Indian cricketer Mohammed Shami appeared before election officials in Kolkata. He was summoned for a hearing due to discrepancies found in his voter registration form. Shami, who has resided in Kolkata for years, was previously unable to attend due to cricket commitments
India-Poland Ties: EAM Jaishankar urged Poland to display zero tolerance for terrorism and also emphasised India's stance on the Ukraine conflict and termed "selective targeting" of New Delhi "unfair and unjustified." India-Poland Ties: External Affairs Minister (EAM) S
At the time of writing, around 76.8 per cent of users had voted in favour of the idea, although Musk has not clarified whether the poll reflects any serious takeover plan. New Delhi: Elon Musk has once again grabbed global attention by taking a business dispute to social media
RRB Group D Vacancy: The Railway Recruitment Board has postponed the application process for 22,000 RRB Group D posts. Initially, applications were set to start on January 21t, but they will now commence on January 31. According to the revised schedule by the Railway Recruitment Board
From AI-generated informational videos to car-calling systems, Delhi Traffic Police has rolled out a slew of technology-driven measures to ensure smooth traffic flow and a hassle-free commute for people heading to Kartavya Path for the Republic Day parade and the Beating Retreat ceremony
Russian investment envoy Kirill Dmitriev is planning meetings with members of the US delegation on the sidelines of the World Economic Forum annual meeting in Davos, the Kremlin said on Tuesday, signalling rare direct engagement between Moscow and Washington
The Supreme Court has expressed strong displeasure with former Union Minister Maneka Gandhi's public criticism of its orders concerning stray dogs. The court stated that her remarks constitute contempt of court. Justices noted her broad criticisms without consideration
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Tuesday congratulated Nitin Nabin as he took over as BJP president and said, “I am a Karyakarta and Nitin Nabin is my Boss now." “I congratulate Nitin Nabin for becoming the president of the Bharatiya Janata Party, the world's largest political party
‘A bill to destroy MGNREGA’: Why experts fear the worst from new job guarantee bill
Thirty-five-year-old Haroli Shekhar lives in a village in Raichur, one of Karnataka's poorest districts.
Every day, seven members of his large family of landless labourers go out seeking work. Sometimes, they labour at construction sites, but most of the time they end up finding work under the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act.
The landmark law was enacted by the Congress-led United Progressive Alliance government in 2005. It made the government legally bound to provide at least 100 days of work to every rural household that demands it, failing which it must pay them an unemployment allowance.
Shekhar, a resident of Heerapur village, said he sometimes has to wait a month or two to get work under the scheme and payment is often delayed. Even so, he manages to earn Rs 15,000 a year through MGNREGA. “I mostly dig trenches or help in building canals for irrigation in the area around my village,” he told Scroll.
The major benefit, he said, is that he gets to live in his village with his two children, rather than move to distant cities for work.
On Monday, with the Narendra Modi government proposing a new bill to replace the law, Shekhar's safety net might be under threat.
Experts Scroll spoke to said the new bill removes several key provisions of the rural employment guarantee, such as the power of gram panchayats to allocate work in response to demands from workers.
It consolidates decision-making with the central government, while transferring greater financial burden on to the states. It even proposes to give the Centre the power to decide in which region or area it wants to allocate work and how much funds a state should be sanctioned.
Economist Jean Dreze said the new law “is all set to destroy MGNREGA in the guise of revamping it as a new scheme”.
“It provides a work guarantee without any guarantee that the guarantee applies,” he added.
Chakradhar Buddha, a researcher with LibTech India, a coalition that works to improve public service delivery, agreed with Dreze. “This was the first programme which guaranteed employment in the country,” said. “But if the new bill is passed, people will not get jobs if they demand it. They will get jobs if the central government has the budget and thinks it fit to give work in their village.”
He added: “With this, we are going back to pre-NREGA days.”
The central government plans to replace the rural employment guarantee law with the Viksit Bharat Guarantee for Rozgar and Ajeevika Mission (Gramin), or VB–G RAM G, Bill, 2025.
The bill increases the minimum number of guaranteed work days from 100 to 125.
But the most contentious part of the bill relates to the powers that the central government has kept for itself.
Section 4 (5) of the bill states. “The Central Government shall determine the State-wise normative allocation for each financial year, based on objective parameters as may be prescribed by the Central Government.”
“NREGA was a demand-based scheme that determined work allocation,” said Nikhil Day, rural activist and founder of Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan. “Through this section, the government ends that demand. Now the central government will decide the allocation.”
Moreover, the work will be planned under Viksit Gram Panchayat plans, which will be prepared by local gram panchayats, but only after approval by the central government. This effectively reduces the power of gram panchayats to formulate work orders.
The funding pattern has also changed, to the detriment of states.
Under the existing scheme, the Centre paid 100% of the wages and 75% of material cost.
According to the new bill, the Centre will provide 60% of funds to all states, apart from the ones in the North East. The rest has to be borne by the state governments. In the North East and in Uttarakhand, Himachal Pradesh and Jammu and Kashmir, the Centre will pay 90% of the wages.
“The new scheme is just another centrally-sponsored scheme with 60:40 cost-sharing, at the discretion of the central government,” said Dreze.
State governments can only decide on procedures to maintain accounts of labourers and expenditure related to implementation of the scheme.
If the state spends in excess of the funds allocated by the Centre, it will have to bear the cost, as per procedures laid down by the central government, the bill says.
Dey pointed out that if states are forced to pay more under the scheme, they may no longer be able to afford it or prioritise work under the scheme for people.
John Brittas, Rajya Sabha Member of Parliament from Kerala, said on the social media platform X that if the new bill is implemented, “states will have to shell out around Rs 50,000+ crore. Kerala alone will have to bear an additional Rs 2,000-2,500 crore”.
For Venkateswarlu Kuruva, a social activist based in Raichur, the whittling down of state powers is a clear reason to worry.
He lives in Karnataka, a state run by the Congress, the party that sits in Opposition at the Centre. “People will lose the right to work and earn” if this comes into effect, he said.
Several experts told Scroll that the new law will lead to inequitable access to employment and incentivise distress migration.
For instance, Section 5 of the bill states that the Centre will pick rural areas in every state where work will be provided.
In Raichur, Kuruva said that after MGNREGA was implemented in 2005, there was a decline in migration and people began to work near their home. “But now if a particular village is not listed for work allocation, people may be forced to move to cities for work,” he said. “That will be the worst possible outcome.”
The bill also proposes a 60-day pause on guaranteed work during agricultural seasons. The government has reasoned that this will “facilitate adequate farm-labour availability during peak agricultural seasons”.
Experts pointed out that this puts farm labourers at a disadvantage.
The rural employment guarantee scheme not just acted as a cushion, but also empowered them to bargain for better wages during peak agricultural seasons. “If there is a clause that there will be no work at all during that time, then labourers will lose the bargaining power,” Dey said.
Buddha, from LibTech, said, “MGNREGA destroyed the dependence of labourers on landlords. But this bill effectively destroys that privilege for at least two months.”
Dey added: “It will put landlords in feudal control, and can lead to exploitative wages.”
As Scroll has reported, the Modi government's insistence on biometric attendance and mandatory Aadhar-based payments has derailed the scheme and squeezed out workers.
The new bill increases the digital burden on workers.
It proposes to track attendance and payments with the help of artificial intelligence and dashboards.
Buddha, the researcher from LibTech, said that the introduction of technology had already squeezed workers out of the scheme.
For instance, he said, mandatory online Know Your Customer, or e-KYC, verification, led to the deletion of at least 27 lakh workers between October 10 and November 14. The new bill may push more needy beneficiaries away from the scheme if there is a tech failure in remote rural areas.
Kuruva, who has been helping workers get re-registered after their names were deleted due to e-KYC, said, “Technology has been stripping away the right to earn”.
Source: Scroll
Related Posts: Goldilocks' Year Awaits Indian Markets With Likely 11% Return Nightclub where fire claimed 25 lives flagged for illegal construction in 2024 27-Year-Old Engineer Dies As Car Plunges Into Drainage Pit India's thriving online delivery platforms face a year of reckoning China’s population falls for a fourth straight year Space sector eyes further investment growth in 2026 after record year One dead, four wounded in Czech town hall shooting What Is Blue Davos And Why Is 2026 The ‘Year of Water’ Tax Year’ Replacing ‘Assessment Year’ In New Income Tax Law From 1 April 2026 Gurugram doctor runs his Scorpio over 43-year-old delivery worker multiple times
A major tragedy was averted when security forces detected and defused an Improvised Explosive Device (IED) on the Srinagar-Baramulla National Highway in North Kashmir. Security forces in Jammu and Kashmir averted a potential attack after discovering a suspected improvised explosive device (IED) in
1 days ago
Being locked barefoot in an executioner's chair sounds uncomfortable, but that is what Chris Pratt requested for his latest film, Mercy. More familiar as a wisecracking action hero in blockbusters like Guardians of the Galaxy and Jurassic World, this role is quite a departure for him
1 days ago
Bodoland Lottery Results Today 20 January 2026 Live: The Assam Bodoland Lottery Department will declare its results today at 3 PM. Participants can view their results at bodollotteries.com, the official website, scroll down for more details.Bodoland Lottery Results Today 20 January 2026 Live: The
1 days ago
Just yesterday, the prime minister made the case for "calm discussion" with the United States. He wakes up this morning to President Trump personifying a political Catherine wheel: spinning, unpredictable, colourful and firing off reactions at every angle.Just yesterday
1 days ago
US President Donald Trump spoke with NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte about Greenland. They agreed to a meeting in Davos, Switzerland. Trump highlighted Greenland's vital role in national and global security. The Arctic island's strategic location and its connection to transatlantic defense
1 days ago
Tamil Nadu Governor RN Ravi on Tuesday walked out of the state Assembly without delivering the customary address on the opening day of the first session of the year. This is the fourth consecutive year that Ravi has walked out of the Assembly. On Tuesday
1 days ago
A 43-year-old delivery agent was allegedly run over at least four times by an SUV in Gurugram's Sector 93 on Monday, leaving him critically injured. A purported CCTV video of the incident surfaced on social media, showing five to six Swiggy riders standing at a roadside pickup point waiting to
1 days ago
India's first Switzerland-like funicular railway has opened at Malanggad near Kalyan in Thane district, reducing the two-hour uphill trek to the interfaith dargah to a quick 7-10 minute ride for Hindu and Muslim devotees. Thane gets India's first Switzerland-like cable car
1 days ago
Fuel stations are designed with several safety systems in place, but small mistakes by customers can still lead to dangerous situations. These simple safety steps can significantly reduce the risk of fire at fuel stations. Fuel stations are designed with several safety systems in place
1 days ago
The OnePlus 15 made its debut a few weeks back and the leaks about the OnePlus 16 have already started to surface online. The new leaks by Chinese tipsters claim that the company is testing some serious hardware upgrades for the OnePlus 15 successor
1 days ago
While Uthappa is a proponent of the system, he acknowledged that implementing such a drastic change is not without its risks. Former Indian cricketer Robin Uthappa has reignited the conversation regarding split-coaching for the national side following a historic series loss to New Zealand. Uthappa
1 days ago
US President Donald Trump threatened to impose 200 per cent tariffs on French wine and champagne after France indicated that it would decline his invitation to join a proposed “Board of Peace". The body was initially envisioned to oversee the reconstruction of war-ravaged Gaza
1 days ago
Take an exclusive look inside Farah Khan's massive, palace-style set as part of The 50 House Tour, showcasing grandeur on an epic scale. Indian television audiences have a new reason to be excited as the much-anticipated reality show The 50 gears up for its grand premiere on February 1, 2026
1 days ago
Atlee and Priya tied the knot in November 2014. They were blessed with their firstborn Meer in 2023. Mumbai: Filmmaker Atlee and his wife Priya are all set to expand their family of three. On Tuesday, Priya and Atlee, who are already doting parents to son Meer
1 days ago
Skoda Kushaq Facelift: The updated midsize SUV brings changes to its exterior design, interior features, and powertrain options. Pre-bookings are now open, with prices expected to be announced in March. Skoda Kushaq Facelift: Skoda has revealed the Kushaq facelift for the Indian market
1 days ago
Before Monday's (January 19, 2026) fixture in the Women's Premier League, Gautami Naik was a largely unknown commodity in Royal Challengers Bengaluru's star-studded batting unit. That is likely to change after the 27-year-old's 55-ball 73 — the middle-order batter's maiden half-century in her
1 days ago
The Supreme Court has dismissed a plea from YouTuber Savukku Shankar. He sought to unseal his Chennai office and retrieve seized devices. The court directed him to approach the judicial magistrate. This follows allegations of assault and extortion by a film producer
1 days ago
Why Is Indian Stock Market Falling? The Indian stock market remained under heavy selling pressure for the second straight session on Tuesday, January 20, as weak global cues, rising trade-war concerns and muted Q3 earnings dampened investor sentiment
1 days ago
Pakistan Cricket Board has paused preparations for the T20 World Cup 2026 due to uncertainty over Bangladesh's participation. Pakistan supports Bangladesh's demand to shift matches away from India over security concerns, threatening its own involvement if the issue isn't resolved
1 days ago
The Indian Army's Eastern Command has sought the intervention of West Bengal Governor C.V. Ananda Bose in connection with Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee's recent allegation that a senior Army officer was using the command base at Fort William and working on the SIR exercise at the behest of the BJP
1 days ago
In the tit-for-tat exchange between Manchester United defender Lisandro Martinez and two of the club's most famous recent players, Nicky Butt and Paul Scholes have had their say. On the same 'The Good, The Bad, The Football' podcast where they upset Martinez with their mickey-taking before the
1 days ago
European leaders take the stage on Tuesday (January 20, 2026) ahead of Donald Trump at the gathering of global elites in Davos, as the US president dangles tariff threats in a bid to pressure the EU over Greenland. Mr. Trump is set to dominate the week at the Swiss ski resort, with a U.S
1 days ago
King Mohammed VI of Morocco accepted an invitation by President Donald Trump to join as a founding member of the U.S.-led Board of Peace, Morocco's Foreign Ministry said on Monday (January 19, 2026)
1 days ago
In a classroom in Uttar Pradesh's Gorakhpur, an emotional moment involving a single father and his daughter has left many shaken. The man arrived at his daughter's school with tears in his eyes. While holding his daughter close, he requested the teacher not to beat her
1 days ago
Calling the large force of delivery partners in India a 'third pillar' of the job market, a top Swiggy executive has said their job should be seen as flexible employment rather than gig work. "Gig sounds like a little bit of a fancy term, but the reality is it's flexible employment
1 days ago
Renewable energy to get fresh Budget boost with PM KUSUM 2.0: As India heads into the Union Budget 2026, sources told ET NOW that the renewable energy sector will likely get a fresh boost in the Budget. According to the sources, the government may announce the next phase of the PM KUSUM scheme in
1 days ago
Vivo has confirmed the India launch of its next premium smartphone, the Vivo X200T. The handset will expand the company's X200 series, which debuted last year, and will sit alongside the Vivo X200 and Vivo X200 Pro. Here is everything that has been announced so far, along with key rumours
1 days ago
