Aston Villa manager Unai Emery may not believe his team are Premier League title contenders - but he is "dreaming" of Europa League glory after reaching the last 16. Villa defeated Fenerbahce 1-0 in Turkey to ensure a top-eight league-phase finish with a game to spare
Star Washington Spirit and United States of America forward Trinity Rodman on Thursday became the world's highest-paid women's footballer ever, after she signed a record deal with Spirit. She agreed to a contract through 2028 worth over $1 million per season
The government's proposed Design Linked Incentive (DLI) scheme 2.0 for semiconductor and chip design companies is expected to shift from the reimbursement-heavy structure in its first iteration, with policymakers pushing for greater accountability, ownership
Brazil president India visit: Modi conveyed to Lula that he looked forward to welcoming Lula to India at an early date. Lula is planning to visit India for the AI Summit and State visit next month. PM Narendra Modi and Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva on Thursday held a telephone
A five-year-old preschooler in Minnesota was taken into custody by federal immigration agents along with his father as they returned home, according to school authorities and the family's lawyer. The father-son duo was later transferred to a detention center in Texas
EC terms SIR fair, just, reasonable; urges SC to reject pleas against electoral rolls revision
Election Commission has stood its ground regarding the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls in Bihar, presenting its case to the Supreme Court. The commission emphasized that the process is both just and well-founded, urging the court to dismiss any opposition from NGOs and political entities.
New Delhi: The Election Commission on Thursday termed the decision to undertake Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls "fair, just and reasonable", and urged the Supreme Court to reject pleas challenging the exercise in Bihar.
It argued that a roving and fishing enquiry into the special scrutiny cannot be done at the behest of a few NGOs and politicians.
"None of the 66 lakh persons, whose names were deleted in Bihar SIR, came to this court or high court or filed pleas with the Election Commission. A roving and fishing enquiry cannot be permitted at the instance of ADR (Association for Democratic Reforms) and the PUCL (People's Union for Civil Liberty) and a few parliamentarians," said senior advocate Rakesh Dwivedi on behalf of the poll panel.
The submissions were made by the senior lawyer during the final hearing on a batch of petitions challenging the Election Commission's decision to undertake SIR in different states, including Bihar.
Referring to a judgment in which the top court had refused a plea seeking re-introduction of paper ballot and discarding the EVMs, he said, "In short, we must follow Europe. If they go for EVMs, then we must go for it. And if they go for a paper ballot, then we go for it."
He said one person writes an article in a newspaper, and the other files a petition in the top court referring to that.
Dwivedi urged the bench of Chief Justice Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi to dismiss the pleas with cost while defending the SIR as a lawful and transparent exercise of statutory powers under the Representation of the People Act, 1950.
He argued that once the Election Commission invokes its powers under Section 21(3) of the 1950 Act, the manner and procedure of conducting a special revision are left entirely to its discretion.
Dwivedi argued that Section 21(3) operates independently of Section 21(2), which governs routine and periodical revisions. "There is no compulsion under Section 21(3) that every SIR must be identical in nature," he said.
He said the SIR exercise had not been undertaken for nearly 20 years in Bihar and was conducted in response to changing demographic realities, including urbanisation and population movement.
According to Dwivedi, merely adopting a different methodology or deviating from the manual governing routine revisions could not, by itself, render the exercise suspect or ultra vires.
The CJI, however, observed that if the poll panel's argument that Section 21(3) grants unfettered discretion were accepted, "the case would end there".
Dwivedi placed significant reliance on the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2003, which, he said, was enacted after the last SIR and introduced stricter requirements for establishing citizenship, including proof relating to parents' citizenship.
He pointed out that the amendment was passed during the tenure of then prime minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee with bipartisan support, demonstrating legislative consensus on the need to examine citizenship due to increasing cross-border migration.
Justice Bagchi questioned whether the amended citizenship framework was a trigger for the present SIR, noting that the Election Commission's order did not explicitly cite trans-border or illegal migration as its basis.
"The word 'migration' ordinarily refers to lawful movement. Inter-state migration is a constitutional right," Justice Bagchi observed, adding that if the SIR was being defended solely as a roll revision exercise after two decades, the larger question of citizenship determination might not arise at all.
Dwivedi responded that the amendment had never been operationalised earlier and that the present SIR provided an appropriate opportunity to take note of the changed legal framework.
He clarified that the objective was to examine citizenship within the contours of Article 326 of the Constitution, which guarantees adult suffrage.
Emphasising transparency, Dwivedi said that Booth Level Agents (BLAs) conducted house-to-house verification, over five crore SMS alerts were sent to voters, and the process strictly followed procedural safeguards.
Nearly 76 per cent of voters did not have to submit any documents, while others were permitted to furnish one of 11 prescribed documents, he highlighted.
Dwivedi said the SIR could not be labelled as "manifestly arbitrary".
Justice Bagchi, however, observed that "manifest arbitrariness" had evolved as a facet of substantive due process and was now applicable even to primary legislation.
Dwivedi cautioned against importing American notions of "due process" into Indian constitutional law, remarking that US courts often re-evaluate policy decisions, a practice the Supreme Court has consistently resisted.
"US court judgments have been cited... Where is the US following due procedure of law? President Trump can just pick the President of Venezuela for trial. Where is the due process, and now he wants Greenland also. Here, the petitioners want to import that," he said.
The CJI said that courts here have occasionally used the phrase "due process" without fully appreciating its American constitutional origins.
The petitioners argue that the SIR's departure from the "prescribed manner" of revision under Section 21(2) lacks transparency and could lead to the arbitrary exclusion of genuine citizens.
Add as a Reliable and Trusted News Source Add Now!
Source: EconomicTimes
Related Posts: West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee creating situation to stop SIR process Is ‘fair use’ really fair to artists under Indian copyright law Bengal SIR important World Book Fair in Delhi turns into a fish market as crowd loots books Supreme Court on SIR highlights Chaos At New Delhi World Book Fair As Visitors Climb Onto Shelves For ‘Free India pacer Mohammed Shami appears before SIR panel in Kolkata SIR Timeline Faces Uncertainty As Supreme Court Order May Push Hearing Supreme Court hearing on SIR LIVE updates Supreme Court hearing on SIR updates
Adar Poonawalla has announced plans to bid for the Royal Challengers Bengaluru IPL team. The current owners are seeking a new buyer for the franchise. This development comes as RCB considers moving its home matches from Bengaluru. Other potential buyers are also reportedly in contention
Just now
WASHINGTON (AP) — All-Star left-hander MacKenzie Gore is headed to the Texas Rangers in a trade that sends five prospects back to the Nationals in the biggest move of new Washington president of baseball operations Paul Toboni's roster rebuilding efforts
Just now
Lewis Hamilton is no stranger to podiums, but now he's eyeing one in Hollywood. The seven-time F1 world champion is officially an Oscar-nominated producer, with F1 The Movie, the Brad Pitt-led racing blockbuster he executive produced, landing four Academy Award nominations
Just now
It was hard to see how Thursday night could have gone much worse for Nottingham Forest. As they fell to a dour defeat in Braga, they completed the unholy trinity of scoring an own goal, missing a penalty and receiving a red card. Having begun the evening with hopes of pushing on for a top-eight
Just now
Election Commission has stood its ground regarding the Special Intensive Revision of electoral rolls in Bihar, presenting its case to the Supreme Court. The commission emphasized that the process is both just and well-founded, urging the court to dismiss any opposition from NGOs and political
Just now
South Africa has suffered injury setbacks ahead of the T20 World Cup, and the upcoming three-match T20I series against West Indies, with batter Tony de Zorzi and all-rounder Donovan Ferreira ruled out, Cricket South Africa (CSA) confirmed on Thursday
Just now
The poll body issued an order allocating the whistle symbol as the general symbol for the upcoming Assembly elections in Tamil Nadu. The Election Commission on Thursday allotted “whistle symbol” to actor Vijay's Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam
Just now
ZEEL Q3 Results FY2026: Zee Entertainment Enterprises Limited (ZEEL) has reported 5.37 per cent YoY decline in its consolidated net profit at Rs 154.8 crore in the third quarter of current financial year (Q23 FY2026). The media and entertainment conglomerate had logged a net profit of Rs 163
Just now
The Congress party alleged that the recently enacted G RAM G scheme was part of the Centre's design to deny workers right-based MGNREGA and by ending it, the government has attacked the poor and weaker sections of rural India, and this is being opposed across the countryThe Congress party alleged
Just now
Davos: Madhya Pradesh wants to play the most important role in INDIA'S progress; the state govt already prepared its plan and is committed to it, said Chief Minister Mohan Yadav at the WEF summit. Madhya Pradesh has introduced multiple reforms and is offering financial incentives for setting up new
Just now
Former India spinner Ravichandran Ashwin believes skipper Suryakumar Yadav finally put his recent form struggles behind him with a fluent 32 off 22 balls in the first T20I against New Zealand. Former India spinner Ravichandran Ashwin believes skipper Suryakumar Yadav finally put his recent form
Just now
On January 19, Sumona Rahman Choudhury and 14 other booth level officers in Assam's Sribhumi district were called for a training session as part of the ongoing “special revision” of electoral rolls ahead of the Assembly elections this year
Just now
Thursday had been earmarked for Australians to mourn the victims of last month's Bondi shootings. Those who had lost loved ones in the antisemitic attacks wanted it to be a chance to remember the dead, and spread light and kindness in their honour. Instead
Just now
The end is in sight for Casemiro at Manchester United. The club have confirmed the Brazilian midfielder will leave when his contract expires at the end of the season, opting not to activate the one-year extension available to them. After three turbulent, trophy-laced years
Just now
IMD issued a yellow alert for Delhi today (Jan 23) with rain and gusty winds predicted. AQI improves to 322 as CAQM revokes GRAP Stage III curbs. Check the Republic Day weather forecast and temperature updates. The IMD has issued a yellow alert for Delhi today as an active western disturbance
Just now
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy addressed the World Economic Forum (WEF) on Thursday, January 22, where he delivered a sharp warning to Europe and accused it of failing to act against global threats despite recognising them every year. “Just last year, here in Davos
Just now
US President Donald Trump had a very noticeable bruise on his left hand at the World Economic Forum in Davos, Switzerland, leaving the Internet buzzing with various speculations about his health. Netizens had a lot to say about the bruise, including claims that Trump was “nearing his
Just now
Delhi and Gurugram authorities have issued traffic advisories for January 22, warning commuters of delays and restrictions in parts of the NCR because of Republic Day rehearsals. Delhi Traffic Police has notified restrictions around Vijay Chowk during rehearsal hours
Just now
Tirupati: Ahead of the annual Ratha Saptami festival at Tirumala, the Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams (TTD) has announced a temporary suspension of Sarva Darshan token issuance for three days to manage the expected surge of devotees. According to the official notification
Just now
Hollywood has revealed the nominations for this year's Oscars, which will honour the film industry's finest stars and movies from the past 12 months. Sinners leads the way with a record 16 nominations, breaking the record for the most Oscar nominations
Just now
A tiny South American nation with deep Indian roots has achieved what no global power has: total food self-sufficiency across all seven food groups. New Delhi: There is only one country in the world that produces every food item its people eat. Nothing comes from outside
Just now
Also Known as the “Surya Jayanti” or the birthday of the Sun God, this day marks the moment Lord Surya began enlightening the universe. On Sunday, January 25, 2026, devotees across India and the world will celebrate Ratha Saptami, a highly auspicious festival dedicated to Lord Surya
Just now
Microsoft could be close to having a free version of the Xbox Cloud Gaming service available in the market. The online gaming platform lets you enjoy some of the popular Xbox game titles just with the help of high-speed internet, and a subscription to access all these games which makes it cheaper
Just now
MIAMI GARDENS, Fla. (AP) — Jeff Hafley was a football coach before he was a football coach. The new coach of the Miami Dolphins played his college football at Siena, with home games before small crowds at what was a decaying minor-league baseball field in a suburb of Albany, New York
Just now
She symbolises rising female leadership in the armed forces. New Delhi: India is gearing up to celebrate its 77th Republic Day. Among those preparing for the grand parade on Kartavya Path is 26-year-old Assistant Commandant Simran Bala. On January 26
Just now
President Donald Trump has filed a $5bn (£3.7bn) lawsuit against America's biggest bank JPMorgan Chase, accusing it of illegally closing his accounts for political reasons. The lawsuit, which also names the bank's chief executive Jamie Dimon
Just now
Jeff Bezos' aerospace company, Blue Origin, completed its first spaceflight of 2026, where it carried six crew members to the edge of space aboard a rocket from its West Texas Site. The New Shepard NS-38 took off on Thursday at approximately 9:55 pm (Indian time), despite a 25-minute delay
Just now
