On the Multi Commodity Exchange (MCX), gold futures (April 2) were trading around 1 per cent, or Rs 1,313, lower at Rs 1,51,712, hitting an intraday low at
Latest News

On the Multi Commodity Exchange (MCX), gold futures (April 2) were trading around 1 per cent, or Rs 1,313, lower at Rs 1,51,712, hitting an intraday low at around 10:22 am. Similarly, silver futures (May 5) declined to Rs 2,43,083, down 2 per cent or Rs 5,111.On the Multi Commodity Exchange (MCX)

Oil and gas prices have risen sharply after fresh strikes hit energy infrastructure in the Middle East, including Qatar's main gas facility
Business

Oil and gas prices have risen sharply after fresh strikes hit energy infrastructure in the Middle East, including Qatar's main gas facility. Gas prices jumped by about 25% on wholesale markets in the UK and Europe in early trading, before easing slightly

So far in 2026, more than 35,000 job cuts have been reported across over 50 companies, according to layoffs tracker Layoffs.fyi. HSBC Holdings Plc is
Business

So far in 2026, more than 35,000 job cuts have been reported across over 50 companies, according to layoffs tracker Layoffs.fyi. HSBC Holdings Plc is evaluating a fresh round of deep job cuts that could impact as many as 20,000 roles over the coming years

<h4 class=
Education

GATE Result 2026 declared at gate2026.iitg.ac.in, direct link to check here Published on: Mar 19, 2026 3:06 PM IST By HT Education Desk | Edited by Papri Chanda Prefer HTon Google Quick Read Share via Copy link Indian Institute of Technology, Guwahati has declared GATE Result 2026

The Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas has said only those who haven’t completed the eKYC process need to act; existing compliant users
Business

The Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas has said only those who haven’t completed the eKYC process need to act; existing compliant users, especially under the PM Ujjwala Yojana, are not required to update their KYC frequently. LPG consumers may need to complete the Aadhaar-based authentication

A twist in the tale: are scientists wrong about dark energy?

Posted By: Tarun Kumar Posted On: Dec 30, 2025Share Article
A twist in the tale
The Hubble space telescope's view of the galaxy in 2018. The type Ia supernova SN 2018gv is visible near the left edge.. | Photo Credit: ESA/Hubble & NASA, A

A twist in the tale: are scientists wrong about dark energy? Premium

All major discoveries in cosmology underline the maxim that the universe is not only stranger than we suppose but that it is stranger than we can suppose. The latest example of this is a study by researchers at the Yonsei University in South Korea that said the expansion of the universe is slowing down.

The study, published in Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society of November 6, is in sharp contrast to the standard model of the universe, called Lambda-Cold Dark Matter (LCDM), which speaks of an accelerating universe.

Accepted theory says the universe began about 13.8 billion years ago from a single, infinitely dense point that exploded cataclysmically in a ‘Big Bang', leading to the formation of matter, energy, and space. As the explosion spread rapidly, it engendered subatomic particles such as protons, neutrons, and electrons before matter collapsed under gravity to form galaxies, stars and planets.

While the American astronomer Edwin Hubble confirmed that the universe was expanding in the 1920s, cosmologists conjectured that gravity must have also slowed down the expansion at some point. This is why they were surprised when, in 1998, astronomers who were measuring the distances to faraway galaxies using the light from exploding stars called Type Ia supernovae concluded that 9 billion years after the universe began, its expansion actually gained momentum.

They figured the impetus came from a mysterious force known as ‘dark energy', which makes up about 70% of the cosmos. In 1917, Albert Einstein had proposed that its effects can be represented in equations by the cosmological constant lambda (Ʌ).

For proving that the expansion of the universe had indeed speeded up, three scientists — Saul Perlmutter, Brian Schmidt, and Adam Riess — were awarded the 2011 physics Nobel Prize. The trio and the teams they led had calculated the distances to Type Ia supernovae by using their apparent brightness as “standard candles” and measuring the redshift, i.e. the stretching of light due to the expansion of the universe. This helped them determine the speeds at which different parts of the universe were receding from the earth.

Their data showed that the universe was accelerating as dark energy forced galaxies apart ever faster. An analogy astronomers often use to illustrate this is the way raisins in rising bread dough move away from each other. Thus, in the LCDM model of cosmology, gravity binds planets, stars, and galaxies together, while the anti-gravity properties of dark energy push galaxies further away from each other, driving the universe's expansion.

The Yonsei University study introduced a dramatic twist to this cosmic tale by suggesting that dark energy may actually be weakening, putting the brakes on the universe's acceleration.

“Our study shows that the universe has already entered a phase of decelerated expansion at the present epoch and that dark energy evolves with time much more rapidly than previously thought,” Yonsei University astronomy professor Young-Wook Lee, who led the study, said.

The findings tie in with similar data from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) in the USA: that Type Ia supernovae may not be the universe's “standard candles” after all, since their luminosity could be affected by the age of their parent stars.

If dark energy density is not constant in time, it flips conventional cosmological wisdom on its head, forcing scientists to look afresh at a universe that may be decelerating, and perhaps eventually contracting before collapsing in on itself in a ‘Big Crunch'.

The study has already set off a fierce debate amongst cosmologists, with many doubting if there is enough evidence to revamp the LCDM any time soon, or if at all.

For instance, in an email to the author, University of Michigan cosmologist Dragan Huterer expressed doubts about dark energy evolving with time. “But this is really hard to evaluate as we do not have any compelling theoretical models for dark energy. So, from a theoretical point of view, it is not clear,” Prof. Huterer added. ”From the observational/experimental point of view, the statistical significance of the findings is strong, but not sufficiently strong to claim a discovery. We need to collect and analyse more data to be sure.”

Brian Schmidt, distinguished professor of astronomy at the Australian National University and one of the three astrophysicists who won the Nobel Prize for their work on dark energy, is sceptical about the study's consequences for the LCDM.

“If validated, these findings would not negate the (standard) model of the cosmos, but would modify it,” Prof. Schmidt wrote in an email. “Basically, instead of a constant [cosmological constant], we would have something that evolves over time.”

He said he doesn't think that this would give rise to whole new subfields of astrophysics either.

“If true, it will give theorists a new set of clues to understand dark energy. I think it would be contained in the current theoretical cosmology community — and not (in) a new subfield.”

Prof Huterer also said that “these developments would still continue in the realm of data-driven cosmology. And the fact that Type Ia supernovae have some new properties would inform the existing field of Type Ia supernovae astrophysics.”

Adam Riess, professor of physics and astronomy at the Johns Hopkins University who shared the 2011 Nobel Prize, also said the Yonsei University study doesn't hold water.

“The study claims that Type Ia supernovae become systematically fainter with redshift because their progenitors evolve with cosmic time,” he said. “We show this is not supported by the data. Modern supernovae analyses already model and marginalise host-related systematics, like stellar mass and star-formation history, and when these are included, there is no significant evidence for luminosity evolution.”

According to Prof. Riess, “the study result arises from a very particular way of slicing the data and from assumptions that aren't consistent with how supernova cosmology is done today.”

When the Dark Energy Survey 5 Year dataset sample is analysed with standard methods, he continued, “the allowed level of evolution is an order of magnitude smaller than what their model predicts. In short: their proposed effect isn't seen in real data, and current analyses already guard against it.”

Wherein lies the rub then? According to Prof. Riess, the new study makes a leap from host galaxy age to supernova age that is not physically justified. This is something scientists have already tested and corrected for with much larger datasets.

“Present studies already correct for their claimed effect (age) because they correct for galaxy mass, and galaxy mass and age are directly correlated,” he said.

Taken together, the jury is out on the Yonsei University study. Cosmologists are currently looking to state-of-the-art instruments such as the Vera Rubin Observatory in Chile and NASA's upcoming Nancy Grace Roman space telescope to throw light on dark energy's role in the fate of the universe — whether it will eventually slow down and end in a Big Crunch or continue to expand until it fades away into virtual nothingness.

Prakash Chandra is a science writer.

Published - December 30, 2025 05:30 am IST

astronomy / physics

Comment on Post

Leave a comment

If you have a News Orbit 360 user account, your address will be used to display your profile picture.


For Gudi Padwa 2026, actress Isha Koppikar has shared that she is focusing on teaching her daughter, Rianna, the core values behind the festival rather than
Life Style
Isha Koppikar turns festival into a lesson

For Gudi Padwa 2026, actress Isha Koppikar has shared that she is focusing on teaching her daughter, Rianna, the core values behind the festival rather than just the rituals. New Delhi: As the country celebrates Gudi Padwa today, actress Isha Koppikar reflected on how she marks the festival

1 days ago

IMD issued a widespread alert for rain and thunderstorms across Delhi-NCR, Rajasthan, and Central India starting today, March 18, 2026
Latest News
Delhi-NCR weather update

IMD issued a widespread alert for rain and thunderstorms across Delhi-NCR, Rajasthan, and Central India starting today, March 18, 2026. Heavy snowfall is predicted for Jammu & Kashmir and Himachal Pradesh. A much-needed respite from the rising March temperatures is on the horizon

1 days ago

Ishan Kishan has been appointed stand-in captain of Sunrisers Hyderabad ahead of IPL 2026, with opener Abhishek Sharma named his deputy
Sports
Kishan to lead Sunrisers in Cummins’ absence

Ishan Kishan has been appointed stand-in captain of Sunrisers Hyderabad ahead of IPL 2026, with opener Abhishek Sharma named his deputy. The India wicketkeeper-batter will lead the side in the absence of regular skipper Pat Cummins, who is currently recovering from a back injury that also ruled him

1 days ago

<strong>rajresults-nic-in, Rajasthan Board RBSE Class 10th Results 2026 Date And Time Live:</strong> The Rajasthan Board of Secondary Education
Education
RBSE 10th Results 2026 Date And Time Live

rajresults-nic-in, Rajasthan Board RBSE Class 10th Results 2026 Date And Time Live: The Rajasthan Board of Secondary Education (RBSE) is expected to declare the results for the class 10th board examination soon. According to media reports, the results could be released on March 20, 2026

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Chhattisgarh tables anti-conversion bill

Chhattisgarh tables anti-conversion bill, life term for mass conversionsChhattisgarh govt tables anti-conversion Bill with life term for mass conversion, defines allurement, coercion, and mandates prior declaration Published on: Mar 19, 2026 5:51 PM IST By Ritesh Mishra

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Latest News
Dhurandhar The Revenge actor Danish Iqbal says he didn’t know he was Bade Sahab

Dhurandhar The Revenge actor Danish Iqbal says he didn’t know he was Bade Sahab: ‘Aditya Dhar was so secretive’Danish Iqbal, who plays Bade Sahab in Dhurandhar: The Revenge, revealed that he was initially unaware of his character's identity. Mar 19, 2026

1 days ago

The funding aims to provide direct price support to cotton farmers across the country. New Delhi: The Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA)
Latest News
MSP funding of Rs 1

The funding aims to provide direct price support to cotton farmers across the country. New Delhi: The Cabinet Committee on Economic Affairs (CCEA), chaired by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, on Wednesday approved minimum support price (MSP) funding of Rs 1,718

1 days ago

Rajasthan Royals skipper Riyan Parag stated Sanju Samson's departure cannot be filled. Parag, now captain, emphasized better planning and finishing close games
Sports
Like Rohit and Virat

Rajasthan Royals skipper Riyan Parag stated Sanju Samson's departure cannot be filled. Parag, now captain, emphasized better planning and finishing close games for the upcoming season. He thanked the franchise for their support. Director of Cricket Kumar Sangakkara backed Parag

1 days ago

Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan has declared assets exceeding one crore rupees. His nomination papers reveal movable and immovable properties
Politics
Kerala CM Pinarayi Vijayan declares Rs 1 crore in assets

Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan has declared assets exceeding one crore rupees. His nomination papers reveal movable and immovable properties. His wife also declared significant assets. Vijayan faces six cases, including one under the Prevention of Corruption Act and an Enforcement

1 days ago

Ukraine’s embassy in Delhi on Thursday expressed concern about the arrest of six Ukrainians in the country under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act
World
Possibly orchestrated

Ukraine’s embassy in Delhi on Thursday expressed concern about the arrest of six Ukrainians in the country under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act, claiming that the circumstances in the case suggest that it may be “orchestrated and politically motivated”

1 days ago

Manchester United's fans won't have a chance to see JJ Gabriel in Premier League action at Old Trafford this season, so a good proportion of the 2
Sports
The 15-year-old Man Utd prodigy still too young to play senior football

Manchester United's fans won't have a chance to see JJ Gabriel in Premier League action at Old Trafford this season, so a good proportion of the 2,516 who saw him feature in the 3-2 FA Youth Cup win over Sunderland made sure they got their selfies

1 days ago

For the first time since the league's inception in 2008, Kohli enters the IPL as a one format international player. Batting maestro Virat Kohli has arrived in
Sports
Things will be different

For the first time since the league's inception in 2008, Kohli enters the IPL as a one format international player. Batting maestro Virat Kohli has arrived in Bengaluru to join the Royal Challengers Bengaluru (RCB) camp, marking the beginning of a unique chapter in his storied career

1 days ago

The Bharatiya Janata Party in Assam released its list of candidates on Thursday for the upcoming Assembly elections in the state. The party has fielded Chief
Politics
Assam BJP releases list of candidates

The Bharatiya Janata Party in Assam released its list of candidates on Thursday for the upcoming Assembly elections in the state. The party has fielded Chief Minister Himanta Biswa Sarma from the Jalukbari seat, which he has represented since 2001. Nagaon MP Pradyut Bordoloi

1 days ago

With seven medals, including five golds, at the recent Open Masters Games Abu Dhabi, it is hard to believe Kurian Jacob took up swimming seriously at 70
Life Style
76-year-old athlete from Kerala wins seven medals at Open Masters Games Abu Dhabi

With seven medals, including five golds, at the recent Open Masters Games Abu Dhabi, it is hard to believe Kurian Jacob took up swimming seriously at 70. “I might have started swimming before I started walking,” says Kurian who competed in the 75-79 years old category.With seven medals

1 days ago

The liver is a remarkably resilient organ. It absorbs stress quietly, adapts silently, and continues to function, even when damage has already begun
Life Style
Even If The Blood Tests Look Normal

The liver is a remarkably resilient organ. It absorbs stress quietly, adapts silently, and continues to function, even when damage has already begun. This is precisely why liver diseases are often detected late. Sometimes, liver care doctors come across patients whose blood tests look normal

1 days ago

The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) on Thursday released its second list of 39 candidates for the upcoming Kerala Assembly Elections. With this
Politics
Kerala Assembly Elections 2026

The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) on Thursday released its second list of 39 candidates for the upcoming Kerala Assembly Elections. With this, the party has so far announced the names of a total of 86 candidates. The party has fielded former state BJP president and former Mizoram governor Kummanam

1 days ago

<strong>Chaitra Navratri 2026 day 2 wishes:</strong> Share these heartfelt wishes, messages, images, and quotes with your loved ones on the second
Life Style
Chaitra Navratri 2026 day 2 wishes

Chaitra Navratri 2026 day 2 wishes: Share these heartfelt wishes, messages, images, and quotes with your loved ones on the second day of Chaitra Navratri. Om Brahmacharinyai Namah! Chaitra Navratri 2026 day 2 wishes: The second day of Chaitra Navratri is dedicated to Maa Brahmacharini

1 days ago

If there’s one thing Indian television never shies away from, it’s going all in—on drama, imagination, and moments that blur the line between the
Latest News
“First In My Bloodline To See Patriotic Naagins”

If there’s one thing Indian television never shies away from, it’s going all in—on drama, imagination, and moments that blur the line between the unexpected and the unforgettable. And now, a scene from Naagin 7 has taken that reputation to a whole new level

1 days ago

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee has expressed alarm over the
Politics
EC transferred over 50 officials

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee has expressed alarm over the "arbitrary removal of more than 50 senior officials" in the poll-bound state, calling it "political interference of the highest order." She alleged the Election Commission's actions amounted to "systematic politicisation of

1 days ago

The decision to strip Senegal of the 2025 Africa Cup of Nations title is
Sports
We must denounce

The decision to strip Senegal of the 2025 Africa Cup of Nations title is "abject" and "we have to denounce it", a senior figure at African football's governing body has said. Senegal beat Morocco 1-0 in January's final but the Confederation of African Football (Caf) overturned the result on Tuesday

1 days ago

Most factories in Morbi, India's ceramics hub in the western state of Gujarat, have shut down for nearly a month due to gas shortages triggered by the Iran war
World
India's ceramic hub grinds to a halt as Iran war chokes gas supply

Most factories in Morbi, India's ceramics hub in the western state of Gujarat, have shut down for nearly a month due to gas shortages triggered by the Iran war, according to the local manufacturers' association. Morbi produces about 80% of India's ceramics - mainly tiles and sanitaryware - and

1 days ago

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.<h4 class=
Technology
Best oven toaster grills in India

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Best oven toaster grills for Indian homes: Top 7 OTG picks for baking, grilling, toasting and moreOven toaster grills are a versatile kitchen appliance that can be used for baking

1 days ago

Delhi Capitals revealed their new jersey for the upcoming IPL 2026 season. The design reflects the team's tiger spirit. For the first time
Sports
Delhi Capitals unveil new jersey for IPL 2026

Delhi Capitals revealed their new jersey for the upcoming IPL 2026 season. The design reflects the team's tiger spirit. For the first time, both men's and women's team captains are featured together. The franchise also appointed John Mooney as its new fielding coach

1 days ago

<h4 class=
Sports
AFCON final controversy

AFCON final controversy: CAF chief defends Morocco title decision amid Senegal corruption probe call Published on: Mar 19, 2026 6:10 PM IST Written by Neelav Chakravarti Share via Copy link CAF President Patrice Motsepe stands next to Senegal's Sadio Mane with the Man of the Competition award after

1 days ago

<strong>Why Did Share Market Fall Today? </strong>Benchmark equity indices Sensex and Nifty fell sharply by over 3 percent on Thursday
Business
Rs 12 Lakh Crore Wiped Out As Sensex Crashes 2

Why Did Share Market Fall Today? Benchmark equity indices Sensex and Nifty fell sharply by over 3 percent on Thursday, snapping a three-day rally, as rising crude oil prices and weak global cues weighed on sentiment. The Sensex dropped 2,496.89 points, or 3.26 percent, to close at 74,207.24

1 days ago

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.<h4 class=
Technology
Ceiling fans for home

Editorial independence is core to our work. Some links may earn us a commission, without influencing our opinions.Ceiling fans for home: Top 7 options that fit different room needsPlanning to upgrade cooling this summer 2026? These ceiling fans for the home offer steady airflow, lower power use

1 days ago

US President Donald Trump has threatened to blow up a major gas field in Iran if it attacks the US's Gulf Arab ally Qatar again. Trump's threat came after a
World
Trump threatens to blow up

US President Donald Trump has threatened to blow up a major gas field in Iran if it attacks the US's Gulf Arab ally Qatar again. Trump's threat came after a day in which Israel hit Iran's South Pars - part of the world's largest natural gas field

1 days ago


Sing Up