One of the defining characteristics of mature consumer markets is not simply the abundance of products, but the quality of consumer decision-making
Business

One of the defining characteristics of mature consumer markets is not simply the abundance of products, but the quality of consumer decision-making. Across sectors, rising financial awareness, easier access to information and digital discovery are changing what people choose to buy and how they

Imagine reaching retirement with a bond portfolio that works like a staircase. One bond matures this year, another next year, and another the year after
Business

Imagine reaching retirement with a bond portfolio that works like a staircase. One bond matures this year, another next year, and another the year after, giving you access to money at different points instead of having to unlock the entire investment at once

<strong>Augmont Enterprises IPO Day 2:</strong> The initial public offering (IPO) of integrated gold and silver platform Augmont Enterprises Ltd is
Business

Augmont Enterprises IPO Day 2: The initial public offering (IPO) of integrated gold and silver platform Augmont Enterprises Ltd is witnessing its second day of bidding today, August 24. So far, the public issue has been subscribed 2.88 times. The Rs 825-crore IPO

<h4>Gold prices remain high in India; check 22K, 24K rates in Mumbai, Delhi, Bengaluru</h4> <h4>International gold prices also climbed to a
Business

Gold prices remain high in India; check 22K, 24K rates in Mumbai, Delhi, Bengaluru International gold prices also climbed to a more than three-month high on Monday. Published on: Aug 24, 2026, 13:46:24 IST By HT News Desk Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Gold prices remained high in India on

Nearly three-fourth of large-cap active funds underperformed a blended (LargeMidCap) benchmark over a 10-year period, according to the 2025 report by SPIVA
Business

Nearly three-fourth of large-cap active funds underperformed a blended (LargeMidCap) benchmark over a 10-year period, according to the 2025 report by SPIVA (S&P Indices Versus Active). In this article, we discuss two reasons that could, perhaps

<strong>Indian Stock Market Today, August 24:</strong> The domestic equity markets opened higher on Monday, but gains remained measured as
Business

Indian Stock Market Today, August 24: The domestic equity markets opened higher on Monday, but gains remained measured as investors continued to track elevated crude oil prices and geopolitical tensions in West Asia. At 9:16 am, the BSE Sensex was up 205 points, or 0.26%, at 77,746.06

Businesses from India and the U.S. have expressed interest in investing in Bangladesh and made proposals to improve the country's investment climate
Business

Businesses from India and the U.S. have expressed interest in investing in Bangladesh and made proposals to improve the country's investment climate, Commerce Minister Khandakar Abdul Muktadir has said. Mr. Muktadir’s remarks on Saturday (August 22

Minimalistic retractable door handles became a signature feature of electric vehicles (EVs), but the controversial designs are now at the centre of China's
Business

Minimalistic retractable door handles became a signature feature of electric vehicles (EVs), but the controversial designs are now at the centre of China's biggest car recall, affecting more than 4 million vehicles. The recall, which includes 2.98 million Chinese-made Teslas

How the IMF underplays its own assessment of the real cost of war

Posted By: Jaydatt Chaudhary Posted On: Apr 28, 2026Share Article
How the IMF underplays its own assessment of the real cost of war
Palestinian children stand near tents for displaced people, in Gaza City on August 29. | Bashar Taleb / AFP

The International Monetary Fund’s April 2026 World Economic Outlook arrives with an unusually candid subtitle – Global Economy in the Shadow of War – in the same month that NATO has locked in its most ambitious military spending target in history.

The opening analytical chapter notes explicitly that NATO members committed in June 2025 to raise annual defence and security-related spending to 5% of GDP by 2035, “more than double the previous 2 percent guideline”.

Two substantial chapters of empirical research follow. They document, carefully and at length, what that kind of spending surge does to economies. Then, with equal care, they decline to say whether it is wise.

Chapter 2 of the IMF report draws on data from 164 countries since 1946 to study what happens when governments rapidly scale up military spending. A typical defence spending boom, it finds, raises outlays by about 2.7 percentage points of GDP over two and a half years.

This is, as the IMF notes, “broadly similar” to what NATO members now need to do to reach their 5% target.

Roughly two-thirds of such buildups are financed by borrowing. Public debt rises about 7 percentage points within three years. When the buildup is paid for by cutting other government programmes rather than borrowing, what the IMF calls “the guns versus butter trade-off emerges” – spending on social protection, health, and education falls sharply.

In wartime, the debt costs nearly double: a 14 percentage point jump, with social spending cut regardless of how the buildup is financed.

Responding to the IMF findings, Poland’s finance minister admitted that his country’s 5% defence target “is a lot” – while justifying it by invoking Russia’s threat to neighbouring states.

That exchange captures the central tension the IMF report raises but cannot resolve: the economics of military spending and the security calculus are treated as separate rooms, and the door between them is locked.

The IMF report says that a military spending buildup that prioritises domestic production and research could “support long-term productivity growth”.

But the return on military spending depends heavily on where the money actually goes. When a country buys most of its weapons from foreign suppliers, as most developing countries do, the spending flows out of the domestic economy rather than generating local jobs, wages or industrial capacity. The money leaves as imports.

It is left for the reader to draw the implication of the IMF suggestion that who gets the defence contracts matters enormously to the economic outcome.

Chapter 3 of the April 2026 World Economic Outlook report completes the picture from the other side. Drawing on global conflict data since 1945, it finds that actual wars generate output losses exceeding those from financial crises or natural disasters – roughly 7% of GDP within five years of the onset of conflict, with scars persisting a decade later.

In 2024 alone, more than 35 countries experienced active conflict, roughly half classified as fragile and conflict-affected states.

But recovery, the IMF says, is “slow and uneven”, critically dependent on whether peace, once achieved, holds. Where it does not, “output fails to recover”. Notably, the chapter acknowledges that recovery outcomes depend heavily on political factors, including power-sharing arrangements and security guarantees.

But these possibilities, the IMF says, “lie beyond the scope of the chapter’s analysis” – a caveat in a bracket.

There is a methodological move in Chapter 2 that deserves attention. The chapter opens with a dataset of 164 countries – establishing that defence spending booms are now most frequent in emerging markets and developing economies. But the dataset narrows when the analysis turns to its policy-relevant core – what a well-designed military buildup looks like, how to maximise economic returns, what governments should do.

The detailed breakdown of what defence budgets are actually spent on covers only 35 NATO and EU member countries. The model simulation of a large defence buildup is explicitly “calibrated to the European experience”, with the assertion that results “can be generalised to other contexts”.

Imagine a study of road accidents across every city in India that then uses only data from Mumbai’s expressways to recommend national speed limits – and presents the conclusions as universally applicable.

The world’s most conflict-affected regions – West Asia and sub-Saharan Africa, which Chapter 3 identifies as bearing a disproportionate share of active global conflicts – provide the data that establishes how serious things are. These countries then exit the analysis at the point where conclusions about what to do are drawn. The non-Western world frames the problem while the Western world supplies the solution.

The IMF’s largest shareholder is the United States, which is also NATO’s founding military guarantor. The normative lens and the geopolitical architecture it reflects are, in this instance, the same thing.

Chapter 2 contains an important acknowledgment which is instead a footnote. After noting that higher defence spending could serve as a deterrent to conflict, the chapter immediately cites research showing that “deterrence effects are modest”.

Military buildups, it acknowledges, lead to only “a small and persistent decline in conflict over the long term, with no effect on short-term conflict risks”.

In other words, the core security justification for spending more is empirically weak, by the IMF’s own account. But this merits only a footnote while the chapter’s main text proceeds as if the security rationale is settled.

NATO was founded in 1949 as a US-led military alliance. Since the Cold War ended in 1991, its expansion eastward has been the defining geopolitical fault line in Europe’s relationship with Russia.

Today, European governments are simultaneously pursuing ceasefire negotiations to end the Russia-Ukraine war and locking in military spending commitments that would push their defence budgets to levels not seen since the Cold War.

A figure in Chapter 2 of the IMF report plots world average defence spending since 1946 against the NATO 2035 target of 5% of GDP. The gap between them is visually stark: the global GDP-weighted average has hovered between 2% and 3% for decades, peaking during the Cold War and declining sharply after 1991.

The NATO target would take member states back above those Cold War peaks – while, simultaneously, a fragile peace process in Ukraine is underway.

The IMF report does not comment on this juxtaposition. Its authors, if asked whether the 5% target is consistent with the chapter’s own findings, can only say that spending targets are set by security risk perceptions and that assessing those perceptions is “beyond the scope of the chapter’s analysis”.

Consider what the IMF has actually established across these two chapters: that large buildups are fiscally dangerous and socially costly; that wars cause lasting economic damage disproportionately borne by the world's poorest and most fragile states; that the deterrence argument for heavy military spending is, by the chapter's own citation, empirically modest; and that the analytical framework used to draw policy conclusions is calibrated to Western European experience and presented as universal – while the countries bearing the greatest conflict burden are used to frame the problem, then exit the analysis.

That last point has a human face the report does not show. The dataset begins in 1946. The Partition of South Asia – the price at which freedom from colonial rule was attained in 1947, and which killed up to a million people in communal massacres and displacement alone – is invisible to that definition. So is much of the violence that has actually ended the lives of millions across Asia, Africa and Latin America in the eight decades since. What appears instead are output loss percentages.

The report’s Executive Summary notes its own findings – and then recommends fiscal prudence and structural reform. The distance between the data and the recommendation is a choice about whose experience of war counts as evidence, as context and who gets to set the norms to assess and decide.

That choice now has a very specific weight. The same World Economic Outlook that brackets geopolitics as beyond its analytical scope, models three scenarios for what happens to the global economy if the West Asia war spreads – including a scenario that the IMF associates with global recession.

The war it is modelling is being fought with US military support against a country whose defeat has been a stated US foreign policy objective for decades. The NATO spending target the IMF declines to evaluate was set in the same institutional moment. The dataset it uses to model optimal defence spending draws on the military experience of the NATO alliance whose expansion helped produce the conditions for the conflicts now driving the outlook dark.

A 17-year-old reading this in Delhi or Lahore or Nairobi is not wrong to feel that the world is poised at something dangerous – and that the institutions tasked with providing the global economic outlook are describing the fire while carefully avoiding the question of who lit it and why.

Veena Naregal is professor of sociology at the Institute of Economic Growth, Delhi.

Source: Scroll
Related Posts: Business and Economy, imf world economic outlook april 2026, imf world economic outlook cost of conflict, imf defence spending, imf military spending, NATO, Ukraine

Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


<strong>Tempsens Instruments India IPO Day 3:</strong> The initial public offering (IPO) of temperature sensing and heating solutions provider
Business
Tempsens Instruments IPO Last Day

Tempsens Instruments India IPO Day 3: The initial public offering (IPO) of temperature sensing and heating solutions provider Tempsens Instruments Ltd is witnessing its final day of bidding today, August 24. So far, the public issue has been subscribed by a strong 31.34 times. The Rs 650-crore IPO

11 hours ago

<h4>S&P 500 just hit a level seen only once before in 155 years — could a market crash be next?</h4> <h4>The S&P 500 CAPE ratio hit 40 for
Business
S&P 500 hits rare level seen only once before

S&P 500 just hit a level seen only once before in 155 years — could a market crash be next? The S&P 500 CAPE ratio hit 40 for only the second time in 155 years, raising concerns about valuations, future returns and a possible market correction. Updated on: Aug 23, 2026

14 hours ago

<h4>Anthropic $2 trillion IPO: Why investors think it could be worth more than SpaceX</h4> <h4>Anthropic could reach a $2 trillion IPO
Business
Anthropic $2T IPO

Anthropic $2 trillion IPO: Why investors think it could be worth more than SpaceX Anthropic could reach a $2 trillion IPO valuation as revenue surges, raising questions about whether the AI company can be worth more than SpaceX. Published on: Aug 23, 2026

14 hours ago

US President Donald Trump has said Canada wants
Business
Trump says Canada wants

US President Donald Trump has said Canada wants "the benefits of being a State, without being one" after trade talks between the two countries collapsed late on Friday. In his first comments since negotiations broke down, triggering new 50% US tariffs on a range of Canadian goods

1 days ago

India’s payments sector has raised $5.8 billion across 371 equity funding rounds since January 2021, while producing eight initial public offerings (IPOs)
Business
Indian payments firms raised $5

India’s payments sector has raised $5.8 billion across 371 equity funding rounds since January 2021, while producing eight initial public offerings (IPOs) and triggering 25 acquisitions, as the industry increasingly consolidates around a handful of well-funded players

1 days ago

<h4>Can Reddit survive in the AI era?</h4> <h4>It wants more cash for its data—and more of people’s time</h4> Published on: Aug 22
Business
Can Reddit survive in the AI era

Can Reddit survive in the AI era? It wants more cash for its data—and more of people’s time Published on: Aug 22, 2026, 16:40:48 IST The Economist Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Earlier this summer “Backrooms”, a horror flick, became one of the most successful independent films ever

1 days ago

What with a 250th birthday, Taylor Swift's wedding and the football World Cup, Americans could be forgiven for taking their eye off the ball this summer
Business
Why the US economy is ringing alarm bells

What with a 250th birthday, Taylor Swift's wedding and the football World Cup, Americans could be forgiven for taking their eye off the ball this summer. But signs of economic trouble have been building. This week they hit the headlines when US national debt passed the $40tn (£29.4tn) mark

1 days ago

Insurance regulator IRDAI has directed Edelweiss Life Insurance and Pramerica Life Insurance, in separate orders on August 20, not to open new place of
Business
IRDAI bars life insurers Pramerica

Insurance regulator IRDAI has directed Edelweiss Life Insurance and Pramerica Life Insurance, in separate orders on August 20, not to open new place of business for six months for non-compliance with Expenses of Management (EoM) limits in 2024-25

2 days ago

India remains a very attractive destination for global investments and its economic fundamentals form the basis for strong investor confidence, Jyoti Jeetun
Business
India remains very attractive destination for global investments

India remains a very attractive destination for global investments and its economic fundamentals form the basis for strong investor confidence, Jyoti Jeetun, the Minister of Financial Services and Economic Planning of Mauritius told The Hindu in an interview

2 days ago

A fresh wave of US tariffs on a wide array of Canadian goods has come into effect as of midnight on Saturday after a last minute break down in trade talks
Business
Canada says it will match US tariffs

A fresh wave of US tariffs on a wide array of Canadian goods has come into effect as of midnight on Saturday after a last minute break down in trade talks. Announcing the suspension of negotiations shortly before the Friday night deadline, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney said he would impose

2 days ago

<strong>TCS Employee Surveillance Row:</strong> Tata Consultancy Services (TCS), India’s largest IT services company, on Friday denied reports
Business
TCS Denies Employee Surveillance Reports

TCS Employee Surveillance Row: Tata Consultancy Services (TCS), India’s largest IT services company, on Friday denied reports that it is using monitoring tools to track individual employee activity on company-issued laptops. The IT giant said the purpose of the tools is to monitor the overall

2 days ago

<h4>Walmart stock falls 9% as retailer finally brings Apple Pay, Google Pay</h4> <h4>Walmart stock fell 9% after earnings despite beating
Business
Walmart stock falls 9% as retailer finally brings Apple Pay

Walmart stock falls 9% as retailer finally brings Apple Pay, Google Pay Walmart stock fell 9% after earnings despite beating estimates and raising guidance. The retailer will add Apple Pay and Google Pay Tap to Pay from August 24. Updated on: Aug 21, 2026

2 days ago

TikTok has agreed to pay $400m (£293m) to the US to end a lawsuit alleging its platform violated children‘s privacy, marking one of the largest ever
Business
TikTok to pay $400m to US in one of largest child privacy settlements

TikTok has agreed to pay $400m (£293m) to the US to end a lawsuit alleging its platform violated children‘s privacy, marking one of the largest ever settlements over the issue. The deal stems from a 2024 suit by the Department of Justice under former President Joe Biden alleging TikTok and its

2 days ago

<h4>What’s next for Nvidia after the AI chip boom? Wall Street wants more—here’s what investors need to know</h4> <h4>Nvidia stock
Business
What’s next for Nvidia after the AI chip boom

What’s next for Nvidia after the AI chip boom? Wall Street wants more—here’s what investors need to know Nvidia stock faces high expectations ahead of August 26 earnings as Wall Street watches AI growth, valuation, open-source models and Nvidia's next big story. Updated on: Aug 22, 2026

2 days ago

<h4>Costco dividend rises: Why a $10,000 investment pays only $61 yearly</h4> <h4>A $10,000 Costco investment earns only about $61 a year in
Business
Costco dividend rises

Costco dividend rises: Why a $10,000 investment pays only $61 yearly A $10,000 Costco investment earns only about $61 a year in regular dividends. Here’s why investors still buy COST for growth and special dividends. Updated on: Aug 20, 2026

3 days ago

Leaving education, getting a job, buying a home and perhaps starting a family: the path previous generations followed may seem a distant dream to many now
Business
UK millennials are struggling to buy a home - but is it actually getting easier

Leaving education, getting a job, buying a home and perhaps starting a family: the path previous generations followed may seem a distant dream to many now. But is it getting a bit easier - at least when it comes to getting on the housing ladder? Today's prospective first-time buyers may well feel

3 days ago

Nearly six months after US President Donald Trump vowed a swift victory over Iran, the conflict appears to be at a standstill, with prospects of a military
Business
How much could Trump's 'economic D-Day' hurt Iran

Nearly six months after US President Donald Trump vowed a swift victory over Iran, the conflict appears to be at a standstill, with prospects of a military victory or negotiated settlement growing dimmer. To break the deadlock, Trump has vowed an "economic D-Day" under which any country that does

3 days ago

<h4>Why US stocks fell today: Dow, S&P 500, Nasdaq drop as oil and bond yields rise</h4> <h4>US stocks fell as oil prices and Treasury yields
Business
Why US stocks fell today

Why US stocks fell today: Dow, S&P 500, Nasdaq drop as oil and bond yields rise US stocks fell as oil prices and Treasury yields rose. Dow, S&P 500 and Nasdaq dropped as Trump's Iran threat, Walmart and the bond market hit Wall Street. Published on: Aug 20, 2026

3 days ago

<h4>Crypto stocks surge as Trump backs Clarity Act: Coinbase, Circle, miners rise</h4> <h4>Crypto stocks surge as Trump backs the Clarity Act
Business
Crypto stocks surge as Trump backs Clarity Act

Crypto stocks surge as Trump backs Clarity Act: Coinbase, Circle, miners rise Crypto stocks surge as Trump backs the Clarity Act. Coinbase, Circle, Bitcoin miners and other crypto shares rise as investors expect clearer US crypto rules. Updated on: Aug 20, 2026

4 days ago

<strong>Stock Market Today, August 20:</strong> The domestic equity market snapped its seven-day losing streak and ended sharply higher on Thursday
Business
Market Snaps 7-Day Losing Streak

Stock Market Today, August 20: The domestic equity market snapped its seven-day losing streak and ended sharply higher on Thursday, August 20, as broad-based buying lifted sentiment across sectors after the US Treasury stepped in to contain the surge in global bond yields

4 days ago

The Reserve Bank of India RBI has accorded its approval to Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) for acquiring an aggregate holding of up to 9
Business
RBI allows LIC to increase holding in HDFC Bank from 4

The Reserve Bank of India RBI has accorded its approval to Life Insurance Corporation of India (LIC) for acquiring an aggregate holding of up to 9.99% of the paid-up share capital or voting rights in HDFC Bank Ltd., the bank said in a filing with the exchanges on Wednesday (August 19, 2026) night

4 days ago

Customers have shared their outrage after an app used by many businesses to track timesheets and produce invoices hiked bills by as much as 1500%
Business
UK business hit by

Customers have shared their outrage after an app used by many businesses to track timesheets and produce invoices hiked bills by as much as 1500%, with one person calling it "daylight robbery". Richard Haldenby, head of UK consultancy firm Salentis

4 days ago

<strong>Bitcoin Price Today, August 20:</strong> Bitcoin surged to the $70,000 mark on Thursday, recording one of its sharpest gains in recent
Business
Bitcoin Hits $70

Bitcoin Price Today, August 20: Bitcoin surged to the $70,000 mark on Thursday, recording one of its sharpest gains in recent months as a combination of lower US Treasury yields, a weaker dollar, strong institutional demand and large-scale short liquidations pushed the broader cryptocurrency market

4 days ago

US President Donald Trump has said he will launch tougher economic measures against Iran, as well as any country and that helps or does business with the
Business
Trump vows tougher economic measures on Iran and supporting countries

US President Donald Trump has said he will launch tougher economic measures against Iran, as well as any country and that helps or does business with the country. He wrote in all capital letters on Truth Social that he was launching "the most crushing economic operation ever taken against any

4 days ago

The domestic equity markets were trading firmly higher on Thursday, August 20, with buying visible across large-cap, mid-cap and small-cap stocks
Business
Sensex Gains 628 Points

The domestic equity markets were trading firmly higher on Thursday, August 20, with buying visible across large-cap, mid-cap and small-cap stocks. The gains strengthened through the session, with the benchmark Sensex rising more than 600 points by 1:20 pm

4 days ago

U.S. President Donald Trump will host ​cryptocurrency executives at the White House on Wednesday as U.S. ‌financial regulators this week prepare to advance
Business
Trump to host crypto executives as SEC considers regulations

U.S. President Donald Trump will host ​cryptocurrency executives at the White House on Wednesday as U.S. ‌financial regulators this week prepare to advance their framework ​for certain digital assets. Trump, who has ⁠earned more than $1.4 billion from his family’s crypto ventures

4 days ago

<h4>Telecom inflation, chargers and the number 45, and Small Talk ASL app</h4> <h4>Beyond the regular noise, a closer look at personal
Business
Telecom inflation

Telecom inflation, chargers and the number 45, and Small Talk ASL app Beyond the regular noise, a closer look at personal technology. 20 August 2026. Published on: Aug 20, 2026, 08:00:58 IST By Vishal Mathur Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Opening thoughts. Josh Staub

4 days ago