Gurgaon woman busts myth of ‘lavish corporate life’, says salary disappears after paydayA Gurgaon woman shared how bills and daily expenses left her with little of her salary soon after payday. Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 14:24:23 IST By Mahipal Singh Chouhan Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy
Who is Hannah Israel? Heartbroken owner speaks out after beloved donkey HeeHaw is killed by cop: ‘He was my son!’Hannah Israel, the owner of a donkey, HeeHaw, was left heartbroken after a Cedartown police officer allegedly shot the animal dead in Polk County. Published on: Sep 1, 2026
India is preparing a framework that would let AI agents make small digital payments without approval for every transaction, three sources familiar with the matter said, potentially making UPI one of the world's largest networks with agentic payments
Founder who survived on bread, water at 18 thinks everyone should go ‘completely broke’ onceA Mumbai-based founder claimed that surviving on bread and water at 18 removed his fear of startup failure and financial losses. Updated on: Sep 1, 2026
The US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and 22 states sued Amazon on Monday for allegedly "manipulating" online auctions for digital advertising, resulting in more than $20 billion in overcharges for 1.2 million customers. Amazon "has secretly and systematically overcharged its approximately 1
‘Prove my role, I’ll retire’: Karanataka minister Priyank Kharge challenges HD Kumaraswamy over KPSC rowKarnataka minister Priyank Kharge claimed Kumaraswamy was asked by the RSS or Amit Shah to target him. Updated on: Sep 1, 2026, 14:28:17 IST PTI Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link
Always looking for a sweet treat after dinner? Fitness coach Eric Roberts shares 3 reasons for late-night sugar cravings Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 14:09:20 IST By Eshana Saha Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Read more to find out why your sugar cravings intensify at the end of the day!
3-year-old kidnapped from Delhi found 1,000 km away in Bihar; accused woman had 6 daughters, wanted a sonThe child went missing while he was playing near his mother, who had gone to the hospital to collect medicines, police said. Updated on: Sep 1, 2026
Do animals have rights? The SC ruling on stray dogs shows why this needs to change
The recent Supreme Court judgement directing municipal authorities to remove stray dogs from the streets of the Delhi National Capital Region has now been modified.
A three-judge bench has now ruled that municipal authorities must release dogs back into their original territories after they are sterilised, dewormed and immunised. The only exceptions are rabid or aggressive dogs.
The earlier directive by the division bench – mandating that stray dogs be removed, placed in shelters, and not released back into streets had sparked widespread controversy. Activists, politicians, and concerned citizens reacted strongly, urging the government to adopt humane and scientific solutions instead.
The ruling was quite shocking, given its sweeping severity, but it also appeared to be a knee-jerk response to the perceived threat of rabies and its transmission from infected dogs to humans.
And while much ink has been spilled on the earlier Supreme Court order, a far deeper issue, rooted within our legal system, continues to be overlooked – what makes it possible for the judges to give such harsh directives that show such little regard for the lives of the animals, while prioritising human rights and welfare?
The Supreme Court's reiteration of the legal status of animals in India – first in Animal Welfare Board of India vs A Nagaraja & Ors (2014), and again, in Animal Welfare Board of India vs. A Nagaraja & Ors (2023) judgement – is instructive when read in the context of the present issue.
In both instances, the court engaged with the tension between human interests and animal welfare. While the 2014 case centered on the legality of jallikattu, a bull-taming sport, and its place within Tamil cultural tradition, the 2023 judgment reaffirmed a particular legal characterisation of animals.
According to the 2023 judgement: “Animals are world-wide legally recognised as ‘property' that can be possessed by humans…Right to hold on to a property which includes animals also, is now only a legal right…”
In the jallikattu case, where public discourse largely focused on bulls, animal rights and cultural preservation, a critical yet underexamined aspect of the judgement was the court's emphasis on animals as “legal property”.
This classification quietly justified the exploitation of bulls' natural nervousness as prey animals – during the taming event, bulls are chased by a crowd, thus placing them in terrifying situations and subject to distressing practices.
Similarly, the directives on Delhi's stray dogs implicitly reinforced this same legal status, legitimising their relocation in ways that would result in unnecessary suffering.
The premise that stray dogs could be removed from their familiar surroundings and transported to “far-off places,” even at the cost of their well-being, was made tenable only because they are deemed the “property” of the state.
We seem to accept this classification of animals as “property” with little scrutiny or resistance. It is precisely this problematic legal fiction that continues to shape – and often distort – judicial approaches to animal welfare in India.
We are legal persons, animals our legal property
In legal terms, every entity is classified as either a legal person or legal property. A legal person is considered the “subject of rights”, meaning they can hold and exercise rights under the law. Humans, as natural persons, are legal persons, as are companies, certain religious idols and scriptures that have been granted legal personhood in India.
In contrast, a legal property is seen as the “object of rights”, over which legal persons can assert their rights. In India – as in many other legal systems around the world – animals remain categorised as property, subject to human ownership and control.
Perhaps this is why pet guardians are referred to as “owners” rather than friends, family or companions. The notion that animals are comparable to lifeless objects renders them especially susceptible to indifference and objectification, as is evident in the case involving Delhi's stray dogs.
This classification also allows for their interests to be overridden in favour of human interests, often without any genuine effort to strike a balance between the two.
Outdated animal protection laws and poor enforcement further exacerbate the consequences of this legal framework. For example, the ineffective implementation of the Animal Birth Control Rules, 2023 highlights how animals are first ignored, and then penalised for failures rooted in human negligence, through decisions such as the recent Supreme Court directives.
The outdated legal designation of “property” strips an entity of their subjectivity, as well as their basic rights,while also opening doors to a host of systemic injustices – not just for animals, but for any being trapped within this status.
In 2020, the People's Charioteer Organisation in India filed a public interest litigation in the Supreme Court, seeking recognition of the entire animal kingdom as “legal persons”.
The petition which had highlighted the dismal state of animal welfare in India, marked by insufficient regulation, poor data on animal cruelty and other systemic failures was dismissed in 2023 as the judges observed that the prospect of granting legal personhood to animals in India to be a “bleak possibility”.
This was likely due to the implication that animals, if accepted as legal persons, would then possess rights that could compete directly and equally with those of humans under existing legal frameworks.
While the Punjab and Haryana High Court and the Uttarakhand High Court have taken more progressive stances in the past – removing animals from property status and recognising them as legal persons – a nationwide order on similar lines now appears unlikely.
So, should animals remain shackled to their current legal identity? The answer may lie in advocating for a middle ground – an intermediary space between personhood and property.
In several jurisdictions, animals are neither legal persons nor mere property. For instance, Austria's Civil Code explicitly states that “animals are not things; they are protected by special laws”, while the Animal Welfare Act of Switzerland acknowledges animal sentience and protects concepts like animal dignity and well-being.
In 2022, the United Kingdom passed the Animal Welfare (Sentience) Act, officially recognising its animals as sentient beings. This is an important source of inspiration for India, where the lingering colonial-era view continues to reduce animals to property.
This middle path of accepting animals as living, sentient beings, though not full legal persons, is a more acceptable solution to the “legal property” conundrum surrounding animals. It highlights that animals, like humans, are living beings too, but is unlikely to trigger massive legal and social upheaval as it does not demand an equal status for animals in the anthropocentric society that we live in.
It also fosters hope for a more equitable consideration of animal interests, especially in matters of human-animal conflict.
Moreover, language shapes our perception. When a society continues to frame animals as possessions rather than sentient beings, it is little wonder that many – especially those indifferent to animal welfare – remain devoid of empathy.
While the Supreme Court's Directions have now been modified to be more humane and considerate of animal rights, this shift does not ensure that similar humane considerations will be applied in future cases involving conflicts between humans and animals.
What is needed is an updated legal framework that recognises animals not merely as property, but as sentient beings deserving of inherent protection – beyond the changing tides of society and the biases of the judiciary.
Ashima Sharma is Assistant Professor, BML Munjal University, Haryana, and doctoral candidate (Animal Rights and Law), OP Jindal Global University.
Originally published under Creative Commons by 360info™.
Source: Scroll
Related Posts: Iran supreme leader admits thousands killed during recent protests Courts can't sit in judgement in matters of religious belief of denomination Norway's PM agrees crown princess had 'poor judgement' over Epstein links Shardul Thakur reacts to Hardik Pandya’s absence from MI’s recent games Iran's Khamenei says recent anti-government protests akin to Selections driven equally by long-term planning and recent performances Major tech outages in recent years ISRO gets ready for one of its busiest times in recent memory Are we teaching enough of India’s recent past in our history classes Candidate lists OnlyFans as ‘recent experience’ for a director-level job role
63-year-old grandmother shares 1 exercise senior citizens must do to stay independent as they age: 'Knee pain is tricky' Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 14:05:05 IST By Sanya Panwar Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Think you should skip squats due to knee pain? This 63-year-old fitness coach says
5 hours ago
India’s economy grew 7.8% year-on-year in the April-June quarter of FY27, significantly stronger than the market expectation of around 7.1% and above the Reserve Bank of India’s 7% projection. The latest number is particularly important because it came at a time when the global economy was
5 hours ago
Like many Gen Zs in Kozhikode, Athira K.B. enjoys eating out and spends much of her free time watching short food videos on Instagram. “If a restaurant regularly pops up on my feed, I instantly feel like checking out what makes it so special,” the 22-year-old college student says
5 hours ago
As Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh Mohan Bhagwat took the stage at New York City’s Madison Square Garden on Saturday to deliver a message of “universal oneness”, a group of nearly 90 American politicians was preparing a different memo: they would not accept political contributions from entities
5 hours ago
A five-member bench of the National Company Law Tribunal on Tuesday stayed the approval of a repayment plan under which media baron Subhash Chandra was allowed to pay Rs 6.2 crore to creditors against admitted claims of about Rs 22,006 crore in his personal insolvency resolution process
5 hours ago
US President Donald Trump’s tenure has vindicated many in the Indian foreign policy establishment prone to reflexive anti-Americanism. However, the recent history of intensified engagement between India and the US, the ongoing bureaucratic collaboration
8 hours ago
Sensex, Nifty open flat amid renewed crude oil price rally, global tensionsThe 30-share BSE Sensex declined 307.24 points, or 0.40 per cent, to close at 76,957.27 with 20 of its constituents ending lower and 10 with gains on Monday Updated on: Sep 1, 2026
8 hours ago
U.S. President Donald Trump threatened on Monday (August 31, 2026) to hit Iran “hard” after the two foes traded fire for the first time in weeks, as his Treasury secretary vowed to keep up a pressure campaign aimed at hobbling Tehran’s economy. After six months of war
8 hours ago
Step inside Mouni Roy’s beautiful 4 BHK apartment in Mumbai featuring minimal décor and a cosy library Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 11:30:03 IST By Anukriti Srivastava Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Mouni Roy gave a house tour of her Mumbai 4 BHK apartment
8 hours ago
OpenAI denied Apple's allegations of trade secret theft on Monday, saying the iPhone maker failed to show any confidential information was stolen by former employees."This dispute is a mess of Apple's own making, and it is trying to blame everyone else
8 hours ago
The toll in the flash flood and mudslide in Nepal and China, which occurred on August 26, rose to 1,003 on Tuesday. Of these, 987 deaths were reported in Nepal. The remaining 16 deaths were on the Chinese side of the border, AFP reported. More than 3
8 hours ago
September 1, 2026, Birthday Horoscope: Don't let fear overpower you from experiencing something genuine todayYour birthday falls on September 1, 2026 here’s what your year ahead looks like, as per Tarot. Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 11:01:25 IST By Kishori Sud Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link
8 hours ago
Toxic worldwide box office collection day 6: Yash film crashes, crawls past ₹300 crore; yet to surpass Adipurush, PeddiToxic worldwide box office collection day 6: Yash's pan-India film is now earning less than ₹10 crore per day worldwide after bad word-of-mouth. Updated on: Sep 1, 2026
8 hours ago
Naseeruddin Shah wishes 'more strength' to student protestorsFrom backing student protests to praising theatre behind bars, Naseeruddin Shah speaks up on protest, performance and the power of truth Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 11:33:59 IST By Aadrika Sominder Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link
8 hours ago
The families of more than 600 workers believed to be trapped in a vast network of mud-filled tunnels along Nepal's Trishuli River are clinging to hope their loved ones can be found alive. Rescuers continued battling to reach them on Monday, using explosives to blast into the hillside before pumping
8 hours ago
Maharashtra, Assam, Bengal, Bihar join Centre in SC bid to quash FIRs against CJP protestersThe move came a day after the Centre moved the court seeking quashing of FIRs registered in connection with the CJP-led protests Updated on: Sep 1, 2026
8 hours ago
European traveller says he was scared to visit India due to 'bad image, stereotypes': 'I found more kindness than chaos' Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 10:51:25 IST By Sanya Panwar Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Expecting chaos, he found kindness: Robert says India changed how he judges places
8 hours ago
Over 200 Zomato employees in 'customer delight' section in Hyderabad to be laid offEmployees impacted by the layoffs will also be helped in their search for relevant opportunities. Published on: Sep 1, 2026, 09:36:24 IST By HT Business Desk Prefer HTon Google Share via Copy link Zomato is expected
8 hours ago
Refrain from sharing the Universal Account Number (UAN), password, One-Time Password (OTP), and Aadhaar details. New Delhi: EPFO has issued a cyber awareness advisory to stay alert against frauds. Cases of fraud are becoming increasingly prevalent, particularly through digital modes
8 hours ago
Meta is fixing a loophole that allowed wearers of its AI smart glasses to secretly record others without consent. Meta’s new AI smart glasses feature a white light sensor that starts blinking when the wearer is taking a photo or video through their device
8 hours ago
‘Bengaluru Metro discipline deserves appreciation’: Woman praises commuters for orderly queues, offering seatsA woman lauded Bengaluru Metro commuters for disciplined boarding, respectful behaviour and offering seats to women. Published on: Sep 1, 2026
8 hours ago
Manchester City have opened talks with Chelsea in their bid to sign midfielder Enzo Fernandez. In what is set to be one of the key narratives on transfer deadline day, City have set the wheels in motion towards what would be one of the most expensive deals of the summer
8 hours ago
PM Modi hails ‘herculean feat’, Congress asks ‘where are jobs?’: GDP figures draw mixed responseTaking a jab at his critics, Modi said some people in India, “drowned in an atmosphere of despair”, were spreading “lies” across the country. Published on: Sep 1, 2026
8 hours ago
The company said the move is aimed at strengthening transparency and food quality for consumers, and warned that restaurants failing to comply with its requirements could be removed from the platform. New Delhi: Food delivery platform Zomato on Monday said it has adopted a zero-tolerance policy on
8 hours ago
As Janmashtami approaches, homes begin to take on a festive glow. Laddu Gopal gets a new outfit, the little cradle is beautifully decorated, flowers are brought in and preparations begin for the midnight celebration. Amid all these preparations
8 hours ago
The company said Shipsy Brain draws on data linked to more than five billion shipments. This includes more than 50 billion operational events, 1.5 billion automated and human decisions, 100 billion GPS pings and over 5,000 logistics workflows. Enterprise firm on September 1 launched in beta
8 hours ago
A Singaporean diplomat who led the adoption of the UN Ocean Treaty, a Myanmar activist who put his freedom on the line for democracy, and a former Bangladeshi teacher who brought compassion to the poor were named on Monday as the winners of this year’s Ramon Magsaysay Awards
8 hours ago
