Australia's most decorated living soldier, Ben Roberts-Smith, has been released from jail after being granted bail over alleged war crimes. The Victoria Cross recipient and former corporal in Australia's Special Air Service (SAS) Regiment was taken into custody last week
India's smartphone shipments fell 3% year-on-year in the first quarter of 2026, marking their weakest quarterly performance in six years as cost pressures, price hikes and soft demand weighed on sales, said on Friday.Over 80 smartphone models saw average price hikes of 15%
Charlie Kirk murder accused pushes to ban cameras from court, says live broadcasts violate his right to fair trialTyler Robinson is due in court Friday as his attorneys press their claims that biased coverage is tainting potential jurors in his aggravated murder case. Published on: Apr 17
SpiceJet flight clips Akasa plane at Delhi airport; probe orderedThe incident occurred around 2.15pm near Terminal 1 in IGI. Updated on: Apr 17, 2026 1:52 PM IST By Jasjeev Gandhiok Share via Copy link Two aircraft — operated by SpiceJet and Akasa — clipped wings while taxiing at Delhi’s
Theegala gets off to a good start at RBC HeritageTheegala gets off to a good start at RBC Heritage Published on: Apr 17, 2026 12:46 PM IST PTI Share via Copy link Hilton Head Island , Sahith Theegala started his week at the RBC Heritage with an opening round of 2-under 69 and was placed T-27 on the
The Supreme Court on Friday declined Congress leader Pawan Khera’s petition to vacate a stay on a Telangana High Court order granting him transit anticipatory bail in a case registered by the Assam Police, Live Law reported. A bench comprising Justices JK Maheshwari and Atul S Chandurkar also
The Centre’s proposal to expand the Lok Sabha and carry out a fresh delimitation exercise has triggered an intense political and constitutional debate, particularly around its potential impact on southern states. At the centre of the discussion is whether the proposed expansion will maintain the
A heartwarming video of a father intently reading his son’s job offer letter from Amazon has gone viral on social media, touching thousands with its simple display of pride and sacrifice. The now viral video, which has been widely shared and praised for its authenticity
‘A permanent surveillance backdoor’: Why Sanchar Saathi app order raises privacy fears
The Union government's direction on Friday that all mobile handsets sold in India should have a state-owned app pre-installed has elicited alarm from lawyers and digital rights groups, who contend that this could allow the authorities to spy on citizens.
The government requiring its Sanchar Saathi app to be forcibly installed on all mobile phones is a “serious breach of privacy”, said Prateek Waghre, former Executive Director of Internet Freedom Foundation, a Delhi-based digital rights think tank.
“With complete disregard for their consent, people aren't being given a choice to prevent the forced installation of this application,” he said.
Bharat Chugh, Delhi-based lawyer and former civil judge, described the order as “Orwellian”, given the scope for state snooping. “A non-removable app which may have access to calls, messages, and storage risks creating a permanent surveillance backdoor,” he said.
The government claimed that its order under the Telecom Cyber Security Rules, 2024, is part of a broader push to “curb the misuse of telecom resources in cyber frauds” and to strengthen “telecom cyber security” across the country. Specifically, the order lays out that it would prevent spoofing of a device's international mobile equipment identity number: a 15-digit number unique to each mobile phone.
Till now, the Sanchar Saathi app could have been downloaded voluntarily. Government data claims that more than one crore Indians are already using the app.
Apart from forcible installation on new phones, the government directive orders device manufacturers to make sure none of the app's features can be “disabled or restricted”. For phones that have already been made and are currently being sold in India, it says that “manufacturers and importers” should install the app “through a software update”.
Though purportedly intended only to prevent IMEI spoofing, the Sanchar Sathi app, once installed, can take pictures and videos, read call logs, view as well as send SMSes, read and write into the phone's storage and even control the phone's torch.
The Internet Freedom Foundation said in a statement that “forcing every smartphone to carry a permanent government app for a simple verification task is excessive and violates the Puttaswamy proportionality standard”.
The standard to which they were referring was established in 2017, when a nine-judge bench of the Supreme Court of India unanimously held in Justice KS Puttaswamy (Retd) v Union of India that the right to privacy is a fundamental right.
The Supreme Court ruled that any restriction on privacy must be supported by a valid law, serve a “legitimate public purpose” such as national security or public interest and be “proportionate”, meaning the intrusion is necessary, limited and uses the “least intrusive way” to achieve the goal.
The Internet Freedom Foundation stated that even if one assumes the government's order is legal and necessary for checking whether a phone's IMEI number is genuine, it “fails the proportionality test”. This is because the government already has other, less intrusive tools to verify IMEI numbers without needing a permanent app on every device.
Supreme Court lawyer Sanjay Hegde agreed. “As per KS Puttaswamy, the extent of intrusion can only be that which is necessary,” he said. “Here in the garb of security, the intrusion is vast, unfettered, unguided and is totally disproportionate. The app ought to be struck down on that account.”
The nature of a modern mobile phone and the vast access it has to private data makes this order very troubling, experts said.
“Tomorrow, an upgrade could mean the state has access to virtually your digital self and you will have no autonomy at all,” explained Ashish Goel, a lawyer based in Delhi and an expert in constitutional law.
Bharat Chugh said that without clear legal limits or a strong data protection law, forcing Sanchar Saathi risks turning every smartphone into a surveillance tool without any guardrails. “While preventing handset fraud is undoubtedly a legitimate objective, this approach is far from the least intrusive option available,” he said.
This level of state surveillance might be unprecedented in a democracy. “To the best of my knowledge, no other liberal, democratic country have attempted such a measure under the guise of cyber safety,” Prateek Waghre of the Internet Freedom Foundation said, describing it as the start of a new wave of app-based government surveillance. “This also potentially paves the way for the government of India mandating installation of even more intrusive and problematic applications in the future.”
There is a serious issue of consent, Chugh pointed out. “In the digital age, meaningful consent requires real choice,” he said. “Here, users cannot opt out, uninstall, or restrict the app, which erodes both privacy and autonomy by reducing individuals to passive subjects of state surveillance.”
In addition, Chugh noted that the directive is opaque and provides no clear legal framework for such sweeping control over a user's mobile device. “It has not been debated in Parliament, and there is no judicial or independent oversight to govern the app's operation, future updates or data use,” he said. “This absence of procedural safeguards is deeply troubling.”
Apar Gupta, a lawyer in Delhi and founder-director of the Internet Freedom Foundation, explained that the app itself might lead to more digital vulnerabilities. “Putting a single, privileged government app on hundreds of millions of devices creates a very attractive target,” he told Scroll. “Any vulnerability or misconfiguration in that app becomes a systemic risk, not an isolated bug.”
The Internet Freedom Foundation said the concerns grow more intense when the order's scope and lack of safeguards are examined. The government uses “telecom cyber security” as a broad justification, but does not clearly define what the app is allowed to do, it said.
It added that rules also refer to preventing acts that “endanger telecom cyber security”, a vague phrase that could allow the app's functions to expand over time.
According to Internet Freedom Foundation, while the app may currently appear to be a basic IMEI checker, an update could easily turn it into a tool to scan a user's mobile phone allowing for the government to detect VPN use, track SIM activity, read SMS logs or track apps it has banned.
VPNs or virtual private networks securely connect users to the internet, protecting them from being tracked or their data being taken.
On social media, founder and editor of technology policy website Medianama, Nikhil Pahwa, illustrated just what this ability to control a user's mobile phone would look like. “A government application can also be used to implant files on your device,” he said. “[It] has happened before, in the Bhima Koregaon case where documents were allegedly put on laptops and used to frame a conspiracy.”
The Bhima Koregaon case relates to the investigation and arrests that followed violence on January 1, 2018, near the village of Bhima-Koregaon in Maharashtra. The violence broke out a day after the Elgaar Parishad, an event in Pune organised by activists, lawyers, and cultural groups to mark a historic Dalit victory over the Maratha army in 1818.
A report by a US-based digital forensics firm said that a hacker planted 22 incriminating files on accused activist Rona Wilson's computer after the Bhima-Koregaon violence in January 2018, Article 14 reported in 2021.
These files were later used by the Pune police and then the National Investigation Agency as key evidence, leading to the arrest of Wilson and 15 others, including lawyers, academics and musicians in the case, the report said.
Source: Scroll
Related Posts: How your sleep direction impacts your energy Shah Rukh Khan Reveals Bobby Deol Complained About Aryan Khan's Direction Judicial direction to reduce GST on air purifiers violates separation of powers TVK moves SC against Madras HC's SIT probe direction Trump says Europe ‘not heading in the right direction’ as he addresses Davos summit amid standoff over Greenland Apple’s chosen direction for all things incoming Soccer-Juventus heading in right direction Government likely to roll out mobile PLI 2 Union Budget 2026 Date Set For Sunday As Key Panel Clears Parliament Calendar Date, time and where to watch the Union Budget speech live
Gold rate today: Prices fall amid US war on Iran, 24K at ₹1.53 lakh; check latest rates in your cityOver the past week, 24-carat gold has eased by 0.41%, while it is down 5.74% over the past month. Updated on: Apr 17, 2026 12:29 PM IST By HT News Desk Share via Copy link Gold prices declined on
2 hours ago
A 10-day ceasefire deal agreed between Lebanon and Israel took effect on Thursday (April 16, 2026), as U.S. President Donald Trump said he was trying to set up the first-ever meeting between the leaders of the two countries. The truce, which Mr
2 hours ago
Vivo Y600 Pro has been officially teased in China, with the brand revealing key details about its design and positioning. The most interesting aspect of this phone is that it will pack the largest battery ever seen on a Vivo phone. Here’s a look at what to expect from it
2 hours ago
China is using social media platforms like Douyin to spread messages from Taiwanese opposition figures. These clips are then shared on platforms popular in Taiwan, aiming to discredit President Lai Ching-te's government. The campaign seeks to weaken Taiwan's resolve and discourage defense spending
2 hours ago
Nearly 20% of the 1,478 candidates contesting the first phase of the West Bengal polls are crorepatis, with a significant share belonging to the Trinamool Congress (TMC), while the poorest candidate has declared assets of just ₹500, according to an analysis of poll affidavits
2 hours ago
The round of job losses, the biggest at the BBC since 2011, is being set in motion before the former top Google executive Matt Brittin takes over as director general next month. BBC Layoffs: UK media giant British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) on Wednesday announced that it has planned to axe as
2 hours ago
A new space race is unfolding as the United States and China compete for lunar dominance. Both nations are pushing for crewed Moon landings, with the US Artemis program and China's 2030 goal. They are also vying to set the rules for future lunar governance
2 hours ago
The 2026 Yamaha Fascino 125 Fi Hybrid has been launched at Rs 76,500 for the base model(drum), and the top variant(disc) will set you back by Rs 95,200. The new updates include newly sculpted tail section, redesigned taillights, flashers, and distinctive V‑iconic taillight design
2 hours ago
A viral video showing Donald Trump handing a $100 tip to a DoorDash delivery worker inside the White House has taken over social media, but even he now admits it didn’t quite land the way it was meant to. Speaking at a roundtable in Las Vegas, Trump addressed the moment directly
2 hours ago
'The camel dreams of cottonseed...': Iran mocks Trump's peace deal claimsThe Iran state media also shared a Persian proverb: "The camel dreams of cottonseed; sometimes gulping it down, sometimes eating it grain by grain" Updated on: Apr 17, 2026 12:29 PM IST By Karishma Ayaldasani Share via Copy
2 hours ago
Chinese carmaker Seres has been granted a patent for what it calls an "in-vehicle toilet" that slides under a passenger's seat for visits to the loo while on the road. The feature is meant to "satisfy users' toilet needs on long journeys, while camping or while staying in the car"
2 hours ago
Chennai's Chepauk-Thiruvallikeni constituency sees a key contest between Udhayanidhi Stalin and Adhi Rajaram. Stalin seeks re-election from this DMK stronghold. Rajaram aims to end the DMK's dominance and promises development. Other candidates are also in the fray
2 hours ago
Clashes erupted between police personnel and protesters in Manipur’s Imphal West district after thousands defied orders prohibiting public gatherings to take out a torch rally against a recent attack that killed two children, India Today NE reported
2 hours ago
The Supreme Court on Friday (April 17, 2026) cautioned the Madhya Pradesh government that it would order the deployment of paramilitary forces to curb rampant illegal sand mining in the ecologically fragile and protected National Chambal Gharial Sanctuary if the State failed to initiate prosecution
2 hours ago
India has entered summer, and some parts of the country are already facing harsh weather conditions. The heat of the summer season is slowly but surely getting unbearable. When the mercury crosses 40°C, which has been predicted to happen this month
2 hours ago
World Athletics on Thursday rejected applications from 11 elite athletes seeking to transfer their allegiance to Turkey, dealing a major blow to the country’s medal prospects at the 2028 Olympics. Four leading Jamaicans, including 2024 Olympic men’s discus gold medallist Roje Stona
2 hours ago
The Indian rupee gains against the US dollar in early trade on Friday, supported by easing geopolitical tensions, positive domestic equity markets and fresh foreign fund inflows. The Indian rupee strengthened by 39 paise to 92.75 against the US dollar in early trade on Friday
2 hours ago
India has slipped from the world’s fifth-largest economy to sixth place in 2025, according to the latest International Monetary Fund estimates, even as it continues to remain the fastest-growing major economy globally. The decline in ranking is not because India’s economy shrank in real terms
2 hours ago
Viral video shows Hyderabad security guard working under mosquito net at night, raises questions on dignity of labourA Hyderabad security guard was seen sitting under a mosquito net on night duty, sparking debate over poor working conditions and lack of basic facilities. Published on: Apr 17
2 hours ago
Alia Bhatt's sister Shaheen Bhatt gets engaged to boyfriend Ishaan Mehra, actor says she is ‘currently weeping’Shaheen Bhatt announced her engagement to her boyfriend, Ishaan Mehra, on Instagram. Check out how Alia Bhatt reacted. Apr 17, 2026
2 hours ago
As India’s AI ecosystem moves from experimentation to execution, the need to recognise real, measurable innovation has become critical. The ET Most Innovative AI Product Awards 2026 is designed to evaluate AI products based on architecture, deployment, and business impact across startups, SMEs
2 hours ago
Google Gemini now uses Photos to understand your taste and create custom imagesGoogle adds Personal Intelligence to Gemini, letting it auto-use Google Photos to create personalised AI images without manual uploads or detailed prompts. Updated on: Apr 17
2 hours ago
Shruti Haasan looks stunning in a crimson cocktail saree as she poses with a suited Kamal Haasan at INCA Awards 2026The father and daughter turned heads on the red carpet as they posed in dapper outfits. Here's a closer look at what Shruti Haasan and Kamal Haasan wore. Updated on: Apr 17
2 hours ago
, India’s fourth-largest software services exporter, reported a decline in attrition to 13.8% from 14.2% in the fourth quarter on Thursday.After a net addition of 6,529 employees in the December quarter, the company added only 136 staff between January and March, taking its total headcount to 242
2 hours ago
IGPL South Africa: Red-hot Mane fires flawless 64 to take six-shot leadIGPL South Africa: Red-hot Mane fires flawless 64 to take six-shot lead Updated on: Apr 17, 2026 1:58 PM IST PTI Share via Copy link Johannesburg, Continuing his red-hot form
2 hours ago
In 2025, Alia Bhatt’s sister, Shaheen Bhatt, made her relationship with fitness coach Ishaan Mehra Instagram official. Since then, the duo has been giving major couples on social media. Interestingly, the couple is now engaged. On April 17, Shaheen took to social media and shared a series of
2 hours ago
Brent crude slipped toward $98 a barrel, while West Texas Intermediate hovered near $93, partially reversing previous session’s sharp gains Oil prices eased after US President Donald Trump struck a more optimistic tone on the prospects of a lasting ceasefire with Iran
2 hours ago
