architecture, Engineering
1 days ago
Having read several of Saikat Majumdar’s novels and a couple of his non-fiction books, I consider him one of those rare contemporary writers who move seamlessly across fiction, nonfiction, and academia – embodying the spirit of a true literary polymath
1 days ago
Ausa police in Maharashtra’s Latur district have registered a First Information Report (FIR) against Cockroach Janta Party (CJP) founder Abhijeet Dipke, associate Ajinkya Shinde, and three to four unidentified individuals following allegations of unorganised intrusion, filming
1 days ago
For generations, the pursuit of grades or marks has ruled Indian academia. Teachers quite often lament that this socially constructed obsession with high scores impedes authentic contextual learning. Yet the contemporary learner is moving away from a test-oriented approach to ask: What will I get
2 days ago
A moving note reading “I will become a doctor in my next life" was recovered after a 19-year-old NEET aspirant died by suicide at his residence in Maharashtra’s Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar district. The deceased, identified as Krishna Subhash Sonawane
2 days ago
The National Testing Agency (NTA) on Thursday night defended its Rs 200 fee for challenging an answer key, saying the system is “designed to be fair" to all students. The agency also rejected concerns that the charge is “too expensive". The NTA’s answer key challenge process allows candidates
2 days ago
The President of India, Droupadi Murmu, will confer the National Teachers Awards on 48 school teachers at Vigyan Bhawan, in New Delhi, on September 5, 2026. The purpose of the National Teachers Award is to celebrate the unique contribution of some of the finest teachers in the country and to honour
2 days ago
The COVID-19 pandemic permanently reshaped how colleges and universities deliver coursework, conduct exams, and share resources. The shift toward hybrid and blended learning that it accelerated has become the new standard. For many students, this transformation has unlocked greater flexibility and
2 days ago
AP ICET Counselling 2026 : The Andhra Pradesh State Council of Higher Education (APSCHE) has officially announced the schedule for the AP ICET 2026 centralised web counselling. Candidates seeking admission to MBA and MCA programmes at universities and affiliated colleges in the state can commence
2 days ago
The Centre on Thursday (August 20, 2026) told the Supreme Court that the 2026 University Grants Commission equity regulations on preventing caste-based discrimination on campuses is under reconsideration. On January 29, the apex court had directed that the University Grants Commission (Promotion of
4 days ago
In June 2026, thousands of students gathered at Delhi’s Jantar Mantar after the National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test (NEET-UG) was cancelled following a paper leak, demanding accountability from the government. The protests, which culminated in the resignation of Union Education Minister
4 days ago
Following NEET UG, irregularities have also come to light in the UGC NET June 2026 examination. However, the Central Government told the Supreme Court on Wednesday that the system used to conduct NEET UG is foolproof and difficult to breach. The government explained that several moderators are
4 days ago
The NCERT has reconstituted the textbook development team for classes 11 and 12 political science with a mandate to integrate cultural rootedness, Indian knowledge systems and inclusion, with at least four of the members having direct or indirect links with the RSS
4 days ago
The Delhi High Court has put JNU’s postgraduate admissions on hold. The court has stopped the university from finalising any admissions that use extra “deprivation points." The court said adding bonus marks to scores from a big national exam like CUET is unfair
4 days ago
In many Maths classrooms, a student encounters a challenging question, pauses for a moment, and almost immediately looks towards the teacher for assistance. Within seconds, a method is demonstrated, the solution is revealed, and the class moves on. The problem is solved
5 days ago
A university convocation is traditionally a rite of passage—a solemn initiation where the next generation of legal minds are welcomed into the fold of justice. However, this month, the halls of NALSAR University of Law became the site of a regulatory tantrum that threatened to undermine the very
5 days ago
IIT Kharagpur will begin the registration process for the Joint Admission Test for Masters (JAM) 2027 on September 5, 2026. The application window will remain open until October 12, 2026. The institute, which is organising the examination this year
6 days ago
Mumbai: The Karnataka High Court admitted a fresh plea by Qatar Holding LLC against debt-laden edtech firm Byju’s, seeking to enforce a SGD 7.2 million ( ₹53 crore) arbitration award against founder Byju Raveendran and his company Byju’s Investments Pvt. Ltd (BIPL) in July
6 days ago
The Jharkhand government, led by Chief Minister Hemant Soren, announced on August 17, 2026, that the JSSC Combined Graduate Level (JSSC-CGL) examination held in 2024 has been cancelled. The government has also ordered a detailed investigation into alleged irregularities in government recruitment
6 days ago
The Enforcement Directorate (ED) on Tuesday carried out searches at 21 locations in Karnataka and Ahmedabad over alleged irregularities in the Karnataka Public Service Commission’s (KPSC) Veterinary Officers recruitment examination, ANI reported
6 days ago
For decades, India’s school education policy pursued a simple objective: to bring a school within reach of every child. The neighborhood school became an instrument of social justice, particularly for poor and rural families. However, many such schools have limited infrastructure and serve very
6 days ago
