The Delhi High Court has stayed proceedings in a criminal defamation case filed against Sudarshan TV and its editor Suresh Chavhanke in connection with allegations that his channel made false accusations against a madrasa. The case against Chavhanke was filed by Mohammed Tufail Khan
The Trump Intervention That Got the DOJ Off Live Nation’s Back Antitrust case started out aiming to force the concert giant to sell Ticketmaster. After two White House meetings, a deal kept the company intact. Published on: Aug 24, 2026, 14:02:07 IST WSJ Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link The
China said on Sunday (August 23, 2026) it was postponing its planned ambitious Chang'e-7 lunar mission, which was set to carry out explorations including searching for water ice on the moon. The Chang'e-7 spacecraft was originally set to lift off in the coming days from the Wenchang Space Launch
Canada’s Carney Puts His ‘No Deal Is Better Than a Bad Deal’ Doctrine to the Test The prime minister ’s approach has broad support from the Canadian public and his political opponents, but it isn’t without risks. Published on: Aug 24, 2026, 14:05:27 IST WSJ Prefer HTon Google Share via
An Indian national was killed in a shooting incident in New York on Friday night, said the Indian consulate general in the city. The man, Gurdeep Singh, was killed on Crescent Street in the city’s Brooklyn area, in what police believe may have been a road rage incident, CBS News reported
A group of former cricket captains, including Indian batting legend Sunil Gavaskar and one of England's longest-serving skippers Sir Alastair Cook, have called on Pakistan to ensure its ex-PM Imran Khan be given proper care while in custody. The cricketer-turned-politician has been in jail since
Fewer than 20 commodity vessels transited the Strait of Hormuz at the weekend, shipping data showed on Monday (August 24, 2026), as Iranian and U.S. blockades restrict traffic through the chokepoint for energy shipments. Four vessels crossed the strait on Sunday (August 23, 2026)
India had asked the United States not to allow reporters to ask questions during Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s meeting with President Donald Trump on the sidelines of the G7 summit in France in June, US Ambassador to India Sergio Gor said on Saturday
‘Enemies within’: How Pakistan rounded up Bengalis into interment camps as leverage after 1971
Growing up in the 1980s in Bangladesh, I had heard many stories of the 1971 war. I knew about the Bengalis working, for example, in the civil service of Pakistan, like my uncle who was stranded with his family until their repatriation in 1974.
However, I had never heard much about Bengalis imprisoned in internment camps in Pakistan, or come across any literature about them. History books in Bangladesh highlight Bengali officers who joined the liberation efforts, but Bengali civilians interned in West Pakistan are invisible from this narrative.
Indeed, in the annals of Southasian history, few events are as freighted with silence and selective memory as the break-up of Pakistan in 1971.
Ilyas Chatta's recently published book Citizens to Traitors: Bengali Internment in Pakistan, 1971-1974 (Cambridge, 2025) fills this vacuum. The book has a powerful thesis: the internment of Bengalis in Pakistan from 1971 to 1974 was not merely a logistical consequence of war, but a calculated political tool used in one of the largest cases of mass internment in Southasia.
Chatta's scholarly work, an essential addition to the historiography of the conflict, excavates a story of state-sanctioned internment, betrayal, and the complex calculus of citizenship and nationhood that remains largely unknown.
This nonfiction book is a straightforward, somber and heart-wrenching account of human misery, that tells the story of how a postcolonial state in the throes of a profound identity crisis, wielded its power to “make and unmake” citizens. It raises questions about the political uses of the concept of “treason”, humanised by stories of Bengali-Pakistani inter-marriage and individuals who invested their livelihood in the nation they thought was theirs, only to be reclassified overnight from citizens to traitors.
The story of wartime internment of Bengalis in West Pakistan is “long overdue” as Chatta argues. The “state-centred narrative” and focus on “national interest” caused a “double exclusion” for this group, making them invisible in popular memory and “denied a voice within their own community” – an effect described as “silences within silences” by the anthropologist Michel-RolphTrouillot in Silencing the Past: Power and the Production of History (Beacon Press, 2015).
The creation of Bangladesh from erstwhile East Pakistan is a story of brutal civil war and the rise of a new linguistic national identity. The broader narrative of military and diplomatic conflict has been well documented, but the fate of thousands of Bengalis trapped in West Pakistan in its aftermath has long remained a footnote.
With 93,000 Pakistani prisoners of war in Indian custody after the war, the Pakistani state made a move of calculated realpolitik. It rounded up over 81,000 of its former Bengali citizens – civil and military personnel along with their families – into camps as leverage.
According to Chatta's research, there were estimated to be about 400,000 Bengalis in erstwhile West Pakistan after 1971. While ordinary Bengalis were not interned, they faced strict scrutiny. The war intensified patriotic sentiment in Pakistan. Bengalis were immediately suspected and could be arrested and detained under the Defense of Pakistan Rules.
It took a few agonising years for an exchange to take place. The Bengalis stranded in Pakistan, cast as “enemies within”, were finally repatriated in 1974 in a tripartite negotiation.
Organised in seven aptly named chapters, the book offers a piercing conclusion. It goes beyond high-level geopolitics to a human-scale reconstruction of events.
The first chapter, “Making of a Traitor”, shows how the real reasons for the war – like longstanding regional and political inequality – were recast into a national story in West Pakistan, portraying the Bengalis as villains who acted against the country that was supposed to unite Indian Muslims.
The introductory chapters draw on data points such as the unequal representation of Bengalis in the civil and military services, providing a statistical backdrop to the political alienation that would ultimately justify their mass detention.
From this foundation, the narrative shifts to the lived experience of internment. The author meticulously catalogues the diverse experiences of Bengalis – not a monolithic group but including military staff, civil servants, students, and workers.
Chapters on “Military Encampment” and “Civilian Internment” detail the distinctions between these experiences. Military personnel and high-ranking civil servants were held in designated cantonment camps, while a broader civilian population, including those laid off from factories, found themselves in squalid camps. The author describes the ‘primitive conditions' and the psychological toll of being isolated and abandoned.
One of the book's most valuable contributions is its focus on the “stranded Bengalis” outside the camps. This group, detailed in Chapter 5, were those who were not formally interned but were left destitute and vulnerable in cities like Karachi and Islamabad.
They were also the target of attacks from members of the Jamiat-Islami and Biharis who arrived from erstwhile East Pakistan and spearheaded public mobilisation against them. As the Bengalis were forced out or fled West Pakistan, Biharis were resettled in their abandoned homes and properties.
These Bengalis, many summarily dismissed from jobs, were quickly plunged from relative comfort into poverty. They relied on the “Langar Khana” or gruel kitchen, charity, and a crucial “grapevine communications network”.
This network exemplifies what Chatta terms ‘defensive resistance,' highlighting the community's resilience under duress. They also established a Bengali Welfare and Repatriation Committee and a Free Medical Scheme, a private health service hailed as a major achievement by Bengali doctors. While not in “captivity” in internment camps, these physicians, unable to leave West Pakistan, established 13 clinics and 10 dispensaries across 10 of their neighbourhoods in Karachi.
As the author notes, Pakistan's refusal to officially recognise its Bengali population as refugees or as a detained community hindered passage of international relief and support services through aid organisations like United Nations Children's Fund and International Committee of the Red Cross.
The chapter “Escape or Die” outlines grueling, desperate escape attempts by Bengalis by air, sea, land, mountains, and deserts when it became clear that repatriation was distant and existing in Pakistan, amidst social animosity, was difficult.
Pakistani authorities offered cash rewards for apprehending escapees and punished those who aided them. Some perished or lost their savings. One account tells of 50 Bengalis paying Rs. 1000 each for a 500-mile truck trip from Karachi to Quetta. Their Pathan agent bribed officials to cross into Afghanistan, but the driver subsequently robbed them of their remaining money and valuables.
A few notable high-profile Bengalis also escaped, like Shahnaz Rahmatullah Begum (1952-2019), a renowned Bengali singer whose Urdu songs were also popular in Pakistan, including patriotic favourites Sohni Dharti and Jeevay Pakistan. She “fled on the very day she was due to appear at a charity concert to raise funds for the POWs in January 1973. Only two weeks earlier, President Bhutto had joined her on stage at a local auditorium to sing the latest patriotic pop song in duet”.
However, “the biggest blow to Pakistan”, notes Chatta, “was the escape of its foreign secretary and veteran loyalist, S. M. Yusuf (1966-1972), who left Islamabad on the night of 19 January and emerged in Kabul in February, from where he flew to New Delhi and then Dacca. His escape was more damaging for the state than any other.”
“The Politics of Triangular Repatriation” outlined in Chapter 7 delves into the complex politics of repatriation. The internment of Bengalis was directly linked to the Pakistani POWs in India. This created a political triangle of Pakistan, India, and Bangladesh, each with a different set of demands and priorities.
Chatta's analysis exposes how this human misery was exploited as a bargaining chip. All three sides exaggerated and tried to paint others as villains and reason for the tragic impasse. The book includes propaganda cartoons and clips from newspapers in Pakistan, Bangladesh and India.
The Pakistani state used the POWs' plight to inflame nationalistic passions – politicians offered to trade their own sons in return for the imprisoned soldiers. They also threatened to put the interned Bengalis on trial if Bangladesh pursued war crimes charges against the Pakistani soldiers for war crimes.
At stake was also the recognition of Bangladesh, by Pakistan, the Arab nations and the UN. The author presents this diplomatic, high-stakes poker game not just as a matter of statecraft, but as a deeply human drama, one that prolonged the suffering of tens of thousands.
A diplomatic solution finally emerged in August 1973 with the signing of a tripartite agreement. Pakistan would repatriate its Bengali internees in exchange for its POWs in India. By mid-1974, nearly 120,000 Bengalis had returned home. But their ordeal was far from over.
In Bangladesh, their return was met not with celebration, but with suspicion and scorn. Branded as collaborators and dismissed from service, many were denied promotions and cruelly labelled “bastard repatriates”. Shafiul Azam, East Pakistan's former chief secretary, was blacklisted for appearing in a Pakistani documentary. Tabarak Hussain, a senior foreign service officer, was demoted upon his return for having “stayed behind” to protect his family.
These repatriates faced a new kind of exile. They were seen as tainted, carrying a “Pakistani mentality” incompatible with the spirit of the new nation. Their suffering was not heroic; it was inconvenient. It was a silent story, a wound unacknowledged by official history. For their children, the stigma of having a “repatriated father” was a social and psychological burden.
A moving foreword, “Ora Fire Elo”, by the US-based Bangladeshi historian Naeem Mohaiemen, describes the ordeal, disappointment and hostility faced by Bengalis returning from Pakistan. These included Mohaiemen's father, a physician in the Army Medical Corps who had been honoured by Pakistan for his service on the frontlines of the 1965 India-Pakistan war.
After 1971, Major Mohaiemen was detained with his wife and son Naeem, then two years old, in Fort Sandeman Camp in Baluchistan. Mohaiemen recounts their breakneck speed drive to the airport after their release, in fear that Pakistan would reverse its decision and cancel flights to Dhaka.
Mohaiemen poignantly describes how, even in post-liberation Bangladesh, these former internees were not seen as returning heroes. Unlike “ninety percent” of those returning who “would be satisfied with two basic meals a day (and) blend in with the hungry masses of Bangladesh”, this “remaining ‘ten percent' could become a national problem”.
In Pakistan, the official discourse has simply erased the internments altogether, a form of “necessary silencing” for a nation that had to reconfigure its identity after a traumatic loss.
In the end, estimates the author, more than three million “stateless” people were left in Dhaka's Geneva Camp and Karachi's Machar Colony, making them massive slums of undocumented people in Southasia.
Chatta has painstakingly dredged through government records and documents for this book, including intelligence records such as Daily Situation Report prepared by Special Intelligence Branch along with other archival and personal information via interviews.
While researching for the project (2015-2023), Chatta faced myriad challenges and discouragement, including from academics. Many advised him to protect the interest of the Pakistan state and its narrative.
Admirably, he persisted because, “What we have in place of history is a shelf full of memoirs of generals and bureaucrats, who have written self-serving books about their involvement in events that led to the most significant political crisis in Pakistan's history,” as he comments in the concluding chapter.
Ultimately, the book's greatest achievement is how it breaks through the “political forgetting” that has long characterized the region and its post-colonial conflicts. By gathering unused archival sources, literary accounts, and personal testimonies, the author has not only written a history of a forgotten internment, he has provided a sobering lesson on the fragility of citizenship, the state's capacity for violence against its own people, and the ways in which historical trauma can be consciously or unconsciously suppressed.
After a long hiatus, as both nations again attempt to improve relations and people-to-people connections, various factors continue to be at play, like war crimes, the Bihari issue, the proximity of both countries to India, and geopolitics. Meanwhile, ordinary people in both places continue to yearn for freedom from suppression and improved economic opportunities.
The book reflects the eternal, simultaneous struggle of good and evil; once unleashed, evil is hard to contain, causing widespread suffering. Yet, the history recorded here also shows the human spirit's ability to overcome adversity.
This is an essential read for understanding the enduring legacies of the 1971 war beyond the diplomatic corridors of power, focusing on the memory and trauma of those who lived through its aftermath.
Irfan Chowdhury is a public-sector policy analyst and adviser from Bangladesh. He writes opinion columns for Bangladeshi dailies and online platforms, like The Daily Star, Dhaka Tribune, Alalodulal, bdnews24, and Sapan News.
This is a Sapan News syndicated feature.
Source: Scroll
Related Posts: World, bengali refugees, bengali refugees 1971, West pakistan bengali POWs, bengali hostages, Pakistan, Bangladesh Liberation War, Bangladesh
Former Australian captain Greg Chappell with the support of 20 other former international skippers appealed to the Pakistan Government led by Prime Minister Muhammad Shehbaz Sharif, to provide ‘humane treatment and proper medical care’ for Imran Khan
11 hours ago
The shock resignation of Tata Sons chairman N Chandrasekaran earlier this month has left corporate India's top job vacant. But finding his successor will be no easy task for the country's most revered conglomerate, whose sprawling $300bn empire spans Jaguar Land Rover and Air India as well as
11 hours ago
Iran's President Masoud Pezeshkian defended a memorandum of understanding with the United States as the best way out of a stalled war. Meanwhile, the new head of the Islamic Republic's top security body warned, in a more forceful tone, of retaliation if neighbouring countries support U.S
11 hours ago
Authorities in China have launched an investigation into reports of formaldehyde being used to preserve the freshness of cabbages for human consumption. Officials in the northeastern Hebei province confirmed that they had verified footage showing individuals dipping cabbages in a solution before
11 hours ago
Three newborns died after a fire that broke out in the neonatal intensive care unit of a government hospital in Maharashtra’s Amravati district in the early hours of Monday, PTI reported. The fire broke out at the Amravati District Women’s Hospital around 3
11 hours ago
Imran's party demands immediate cardiac care for him at Shifa International Hospital Imran's party demands immediate cardiac care for him at Shifa International Hospital Published on: Aug 24, 2026, 11:10:49 IST PTI Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Islamabad
11 hours ago
Japanese Prime Minister Sanae Takaichi’s three-day visit to New Delhi in July 2026 for the India-Japan summit appears to have elevated relations between the two Asian countries into a fresh phase of strategic expansion. Ties had already undergone a remarkable transformation over the past decade
11 hours ago
How well do COVID antivirals actually work? Not as well as we thought How well do COVID antivirals actually work? Not as well as we thought Published on: Aug 24, 2026, 11:11:50 IST PTI Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Sydeny, If you're aged over 70
11 hours ago
On Sunday, in a post on X, Wali said the audio contained "explosive evidence" and claimed that Brar admitted his gang had ordered Nijjar's killing, alleging that the assassination was driven by an inter-gang feud. Ottawa: Three years after NIA designated terrorist Hardeep Singh Nijjar was killed in
15 hours ago
Until recently, there would have been little to distinguish Vietnam's so-called Justice Tree from the hundreds of others lining the streets of Hanoi. Then the bouquets started piling up. It was here that former politician Nguyen Sy Cuong was driving his BMW in May last year when he veered into the
15 hours ago
Fast-fashion giant Shein says it plans to raise up to HK13.86bn (£1.3bn; $1.77bn) when its shares start trading on the Hong Kong stock market on 1 September. In a filing on Monday, Shein said it will offer nearly 280 million shares for between HK$47.60 and HK$49.50
15 hours ago
A fast-moving, wind-driven wildfire near Reno, Nevada, has forced about 42,000 people to evacuate, while another 45,000 have been urged to prepare to leave. The Hawk Fire has burned 15,040 acres, destroyed some homes and injured six people. Officials declared a state of emergency as the blaze
15 hours ago
Former Indian diplomat Navdeep Suri has raised concerns about the verification process under the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls. Suri, a retired Indian Foreign Services officer, went through the process in Punjab. It is among the 16 states where the voter roll revision is being
15 hours ago
A moderate earthquake with a preliminary magnitude of 5.9 rattled eastern Japan, including the Tokyo area, early Sunday (August 23, 2026), injuring more than 20 people, most of them slightly, officials said. There was no danger of a tsunami. According to the Japan Meteorological Agency
1 days ago
Chinese humanoid robots broke records set by humans, including beating Usain Bolt’s 100-meter sprint world record, on the opening day of the Olympics-like World Humanoid Robot Games in Beijing on Saturday (August 22, 2026). More than 2,000 humanoid robots were participating in the event
1 days ago
One afternoon in 1907, a young accountant named Chandrasekhar Venkata Raman walked into the laboratory of the Indian Association for the Cultivation of Science at 210 Bowbazar Street in Calcutta. Though he had a passion for the sciences, colonial India offered no stable careers in the field
1 days ago
Three first information reports were filed against 14 identified and more than 200 unidentified persons on Saturday in connection with clashes between the police and student protesters a day earlier, PTI quoted Ranchi Superintendent of Police Paras Rana as saying
1 days ago
Did an Amazon delivery guy assault a 71-year-old man in California? What we know about the attack and lawsuit A California lawsuit alleged that an Amazon delivery driver assaulted a 71-year-old man at an Elk Grove gas station. Updated on: Aug 23, 2026
1 days ago
‘Pure evil’: Videos of mothers splashing water at their kids spark outrage amid Lindsay Clancy trial Social media videos of mothers throwing water at their children have sparked concerns amid Lindsay Clancy's trial. Published on: Aug 23, 2026
1 days ago
The sister of jailed former Pakistan Prime Minister Imran Khan on Saturday (August 22, 2026) filed a petition in the Supreme Court, accusing the government and senior officials of violating the top court’s order to shift him to a private hospital for medical examination and treatment
1 days ago
The United States and Canada have entered into uncharted territory. The longtime allies and economic partners, who have enjoyed free trade for decades, are now in an escalating trade war with no clear off ramp. And for Prime Minister Mark Carney
1 days ago
Harrisburg weather update: Special Weather Statement issued for central Pennsylvania as thunderstorms bring 40mph wind NWS has issued a Special Weather Statement for Harrisburg and surrounding parts of central Pennsylvania. Published on: Aug 23, 2026
1 days ago
The police in Maharashtra’s Latur have registered a first information report against Abhijeet Dipke, the founder of the Cockroach Janta Party political campaign, for allegedly entering a government school without permission, threatening teachers and defaming the institution
1 days ago
The United States and Iran exchanged defiant messages ahead of Monday’s (August 24, 2026) scheduled announcement of new U.S. economic sanctions that could impact the Islamic Republic and Tehran’s most important trading partners including China
1 days ago
Fourteen people were killed in military air strikes at a monastery in Myanmar early on Friday, opposition fighters and a local rescue worker have said. All of those killed were elderly and a number of monks were also injured, the rescue worker told BBC Burmese, adding that the site was struck twice
1 days ago
Deadly airstrikes in Gaza killed at least ten people on Wednesday. These attacks occurred just days after U.S. negotiators asked Israel to reduce its actions. Israeli troops also crossed the Gaza ceasefire line and detained a Hamas official. The ongoing conflict has killed over seventy-three
1 days ago
The Armed Forces Tribunal on Thursday upheld an administrative censure for a brigadier who was commanding a sector of the Rashtriya Rifles in Jammu and Kashmir’s Poonch district in December 2023 when three civilians died during an interrogation following a militant attack
1 days ago
