Orange alert as rain leaves Gurugram waterlogged; disrupts traffic The Sector 52A market was among the most affected areas, with visuals showing commuters wading through knee-deep water Published on: Aug 24, 2026, 14:14:38 IST By Sampurna Panigrahi, Mihika Shah
‘Buy buy buy!’: Foreign tourist reacts to duty-free shopping after Delhi immigration A foreign tourist has posted a video of his Delhi airport experience, questioning the shopping pitches he encountered just after immigration. Published on: Aug 24, 2026
India security chief visits China for border talks India security chief visits China for border talks Published on: Aug 24, 2026, 14:06:38 IST AFP Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link India's top security official arrived in Beijing on Monday for talks on the countries' disputed Himalayan border
Twenty-one former international cricket captains, including India’s Sunil Gavaskar, Kapil Dev and Dilip Vengsarkar, on Sunday urged Pakistan to ensure that former Prime Minister Imran Khan is examined by a medical board, as directed by the country’s Supreme Court, The Hindu reported
A 25-year-old entrepreneur with a net worth of around ₹4.35 crore has turned to Reddit for advice after a sharp decline in the business that helped him build his fortune. Despite his wealth, he says he is now unsure about what to do next and feels “completely lost
Not a chief guests, celebrity or VIP, but a humanoid robot stole the spotlight at a sandwich shop inauguration. A video from the celebratory event has gone viral, where the robot was seen arriving at the venue with bodyguards. It then proceeded to greet guests and even broke into a dance
‘Jo bhi hai, tera ghar hai’: American compares Indian and US hospitality An American Hindi speaker’s take on Indian hospitality has viewers discussing the differences between socialising in India and the US. Published on: Aug 24, 2026, 13:31:09 IST By Vaishali Kapila Prefer HTon Google Share
Manipur: 1 CRPF personnel injured, 2 houses burnt by unknown armed individuals The gunfight broke out after two houses belonging to separate communities were set ablaze by an unidentified group of people Published on: Aug 24, 2026, 13:49:38 IST By Thomas Ngangom
EC acted within powers in SIR exercise
Election Commission acted within powers in SIR exercise, Supreme Court says
Election Commission acted within powers in SIR exercise, Supreme Court says
The Supreme Court ruled that the EC's SIR exercise was constitutional, necessary for free and fair elections, and within the poll body’s powers.
Updated on: May 28, 2026 10:54 AM IST By Utkarsh Anand Share via Copy link The Supreme Court on Wednesday upheld the validity of the special intensive revision (SIR) conducted by the Election Commission of India (ECI), ruling that the exercise furthered the constitutional objective of free and fair elections and fell within the poll panel’s powers under the Constitution and the Representation of the People Act, 1950. The Supreme Court backed ECI’s SIR exercise and rejected pleas challenging electoral roll revision. (ANI) In a significant 124-page judgment with far-reaching consequences for India’s electoral architecture, a bench of Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant and justice Joymalya Bagchi rejected a batch of petitions challenging the legality of SIR, first undertaken in Bihar and subsequently undertaken across the country. The court held that SIR “neither stands in direct conflict with the RP Act and the 1960 EC Rules, nor does it detract from the constitutional imperative of free and fair elections”, describing it instead as “an exercise traceable to Section 21(3) of the RP Act read with Article 324 of the Constitution, undertaken to advance the very objective which the Constitution is designed to protect.” With the ruling, the Supreme Court effectively settled the debate around the legal validity of SIR and simultaneously defined the constitutional contours of ECI’s powers to undertake large-scale electoral verification exercises in the future. The ruling came after assembly elections were conducted in six regions where SIR was held and millions of names were deleted. In Bengal, 9.1 million names were removed and 2.71 million people – placed under a controversial logical discrepancy category – disenfranchised because the appeals process ran out of time.Challenge to SIR
The petitions, filed by non-governmental organisations Association for Democratic Reforms and People’s Union for Civil Liberties, along with pleas by opposition leaders Manoj Kumar Jha, KC Venugopal, Mahua Moitra and political activist Yogendra Yadav, questioned both the legality and operational framework of SIR, arguing that it resulted in large-scale disenfranchisement and converted ECI into a de-facto citizenship adjudicatory authority without statutory sanction. What the Supreme Court said. (HT)Limited enquiry into citizenship
Rejecting these contentions, the bench held that ECI possessed constitutional authority to undertake a “limited enquiry into citizenship” strictly for electoral purposes. “The commission is empowered, in the exercise of its constitutional mandate, to undertake a limited enquiry into citizenship for the purpose of satisfying itself as to eligibility for inclusion in the electoral roll. Such an enquiry does not amount to a determination of citizenship in the strict sense, and any action taken pursuant thereto is confined to electoral consequences alone,” the judgment held. At the same time, the court clarified that any such finding by ECI will not attain finality on citizenship questions under the Citizenship Act. “It affects the individual’s entitlement to be included in the electoral roll, and thereby their right to participate in the electoral process. It does not, however, operate to divest the individual of claims of citizenship, nor does it foreclose a determination of that question by the competent authority under the Citizenship Act,” the court said. Importantly, the court directed that persons whose names were deleted from the 2003 rolls on the ground that they were suspected non-citizens must be referred by ECI within four weeks to the competent authority under the Citizenship Act, 1955 for adjudication. The competent authority, the bench directed, must decide such cases after notice and hearing, preferably before the next parliamentary, assembly or local body elections. If ultimately found to be citizens, such persons would be entitled to restoration of their names in the electoral rolls.Court on scope of Section 21(3)
The judgment extensively analysed the scope of Section 21(3) of the Representation of the People Act, under which ECI had initiated the Bihar SIR through its June 24, 2025 notification. The petitioners had argued that Section 21(3), meant for exceptional constituency-specific revisions, could not be stretched to justify a statewide or nationwide re-verification exercise. The court, however, rejected this interpretation and held that the expression “any constituency” under Section 21(3) could legitimately extend to “many” or “all” constituencies where circumstances warranted. The court accepted ECI’s justification that rapid urbanisation, migration, duplicate entries, non-reporting of deaths and demographic changes over more than two decades since the last intensive revision in 2003 constituted sufficient grounds for undertaking the SIR. “The restoration of accuracy, completeness, and integrity of the electoral roll is not only legitimate but integral to the constitutional mandate entrusted to the Commission,” the judgment said.On voter roll presumptions
The court also rejected the petitioners’ central reliance on the 1995 decision in Lal Babu Hussein Vs Electoral Registration Officer, where the Supreme Court had recognised a presumption in favour of voters whose names already exist on electoral rolls. While acknowledging that inclusion in the electoral roll creates a presumption of validity, the bench clarified that such a presumption is “rebuttable” and cannot operate as “a blanket embargo” on ECI’s powers to undertake systemic electoral verification exercises. “The nature of this presumption must be correctly understood. It is, at its core, an evidentiary presumption… Such a presumption cannot be elevated into a rule of substantive law that forecloses enquiry,” the judgment held. The bench further held that an intensive revision exercise undertaken by the commission is fundamentally different from individual adjudicatory proceedings contemplated in Lal Babu Hussein. “When the commission embarks upon such an exercise, it acts not as a mere adjudicator between competing claims but as a constitutional authority discharging a duty of systemic oversight,” it noted.Court upholds proportionality of SIR
The judgment also upheld the proportionality of SIR, holding that the measures adopted bore a “rational nexus” with the objective sought to be achieved and were not “manifestly excessive”. The court accepted ECI’s contention that a comprehensive statewide exercise was necessary because the identified inaccuracies were systemic in nature and could not be addressed through piecemeal constituency-level revisions. “A targeted or constituency-specific approach may address isolated irregularities, but would be ill-suited to remedy structural deficiencies that pervade the entire roll,” the bench said. At the same time, the court acknowledged concerns raised regarding documentation requirements, transparency and access, particularly for economically vulnerable and migrant populations. It noted that many of these concerns were addressed through interim directions issued by the Supreme Court during the pendency of the case. These included directions expanding the list of acceptable documents to include Aadhaar cards, requiring publication of lists of excluded electors with reasons, deploying paralegal volunteers through legal services authorities and enabling political parties through booth-level agents to assist electors in filing claims and objections. “The proportionality of a measure must ultimately be assessed not in the abstract, but in the manner in which it is implemented,” it underlined. The court also affirmed ECI’s documentation regime, rejecting allegations that the exclusion of certain identity documents was arbitrary. “The classification of documents, including the exclusion of certain categories, is based on intelligible criteria having a direct nexus with the objective of ensuring the integrity of the electoral roll,” the judgment held. The court further ruled that the deletion process under the SIR framework did not violate Rule 21A of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, observing that safeguards of notice, enquiry, hearing, speaking orders and appellate remedies remained substantively preserved within the revised framework. “The form may differ, but the substance remains intact,” held the bench while upholding the procedural framework adopted by ECI.Lawyers who appeared
During the hearings spread over nearly three months, senior advocates Kapil Sibal, Abhishek Manu Singhvi, Gopal Sankaranarayanan, Raju Ramachandran, Shadan Farasat and advocates Prashant Bhushan, Vrinda Grover and Fauzia Shakil, among others, had appeared for the petitioners. The ECI was represented by senior advocates Rakesh Dwivedi, Maninder Singh and Dama Seshadri Naidu. Election Commission Of India Supreme Court Voter Voting Eci Check India news real-time updates, latest news, CBSE 12th Result 2026 LIVE from India on Hindustan Times and more across India. Home/India News/Election Commission Acted Within Powers In SIR Exercise, Supreme Court Says See LessThe Supreme Court on Wednesday upheld the validity of the special intensive revision (SIR) conducted by the Election Commission of India (ECI), ruling that the exercise furthered the constitutional objective of free and fair elections and fell within the poll panel’s powers under the Constitution and the Representation of the People Act, 1950.
In a significant 124-page judgment with far-reaching consequences for India’s electoral architecture, a bench of Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant and justice Joymalya Bagchi rejected a batch of petitions challenging the legality of SIR, first undertaken in Bihar and subsequently undertaken across the country.
The court held that SIR “neither stands in direct conflict with the RP Act and the 1960 EC Rules, nor does it detract from the constitutional imperative of free and fair elections”, describing it instead as “an exercise traceable to Section 21(3) of the RP Act read with Article 324 of the Constitution, undertaken to advance the very objective which the Constitution is designed to protect.”
With the ruling, the Supreme Court effectively settled the debate around the legal validity of SIR and simultaneously defined the constitutional contours of ECI’s powers to undertake large-scale electoral verification exercises in the future.
The ruling came after assembly elections were conducted in six regions where SIR was held and millions of names were deleted. In Bengal, 9.1 million names were removed and 2.71 million people – placed under a controversial logical discrepancy category – disenfranchised because the appeals process ran out of time.
“The commission is empowered, in the exercise of its constitutional mandate, to undertake a limited enquiry into citizenship for the purpose of satisfying itself as to eligibility for inclusion in the electoral roll. Such an enquiry does not amount to a determination of citizenship in the strict sense, and any action taken pursuant thereto is confined to electoral consequences alone,” the judgment held.
At the same time, the court clarified that any such finding by ECI will not attain finality on citizenship questions under the Citizenship Act. “It affects the individual’s entitlement to be included in the electoral roll, and thereby their right to participate in the electoral process. It does not, however, operate to divest the individual of claims of citizenship, nor does it foreclose a determination of that question by the competent authority under the Citizenship Act,” the court said.
Importantly, the court directed that persons whose names were deleted from the 2003 rolls on the ground that they were suspected non-citizens must be referred by ECI within four weeks to the competent authority under the Citizenship Act, 1955 for adjudication.
The competent authority, the bench directed, must decide such cases after notice and hearing, preferably before the next parliamentary, assembly or local body elections. If ultimately found to be citizens, such persons would be entitled to restoration of their names in the electoral rolls.
The petitioners had argued that Section 21(3), meant for exceptional constituency-specific revisions, could not be stretched to justify a statewide or nationwide re-verification exercise. The court, however, rejected this interpretation and held that the expression “any constituency” under Section 21(3) could legitimately extend to “many” or “all” constituencies where circumstances warranted.
The court accepted ECI’s justification that rapid urbanisation, migration, duplicate entries, non-reporting of deaths and demographic changes over more than two decades since the last intensive revision in 2003 constituted sufficient grounds for undertaking the SIR.
“The restoration of accuracy, completeness, and integrity of the electoral roll is not only legitimate but integral to the constitutional mandate entrusted to the Commission,” the judgment said.
While acknowledging that inclusion in the electoral roll creates a presumption of validity, the bench clarified that such a presumption is “rebuttable” and cannot operate as “a blanket embargo” on ECI’s powers to undertake systemic electoral verification exercises.
“The nature of this presumption must be correctly understood. It is, at its core, an evidentiary presumption… Such a presumption cannot be elevated into a rule of substantive law that forecloses enquiry,” the judgment held.
The bench further held that an intensive revision exercise undertaken by the commission is fundamentally different from individual adjudicatory proceedings contemplated in Lal Babu Hussein. “When the commission embarks upon such an exercise, it acts not as a mere adjudicator between competing claims but as a constitutional authority discharging a duty of systemic oversight,” it noted.
The court accepted ECI’s contention that a comprehensive statewide exercise was necessary because the identified inaccuracies were systemic in nature and could not be addressed through piecemeal constituency-level revisions. “A targeted or constituency-specific approach may address isolated irregularities, but would be ill-suited to remedy structural deficiencies that pervade the entire roll,” the bench said.
At the same time, the court acknowledged concerns raised regarding documentation requirements, transparency and access, particularly for economically vulnerable and migrant populations. It noted that many of these concerns were addressed through interim directions issued by the Supreme Court during the pendency of the case.
These included directions expanding the list of acceptable documents to include Aadhaar cards, requiring publication of lists of excluded electors with reasons, deploying paralegal volunteers through legal services authorities and enabling political parties through booth-level agents to assist electors in filing claims and objections. “The proportionality of a measure must ultimately be assessed not in the abstract, but in the manner in which it is implemented,” it underlined.
The court also affirmed ECI’s documentation regime, rejecting allegations that the exclusion of certain identity documents was arbitrary. “The classification of documents, including the exclusion of certain categories, is based on intelligible criteria having a direct nexus with the objective of ensuring the integrity of the electoral roll,” the judgment held.
The court further ruled that the deletion process under the SIR framework did not violate Rule 21A of the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, observing that safeguards of notice, enquiry, hearing, speaking orders and appellate remedies remained substantively preserved within the revised framework. “The form may differ, but the substance remains intact,” held the bench while upholding the procedural framework adopted by ECI.
The ECI was represented by senior advocates Rakesh Dwivedi, Maninder Singh and Dama Seshadri Naidu.
Source: HindustanTimes
Related Posts: "Supreme Court,Election Commission of India,special intensive revision,free and fair elections,Representation of the People Act"
No need to panic over H1N1 surge in K'taka: Minister Khader No need to panic over H1N1 surge in K'taka: Minister Khader Published on: Aug 24, 2026, 13:51:09 IST PTI Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Bengaluru, Karnataka Health Minister U T Khader on Monday assured the public that there was no
8 hours ago
‘You endorse misogyny, cut the crap’: Shehzad Poonawalla joins BJP attack on Rahul Gandhi's ‘smash patriarchy’ call Shehzad Poonawalla and BJP were responding to Rahul Gandhi's call to "smash the patriarchy" during his party's 'Chhatro ki Goonj' programme in Pune. Updated on: Aug 24, 2026
11 hours ago
For Delhi-NCR residents, Guleria struck a reassuring note while explaining why this year’s wave has felt worse, but citizens need not panic The H1N1 virus driving Delhi-NCR’s current flu surge appears to be changing its structure — a process that is making it spread faster and slip past the
11 hours ago
A job applicant’s unusual rejection from a software engineering internship has left the internet divided after the candidate was reportedly turned down over the name of their resume file. The incident was highlighted in a now-viral post on X by user @adnaannasir_
11 hours ago
Elderly woman killed, husband injured in SUV hit-and-run at Delhi's posh GK-1 The woman, identified as Shashi, was declared brought dead at the hospital, while her husband Kulbhushan (65), was left injured. Published on: Aug 24, 2026, 11:00:26 IST By HT News Desk Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy
11 hours ago
Woman reflects on high-rise living in big cities: ‘Even the slice of the sky is fixed for us’ A woman shared her thoughts on high-rise life, saying big-city living can feel confined despite better work opportunities. Published on: Aug 24, 2026
11 hours ago
Governor Abdullah Sarhadi gives money to treat a boy's broken arm and hands out funds for a local mosque - then, in his office in northern Afghanistan, an astonishing exchange unfolds. A young woman tells the grey-bearded former Taliban commander that she wants to divorce her husband
11 hours ago
Andy Burnham is marking his first foreign visit as prime minister with a trip to Kyiv - and will hand over blueprints so Ukraine can build its own long-range missiles. The prime minister will chair his first meeting of the "coalition of the willing"
11 hours ago
Apple’s next iPhone launch is getting closer, and the company’s usual September schedule is beginning to take shape. According to a recent Forbes report, Apple could hold its special event on Wednesday, September 9, where it is expected to introduce the iPhone 18 Pro and iPhone 18 Pro Max
11 hours ago
Fugitive gangster Goldy Brar has, in an audio clip, purportedly claimed responsibility for the killing of Khalistani separatist leader Hardeep Singh Nijjar in Canada, The Indian Express reported. The newspaper said it could not independently verify the authenticity of the audio clip
11 hours ago
Dad crashes daughter’s late-night work meeting over parcels: ‘Ek paise ki saving nahi karti’ A father’s surprise appearance during his daughter’s work call turns into a lecture on spending and saving. Updated on: Aug 24, 2026, 10:56:44 IST By Vaishali Kapila Prefer HTon Google Share via
11 hours ago
A Zimbabwean content creator’s tongue-in-cheek take on life in India has caught the attention of social media users after he shared 10 everyday conveniences that have completely changed his standard of living. From paying for almost everything with just a phone to having food
11 hours ago
Starting September 1, passengers traveling internationally will be required to use an e-boarding pass on their smartphones for immigration clearance, as announced by immigration authorities. This significant change comes as the Bureau of Immigration (BOI)
14 hours ago
The September 2026 US Visa Bulletin brings a mixed picture for Indian green card applicants. While some family-sponsored categories have moved forward, several employment-based categories remain severely constrained, with two India-specific categories listed as unavailable and the State Department
14 hours ago
The Maharashtra Transport Department has issued notices to 777 drivers for lacking practical knowledge of Marathi, The Hindu quoted unidentified officials as saying on Saturday. A total of 5,211 drivers were tested during a statewide inspection campaign that began on August 20, including 3
14 hours ago
19-year-old killed, friend injured after truck hits motorcycle on Delhi's Indraprastha flyover A police team reached the spot and found a motorcycle lying in a damaged condition and two people seriously injured. One of them died in the hospital. Updated on: Aug 24, 2026
14 hours ago
Indian woman reveals why her family returned to India after 13 years in US: ‘You don’t really belong here’ A woman shared five reasons her family decided to leave the US and return to India after 13 years. Published on: Aug 24, 2026, 07:43:56 IST By Mahipal Singh Chouhan Prefer HTon Google
14 hours ago
New UK PM Andy Burnham to make visit to Kyiv on Monday: office New UK PM Andy Burnham to make visit to Kyiv on Monday: office Updated on: Aug 24, 2026, 07:41:28 IST AFP Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link British Prime Minister Andy Burnham will visit Kyiv on Monday on his first international
14 hours ago
Bengaluru vs Gurgaon? Man who lived in both cities explains why the comparison is ‘completely pointless’ A man said the Bengaluru versus Gurgaon debate was pointless and urged people to live in both cities before deciding. Published on: Aug 24, 2026
14 hours ago
Circle Wealth CIO and Managing Partner Chadha said the market was rewarding companies with strong earnings and improving outlooks, even as large-cap stocks remained under pressure. Diwali season is expected to bring a fresh boost for Indian equities following strong corporate earnings
14 hours ago
The restriction was imposed under Section 26A of the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940, which governs the import, manufacture, distribution, and sale of drugs and cosmetics. The central government on Saturday restricted the manufacturing, sale and distribution of all fixed-dose combinations (FDCs)
14 hours ago
Ukraine backers gather as war escalates, air defence runs low Ukraine backers gather as war escalates, air defence runs low Updated on: Aug 24, 2026, 07:41:29 IST AFP Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Ukraine on Monday hosts a meeting of its key European backers to press for critical
14 hours ago
'Trouble proving citizenship after representing India in 3 countries': Ex-envoy to ECI over Punjab SIR Suri served as India’s ambassador to the UAE and Egypt and high commissioner to Australia. Updated on: Aug 24, 2026, 07:34:33 IST By HT Correspondent Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link
14 hours ago
2 killed after illegal building in Hyderabad's Gachibowli caves in Officials alleged that the building was built over or adjacent to a drain without the required permissions. Published on: Aug 23, 2026, 14:41:02 IST By Srinivasa Rao Apparasu Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link At least two
1 days ago
J'khand: Compensation of ₹31 lakh each given to families of 3 engineers burnt alive at steel plant J'khand: Compensation of ₹31 lakh each given to families of 3 engineers burnt alive at steel plant Published on: Aug 23, 2026, 14:43:04 IST PTI Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Ramgarh
1 days ago
Jaiñtia Hills to the G7: Can Meghalaya turn ‘Lakadong’ into a global brand? The high-curcumin turmeric has gone from an obscure hill crop to a GI-tagged premium product showcased before world leaders. Updated on: Aug 23, 2026, 14:48:20 IST By David Laitphlang
1 days ago
Ex-NRI shares why she takes auto for 1 km ride to gym after moving to India: 'Life here is a compromise' The woman shared that she has to walk through an area where "everybody stares", while the pathway is "ubad-khabad", dirty and encroached. Updated on: Aug 23, 2026
1 days ago
